First off I will say I love Witch Wich and have been eating at their restaurants for years. Overall my recent experience was good but it seems like they have drastically cut back on the amount of meat and toppings they put on their sandwiches. What was there was good and to be honest I have cut back so it was fine with me but it is a lot different than a few years ago. But I do say I love the French fries - they are always crispy and not greasy. The only problem this time was they used way too much salt, and I do like them salty so that was unfortunate but we ate them anyway! The service was good and the tables were clean. Overall, I will keep coming back because the food is good and always seems fresh. read more

We stopped here for lunch and had a great experience! When we walked in, we were greeted and there were people inside eating. We went to the station where you pick what kind of sandwich you would like. They have labels on a paper bag where you pick exactly what kind of sandwich you would like along with the toppings. It is very easy because they provide red sharpies and they have everything you need. When we brought our bags to the cashier, she was very friendly. She asked if we wanted any drinks or fries as a side and we declined. She told us that our sandwiches will be out soon. We walked to a table to wait and we saw a wall that was dedicated to drawings other people have made on their sandwich bags and it was interesting! They have tables inside and outside. Once our sandwiches were done, she brought them to us and we enjoyed them at home. We really liked our sandwiches! We will definitely be coming back! read more

Which Wich - Sandwiches Near Me - Pooler, Georgia

The sandwich's were great. The staff were super friendly. The order was done fast and the fries were hot; nice and fresh. Plus the store was clean and spotless. read more

See all

Great for vegans in a rush! The service I received was good. Bathrooms were very clean. A much better option than Subway and they have fries! read more

This location looks like it was recently opened in the Pooler area. Located in a strip mall. Haven't been to a Which Wich in years. It used to be you took the paper bag and Sharpie and wrote out your sub order on it and gave it to them to ring up but now there is a kiosk you put your sandwich order in. Many options for all walks to choose from here. Very clean, and the restaurant was quiet. The employees were very helpful also. They have kiddie menu options. I had the Reuben sub and it was good. Only thing I miss is the muffuletta, wish they'd bring that back. read more

I haven't been to a Which Wich since I went on a college visit at Grand Valley up in Michigan. The vegetarian options here are amazing! I love how customers have a choice between chips, fries, and can even add a cookie! The store was clean and well stocked! Staff were very welcoming and provided fast service. read more

Which Wich is open! I'm excited that my favorite sandwich shop is now open in Pooler. It's located in the new strip in front of the Tanger Outlet, just past Applebee's. How do you which wich? Grab a bag & a sharpie, mark on the bag all things to make your sandwich perfect for you - size, bread and all the toppings you want! The list of toppings is a million times more than your regular sandwich places. They also have fries, chips, milk shakes, vegan/vegetarian and gluten-free options. Ask about the "secret menu" of customer favorites that aren't on the menu. My favorite is the meatball grinder and I was excited to see it on the manager's secret menu. While this shop is small, it has comfortable seating, great soda/tea selection and is bright & cheerful. The staff is excited about their new location and were eager to help customers create their custom-crafted sandwich. Go check them out! read more

See all

We have visited this location numerous times now. The staff members are really nice and friendly. On Wednesdays they offer their signature sandwich for $5 making it "Wicked Wednesdays". It is a sandwich that offers 5 meats and 3 cheeses. Pretty good bang for your buck! Our kids love that there is a fries option as a side vs. just chips like other sub places. Ordering here for the first time was a little different though. The staff will walk you through the process. You will have to look to the right as you walk in under the menu. You will then grab a sandwich bag, write your name on it and choose the options you like and take the bag up to the register. read more

Easy in & out sandwich shop at the outskirts of the Tanger Outlets. I like their concept of handing them a slip filled out exactly how you want which sandwich, you pay, and your sandwich is made pretty quickly. I can't give it 5 stars because the staff could be friendlier and more attentive. But the sandwiches are good. read more

Stopped in for a quick dinner with my teenager. The ordering process is fun and simple. Serves was slow but decent. My daughter ordered the BLT... it's not as good as the picture makes to look. The fries and house sauces are AMAZING. PS up charge your drink, save the planet, and get a cup to take home. Winning. read more

Which Wich - fries and dips on a table - Sandwiches Near Me - Pooler, Georgia

I remember reviewing this place, but somehow I can't locate my previous review. This is a nice sandwich place, but I think they may have ventilation issue. It gets sort of smoky inside. read more

Which Wich - Sandwiches Near Me - Pooler, Georgia

See all

amazing sandwiches!!! i would most definitely be back! The store was clean , the staff was amazing and the service was top tier! read more

A huge improvement from the initial days! The menu is simpler and the order is on point! Great staff - always polite and happy to see you. Not to mention the place is always sparkling clean! Nice job and keep it up! read more

