Wife and I were wondering where to eat and saw the Black Dog Tavern open. Did. It realize the…read morestory behind the Black Dog which was quite interesting. The clam chowdah was amazing. And I am picky on chowdah. The croutons were a great touch. Waitress was very nice and explained the Black Dog story. Was great for tavern food, reasonably priced for MV. Highly recommend.

PROS: This is the oldest tavern on the island and one of the oldest in the country! Food is…read moreamazing, everything is well priced, atmosphere is older than dirt, and it has a nice view of the water. Natasha, the waitress was super nice! CONS: very minimal parking out front and there's only two bathrooms that hold one person each OVERALL: I highly recommend coming here if you're on this island! Especially if you enjoy history

Staff very accomodating, provides great service. Some of the seating is very cozy, makes you feel…read morelike you came with the people sitting next to you, but defiworth a visit for a great breakfast or brunch. We took a natural juice to sip on our walk home. I even ordered almond crusted French toast to go home with. Good thing I did, because the rain caused us to spend time indoors and take a long nap. Did I say the food was tasty? Worth the 1 hour wait outside the entrance.

This restaurant is a Vineyard institution but is always crazy busy during the summer. We came in…read moreearly October for lunch, and got right in. What a charming place! So cute inside and loved the counter and kitchen visibility. The menu is varied and interesting. My husband had the "Cobb Salad" which was delicious, but I'm not sure why they call it a Cobb. Definitely different ingredients than a traditional one. We asked for extra dressing on the side, which it definitely needed. I had the fried chicken & waffles with hot honey (a special) and it was amazing!! It came with 3 large and 1 small piece of boneless chicken, and my only complaint is that 2 of the pieces were hot, and 2 were lukewarm. And they were out of iced tea. But definitely recommend.

Sorry to say a) pie was not great and b) the price was psychotic…read moreover rated and way over priced

We've enjoyed 4 different pies and they were all exceptional! And I love to bake pies. Highly…read morehighly recommend Pie Chicks

Olive was a great server and the cook was amazing!! Drinks and food were over the top!!read more

My order: Fish and chips (gluten free) and margarita with Tajin…read moreThe Review: I can't pass up a beautiful patio, and Fish was perfect. We were greeted by very attentive staff, who explained all of the gluten free options (which were plentiful). Most importantly, the margaritas were strong and we were able to choose the rim, so we went with Tajin! As for the food, it's not every day that you find GF fish and chips, so we went for it. It was delicious and crunchy, with a great tartar sauce. Why four stars? The slaw was a bit drenched in sauce and thus difficult to eat--I would have loved a crisp and crunchy slaw. Additionally, we got French fries that were still frozen mixed in with cooked ones. Luckily, the staff speedily replaced them. A low key, pleasant night out, I would still definitely recommend Fish to both visitors and islanders alike!

Excellent apps and main. Including a Sunday Roast. Poutine is especially good…read more Friendly staff Warm atmosphere

We went to The Attic for dinner and had a bit of a mixed experience. On the positive side, the food…read morewas delicious and we really enjoyed the warm, cozy atmosphere--it's a great spot in terms of ambiance. Unfortunately, the service left a lot to be desired. Our server made several mistakes throughout the evening and had an unexpectedly aggressive attitude. He forgot my sister's wine twice, brought out an incorrect order, and mishandled my mom's dessert request. There was also confusion around the dessert order. My mom wanted one scoop of gelato and asked about the available flavors. The server was very unclear, using "sorbet" and "gelato" interchangeably throughout the conversation. In the end, she ordered one scoop of "lemon gelato," as he described it, which should have been $3. So we were surprised when the bill came and showed a $14 charge for lemon sorbet--which wasn't even listed on the menu. When we pointed this out, the server responded in a pretty surly manner, though the charge was eventually corrected. After we paid, he brought over a scoop of vanilla gelato and said it was "on him," but the delivery felt sarcastic and he placed it on the table quite aggressively. By that point, we were already full and honestly just ready to leave. Overall, the food and atmosphere were great, but the poor service really put a damper on the evening and left us ending the night on a negative note. Since we were a party of six, a 20% gratuity was automatically added to our bill, which was unfortunate given the level of service we received.

I had the breakfast burrito. It was delicious. The coffee was average. They forgot to put sausage…read moreon my wife's breakfast sandwich. There's no place to sit. It was raining out so you couldn't sit on the deck. So we left and ate in the car, but by that time it was too late to go back and tell them they messed up on the breakfast sandwich. Oh well. Counter service only, no indoor seating.

Loved the gluten and dairy free options. They had a vegan and gluten free chocolate cookie that was…read moreso delicious. They also are able to make an egg burrito into a bowl and the have gluten free toast. I did not enjoy the iced coffee. It seems they use hot coffee and put over ice and then the ice melts and it doesn't taste the same. Also, they need to clean up to front of the store. They are storing all sorts of drinks when you walk win and it looks messy.

4.5 Came here for…read moredinner, 3 of us, thinking we had made a reservation which apparently didn't go through. But they graciously squeezed us in (although were moved half way through). Really beautiful setting and ambience. Some dishes were amazingly delicious like the Brussels , the fish, the butterscotch pudding. Boulliabase was disappointing for me - very salty. But overall a great dinner and night!

We capped off our day trip to MV with dinner at Beach Road, and the meal did not disappoint!…read more We came as a large group for a celebration, and both the service and the sunset views were phenomenal. The vibes felt very relaxed and charming, yet still sophisticated and upscale at the same time. Service was attentive and friendly, and they were very knowledgeable about the menu. All of the seafood that we ate was delicious - the hamachi crudo was fresh with well-balanced flavors, and the spanish octopus was tender. We got the atlantic cod and bouillabaisse as mains, both excellent. Would definitely return for a special night out!

I am recovering from surgery and my daughter bought Italian Wedding Soup for me from Rocco's. It…read morewas delicious!! I called them a few days later to order more. I told the young woman who answered the phone that I was recovering from surgery. She very kindly offered to bring the soup to the car for me so I didn't have to walk in myself. What a pleasant surprise! The entire crew at Rocco's is always great...and this gesture was more proof that they care about their customers. Thank you Rocco's!!!

Rocco's Pizza absolutely knocks it out of the park every single time. This is our family's (and our…read morerestaurant family's) go-to spot for pizza and Italian dishes, and for good reason--the food is consistently incredible. The pizza is everything you want: perfectly crisp crust, rich sauce, and generous, high-quality toppings. You can tell they care about every detail. Beyond the pizza, their Italian dishes are just as impressive--comforting, flavorful, and clearly made with experience and pride. The atmosphere is welcoming, the staff treats you like family, and the whole place has that rare, authentic vibe that keeps you coming back. If you're looking for a place that delivers both quality and heart, Rocco's is it. Easily 5 stars.