Came in for a sandwich and even though it smelled funny, stayed around to see how good the spot was. There's a sandwich of the day which starts off at seven dollars for a regular size sandwich. Today, Tuesday, December 2 the sandwich of the day was the Gyro witch. I'm glad it was because I definitely wanted to try this kind of sandwich and it actually did not disappoint. The meat they use is Gyro style meat made of beef and lamb, not the best I've had but good enough to satisfy my hunger. The toppings really made the sandwich, the sandwich comes with tzatziki sauce and cucumber, but I added a spinach, red onion, hummus, and banana peppers to mine. I had mine with the wheat bread, which was also pretty good. As far as affordability, definitely a good spot to check out. I wouldn't necessarily consider the taste of the sandwich superior though. The girl at the checkout was really friendly. I was a little concerned about the cleanliness behind the counter and the weird smell when I walked in, but other than that, the space was not terrible. read more

Which Wich - Sandwiches Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

Ordered a regular size Cuban and a regular size BLT with extra bacon. The Cuban was so small, I could wrap my fingers all the way around it. Like a very small burrito. A Cuban only has meat and pickles. You can't skimp on meat if that's the main ingredient! There was literally bread showing thru the "layer" of grey pulled pork meat. I paid $15.50 I paid $3 more for extra bacon on the BLT. What I got was extra large pieces of undercooked fat. There was one piece so large, I thought it was a potato chunk!! I wish it had been a potato instead of a large, floppy piece of pork fat. I paid $17 for extra large flabby pork fat. Can you tell how much I adore pork fat by how many times I am emphasizing PORK FAT??? For the record, I would like to present to you: Photo Exhibits A thru WTF!!? (Photos disappeared after I recd a message from the manager?) Uploading a second time. read more

See all

***UPDATE TO REVIEW*** Owner reached out regarding my review and told me I was lying and I never had my child there. Please see the attached pic of my son in the restaurant yesterday lol. He also stated I didn't have my baby with me and I was welcome to review footage. I literally walked in with my infant daughter on my hip. Then proceeded to walk out to the truck to change her diaper because again, they don't have changing tables in the restroom. This place sucks and the owner is a tool. Rather than accepting responsibility for poor service and shitty employees he'd rather call customers liars. If he really wants to play this game I also have dashcam footage of us walking into the restaurant with our 2 children. I literally have no reason to lie, but now they've pissed me off so AVOID AT ALL COSTS Walked in and the place was empty minus 2 people who ordered to go. Counters were dirty and so were the tables and chairs. Restrooms were also gross, and there were no changing tables, had to change my baby in the car. Workers were rude, didn't wear hair nets and their attitude was awful, treated my family like a bother when we ordered. They acted like cooking fries was the end of the world, take it off the menu then! All she did was take them out the freezer in a bag that was already portioned and threw it in a fryer. My family mostly enjoyed their food but we also have eaten since the evening before so we were starving. My buffalo chicken sandwich was lazily put together. The French dip was cold, and did I mention I had to clean our own table and dirty high chair? $42 for 3 sandwiches, 3 fries and 1 drink. Next time I'd rather go to Subway. Place sucks but now we know where not to go read more

Which Wich - Sandwiches Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

I placed an online order through Grubhub. At first it went through to my closest which wich, but was switched to this one instead (not sure what happened there). Order took 2 hours to be made and delivered, but once it did arrive I was pleasantly surprised. A lot of reviews show how their sandwich was bad or made poorly, but part of that can be avoided if you know how to order a good sandwich! My grinder tasted great, made exactly as I ordered, and had no issue with the meat or portions of my toppings. Everything was packed and wrapped nicely. Despite taking 2 hours, it wasn't soggy either (however I didn't add spreads/condiments). This was my first time trying which wich and safe to say I will be trying it again in the future! Edit: The owner reached out and offered to help me understand what happened with the online order, even offering compensation on their end despite it not being a fault of their own. Very courteous! read more

First of all- I love Which Wich. I'm hooked for life. What other restaurant like this has an extensive menu with tons of options. Hungry for lunch? Get Hot sandwiches, cold sandwiches, wraps, kids meals, cookies,fries, shakes, and the list goes on for a while. Not to mention you can get all their great sandwiches through catering. Yes, you heard me right. They cater! Needless to say this particular sandwich shop stood out to me. When I stoped in the owners were there and they were genuinely kind and very nice. It's always good to see that they care enough to be present. I don't think I've ever seen owners at other places. But needless to say that the employees were very happy and everyone was professional. Usually when I go out to eat I look around. This place was clean and spotless. Tables cleaned and ready to go. I noticed behind the counter as well. No change- spotless and clean. They kept everything clean and that really gave me some peace of mind for sure. My Sandwich was extremely huge just like I ordered it and it was delicious. Perfectly made. In fact everything ordered for the rest of our party of 4 was made perfect and devoured on the spot. Next time I go back I'm going to try something new because I I know everything on the menu is excellent. On a side note- our Church catered them for a youth event and every meal came in a box with a side item. Everyone was beyond happy and full afterwards to say the least. Overall this is the best spot to get breakfast lunch and dinner. You can't beat the price, the good value, the professional staff, the cleanliness. 10 star rating on the smaller 5 star scale. read more

