I have ordered from this place via Door Dash quite a bit, but I went inside for the first time today. I am a big fan of sandwiches so I should have actually been eating here a long, long time ago. I was surprised that the ordering island looked like a bank lobby with slips to write out what you want. I guess we must have looked confused because an associate came out to explain the ordering process in a friendly way. I stuck with my usual. A turkey on wheat sub with provolone tomatoes and lettuce... Dressed to kill with oil, vinegar, oregano and black pepper. It did not disappoint. I also indulged my sweet fang with their delicious, better than anyone's Oreo Milkshakes. This is not hyperbole but theirs are " the" best cookies and cream shakes around, even without whipped cream. My order took exactly 13 minutes to be made and I paid just under $20, but I got the 14" sub which will be my lunch tomorrow too. "Yes, " I thought smug and happy with my lunch choice. What a nice little sandwich place. read more

See all

I used be more of a fan. My husband and I both got wich wich sandwiches. Mine had avocado and it was old and not good tasting. We ordered from the app and they didn't follow what we wanted because I asked for no lettuce and on one there was lettuce. I don't know what's going on there but it's not the same anymore. read more

Terrible. I don't know what's going on with this location. Years ago I used to order from them often. I used to receive well-made sandwiches. However, over the past year and a half they've gone downhill. I keep trying to give them another chance but I will not ever give them my business again. Tonight, we ordered from DoorDash. Ordered a grinder sub. You can see in the picture what I received. I could barely see the meat on the sandwich. I feel like I got a sub with tomatoes. There's not even lettuce on the whole sandwich. read more

Which Wich - Apparently I ordered a tomato sub - Sandwiches Near Me - Huntersville, North Carolina

Nice shop I really enjoyed the food and the sandwich was very tasty I got their sandwich of the day was not disappoint. read more

Which Wich - Sandwiches Near Me - Huntersville, North Carolina

Three stars. My sandwich was missing several ingredients as ordered, including salt & pepper and olive oil, so it was very bland. And was full to the brim with lettuce. Disappointing. read more

Ordered 2 sandwiches (turkey / turkey club) to go and was very disappointed with the following issues: the bread on wife's turkey sandwich was stale and hard so she had to replace the bread at home; my turkey club sandwich was missing the deli mustard so it was dry; both sandwiches were very skimpy on the portion of meat-- In comparison to Jimmy John's or Jersey Mike's, there is more meat, better fresh bread, and more value for the price read more

Mediocre at best. Minimal meat for a $12 sandwich.I knew I should have stuck with what I knew, but now I know. read more

Which Wich - "Grinder" - Sandwiches Near Me - Huntersville, North Carolina

Simply put, the single best sandwiches in the area. Period. Quickly became my default spot for a sandwich.

Did a same day catering order and it was on time and delicious! The man who rang us up was incredibly nice and gave us some treats for the kids. Will definitely use them again. read more

This review is based on their Meatball Sub. It was my first time trying Which Wich and after trying the meatball sub I see why I was never in a rush to try them. The service was excellent and the workers were friendly and informative, but the bad sub overshadows the good customer service. The Meatball Sub is packed with bland meatballs, very chunky pomodoro sauce (which I dislike) pesto sauce, and of course provolone and mozzarella cheese. My sub was a mess! As I picked it up meatballs started falling out of the sub due to how wet and soggy the bread was. The meatballs had no taste and the sub was a big disappointment. read more

Which Wich - Meatball Sub (too sloppy for me) fell apart - Sandwiches Near Me - Huntersville, North Carolina

Ambiance was good - although it was take out. Service was good. Food was good. Nothing was great but it was solid and we would go back.

Absolutely terrible customer service and negligent managers/owners. Their app took our order for delivery and then could not fulfill since their store was actually closed when their own delivery service driver was out there to pick up. Instead of a normal refund process, I got the cancellation email and to call the store for refund. After 7 calls with providing details each time, the manager and the owner did not follow up at all. I had the joy of a server telling me that if it were them, they would not care about the $27. This is very interesting and makes one wonder about value of resources instilled in the team that runs the place. I have now let my credit card company handle it as a dispute. I used to like the place for the simplicity of the food and ability to customize a meal. Clearly between their poorly designed app, their negligence in follow up and lack of care for their customers this is not the same place that once was a great spot in Birkdale village. Just like other restaurants in that area, it may be time for these folks to get swapped out for a more responsible and responsive modern eating place. read more

Although the staff is very sweet and attentive, I don't recommend this location. I have been to which wich locations in other states and areas that have a much better variety on their menu. Every time I come to this location there is less and less on the menu to choose from. It's actually very sad to see. I used to love going to which, wich because the meat and bread was so good, they also had a good selection of cheese. I remember in Tulsa Oklahoma you could get cheese whiz on your sandwiches. At this location they only have four options for cheese. By the next time I go there they will only have two options for cheese probably. Even the chip selection is very limited. It mostly consist of baked chips. read more

