Love this place! I'm from Old Forge Pizza capital of world! Waymart ranks with then on square pizza. Love it!!!! read more

Waymart Hotel Restaurant - Since 1848 - Pizza Near Me - Waymart, Pennsylvania

Let me start by saying that I've gotten takeout from here many times and the food is always good. That said, my experience tonight wasn't great. Had two different waitresses and both weren't great. One was too busy with a big table to help the smaller tables and the other was too busy spending 10+ minutes talking to friends at one table. And then towards the end of our visit they were both too busy chatting at the bar. Food taste was decent. Dumpster fries had good flavor but were soggy because they sat too long. Pizza was ok but didn't seem like wood fired pizza and was light on the pulled pork. Willing to give this place another shot but won't go back if I have another experience like tonight. read more

Waymart Hotel Restaurant - Smoked pork wood fire pizza - Pizza Near Me - Waymart, Pennsylvania

See all

We just can't get our timing right!! Always stealing away to the Waymart, off-season. We've HEARD, that they have an incredible outdoor grill setup...We've HEARD, that the Wrangler BBQ pit was custom made in Indiana...We've HEARD, that the cherry and applewood smoked meats are on display under their pavilion....But We've only been able to TASTE their winter options; an award-winning tray of Old Fashion square (sweeter sauce, two cheese blend), a toasted Cuban with seasoned gravy fries and a crock of French onion soup to boot. It really hit the spot as we split town for the Catskills, and began our journey with some NEPA non-negotiables. Guess we'll have to find our way back once the winter weather breaks. read more

See all

We did not like the food at all! The pizza was so cheesy and gooey, almost tasted undercooked. My kids wouldn't take a second bite. Cute atmosphere but would not return. read more

Served cold had to send meal back salty Service only 1 waitress with lot of tables and exhausted under staff Anbiance looks like farm house kitchen read more

I forgot to take pics of the food, but the bbq was good and plentiful. We shared a combo platter because we saw everyone with to go boxes. The pizzas are big too. Had a few drinks enjoyed the Wild West vibe of this gem. Nice servers and cool location. Most of my pics are of the grounds. You could have a beautiful wedding here. Or any celebration. It's simply beautiful and well designed. read more

See all

I had heard about the Waymart Hotel for many years, but hadn't had a chance to come here until last summer. My wife and I joined our family for dinner and we ate outside in the covered patio in the back of the restaurant. We had potato pancakes to start and while they were a bit dark, they had great flavor and tasted really good with the classic apple sauce and sour cream. My wife had BBQ chicken and I had a brisket sandwich and both of our meals were tasty and very filling. It's a place to get a no-frills tasty meal in an area that doesn't have a lot of dining options and we'd come back here again. read more

See all

This is a mixed review! We came to check out the bbq and both of us agreed that the dinners could have been delicious if they were served hot! They were not even warm! It seemed that the waitstaff could not keep up with the tables and the food wasn't getting served timely from the kitchen. The venue had a fun summertime vibe and the staff were nice enough. It's too bad that they didn't have more help to handle the tables! read more

BBQ was great - there was enough to take half home for lunch the next day. Service was very good.

Just wanted to give a shoutout to Adrian, our waiter tonight! He was professional, yet friendly and very attentive to our needs! Thank you! read more

Food was enough for 3 meals. Huge portions. Servicer was very nice and helpful. Would recommend their pizza and the all the other options.

Ordered stuff pepper special with pasta and linguine with whit clam sauce. Not sure if anybody taste the food they serve Sauces both the white and red sauce totally without any character or flavor does the kitchen staff taste what they serve The salads where fresh the garlic bread was good pasta was cooked correctly Stuff pepper was decent Service was good but my lord those sauces where nasty read more

I work nearby so I visit for lunch when craving the white pizza with tomato! I also like the double crusted cheesesteak pizza, which I take home for the fam who also enjoys it -- We really like the cheese mixture they use. Service is usually great when I eat in. read more

Waymart Hotel Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Waymart, Pennsylvania

My brother and sister-in-law held their son's high school graduation at the hotel today. The two female waitresses were drinking on the job after refusing to serve guests from the bar "because no one was tipping them". The gratuity on this event was $750.00 and pre paid. I guess that wasn't enough. I would NEVER recommend holding an event there given the rude and unprofessional way these two people treated my brother and sister in law. The one server was the owners wife. You can't make this shit up. I'll never step foot in that place again. read more

Service excellent, food is so so. Much better 10 years ago. Save your money. Drive to Lukans in Hawley for great family dining

I would give no stars! Staff were rude and dismissive! Kept saying we are busy! Open tables and they would not bus them. People left... we took an open table and cleaned it after waitress said OK ... whatever. Table was dirty and the staff walked by... people came in after and were given drinks and clams (clam night). The one server told the table next to us clams sold out. It was 5:15 and they opened at 4 and we waited 45 min. We left starving and irritated. Food not good enough to wait this long or treat customers like garbage. We left after no one taking a drink order for almost 45 min at a table. Save yourself a miserable experience! read more

