BLUF: Sweet tooth heaven - whimsical exterior with beautiful dessert cases on the interior…read more This charming bakery is a great stop for anyone who loves homemade baked goods. The cheesecake was rich, creamy, and absolutely divine. The carrot cake was also delicious, though I would've loved a bit more frosting. We also tried a white cake that was dense and reminiscent of a classic wedding cake. But ohh, the cheesecake, the clear winner. The shop itself is adorable, with a whimsical vibe and friendly staff . We enjoyed our first visit so much, we went back the next day! The selection was a bit different on day two so I am glad we gave it another whirl. One of my favorite touches was the exterior--those cupcake cutouts in the fence are just too cute! This bakery is perfect for treating yourself. --- Let me know if there's anything else you'd like to add!

Stopped in for a quick snack while walking around Vineyard Haven. The apple turnover was great. The…read morescones were huge and delicious. We also got the lemon bar, but found the icing too sweet for our liking. Overall we would go back to try more items!

These pies are outstanding. We ordered the apple pie and the pumpkin pie for Thanksgiving. We were…read moreable to place the order up in advance. The staff was friendly, fun and answered all my questions . We picked up the pies at the appointed time and had them for Thanksgiving. They were absolutely DELICIOUS. In fact the pumpkin pie may have been one of the best pies I've ever tasted. Silky, smooth and spiced just right . I have tried their other pies before, chocolate pie, chicken pot pie and their quiche. I've never had an issue with the quality or the service at this wonderful establishment in Falmouth.

The BEST pumpkin pie ever. Not afraid to use spice! Blueberry pie was excellent too. Loved the…read morecrispy, golden crust on both. Great cookies too, definitely give them a try.

PROS: Place had public restrooms, there was a good amount of places to sit, staff was friendly, and…read morethis place was conveniently located near center of shopping district CONS: The guy screwed up the order and also overcharged my friends OVERALL: Just make sure when the person is making your order you watch them carefully and make sure you're charged the correct amount. Otherwise, this place is very nice

We came later in the day and only got a few things. All they had left for fresh bread were…read morebaguettes which was fine with us. Also got pistachio and chocolate chip muffins which were good too. Friendly staff and overall good experience.

Love the nantucket bake shop!! Best donuts and pastries on island - the Boston Creme is out of this…read moreworld. And love their cookies esp the thumbprints. Easy to park and get in and out

Incredible donuts? I think so, although I've been enjoying them for 40 years so nostalgia may play…read morea part. Friendly staff, incredible donuts that sell out, so get there in the morning. Bread-wise - I go with Something Natural vs Bakeshop, so I can't attest. I didn't indulge in their other goodies, but a lineup of coffee cakes, scones, cupcakes and pies are available both fresh and a few in the freezer to be reheated at home. A Nantucket donut staple if you prefer the non cake variety. While I still love me the Downey Flake for their cake donuts, this spot has more variety. I love me their jelly donut so much made with the most lovely raspberry jam. Coffee is out of a self serve pot vs special espresso drinks and the likes, but Espresso Cafe to go is a few doors down.

3rd time visiting Nantucket and have never been able to score one of the famous morning buns. We…read morealmost didn't try this time because we called ahead and were told "we're out right now". After some research, we decided that meant they would be making more, so we walked there and sure enough, there was a fresh tray! We debated about splitting one but got one each and it was totally the right call. They are so good, a bit like a cross between a popover, a croissant and a churro. Worth the wait!

This place is always busy...and they always set such high standards! Food, service and…read moreappreciation is 120%!

We were lucky enough to find Iggy's open early on Fourth of July morning. There was no line because…read morethey are typically not open until later in the day. The shop itself is sun-dappled and very cute if a bit sparsely populated. We snagged a loaf of sharp sourdough along with a plain, chocolate and almond croissant. All of the treats and the bread were delicious!

Delicious. Got the croissants, sticky bun, sourdough rolls, Parmesan bread sticks. All great, but…read morea long line Saturday morning. We wish they were open more days - and the website is a bit confusing.

The baking is still very good…read more The shop is dingy and bare. The exterior is unkempt and uncomfortable. The oatmeal I was just served was gloppy mush with no texture, swimming in browned butter, and served in a bag with a fork and some oyster crackers. I get the impression that they're limping along as a business. If you want some cookies or a coffee cake and you're in the neighborhood, then go for it. If you want to eat, head to the Scottish.

The food here is always good! Breakfast is tasty. I love their lentil curry soup especially in the…read morefall. My favorite is the Grey Barn Bratwurst with saurerkraut, but that is to be no more. Hopefully they find a good alternative supplier. Call your order in ahead in season 'cuz it gets crazy busy.

I am so glad I found Centerville Pies on a work trip! Their quiche was a perfect addition to my…read moremorning rush, ensuring I was eating something substantial. I tried mini mixed berry and pumpkin pies, and hope to go back sometime soon for full size. The staff at the counter were kind and patient with my extended decision-making process!

The worst chicken pie I have ever tasted. Threw it away. Vey strange smell...turned my stomach.read more