We had a reservation for a table of 9 of us and they were very accommodating. The restaurant its self is very loud and I found myself yelling if I wanted to talk to anyone who wasn't next to me. The service was decent and all food came out timely. I had a hugo spritz which was good. However they don't list this drink prices on the menu which is also a turn off for me. Someone in our party got a drink that tasted off and it was comped off the total. The dinner itself was delicious but a bit pricey ($32) for a vodka chicken parm. No one else had anything bad to say about their food either. Overall the service and food were enjoyable but the atmosphere is definitely loud and bit of a pricier location. read more

Wyckoff Tavern - tipsy chicken parmesan - Bars Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

What a great place! Big open dining area with lots of windows. The service was amazing, our server Juan was so friendly and attentive. He was great to our 3 year old grandson, made him feel special. And the food was all delicious, my husband has a delicious cheeseburger that had bacon,tomato,cheese and lettuce on a brioche bun that came with fries , my grandson had chicken fingers(not the frozen type) with fries also, I had a excellent chicken Milanese sandwich that had red onion, tomato, mozzarella cheese and a mango chutney. We will be going back to try dinner! read more

My first time here since new owners revamped the place. I was pleasantly surprised to see the addition of a bar with three large screen TVs. I was meeting a friend so next time will definitely sit at the bar. The menu had many selections for diners with various food issues. I ordered the beefsteak salad which was the perfect size and had large slices of tomatoes, fennel, cucumbers and cabbage. It was in a very light dressing that was the perfect amount. I ordered a piece of grilled salmon to go with it. I just had water but will definitely try a drink next time. Service was very good. The place was absolutely packed for a Tuesday night which was nice to see. Will definitely be back again! read more

Can only speak to the Sunday brunch as I've only been here one time since they changed over to a tavern. Arrived at 11:45 AM and music went on at noon. A lovely solo guitarist whom didn't play too loud and was the perfect backdrop to brunch. Also engaged with the patrons to see if they had any requests. Parking is super easy as not only do you have their lot but you can also park within the shopping center at Boulder run. We arrived at the perfect time because there was a steady flow of people coming in through the rest of the afternoon and it got quite busy. Our waiter, whose name I did not catch, was very attentive and pleasant. He went over the menu and I appreciated that they had their regular menu items in addition to the brunch menu of selections. We all opted for brunch except for one in our party who had the burger, which was fantastic. I do wish the breakfast potatoes were cooked a little more crispy, but flavor was on point. read more

See all

Could definitely offer more vegetarian options. Had the arugula salad with quinoa, feta, asparagus. It was 2 lbs of arugula with a teaspoon each of "the good stuff" , dressing was just okay. Considered the veggie burger but there was no description, just "our blend" which could mean just about anything (ask any vegetarian) I've had my share of lousy veggie burgers after so many decades and it's generally not the kind of thing most servers can describe well. On the other hand, husband loved his burger and staff was very friendly. read more

Prompt service appetizers were filling and dinner was a nice size portion. The atmosphere is family driven and servers are very friendly They knew the specials without looking at a piece of paper. Pricing is average but for the amount of food you get well worth it . read more

See all

A great lunch meal of Thai salad with blackened salmon. The salad was nicely chopped into bite size pieces with peanuts, and crispy wontons throughout and light dressing that had the slightest bit of heat. It was topped with a blackened salmon that was just a bit salty and cooked perfectly. The service was very good. I can't wait to try it again! read more

Wyckoff Tavern - Thai salad with blackened salmon - Bars Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

The only way to put it is that I was disappointed. With a reopening did the new name and a new presence I somehow expected things to be very different. They weren't. The menu was very similar and just wasn't that great. My food came out warm and not hot and it wasn't even crowded there. They still have the fries and I always used to look forward to them but this time they were warm not hot not crispy. Not ok. And it wasn't crowded so they do not have a valid excuse for it at all. Not sure I will be back. read more

Visited Wyckoff Tavern with a friend yesterday for lunch. We were greeted at the door and seated quickly on a Friday! I ordered the Thai salad with Chicken and my friend had the Turkey burger. My salad was delicious and portioned perfectly. My friend loved her turkey burger and raved about the sauce on it! Cocktails were also really good! Our waitress was super nice and attentive! It was a great experience! Happy I can walk there too :) read more

Very cute! Had lunch here with a friend and enjoyed it - staff was super friendly and food was good. Both had salads for lunch which were fresh and flavorful! Nice little spot! read more

First time visiting. Food and staff amazing 100% will be back and tell family and friends about the experience. Our waiter Juan was very friendly and attentive. read more

Wyckoff Tavern - Beer and Wine - Bars Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

Since the change over to Wyckoff Tavern prices are up food quality is not the same .. ordered goats cheese and fruit salad for take out with grilled chicken , barely any chicken which now seems more processed than it used to be. , Barely any goat cheese but plenty of lettuce . It is not worth the money anymore . Please bring back the original Amici fries these are not the same. read more

Food overpriced and nothing great. The service was not great and slow. The noise seemed louder than when it was not a pub. Would not run back. read more

Like coming to this place. Cold beer and good food will always make you feel welcome . Friend swears he saw a leprechaun in the parking lot. Maybe he did? read more

NG.. Waitress after 15 minutes came back and said they took my pad can you order again?? Short pours on the drinks terrible meatballs spinach dip bland shrimp app not very good as well. Didn't bother with entrees left and went to Nellie's. read more

Two visits both just moderately ok in both food and staff, there is room for improvement. Hesitant for a third visit.

