Good pizza and a friendly staff. The crust is a little thicker than what I typically consider New York style, but very good. My only complaints were that drinks are served in bottles and there were no dispensers of cheese and red pepper on the tables. A restaurant this nice should really have a soda fountain. When I asked for Parmesan cheese and pepper, they brought it quickly, but it was in little plastic cups. Those are little details but they distracted from the experience. My guess is that there is probably more takeout and delivery business than dine-in. I'd definitely go back though. The pizza and cheesy bread were both delicious, and the staff was extremely nice and friendly. read more

See all

Won't be ordering any time in the future. Another failed ordered - items wrong (ranch because they were out of Caesar, not including dipping sauce even though I special requested on the order and called to make sure the request was seen, strips of lasagna noddles instead of ravioli). Ashley, the manager was rude and made excuses. Their delivery person was rude when he had to bring back forgotten items. Literally did not stop the car....handled out the widow while still driving. It's a shame - good pizza, poor customer service. read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hartwell, Georgia

This is one of the first restaurants I've tried in Hartwell and I was happily surprised. Their pizza was some of the best I've had. They have a variety of options here as well such as pasta, and Stromboli's. The waitress Ashley was very kind to us and recommended a few other places since we are new to Hartwell. Can't wait to be back to try all of the other options on the menu. read more

I felt silly stopping at this place in (checks notes) Hartwell, Georgia. My life is such that a week before I was actually in New York. I ate all sorts of things; didn't make it to the top pizzerias but there was definitely some pizza in there. So I figured this place would be adequate at best, but there just wasn't a ton else that was open and in this geographic area. Ordering in advance online was wise; it took a half hour to get there and my pizza was still a few minutes away. There were several other takeout customers, but no one eating in despite the considerable effort which had been put into decorating the space with New York memorabilia. The large pizza here is actually large; barely fit in a fridge. And the slices flopped in the way you'd expect. Getting jalapenos and mushrooms was wise as the spicy flavor contrast excited things, but as I dug in more, a little bit of sour flavor in the crust began to add depth. I meant to eat a slice and leave, but I ate a second while wandering around a tiny downtown. It was a salty pizza, and there's not much besides bread and cheese on the menu, but I can say that if I'd gotten this pizza in New York, I wouldn't have been disappointed with it. read more

See all

Well, I wanted to like this place as upon entry everyone was so nice, but when the pizza came it just didn't happen The hamburger on the pizza tasted freezer burnt, hardly no sauce, no garlic, just bland all around. Sadly, I won't be going back read more

An hour wait for a walk-in order. Ordered the stuffed Philly cheesesteak no mushrooms or peppers. Don't order this! No steak! Meatballs. Way entirely too much dough. There was a good 2" of crust around the outside edge and it was a good 2" thick. Nothing between the 2 layers there. Just dough. The rest was ok, not being a Philly cheesesteak. lol The dough is good, I must add, but give me what I ordered. We didn't eat in, so no ambiance. It was clean and there was about 2 tables of people. read more

80s decor ... old school pizza joint. 100% slamming New York style Pizza. thick crust, pan style, cheese...and the calzones great staff, great food. go there, eat a lot, be happy..!! read more

See all

WARNING. DOUBLE CHECK YOUR BILL! First, let me say that everything was going great. The waitress was great. The food was average, but we were having a good time. Then the bill came. It was not itemized and didn't have any amount listed. I took it to the cashier who rang up a ridiculous amount. I requested to see the itemization. After running through everything with the cashier, I began to say what is this amount? She then backtracked and said "Oh, I must not have cleared out the last transaction". Then after clearing around $25 off my bill (for what she claimed was a mistake) it came to the correct amount. She even told the waitress, "He's looking at the numbers, so I need to get this right". No apology. Nothing. It didn't even bother her that she tried to overcharge us by so much. They knew we were from out of town and I feel like they tried to take advantage of us. Don't be afraid to question their charges. Very shady. Disappointing read more