Just too plain. Too many sandwich places out there. Not bad but nothing stands out

So I LOVE this place, BUT to this day I know it happened years ago but I'm very sad that the crab salad was taken off. The chipotle mayo is gone. Balsamic Vinaigrette is gone. Mozzarella needs to be added for a cheese, all I want is my my crab salad back . I love WhichWich and the amazing service but the menu needs to be updated again read more

The food was excellent but customer service needs to work on better communication skills . I had a co-walker tell me about about

I could not believe how long they took to make my sandwich. There was nothing special about it. It came right off the menu. In addition, the sandwich was missing cheese, a standard ingredient. I do not recommend this place. So which which? Not this which. read more

First timer, I ordered the spicy with cheese and it was great! Hand spun shake was great and the fresh lemonade was delicious. Fast service and friendly workers. read more

New Braunfels Which Wich was better than most of the locations I visited. The staff was very friendly and quick. The restaurant was very clean, something I have not seen in the others I visited. I love the seafood but they got rid of my favorite the shrimp. read more

See all

We have been going to this location for years and they've had their good and bad. ‍ BUT TONIGHT THEY LOST MY BUSINESS! *you shouldn't yell in CAPs* psh-ah! We were celebrating my son's birthday tonight and we had just gotten out of a movie and were hungry. It was between 850-852pm and this location says they close at 9pm. So why TF are the employees already bleaching the counters at 850pm?! I get it....showing up to a business right before they close. But the fact is if your OPEN sign is on and flashing....you should be making f*king sandwiches or at least OPEN to making sandwiches. It took my husband flashing his lights and asking TWICE for the employees to turn off their OPEN sign for them to actually f*cking doing it! Why is your open sign on if you are not OPEN to taking my money DURING YOUR BUSINESS HOURS for a service or product provided???? We went to Panera and at least they were HONEST and told us what they had available to sell and what they had out of stock. So I was able to purchase Panera's Mac n cheese for my son's birthday. But which wich just said "we were busy today." So was Panera but they were still honest and sold us goods before they closed at 9pm. They told us what they had to sell. I'm sorry but I'm f*king passed that these millennial just wanted to cut out before "closing time." read more

GIVE THEM YOUR BUSINESS! The absolute BEST customer experience you could imagine. Today is national sandwich day and they were offering BOGO free. We didn't know and paid for both sandwiches. The manager mentioned the deal and after hearing we didn't know about it, he came back with a cash refund for one of the sandwiches. #actsofkindness Thank you Whichwich read more

These guys serve some pretty disgusting avocado, lemme tell ya. Don't pay extra for the avocado!! read more

Which Wich - You're telling me I paid extra for this avocado, huh? - Sandwiches Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

Would not recommend coming here. I found multiple dark hairs in the 2 sandwiches bought today. Didn't notice the hairs until a few bites into the sandwich and pulled one out of my mouth... disgusting . Checked the rest of the sandwich as well as the other sandwich and found multiple hairs in both. Especially with all the illness going around now, extremely unsanitary. read more

Which Wich - Hair in sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

Loyalty member and went to redeem a deal sent by corporate. Had employee explain that "our owner doesn't honor corporate promotions". We opted to just walk out. This is the deal with chains. You are either in or you are out. If not willing to go with national deals, forgo the franchise and put your name on the business. Think/hope this is against the franchise contract and corporate will sort. In meantime, I'm avoiding all Which Wich locations as I don't need the hassle. Shame. As I like their sandwiches and frequented them a lot in the past. Lots of options around now, I think they will realize customer now vote with our $$$. read more

SLOW!!!! Friendly staff, good food, but painfully slow. Came in before 11:30 to order 2 sandwiches. 3 customers in front of me each ordered 1 or 2 sandwiches and my time in restaurant was 22 minutes. read more

Dropped in for a quick bite with the family. I really wasn't in the mood for a sandwich for dinner, but it was worth it. I ordered the wicked that comes with 5 meats and 3 types of cheese. They make it to your liking putting your selected veggies and dressing on it. The sandwich tasted great and I'm a fan now and will be back. read more

Which Wich - Sandwiches Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

This place is love it or hate it. 1. Look at wall and pick sandwich 2. Note number next to your sandwich and pick corresponding brown bag number. It will have your sandwich name on it. 3. Pick up red marker and choose sandwich details 4. Give order to person. 5. Wait for your name to be called. It is quick and efficient. It's good. Nice later stove to a regular Subway. The ice here is amazing. read more

If you appreciate good service this is the wrong place to go. They have a unique ordering system and I've never been here before. Employees were unhelpful and seemed annoyed they had to even talk to me, and I was the only one in the store. read more

We stopped in for quick sandwich for lunch at 11am we were the only 2 people in the place but the guy at the counter made us feel like we were bothering him and the girl making the sandwich just kept shaking her head like we were troubling them. But they made roars of laughter while making our food, we inspected the food, barely any meat on them mostly lettuce. This will be the last time here, sad we use to come here often. read more

Great sandwiches! Great service Reuben my favorite wife loves the witch sandwich. Go back for lunch all the time.