Stopped in because I was so hungry , so while I waited for my philly cheesteak I ate a whole bag of salt and vinegar chips . Did not expect my philly to taste so good , but wow , I gobbled down the whole thing even after I ate a whole bag of chips . Very fresh bread , steak was very tasty , awesome sandwich I'll be back ... read more

Which Wich - Philly cheese steak , wow so surprised it was this good . Lots of flavor and great bread too . - Sandwiches Near Me - Huntersville, North Carolina

Oh Which Wich...I love you! The ordering process is marketing genius! Bags are are neatly organized for you based on your meat/protein choice. Then comes the fun part...deciding any & everything you want on that sandwich. Veggies, condiments, type of bread, extras, etc. It's a bit overwhelming, but I have a favorite combination that I stick with: turkey with white bread (toasted), pickles, avocado, pepper jack cheese, & bacon. Friendly employees make my experience so much better. The employees here get my top vote for their attentiveness & customer service. Reasonable prices. $7.75 for a "combo" meal, which includes a (regular) 7 inch sub, chips & a drink. However, the (regular) 7 inch sub alone is $5.25 & it's filling! They also offer treats such as cookies & milkshakes. They offer catering, as well as online ordering. I definitely choose Which Wich over Quiznos now. read more

See all

Great place to enjoy a delicious sandwich!! It's close to shopping, movie theater and entertainment. The place was spotless clean and the staff very friendly and helpful. Their signature sandwich is a very hearty and meaty sandwich known as The Wicked. A must try! Don't forget also to try their milkshakes and house chips. Great place. Favorite spot! read more

Which Wich - a sub sandwich on a wrapper - Sandwiches Near Me - Huntersville, North Carolina

See all

Sandwich was perfectly filling, tasted fresh and was a wonderful balance of light and hearty. Surprisingly the bread was good too! Had a pleasant dining experience as well. There was a tall cashier with curls who was very charming and helped with everything (it was my first time there). Great customer service. read more

Food is good and quick. However you need to have hand sanitizer available since everyone is touching the same pins, the bags, soda machine etc read more

Love which wish. Great fun atmosphere! Sandwiches are definitely way better than any other sort of chain place I can think of. They're always very helpful and kind. read more

Which Wich - Yummy!!!! Good quality! - Sandwiches Near Me - Huntersville, North Carolina

I'll be keeping this review short and simple (not the elite way I know) Consistently great food and this location has consistently great service, out of the over 50 sandwich's I've order, they've yet to get it wrong. The only thing I'm a little mad about is the house chips no longer being fresh and in a brown paper bag, though they still taste good and are just as salty. All sandwich places have their own way of doing things and the ease of ordering at Which Wich is part of the experience. Enjoy and try the chips :) read more

Very disappointed with my lunch today. I got a turkey sandwich and it didn't have the correct toppings I ordered and they didn't include my chips either. (Which I paid for). This is why I hate ordering delivery because they regularly leave items out of my order or make the sandwich incorrectly. Nothing was rectified when I called the store to complain. Not even a credit to my account. Will not be eating here anymore which is a huge disappointment because I really like Which Which! read more

Let me start by saying that I'm not really a fan of sandwiches. I just think they are kind of boring. But Which Wich has definitely won me over! There are so many choices for different sandwiches, and the prices are really good. I'm hooked on the tomato avocado veggie sandwich - it's loaded with avocado, and I'm thrilled that hummus is an available topping (at no charge). Which Wich serves their vegetarian clientele very well. Other than my favorite, there are several other veggie sandwich options, like the tomato caprese or the Mediterranean, as well as several seafood options. For meat eaters, the choices are unbelievable. My hubby favors the Wicked - it's loaded with five meats (pre-selected) and three cheeses (you select). Olive spread is another available topping, and it works really well on this sandwich. If you haven't been to Which Wich before, I strongly urge you to check out the menu on their website before going. That will help navigate the vast menu and all the condiment options. I appreciate that when you arrive, you step over to the side to place your order on a bag. That way, you are not holding up the line while making your selections. When you're ready, you give the bag to the cashier to ring you up, and then wait for your sandwich to be made. We tried a vanilla milkshake with banana on our last visit, and it was good but a bit pricey ($3.50). Even so, we'll probably get one again, ha ha. Which Wich is a great addition to Birkdale, with reasonable prices and great food. I'm hooked! read more

This place is awesome. The owners are great people, and if you get the App you get a free Wich for your birthday. Always a very good sandwich and tea!!! read more

It's a slightly generous rating, but it's also justifiable based on my most recent experience. It helped that I had been here before and no longer felt like I was taking a quiz when ordering. The service was excellent (including friendly), and the sandwich was great--adding cucumbers helped a lot since they were very fresh and crisp, and this was at night. To top it all off, I had a warm chocolate chip cookie. Yum! read more