We ordered ahead and the pizza was great...hot and lots of toppings!! The people were nice and we had take out. Would order again!!! read more

As you can see this wasn't what I assumed it was. Starting off with the customer service it was amazing. Lady was nice and knew what she was doing. Moving onto the location. It's a bit older on the outside but the inside will surprise you. They have television and good interior designs. BUT the food wasn't as good as the service, it took around 15 minutes to get both appetizers and shortly after the pizza. Rating the cheese knots it was bland. I think if it was a different type of cheese used it would taste better. Moving onto the pizza. Pretty greasy pizza, the sauce was not up to par with most pizza places, and the ingredients didn't stay on the pizza if you pick it up to eat it. This is just my opinion, and you can be different. Always try something before judging a place from someone else's opinion. read more

The pizza was mediocre at best, beginning with a tasteless crust (pizza crust needs a bit of salt for flavor and texture!) and nothing else to make up for it. for almost $17, save your money. read more

FANTASTIC pizza. Hartwell is a small town, with a handful of options for pizza, but this restaurant would hold its own a big city. The food is authentic... family SOUNDS like they're from NY (?), and I promise, it doesn't taste like a 'chain' pizza place. Sometimes there is a wait--sometimes there's not. But if there is, know it's only because like every other small town, we have too many chiefs and not enough indians and help is hard to find. But it's absolutely worth any wait. read more

We've been twice to dine in and enjoyed both times. I wouldn't say it was true New York pizza , but that won't stop me from going back.

I picked the pizza up. Service was fine. I ordered an original crust pizza with pepperoni & banana pepper toppings. The pizza was tasteless. I have had better frozen pizza. read more

Visiting from Texas and so glad to stop at this gem! Service was great the young lady was very sweet, menu has a large selection, and prices are great with portions! Garlic knots amazing and so was spinach ravioli. Will be back before we leave town. Also if anyone cares (like I do), very clean establishment! read more

Hands down the best pizza around! Staff is so friendly and the pizza is FRESH, we never have leftovers !!! Love NY Pizza! read more

New York Pizza - Large meat lover pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hartwell, Georgia

See all

I was not impressed at all with the service or either of the two pizzas that we ordered.

Very limited menu. I was told it was because of remodeling. They didn't have any tea. Only soft drinks and bottled water. the house dressing tasted like old grease/oil. I had a medium pizza and had two slices. The only waitress brought me a tiny box to put 6 slices of pizza in. I'll never go back. Worse place. Tied with the Pizza Hut. read more

In town for a fishing tournament and wanted to try somewhere local vs a chain restaurant. The staff, pizza, baked ziti and anti pasta salad were all fabulous! Would definitely eat here again when back in Hartwell, GA. read more

Unbelievably tasty with supreme quality. The pizza tastes expensive but the prices are low. Staff is extremely friendly and welcoming. We came from Atlanta but found the best pizza we've EVER had. Please do yourself a favor and give these guys a visit, you'll be grateful that you did! read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hartwell, Georgia

Best pizza in Hartwell, GA! Their prices are reasonable over their diverse offering of pizzas.

Always good ! They will Make it the way you want it if you ask nice . Best pizza in Hartwell read more

Air conditioner broken. Pizza fair. Very slow service. Waitress doesn't visit table very often. Had to flag her down to request water refills. No toilet paper or towels in filthy bathrooms. Will not be back. read more

This was our first time having dinner here and it will not be our last. They had the BEST pizza I have ever had. Brittney was amazing hands down best service from her. Joe the cook "chefs kiss" absolutely delicious! read more

This place started out fantastic!! It has slowly gotten worse.. stuffed pie isn't very stuffed!

The pizza was very good. Service was good, order online was easy, and done to perfection. If you desire pizza, give them a try.