Came at 1230 on a busy sunday. Girlfriend use to live in area so she came for the pizza and loved it still... sadly, not my type. American cheese, bland sauce and dough, and just aweful but she gave it 5 / 5 stars. Go figure. Now the bbq is amazing! Brisket is some the best I've ever had. Pulled pork amazing. Smoked sausage was as long as my sons arm. Ribs n everything else phenominal!! Home made sauces and pickles too..... bbq was amazing and when we drive 4 hrs back to visit family in area we will def come here. Girlfriend for their pizza and me to devour insane good bbq!! read more

Waymart Hotel Restaurant - Brisket sammich! - Pizza Near Me - Waymart, Pennsylvania

This is a fun, hopping place. I had no idea it was here and so popular particularly with families. The bbq ribs were excellent. The brisket was average, a little too dry. Beans, baked potato and corn were great. The place is big enough that you can still enjoy your dining experience even if you did not bring your own little kids. A great place to go with family or a group of friends. If it's just the two of you, maybe sit at the bar. read more

Love it here ! Great food great service all around amazing place. Go to place for an amazing meal!

Ooey gooey crave-able goodness! The Original Red Pizza is unique and maybe an acquired taste.... One I definitely missed the last 5 years. First stop after landing....Ice cold Stella, a praiseworthy Pierogie and an amazing slice and I am a very happy girl! Would have gave 5 stars but kitchen was super slow to have an almost empty dining room. read more

Waymart Hotel Restaurant - Original Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Waymart, Pennsylvania

See all

Great food! Especially in the summer when the BBQ pit is open and you can eat outside. Best pizza EVER!

Fried chicken sent back once so black could not cut with a knife replacement so over cooked could not eat service was great drinks great just don't eat read more

First time here after hearing great things from friends. The burger was FANTASTIC. Cooked perfect and juicy. We also ordered the pot stickers steamed and loved them and onion rings....another winner. Will definitely be back. Looking forward to eating outside BBQ in summer and car show Thursdays! read more

We had high hopes for this place but we're very disappointed. Nice looking place but food was awful. Easier to say what was good, the beans coleslaw. Nothing was hot, cornbread was cold. Ribs were just ok, chicken was dry, pulled pork looked awful and didn't taste good and the brisket looked like strips of uncooked bacon. My potato was brown inside and the corn on the cob was inedible. Waitress was very nice and we only waited about 20 min to get our food. The pizza at the next table looked awful. With 2 beers and an iced tea our bill was $89.00. read more

I have never had worse service. First the waitress is clearly overworked and stressed out, you can tell by the way she slams your drinks down and barely breathes to say hello before "what are you having" came out of her mouth. 2nd my husband's food came out a good 20 min before the rest of our order so by the time my orders on the table he's done with dinner. Not sure what kind of service this is but not worth the 50 dollars they required when the bill was on the table. She's lucky my husband felt bad, if it was up to me I would have refused to pay for the meal that wasn't eaten with the rest of my family. read more

Just awful! Don't bother! Terrible service from an angry snowflake, lousy food, and flies everywhere including the food. Waitress forgot to enter an entree so one of our group of 7 never got served. One order came out after everyone else was finished. We had to share dinners. No refills, couldn't get drinks, never saw the waitress after she screwed up the order. Place has gone down hill tremendously. WON'T BE BACK! read more

Only heard good things about this place from locals enough for me to go there for the car show and dinner

Relaxed atmosphere and great food and servers. One of my favorite go to places for drinks and dinner. Thursday nights are classic car night where you can show off your classic car or enjoy looking at them. The patio and the covered deck are the best spots. The landscape is beautiful with so many unique features. Never a disappointment read more

First off, I do not review restaurants often. I need an out of this world experience OR a nightmare in order to take the time to review a restaurant on here. Sadly my first experience at Waymart was more of the latter. We had a 6:45pm Friday night reservation (after the woman on the phone told me I likely didn't need the reservation). We showed up right on time and we weren't seated until 7:10pm. The hostess told us they didn't save a table (and we weren't the only ones with reservations waiting to be seated). After finally getting a table, we waited nearly 10 minutes for the server to show up. It took so long that we gave food and drink orders when she finally did get to us. The restaurant was clearly understaffed and our poor server was literally running from table to table, and back & forth to the kitchen. They have tons of seating in the back but they didn't have the staffing to cover the normal outdoor service, let alone that extra area. Our skewered Old Bay shrimp appetizer was cold when it arrived, so we had the server take it back to reheat it. Once the actual food arrived, the orders were all botched. My girlfriend and I ordered BBQ chicken and pulled pork, and we got ribs and brisket instead (the server allowed us to take those home after she brought us the correct food). My brother's wings showed up after the rest of us were done eating (~20 mins+) after the first entree was served. The server comped those, which was nice. The whole fiasco seemingly took forever & there wasn't much of a way to order more drinks unless we walked to the bar ourselves. My beef (no pun intended) with this whole situation is not necessarily the poor experience, it's more-so the fact that the server is the one really hurting in this situation. I asked her straight up if they were understaffed and she reluctantly admitted they were. People everywhere seemed pissed off & this will directly impact tips (the server's pay). This falls on the manager / owner, who was clearly absent tonight as no one was walking around helping or asking about the experience. The food wasn't bad, but the whole experience certainly wasn't worth the hassle of driving to all the way out to Waymart to pay more than I would've in Scranton or Dickson City. read more