Have gone there multiple times. Food is very good. Biggest issue is the bartenders. They don't look up and act like you are bothering them for service. They are lucky to be in an area where competition is light. read more

I've been here 4-6 times. Terrific food (love the flatbread pizzas!) and they pour a good drink. Service is generally very good but it can get very loud. Good tvs for sports viewing read more

It was loud and they need to address that but the service was great and the food was great. The bartender Ryan was excellent

This place is quickly becoming one of my favorite spots. The atmosphere feels lively and welcoming--friendly staff, and the kind of upbeat energy that makes you want to stay awhile. The pork chop was a standout: perfectly cooked, tender, and loaded with flavor. The chicken wings were another pleasant surprise--large, juicy, and downright delicious. I also tried the tuna tartare, which ranks among the best I've ever had. The only thing I'd change is adding a few more of their homemade tortilla chips, because they're just that good and you'll want extra for scooping. The Orecchiette pasta was another homerun... Add in a full cocktail menu with thoughtfully crafted drinks, and you've got a place that checks every box for a great night out. I'll be back, yet again! read more

We got takeout, so I can only comment on the food and not the overall atmosphere or bar scene. Based on the food alone, I do not recommend this place. It's a far cry from Cafe Amici who had a very reliable menu including delicious salads, pizzas and pasta. The salad we ordered was advertised as a Kale and Romaine Cesar, but what came was a chopped, no frills iceburg salad. If I didn't know better, it could have been a salad kit from the local grocery store. The pizzas (we ordered two) should actually be classified as flatbreads. They were small, soggy and didn't have fresh ingredients as noted on the menu. Also, don't be deceived by the photos they use on their website, which are all stock and not remotely similar to what you'll be served. All of this came with a price tag that was astronomical for what we were given. Save your money and go elsewhere. Bring back Cafe Amici. read more

No comment about the food , service or ambiance. Do not go here As the ownership takes advantage of young kids - busboys etc and does not pay them . It has happened to three young kids !! read more

Very nice , clean and comfortable, got takeout food was delicious , staff was courteous and professional.

Was ok. Went on a Thursday and was tightly packed. Average food. No pub ambiance. Next time drive further up to road to W's Village Grille. Better food, and great atmosphere. Not as crushed in read more

What a great new addition to the area. I came here Saturday night with my parents and what a fantastic experience. The location has ample parking in a private lot, and is near a toy store and a brunch spot. We entered at 5:15 on Saturday and the place was already crowded but not crazy and had a good vibe. You walk past the bar and into the dining room where are high tops and regular tables with multiple tv's on the wall showing college football games, but this is definitely not a sports bar. I did look over their craft signature cocktail menu and everything looked good, but I opted for a main lunch IPA for a beverage of choice for the night. Our waitress was attentive and knew the menu quiet well. I ordered one of the special apps as my entrée, the braised ribs. The ribs were delicious and fall of the bone tender. Total price for my beer, my ribs, parents' glass of wine, arugula flatbread and a turkey burger was 75 dollars which was average for the level of food and attention they paid. Great job and keep up the good work. read more

Went New Years Eve. Staff was very friendly and attentive, burger was A+, place is on small side, but the decor is nice

Tried tonight for the first time. Happy hour food menu was good , the lady that greeted us this evening was not very friendly / nice / at all . She seemed miserable actually . Our waitress was not very attentive , the boys helping out were very attentive . It was on the loud side , and it was busy ; but the server did not provide good service. read more

Extremely loud. Inexcusably high prices. A 15.00 beet salad with minuscule beets and 2 small smears of goat cheese. Waitress indicated the the salad was not 'filling enough' alone and suggested adding the further expensive and super dry and processed breaded chicken. The Defino's should make a better effort! 40.00 (48.00 with tip) for a smallish terrible salad and a 'meh' mocktail! Won't be going back. read more

Great Saturday experience! Loved the vibe with sports on TVs. servers were attentive. Got wings, burgers, pizza and great cocktails. Will be back. read more

enjoyed brunch, eggs Benedict Napa + avocado toast with eggs cooked perfectly! nice holiday atmosphere - good service!!