See all

I'm a little confused by the set up. The lady offering to explain how everything works was very nice and informative but when you sit down and actually look at the wall of bags and slips to write your order on it doesn't really make sense? Why are some sandwich selections bags and others slips? Oh well! Anyway, they have a good amount of options and it's cool they offer fries and not just chips- but overall I wasn't very impressed. The "cheeseburger" sandwich was chopped Philly type meat and the cheese wasn't even melted- sandwich wasn't hot and it wasn't great nor the worst thing ever. I will be back sometime to try it again and hopefully have a better lunch experience! read more

Which Wich - Fries! While we wait on our whiches! - Sandwiches Near Me - Pooler, Georgia

See all

Los sandwich son buenísimo Iloveit so good great service My daughter Loveit one ours favorite Place read more

Food was great and service was very friendly! We each had a bowl-wich and they both were tasty and fresh - Get the fries and shake too.

My new favorite sandwich place. They did not disappoint at all. Me and my husband both had the Philly cheese steak and it was so good. read more

Which Wich - Philly cheese steak. - Sandwiches Near Me - Pooler, Georgia

Ignore the current overall rating and try for yourself. My first sandwich was the Ultimate BLT and it was better than expected. A friend recommended the Banh Mi, so I stopped again yesterday to pick one up. I meant to take a picture, but the looks of it alone erased that thought. Easily one of the best sandwiches I've had in a long time. It's only the second Banh Mi I've ever had, but it's definitely my favorite so far. They have a good variety of sandwiches so I look forward to trying more. read more

Which Wich - Menu - Sandwiches Near Me - Pooler, Georgia

Black bean patty wich with fries. Classic way go to, but this might be the smallest location I've ever been in. The kindness o the stag and unexpected table side delivery were nice. read more

Purchased a Sandwich & fries and they charged me .60 cents for ketchup. Never have had that happen to me before at any establishment lol.

Unfortunately, I'm having to downgrade my review of Which Which. This is the second time in a row that I've been in here and ordered the Banh Mi where I couldn't finish eating it because it was terrible. Today, though, was the worst that I've seen it. This visit started with a very inattentive woman taking my order...which was written on the cards that you order from. I had to tell her three times that I wanted a drink, and I still wasn't charged for it. So when I got my sandwich, I could literally feel alone sloshing through the foil. When I opened it, the entire sandwich was covered in sauce. The bottom bun was virtually nothing because it soaked up so much juice from the pork and sauce. On top of that, the pork was essentially mush. To be quite honest, it was disgusting and I ended up throwing it away after a few bites. Prior to tossing it out, I did bring it to the attention of the employees and was told that that's how they all are. Right! I'll tell you this, I've been coming here weekly since they opened and I've had about 20+ Banh Mi's and they progressively have gotten worse. Not sure when I'll be back to this location, if ever. Really disappointed! read more

First time visiting, probably won't go back. roast beef was dry and overcooked. chips were stale. not worth the price.

I have been here several times with my family and have never been disappointed. The staff are friendly and do a great job in completing your order in a timely manner. You won't be dissatisfied with the menu variety and the fresh ingredients used to make your order. read more

Interesting ordering system... grab a bag and a marker then check the options for sandwich, sides and drink. You write on the bag. Then they put your sandwich in your order bag. The sandwiches are like all the rest. Had 1 sub sandwich joint, had them all except this place has crinkle fries. Yep, fries. read more

Great food, better variety. Most menu options are higher in calories but the flavor is fantastic. Pricing is fair and the staff is quick to make your sandwiches. read more

Very clean store, food ingredients taste fresh and delicious, plus service is awesome. Ricky you're the man!

I love a good sandwich place! Sandwich's are their own food group for me. I'm so glad we finally have a Which Wich location near us. I usually get a turkey sandwich with lots of fixings, my boyfriend got the meatball sub which he said was just OK (but he doesn't order cheese in his subs so, does it really count?). The process of ordering here is unique and fun too, you select a bag, write your name and check off all the items you want. I've always loved this! read more

Which Wich - House Chips - Sandwiches Near Me - Pooler, Georgia

I don't know what it is about this but it's sooo GOOD!! I came the first time for Father's Day when they had their bogo so I tried it. Got the Wicked and Meatball for the hubby. I'm usually not a mixture of different meats on a sub or multiple cheeses. But this sub is perfection. Highly recommend for your first time. Get it as is. I promise you won't regret it. I don't like onions but the shaved onions on it really adds a good balance of flavors. The meatball sub was ok. I wouldn't get it my hubby likes it. I've been there 2 more times since then and I can't wait to try their others ones. I'm on a wicked kick. $5 weds can't go wrong. read more