The workers sit around and just talk. They goof off and aren't quick to service you. You can hear them talk and tell inappropriate jokes while you are waiting and/ or eating. One of the workers, a young hispanic man, was very unprofessional. A woman who seemed to be lesbian was rude as well. read more

Soooo... she did wear her sanitary latex gloves before she made our sandwiches but not after she dragged the dirty trash around wearing the same gloves... I'm sure we will be fine. read more

This location is always busy and the manager is very customer oriented and has his employees trained very well. Our sandwiches have always been excellent! read more

Every single time I come here the food is delicious, except my first. The first time I didn't select the best combo of ingredients,it is hard to decide what to put on my sandwich because I enjoy trying new things. I was a little disappointed until I took a bite of my sisters and boyfriends. IT WAS SO YUMMY! tip: my first time i told them it was my first time there and they gave me a free huge drink, a reusable cup. I love how you can draw on your sandwich bag and hang up it up on their art wall. The ingredients are fresh, local, and DELICIOUS! I have now became a pro on sandwiches here. read more

I really like which wich we come often, the foods consistent and fresh. Today we visited it was busy as usual. We told the guy at the register the restaurant was just too cold to enjoy our lunch. Several people in the place were cold it was a little obvious. He said, Im not cold, Im hot then he asked his fellow coworkers if they were cold they said no were working. He then smelled his armpits and said he was sweating. Blagh.....customer service skills could use a little work. read more

Why have a phone if you don't answer it? Online ordering not working. Food is good, service not so much. Staff is usually rude, or otherwise just not kind. read more

this place was amazing the subs were so good and fresh we will be back soon i think my favorite was the fact that they put enough sauce and pickles on without having to ask for extra read more

Turkey today, loaded with fresh veggies and very fresh wheat roll. The vibe at this location was OK but the service was solid and quick. read more

We waited for 20 minutes because their computers went down and they could not charge us. When everyone ahead of us left we stayed to wait it out. When their systems came back up the cashier who knew we were there first took three other customers ahead of us, even though we had been there for 30 minutes or so already. Terrible customer service. read more

Was disappointed, place was very dirty and it was not busy, we were only ones in there. Staff was standing around doing nothing!

Awesome sandwiches at a great price they are fast if you have a limited lunch hour. My favorite is the thank you turkey. I like that they let you customize your sandwich, they have a paper bag where you write what all you want on your sandwich which is pretty convenient. read more

Which Wich - Outside - Sandwiches Near Me - New Braunfels, Texas

See all

Our first time here. Love the ordering system. Diego, nice young man, took our order. I mentioned it was our first time to eat Which Wich and he gave us a large drink each for free. Sandwiches were delicious. Definitely eat there again. read more

This is my favorite sub shop down here. There are several on the menu I love, but the meatball is my go to. I probably order from here at least twice a month. Great prices and amazing food. Worth it every time! read more

I patronize Which Wich all the time. They're sandwiches are awesome, and 10 times better than Subway. This last visit I got the Ultimate BLT. The sandwich was great, I just don't think it was enough sandwich to charge $7.75. For a little more I could have got a medium sub sandwich instead. At that price the sandwich should have been big enough for 2 to share. Won't make that mistake again! Take my advice and get something other than the Ultimate BLT. They're all good! read more

Love this place. I enjoy the food and the service. The people who work there interact with the customers in a positive way. I always have a great visit. read more

Great sandwiches! Lots of meat and thin bread,offered in lettuce wrap or in bowls as well! When you walk in, they have paper bag's that you pick for what type sandwich you want, then check off the extras. I had the'WICKED' a signature sandwich, it was awesome! Have been back since, highly recommend! read more

Just spent $55 on 4 sandwiches (2 small 2 med.), 3 chips and 3 bottled sodas!! Obviously we were over charged, realized this when I sat down. When I tried to bring this up to the mgr on duty and the fact that one of my sandwiches was wrong, he was so unbelievable rude and rolled his eyes. Sorry guy not my fault that your staff isn't trained well enough to take an order correctly. BAD customer service makes for a bad food experience. read more

Had to walk the entire place just to find a clean table. Over priced for what you get.