We have been going here twice a summer and occasionally during winter for years. It can get really crowded for bbq during summer and now being short staffed everywhere you go I am happy they are still here! Went for cruise night mid august 2022 and it was the best we've had so far! It was not super busy cause we were able to sit at bar outside then move to outside table. Two different combos, Mac n cheese. Wings, beers. Sure some years a potato is slightly underdone or u need to wait pretty long time for a refill or the check but our experience here either for just two or the whole family has always been good to great. read more

Really like having dinner here! The staff is so kind and efficient, the food is really good. We've been here a few times and haven't had a bad meal. read more

Came in this afternoon for an early lunch. Not sure what the other reviewers wrote, but for us New Yorker's this is one of the BEST restaurants around! Everything tasted fresh not frozen, the ribs were delicious with the meat falling off the bone. The pizza is yummy, yes not New York pizza, but again you are not in Ny so there is no comparison. However, the cheese on the pizza was melted to perfection! Dumpster fries are a must, such a messy yet tasty appetizer. Caitlin was our server and she was extremely sweet, helpful, attentive, offered awesome suggestions, and most importantly aimed to please her customers! She always had a smile on her face and did not mind that we were from out of town like we have experienced in other places. Felicia was another young lady who helped us as well, not only is her service impeccable but she is amazing with children! Talked and played with our daughter which allowed us a few minutes to enjoy to ourselves! Thank you for that! For a busy afternoon, there was no wait, and unlike every other restaurant in the nearby areas, the food does not take long at all! After you enjoy your delicious meal take a stroll on the property. It is breathtaking! The waterfall is a beautiful touch. This place is our go to every time we are here and I would recommend anyone to enjoy their BBQ food!! read more

Have been getting their sausage and pepper pizza for years. Have eaten at most pizza places in the valley to Old Forge, and put it up there. I personally think OF pizza is overrated. We've been going to the BBQ Pit for the past few years, and never disappoints. Can't speak to other items on the menu, but these two things are worth the trip. Never had a problem with the service, which I always notice since I worked in the industry for years. read more

Food is definitely 10/10, but service is pretty terrible. Difficult to get a refill, waters, your bill, etc.

Horrible service cook came out to argue that she did not burn my food when on fact the waitress told us it was a hockey puck and was not able to serve it to me when my husband amd son received their meal. I was going to have to wait THEN when finally bringing me my food out after waiting again the waitress fell with it . I am not mad at the waitress shit happens BUT the nasty woman the cook with no teeth who argued about when my order was put in because I asked for a discount our to waiting so long when my family was already finished eating??? OMG told her to just take off bill not waiting again and any normal establishment would have gave a discount horrible customer service horrible food learn to cook your food is overpriced and sucks read more

We usually like stopping here for a drink and a casual dinner but wow today was interesting.... We were sitting at the outside bar when one of the servers, (baseball cap and long pigtails) actually put her foot up on the behind the bar counter (next to the knife and other bar utensils) to TIE HER SHOE!! 2 minutes later another server cut lemons for drinks right where the dirty shoe was!! Disgusting! read more

Just to cover what most people have commented on, the pizza is...different. No, it's not going to threaten any of the great pizza houses of New York, but it is tasty. Like Pizza Hut or Little Caesar's, I can see there being a time I might crave this American Cheese pizza. But the real star of this place is the BBQ. The beef brisket is tender and smokey and the sauce is well spiced. My wife's pulled pork sandwich was outrageously flavorful and she raved, bite after bite. After dinner and appetizers for 7 adults and 1 child, plus a tray of pizza, 8 beers and multiple sodas came to only $134, the Waymart Hotel & Wrangler's BBQ Pit gets an easy 5 star review. read more

See all

I would NOT recommend coming here to eat. Food was nothing special, pricey, service was slow, there was a dead fly in my fries, smothered by cheese sauce, and my family was not satisfied with their meals and wings, saying they tasted strange or flavorless and weren't the flavors they asked for. HOWEVER. And this is a big however. This place shines in it's pizza. We've been getting it forever, ever since I was born and WOW it's delicious. Everyone in the area either loves or hates this pizza, but I promise its amazing. Don't sit and eat, order their pizza for takeout and eat it at home with the family. read more

Perfectly executed! Extra crispy bark pink layer directly under (that means its done right) Juicy white meat And dark meat Sauce is good Like how they throw a lil extra on top And that real smoke read more

Waymart Hotel Restaurant - Boom Ribs. Me and Pork are friends:p - Pizza Near Me - Waymart, Pennsylvania

terrible service, walked into an empty restaurant, after receiving drinks we said we were ready to order buwere made to wait, Then we were ignored for thirty minutes while a table that came in after us was attended to, there was also another table that was ignored as well that came in after. never again, zero stars read more