My son and I came for a quick bite to eat as we were shopping In the area. We went in around 1140. The place is horribly understaffed and the people working could not figure out how to swipe my card. She attempted to enter it into the pad by hand and still failed. When I offered my AMEX she said it doesn't work. If you do not know how to run your shop nor how to work your register then you need to hire people who do. read more

Hubby and I got the BLT and it was delicious!!! I loved the avocado and the sandwich was very fresh. Loved it! We will be back soon. Thank you to all the staff for being so nice and welcoming and showing us how to order since it was our first time eating there! Thank you for smiling and being so friendly. We can't wait to come back and try another sandwich soon!! read more

Which Wich has become our go to sub place in Pooler - consistently yummy subs. The first time here I was a bit confused on the process, however, the lady at the front assisted and explained the process (choose the sub, mark your options on the brown paper sub bag and give it to the cashier). You have the option to have the sub either cold or hot. Also, with the app, we can place the order ahead & define a pickup time - super convenient. read more

Went for a salad. Disappointed for the amount I paid for what I received. Mostly lettuce which was a little browning. The avocado that I paid extra for was literally frozen so not edible. They added very veggies! I would expect to get a decent looking salad for that much money! Paid $12 for a salad and wasn't filled! read more

it's good, but you would think for a $15 sandwich they would give you more than a single slice of turkey and a single piece of bacon

I will never visit this location again. 6 people working, I called in a order, when I went to pick it up, I ask the young woman, who had her purse on the counter, playing with her phone, excuse me, order for so and so. She replied oh we haven't made it yet. I look around 4 customers in the restaurant, who all was eating, and look at her again, still on her phone. I ask can you make it now. Reply oh I guess. I'm sorry, I know it's a low paying job, but it's a job, show some work ethic. read more

This place is good but somewhat pricey! Wasn't really much to brag about! I really don't knnow what I didn't enjoy but they need something EXTRA here and it was just boring to me. We had the philly and the cheeseburger sammy. Maybe try something different than those. read more

Clean. Friendly. Attentive! What a great experience to eat here! They literally care for each individual order. Will def be eating here again read more

I really hate to write this review because the concept for these sandwiches and the quality is great. WHEN they get the order right... which, so far, has been never for us. This review is for the Which Wich in Pooler, Georgia. I think today was the last straw for me because when I took my sandwich back to ask for it to be remade, there was never an apology for getting it wrong, or even courteousness. In fact, the young person with locs working on Thursday, October 24th, at 1:32:24, according to my receipt, looked at me and said, "Well, you SHOULD HAVE written on there what you didn't want." In fact, I wrote down everything we wanted in our sandwiches, down to the kind of sauce. For those who may not know how this place works, when you go into the restaurant (?? food joint? cafe?), you have to write down what you want on papers they provide with red sharpies. Today, they were out of the main papers, so you had to write what you wanted on the back of another paper. I did that. I listed all the ingredients I wanted on my sandwich, so there really was no reason to get it wrong. Fast forward to the moment I walked my sandwich back in to ask for it to be remade, also showing the paper where I had written what I wanted on the sandwich. The woman at the register didn't want to take the sandwich from me and they didn't want to make it over. And then, as I stood and waited, they GATHERED IN A HUDDLE TO TALK ABOUT ME - the customer - QUITE OBVIOUSLY WHILE THE PERSON WITH THE LOCS ROLLED HER EYES. I FELT LIKE I HAD WALKED BACK INTO MY HIGH SCHOOL CAFETERIA AND PAID THEM TO BULLY ME. It felt just like that. This is the third time our order has been messed up. The exact order is a Cheeseburgerwich, no onions, no bacon, cheddar cheese. That's it. That's. It. The worst part is the way I was spoken to and treated, in front of other customers by the person with the locs. It is so easy to just own up to your mistake and apologize. Or make the food over with a smile. It's called good customer service, and here in Pooler, that kind of service is VERY HARD to come by. Unfortunately, they all fall under the same (what my husband and I call) "Pooler-Stink". Restaurants will open, and for the first week or two they will be great. Then they hire a bunch of high school kids who do not care at all about their jobs, don't give them proper customer service training, and then make the customers feel like it's their fault THEY got the order wrong. I am paying for this food - it isn't free. And with that comes, not an expectation of perfect every time, but an expectation that I will be treated well, and that most of the time my food will be made correctly. Unfortunately, even though the sandwiches are good, and I like the owner, we will not be returning to eat here. Sidenote: the owner actually works at another place closer to where I work and he has NEVER gotten my order wrong. He is ALWAYS nice to me when I go and remembers me. THAT is why I return. That is why most people return to places they love - the experience. This is more than the food - it's how you were treated and how you felt when you left. Today I didn't feel good when I left. read more

Great service and tasted great! Super clean and neat inside, got orders fresh and quick and staff was polite.