I eat here every now and then! I went today and they were swamped! Amazing to see! I will say today was just like the others... exceptional service, smiles, moving with urgency etc. The manager / owner has a great business here. I have visited other locations and this is by far the best! I am having a rough week and they made me smile, thank you for that. Thank you for a great visit, now and always. read more

Bumping Which Wich up to 4 stars as they seem to have overcome their early operational hurdles and, as the team has trained, the sandwiches seem to come out much more quickly when they are busy than back in the summer when they opened in Birkdale Village. I wouldn't call it "fast" but it's certainly reasonable given the customer volume. Quality is still quite good and there are enough options to make your head spin but all easily ordered with their bag and marker system. I'm still a happy guy that they chose to replace the yucky Quizno's that used to be there with Which Wich! read more

Cheeze whiz with beef!? Seriously!? After I ate that sandwich I was wondering why the hell I hadn't checked this place out. For a sandwich joint it's so unique. I have to admit I was confused at first. I could use one of those guides for how to properly fill in the bubble because I was Xing instead of filling in. If that was a high school test I would've failed. The way you pick a bag, mark what you want and pass it along. In that sense it really stands out among the "other guys". So ditch your Subway, your Quizno's, your Jersey Mike's and make a special trip to Birkdale to try the cheeze whiz with beef! Load it on with shrooms, bacon, BBQ, A1 and some lettuce to make you feel better about all those bad choices. Keep water close at hand because this is a sodium enriched smorgas-bun of greatness. read more

I received a sandwich that was entirely inedible. Avocado can make or break a sandwich. As a vegan I usually order the avocado with a ton of other veggies. There shouldn't be so much avocado that you don't see or taste anything else and your sandwich falls apart from the mush. Wow. What a waste of money. read more

Nice quick sandwich shop. Very friendly and good food. I enjoy the gyro !! Also sounds like a little thing but nice crushed ice in soda machine !! read more

Would not recommend pickup here. They are slow as Christmas and all casual about finishing up your order so you can go. Made me late for work and I went in with PLENTY of time. Plan to eat in and wait I guess if you want a Which Wich. read more

very rude workers!!!! everyone has a rough day but still you have to be nice to people especially when you are in this kind of business.

Great food! The owners are very friendly, and very accommodating! The food is so fresh and flavorful! I have had the Philly cheesesteak, Reuben, the Ultimate salad, and Buffalo chicken sandwich. They all have been delicious! It's our go-to lunch and casual dinner stop. read more

Staff was super helpful and the create-and-sandwich sheets made picking out and finding what we wanted a breeze! Highly recommend to anyone looking for a quick bite to eat. read more

This joint is tucked away in a small corner of Birkdale. It was a Quiznos, that as far as I saw, no one ever ate there. Anyway, there is a reason while all the yelpers gave it 4 or 5 stars!!! Simply put, they have a ton of variations, allowing you to totally customize your 'wich. They load the meat on! It is freakin' out of this world....... MMMMM getting hungry after this review....... read more

Best Which Wich on the planet. Staff is so nice and sandwiches are made with care. Always a pleasant experience!

Great sandwich place. The manager is very knowledgeable and helpful. GrindersBuffalo ChickenGarden Chips

BLT was delicious. I can't complain about anything. This sandwich was perfect fresh bread , crispy bacon and nice pop of flavor.

My favorite place to get a delicious sub! At first the way you order may seem confusing but it's really great - you pick a bag according to the type of sandwich you want and then check off everything you want your sandwich to be (hot or cold, size, toppings) so there is no confusion. You hand it to the person working the register then they make your sandwich. The bread is fresh and the choice of toppings is very extensive (I personally love spinach and avocado on my sandwich). Whenever I've been there the employees were very friendly and the place was clean. Quick and delicious! read more

I have seen a lot of improvements since this place opened. I remember long wait times my first time here but this visit during the lunch rush was right on par with similar types of sub shops. They have a neat concept of filling out questions on a paper bag (later your sub bag) to place your order. I had the roast beef sub and it was good, not dry and reasonable priced. read more

The children and I opted for some quick sandwiches. After reading about Which Wich on Yelp earlier that day, we headed over. I like the concept of writing out your own sandwich. This should keep you from having errors on your order. The kids were excited to place their own orders and to draw a picture and add it to the window! We ordered three toasted turkey sandwiches and the youngun' ordered PB&J without the crust. The orders were returned in a reasonable amount of time. The kids were estatic about their sandwiches and the delicious Garden Chips we purchased as a side. The sweet tea was satisfactory as well. Rob B. mentioned large portions of meat but my husband mentioned the lack thereof. I dug through my sandwich and found there were perhaps two very thin slices of turkey tucked beneath the fresh and crispy veggies. That said, perhaps I will go with a veggie sandwich on my next visit. read more

Which Wich - Sandwiches Near Me - Huntersville, North Carolina