This used to be a good place to find the occasional coin or valuable but the service is poor and…read morethe quality of what they sell has gone down throughout the years, it's family run and it feels like they just want to talk with each other and not customers. It's a fun place to say you have been once.

I like pawn shops. Eureka have the BEST. The north end of town has the Gold Balls. They're lucky to…read morehave a couple of gems working there. Our local gemologist, Brody, can tell you if that pretty piece is glass or the real deal. But now I've saved the best for the best of the review: my guitar. Jessica you are the Best! THANK YOU ALL! P.S. I've added my autographed guitar strap just to up the value. Justin Haywood if you're curious.

I absolutely fell in love with this shop and its owner. I could've strolled inside for another hour…read moreand kept finding new treasures at each turn. I loved the Asian influence and trinkets/art supplies that you probably can't find elsewhere. Everything was well organized and I would've bought the entire shop if I could! I bought a pair of nice socks, a mood ring, and a ceramic spoon that will be treasured by me for life!

All Under Heaven is one of the best shops in the world... and I have done a LOT of shopping. They…read morespecialize in tea & tea ware, stationary, stickers, cute Japanese cultural items, journals, incenses from around the world, fine greeting cards, and nature-themed decor. Their selection of items is constantly changing, and always extraordinary. If you see something you want, you should buy it - because it will likely be replaced by some other awesome item the next time you visit!

really great selection of cute stuff for gifts in a convenient setting, great parking, great…read moreproximity to restaurants, a park, and to top it all off, really great customer service. I got some little knick-knacks for my friends having lunch down the street. The staff took great care in gift-wrapping the little gifts. I highly recommend a little visit

Another groovy little gift shop in downtown Arcata, CA - also located on Arcata Plaza!…read more They sell a wide range of home decor stuff, bar tools, artwork, kitchen stuff, jewelry, and more! I walked out with a full set of hot sauces - four in all - from Humboldt Hot Sauce. The lady who rung me up - wrapped several of the bottles in tissue paper - to help insure they did not clank around to much in my suitcase on the way home. Can't wait to try them all! The lady who waited on me was very nice! #Plaza

Really fun place to be. We found so many good crystals and the staff are really nice. It's a cozy…read morelittle place with cute stuff. You also don't see things like that very often so its really fun!. You'll love the jewelery, candles and essential oil selection too, and it has a great vibe and location !

When you walk in it's like traveling. Beautiful textiles, books you've never read, mermaid statues,…read morejewelry you've never seen before. It's like a mini portal out Arcata to Indonesia or India. We are lucky to have this little gem in our lil rural town. If you are looking for something different, that special gift for your best friend, you will find it here. Promise.

Came here based on Google reviews to see if I could sell my scrap gold. Staff were friendly and…read morewelcoming to me and my daughter. The shop was bright, clean, and organized. The shop has a beautiful selection, including collectible Fire&Light glass and unique jewelry pieces. Service was efficient and I was paid a fair price for my items within minutes. I recommend and would stop in again.

Knowledgeable and helpful in so many ways. The Staff know their industry and exchange rates…read more Professional!!

Baroni Is a treasure chest of gorgeous jewelry, unique designs, organically shaped, blends of mixed…read moresterling and gold plate, a great set of basics along with extravagant arrangements. Bangles, Malas, and Charms. I've been wearing Sarah's designs since the late 90's and it all holds up well! The settings have evolved beautifully as my life has and I appreciate being able to purchase keepsakes that bring great memories from success' to trials and rites of passage. Baroni jewelry has a depth and feel that brings happiness to give as gifts. Thanks Sarah Baroni!! I've travelled to many places and encountered your designs Australia, Hawaii, UK so awesome!!!

This shop is an absolute treasure. The variety of vendors with speciality items makes shopping for…read moreunique gifts a really fun experience. We come here often for the jewlery jars and vintage style inspiration. As a regular customer, I appreciate the locker policy for keeping my belongings safe and allowing me to shop hands-free. These vendors and employees work hard to upkeep this amazing store and prevent vendor losses. Shop 4th Street Merchantile first for all those special people on your list, or to find something fabulous for yourself. A walk through this place is one of my favorite forms of self-care.

I recently visited 4th Street Mercantile over the weekend and was immediately met with a policy…read morerequiring all customers to lock their personal belongings, including purses, in a locker before entering the store. While I understand that businesses have a right to set security measures, the way this was enforced made me and my friend feel as though we were suspected of theft before even browsing the items. Spending money at a store should be a welcoming experience. Instead, the requirement felt degrading and created an atmosphere of distrust from the very first moment. It is disheartening to be treated with suspicion simply for wanting to shop. Because of this negative interaction and the feeling of being treated as a potential thief, I will not be returning to this establishment. I will also be sharing my experience with friends and family to ensure others are aware of this policy before they plan their visit. If you are planning to go, be prepared to surrender your personal items before you can even look at the merchandise. It is a significant barrier that changes the entire vibe of the shopping experience.

Pretty cute! Glad they hang show posters in the window, it…read moregot me to come in. They have a sweet $1 bin where i saw a $100 retail skirt! Wild. They also had some cool costume hats and leggings :) Also fancy novelty socks, misc jewelry, and glittery cat paintings!

Yesterday, 6/18/24, my daughter and I were wandering around old town Eureka & we stumbled upon this…read moreamazing shop. This is a place you could easily spend hours in discovering treasures. The selection is truly impressive, from literal Victorian clothing, to 1970's disco jumpsuits. My daughter found a gorgeous dress with a black tulle skirt and red satin rhinestone embellished sash for only ten bucks! But the real star of the show was the girl who worked there & I wish I'd gotten her name. She had short dark hair & was the sweetest, most wonderful young woman. She couldn't have known how much her kindness mattered, but it did. We have just moved here & my daughter is having a tough time, worrying about whether or not she'll fit in or be happy here. This salesperson was precisely the kind of person my daughter admires and we talked briefly about anime and video games and...maybe it didn't seem like much to her, but it meant a lot to us. We will certainly be back. Often.