We come here occasionally for breakfast or lunch, the food is always good and so is the service…read more The outdoor patio is our favorite spot except for a noisy vehicle or two on rt. 61.

Came over here from the Wonder Bar in Milan, Stark difference. The bartender was completely…read moreaccommodating, letting us know how long we had to order drinks and food. Nothing but the best experience over here. I'm very sad that the Wonder Bar was not as good but Gilhuly's is owned by the same owner and there's a big difference. Please take note!!!!

We loved the food but we also loved Jeanie even more! She went above and beyond to accommodate our…read morefamily and we really appreciated her efforts! We had the perch sandwich, smash burgers, and the sweet and spicy pepperoni pizza. Chef's kiss! Jeanie, you are hilarious and made our evening. Thank you!

We went there for the first time First the menu that is on…read moreline is NOT what they serve ! My dad got 5 fried shrimp and fries for 20. Then I asked for a hotdog they were out ! 2 cans of pop 6.25 for 2 ! My husband got the perch 3 pieces for 25. We a few fries ! So they had nothing I like so I got pretzel bites , that were terrible and very very hard ! I think they fried them , now why would you do that. I broke a tooth ! And I think they do not believe in Turing o the heat . The only thing that we did like was the dog wondering around it was super cute !

Very quaint and cozy atmosphere. Loved all the Christmas decorations and lights…read more You have to order your food from the bar but they bring your food out to you. The lobster bisque had a very fishy, burnt taste to it. Would not recommend. The side salad was excellent with very fresh, crisp cut vegetables on it. Very refreshing and great mix of flavors. For dinner I had the vegetable pizza. Lots of vegetables, however, it needed to be cooked another 5-10 minutes. The crust was very mushy. The Reuben sandwich was good. The corned beef was tender and had a good flavor. Would give it 3 out 5. They were setting up for a live band. Lots of commotion, however, we did not stay for their set. All in all would give it a 3 out of five. Would like to try it again as it had 4.9 stars. Maybe just an off night?

Good food, great service, and the interior of the old elevator is loaded with antiques.read more

Great neighborhood bar feel with really good food and friendly bartenders…read more I had a burger, 1/2 lb done perfectly with onion rings that were excellent. Last time the onion rings were a little oily, yesterday they were perfect. Our adult daughter just had fried pickles, she said they were great. Perfect batter to pickle ratio and they were spears not rounds which made them great for dipping. Wife had a lake erie perch sandwich, she said it was amazingly good. Busy place, but the kitchen was kerping up about 7:30 on a Friday night. I highly recommend Rudy's especially if your in from out of town.

Located in the very lovely town of Vermilion. They have your normal bar selection for drinks. Menu…read morehas a variety of options. They have burgers, wraps, wings, fish, etc. We ordered a burger and fish and Chips. There sauce is fantastic. Both were very good. Our waitress was very prompt and friendly. It's loud, but such a fun atmosphere. I will definitely be back

Went on a busy Friday during the Fish Festival. I had a quesadilla, my husband got walleye, mom got…read morenachoes and stepdad got shrimp. Everyone enjoyed their dish. The fish was fresh. Quesadilla well seasoned. Nachos were thick chips, held up to all the toppings. Wish it had beans and shredded cheese vs just liquid cheese. Service was prompt and friendly. We had to wait about 10 minutes for a chair for our table, but given how busy it was, it was totally understandable. Would definitely go back again.

We stopped here for their perch dinners after reading the reviews, and the only item on our plates…read morewe found okay to eat was the french fries. Their portions are large. You get a lot of food, but it's not well done. The coleslaw was old and tasted close to expiring. It was chalked full of mayonnaise. The breading on the fish tasted dirty and oily. The grease they used to fry the fish may have been old, and the breading was slightly off from the norm. Also, the perch was full of oil. However, I feel the restaurant/pub was friendly and appeared to provide a safe, clean atmosphere to the locals for drinks. There are also gambling/slot machines on location and people were buying some kind of gambling tickets. Overall, I would not recommend this restaurant for a perch dinner.

Great atmosphere. Good service and decent beer selection. Great wings and good prices.read more

I went to The Feve on Saturday night and had a great experience. The burgers were some of the best…read moreI've had--fresh, flavorful, and cooked just right. Good music, good customer service, and a relaxed atmosphere. It's a great place to grab a drink, have a burger, and just sit and talk. Definitely a spot I'll be going back to.

Best 5 Star bar on the island! Best Bratwurst in Put-In-Bay!…read moreGreat selection of beers! Full bar...

I am a "cheap eats" kind of person, and quality cheap eats are hard to find on Put-in-Bay, Ohio…read more While on PIB, through Yelp, I found Joe's Bar and Restaurant. Although it's outside the main area of eateries around the docks, I decided to give it a try. Before leaving my room, I perused the menu, and on my walk over, I debated my choices: maybe a hot dog with homemade slaw, or a Southwest burger with chipotle sauce, bacon, and pepper jack cheese. Hmmm... Upon arrival, I asked for a menu, and the bartender slapped a wrinkled one on the bar. The first thing I saw was the "Sloppy Scotty," which the menu proclaimed, "It's what put us on the map!" I immediately knew that was what I had to have. I ordered a Maker's Mark with ginger ale, in which the Maker's Mark was liberally poured, and I sat down to await my meal. Service was quick, and when presented with my meal, the first thing I noted was that the hot dog bun was toasted on the outside. It was still a hot dog bun, but the outside kind of looked like Texas toast--just thinner--with Joe's signature "Sloppy Sauce" applied liberally on top, intermixed with mozzarella cheese, and topped with onions. It looked fantastic and tasted even better. It was absolutely delicious. I had an extra Maker's Mark just for good measure and was presented with a $27 bill. The night before, at a different restaurant, I had a couple of beers and a medium-sized perch plate, which was good but cost me $50. Do yourself a favor: if you find yourself on PIB, drop by the unassuming Joe's Bar and Restaurant to grab a bite. You won't be disappointed.

Very good! Service was great. Food was fast and hot. Would definitely come back ! Loved the…read moresetting, very clean.

Been here twice now. I'm an east-sider and don't really make it this far west of Cleveland very…read moreoften, but after taking a couple of group classes in Elyria over the past couple of months, a small group from our class wanted to eat somewhere other than the mundane national chain staples. The first time I found Black River Tavern, I had no idea it was set on a golf course. The restaurant itself is very casual, but elegantly casual. The food: awesome! I got a burger. The burger was great, but the fries were the highlight. Reasonable prices and friendly staff! So the next time I was out there for the class, I suggested we go again! We enjoyed it just as much. And the next time I'm out that way, I certainly wouldn't hesitate to go again. Great place to relax, have a meal, some drinks, and hang out with friends!