We have gone several times; this is my favorite restaurant! Every server we have had has been…read moreEXCELLENT as well as the food. I'm vegetarian and love their selection for me!

Service: 5 Food: 2 Food was mediocre- my husband ordered the…read morespecial and it was flavorless. Left half of the protein off of my pasta.

Stopped into the restaurant tonight - first time in - I had the meat Calzone - my wife had a…read moreHawaiian Calzone - we both enjoyed the meal. Service was quick and easy - clean and a quiet setting- great place to eat- highly recommended.

Cannelloni, lasagna, or baked chicken pasta... you can't go wrong. Friendly service and great food…read moreat very reasonable prices!!

This place is unbelievable. I got the lobster ravioli and my wife got the tortellini. Both of them…read morewere incredible and the tiramisu was great as well. The service was fast and friendly and the prices were extremely good. I will come back any time I am in the area.

We had high hopes for Michaelee's because it was recommended by several people. The inside of the…read morerestaurant was quaint and we were sat in front of the window with a nice view of the square. Our server was friendly and helpful. We asked for recommendations from the menu and she recommended the lasagna and tortellini. I opted for the tortellini with meatballs and my fiancé got the lasagna. When our dishes came out they were both covered in a very chunky tomato sauce, which tasted like a can of diced tomatoes with some seasoning. We were both very disappointed with the flavor. Next time I think I'll try the chicken piccata Gemelli Primavera.

I think their menu and food are great, but their take out salads are much better when they remember…read moreto add salad dressing. Seems to be a trend....

A new place for me , I came here to meet my daughter who lives in Gainesville and wanted something…read moreItalian so our first time here. Quaint, nice ambience service was fantastic. Menu was very Italian, some traditional dishes I'm sure to the owner as well as they were red sauce, which is standard on mini dishes. . This is sangria only so no beer or liquor, which was a little disappointing but does not affect the review. I survived and got a beer later.!! We all ordered with the mixture of pizza to my chicken pasta, tortellini, and shrimp fettuccine. All were well-made, the pizza really stood out with a great crust and flavor. My chicken presented well but was really lacking seasoning but nothing a little salt and pepper didn't correct. Shrimp fettuccine also seem to lack seasoning, but I tend to look for a little more aggressive seasoning before tasting.. Plates were nice portions, even had to get two to go boxes, including half the pizza which we enjoy later.. if you're looking for Italian, this was very good. Very family, friendly and service was impeccable.. Highly recommend!!

When you see this review you might wonder ---small town 4.6 or a real 4.6??…read more This place is worth a visit!!! We had the pizza pepperoni rolls and the chicken Marsala. The bread on the pizza rolls was fresh, light, fluffy and the marinara was perfect- not too acidic or too sweet. The Marsala had fresh garlic, shallots wine sauce. The loaf of a sweeter French style bread came with the Marsala and was fabulous.

Decent Italian restaurant in town. Pizza was ok, there are better options in the area if you want a…read moresolid pie. Calzone was cheesy and flavorful. Ambiance here is mixed as the lighting and staff dress looks upscale but it's really more casual. Come as you are is what I'm saying. Basically if you're craving Italian and don't want to drive far from Andrews this is your best option.

I ordered the Seafood linguine & frankly wasn't expecting too much as it was my 1st visit to Mama…read moreGs. They were very busy & that considered the service was still great. The decor is not something special or spectacular, it's kinda diner style & I think that's why I wasn't expecting much. To my surprise, the food was fantastic and that combined with the great service is why I gave this Restaurant a five star. Good food, number one, good service number two & frankly, the decor can be great or not, It doesn't matter after that.

Good food. Very expencive. 1 hamber 1 small pizza with tip =…read more$60! Waitress was very nice.

We ate here tonight. The restaurant was clean and well managed. The Burrata appetizer is the best…read morewe have ever had. We also ordered the Sausage Pepperoni pizza and the Shrimp Scampi pasta. Tastiest Italian food we have ever had!!!! The best part of the whole experience was Emily!!!!! She was so kind and talkative with us, made us feel like family. All employees we saw were TOP TIER! Good job Max's Lakeside...you know what you are doing with your food and employees!

The food is delicious! We had the burrata with blistered tomatoes and pesto. We shared the…read morespaghetti and three large meatballs. The meatballs were cooked perfectly and tender. We highly recommend the food, but it is not on the lake. We were disappointed that we overlooked the parking lot. Also, we felt rushed even though the restaurant was empty at 5:30. I think we would opt for the Swing Bar next time where you can order from the menu. There was live music, which was inviting. Overall a solid 4 stars! Update--when we paid our bill IN CASH, our server returned and said, "I'm sorry, but we don't accept cash!" What?! Seriously? We put down a card and changed our review. 3 stars for the hovering service. 2 stars for the "no cash" policy" 2 stars for the view 4 stars for the food.

I love this restaurant. Always a hit for visiting guests and family. The food is delicious and the…read moreservice outstanding.

Very nice venue and the food was outstanding! My husband had the lasagna and he loved it! I had the…read moreflounder special which was awesome! We will be back!!

Nice Italian restaurant which has had several owners. Comfortable private booths as well as tables…read more Has veal and chicken and shrimp dishes and all the typical pastas. We had 2 dishes with different cream sauces. Very good. Both the linguini and the rigatoni were perfectly al dente, which is rare. Desserts were homemade sweet, tasty, and authentic. They are garnished with whipped cream and chocolate syrup (see picture ). Service is excellent with young attentive waitresses. Real good Italian food.

Decent Italian food with some good choices. Service was fast and efficient. Ambiance was a typical…read morefamily restaurant with comfortable booth seating.