You won't find a better pizza place in the state of GA or SC. I go around reviewing pizza places in the south for an instagram page and rate this place the highest out of the 43 places I have visited so far. One bite, you know the rules. When I first bit into a slice from New York Pizza I instantly could tell it was made of top quality ingredients. Not only are you going to find the best pizza you could possibly find in the south, but you're going to find a hospitable staff that cares about your dining experience. read more

Great Greek salad, do not deliver more than 5 mile radius. The pizza was great and so were the cheese garlic knots !!!

Pretty good. Had the lunch buffet. Not much selection but it is alittle after lunch time amd the week after Christmas. The salad bar had a nice selection of items. All said it was a good price for what we got. We did get to habe a fresh just made pizza before we left. The crust is thin and buttery. We will come back! read more

Tried this place out while visiting my sister - had the vegetarian. Very good - loved the crust.. Plus it was a great value for the price. I could see this place being a regular if I lived in this part of the world. Guess I will have to wait until the next time I visit and try out something with meat. read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hartwell, Georgia

Oh wow! A NY pizza place in Hartwell!! This is unbelievable. They had a salad bar and pizza bar similar to Pizza Hut's. The salad was mainly iceberg with decent toppings. They had multiple different olive oils to put on also. I used the basil and garlic. It was fresh and tasty! The pizzas were good too. I hade the meat, the covered pie and the apple cinnamon dessert pie. The covered was like a calzone. Very good! The meat had sausage pepperoni and bacon bits. Good too. And the apple cinnamon was a delish sweet treat. They had one waitress and she kept up well since it was just my coworker and i. We missed the Lunch rush by 30 minutes. I will return to this gem. read more

Love this place. We recently moved to the area and this restaurant is now a weekly must have. Service and food is superb!

Perfectly amazing lunch buffet. Great selection and freshness. Very friendly staff. I'll be back. read more

This is our favorite pizza in town. The stuffed NY pie is the best. I dropped one star because I ordered a deep dish Chicago pie and got a pan pizza instead which was not what I was expecting but it was still good. This place serves real pizza and if you haven't tried it, it is so much better then the chain restaurants. read more

First off, let's understand that everyone has a pizza they prefer - for whatever reason, good or bad. What I think that New York Pizza offers that other places do not is an excellent crust - it's not doughy and does not have the taste of dough (like most chain pizza in my experience). It's crusty and has the wonderful taste of crusty baked bread, even on the bottom. The other thing they offer is quality meats and it makes all the difference. During covid days, call ahead and pick one up to go. They also deliver, but I enjoy stopping in just for the smell of great pizza cooking. Leftovers? Place your pizza directly onto a baking sheet and put into a 400F oven for 15 minutes. Even leftover, it's better than most freshly delivered! read more

Me and my husband loves this place the stuff pizza and garlic cheese knots are our favorite one of the best pizza places around almost feels like you're in new York one of our favorite restaurants in town read more

My family and I dined here for dinner tonight and we were pleasantly surprised. We are new to the area and so far haven't been thrilled with the dining options. The stuffed pizza was really good, as was the calzone my daughter ordered. Our younger daughters shared a cheese pizza and ate every last bite, including the crust (this never happens). I ordered the fettuccine Alfredo but did not care for the sauce; this is probably my fault as I am a bit particular about Alfredo, but our waitress was extremely kind and understanding. This dish came with garlic knots which were good and I added a salad. The Italian dressing was so very good. Overall we had a great experience and will be going back for the pizza and calzones. read more

Food was great! It's such a cute environment to go to. There is an awesome salad bar and I am in love with their calzones and garlic knots. The staff is SO SWEET and welcoming! It's a nice place to go eat with a group of family or friends. read more

So I want into the New York pizza place it was very good I had the Garlic Knot which were very tasty and then I had the meat lovers Stromboli which was out of this world I love it I'm going to be coming back to this place read more

Great food We r from Ohio here visiting family The pizza was super yesterday and the Godfather Sub is excellent for today Had the Key Lime Cake yesterday also. First time for it and it's superb You have to ck this place out read more