We enjoyed great service, the outdoor seating, and the cocktails. Chips and guac/pico: The guacamole was really good! That was eaten almost immediately. The pico needed salt (was the consensus). Baja bowl w/ steak: This was fine, nothing very special or unique, just solid. I would have preferred bit more steak, but otherwise this was a good non fish option. Carne asada tacos: These are decent tacos but they aren't going to blow your socks off. The hot sauce helped a lot. The rest of my party really emjoyed their Poke bowls, lobster rolls, oysters, and shrimp tacos Churros: Two dipping sauces and three extra long church's were really good! I also liked the ice cream with it. Key lime pie: This was very good key lime pie! Someone in my party prefers theirs almost frozen (crazy) but this was silky and not overly sweet. read more

Ordered for takeout and I guess they forgot to charge me, they hung up the phone at order and sent me away at pickup... Didnt even occur to me until they left me a voicemail, then proceeded to call me SEVEN TIMES within a day *even though I already said I would come take care of it* instead if accepting their mistake as a loss. A two-appetizer order cost FIFTY DOLLARS and the harassment was priceless. Will not be coming here again read more

Visited during a week day afternoon with no reservation. Quickly greeted and seated on the front patio area with couch and surrounding low stools (if you need back support I would recommend sitting inside) we were promptly served. I had their frose cocktail which was well mixed and refreshing. The elote was more of a chilled dip which was different for me and it was very spicy. The tacos were basic fish tacos with toppings and the size of the three tacos was filling for a lunch portion. $$ read more

So good. So this place does have indoor seating. Just ask we sat outside. It was shaded. But it there is no breeze it gets humid. Maybe bring one of those hand fans. Food was great. Crab cakes, shrimp tacos and fish tacos. read more

Fish MV - Seafood Near Me - Tisbury, Massachusetts

My order: Fish and chips (gluten free) and margarita with Tajin The Review: I can't pass up a beautiful patio, and Fish was perfect. We were greeted by very attentive staff, who explained all of the gluten free options (which were plentiful). Most importantly, the margaritas were strong and we were able to choose the rim, so we went with Tajin! As for the food, it's not every day that you find GF fish and chips, so we went for it. It was delicious and crunchy, with a great tartar sauce. Why four stars? The slaw was a bit drenched in sauce and thus difficult to eat--I would have loved a crisp and crunchy slaw. Additionally, we got French fries that were still frozen mixed in with cooked ones. Luckily, the staff speedily replaced them. A low key, pleasant night out, I would still definitely recommend Fish to both visitors and islanders alike! read more

Fish MV - Seafood Near Me - Tisbury, Massachusetts

See all

Food was excellent. I had the beef tacos. My wife had the fish tacos. Billy was excellent . He serviced us extremely well. Cute little restaurant with some nice tables inside. The outside was full so we sat inside. Didn't care because it was a little chilly outside. Try it. You will love it. read more

Olive was a great server and the cook was amazing!! Drinks and food were over the top!! read more

Fish MV - Seafood Near Me - Tisbury, Massachusetts

This place is great, love the patio seating and the servers were nice. Food was good too! We got 2 dozen oysters and the lobster sliders. I'd say the lobster was a little over cooked but still good. The crispy rice with the spicy tuna poke looked yummy! Gonna try those next time. read more

Fish MV - Lobster sliders - Seafood Near Me - Tisbury, Massachusetts

Yum!!! Can be the one and only word to describe this gem. Got their lobster roll "warm" didn't see it on the menu but you can order it. A ton of lobster. With lobster rolls...it can be overly dressed or you let the lobster speak for itself. In this case the I think the lobster coulda used a touch more butter. The bread was buttered and toasted to perfection! The clam chowder was out of this world. Creamy, rich, flavorful, garlicky... I had last bit I could gather from the bowl. The oysters were super fresh. Went well with the cocktail sauce and vinegar. Shout out to the staff for caring Theit patrons and making sure they enjoy their food the best possible way. Ten out of ten! Highly recommend! read more

See all

not enjoyable in the slightest tbh. the avocado was hard, not a single other thing had flavor. It definitely needed (more) spicy mayo or soy sauce. I've been dying to try this place for years so this was a little disappointing, but maybe I just ordered the wrong thing on a bad night. On the other hand, the staff was so sweet, and the ambiance was perfect!! it was a perfect night to sit outside. read more

Fish MV - mushroom poke bowl - Seafood Near Me - Tisbury, Massachusetts

What a wonderful little spot! You would never know you were sitting right along Main Street, vineyard haven while eating here! The plants and the decking area is such a beautiful spot!! I took my daughter and my daughter in law here for lunch and we were very pleasantly surprised with our experience! Great cocktails and delicious food. We shared a couple of appetizers and they were fresh and yummy! Our waitress was sweet and kind. We enjoyed ourselves very much! read more

I really like this restaurant. It's a solid spot for seafood in MV. It definitely has more of a Mexican vibe to it which I really like. They have tacos, poke bowls, quesadillas, and more. Outdoor seating is really nice and spacious. Food tasted high quality and everything was good. The guac was super chunky and fresh. Poke bowl had lots of good veggies in it. Portions are generous. Would recommend. read more

See all

What a great restaurant! The new menu is a great, the frozen drinks are amazing! So happy with the table service (very nice and welcoming staff); everything moves more smoothly and the ambiance is nicer. Definitely a good choice for all these changes! read more

great choices and vegan options, but not the best food or service. Guac and salsa had no flavor at all, inedible clam chowder, cold tacos, etc. I wouldn't recommend. read more

Fish MV - Mushroom tacos - Seafood Near Me - Tisbury, Massachusetts

love the new full service feature. Great staff and very hardworking. Food and drinks amazing too read more

The long awaited opening of FISH, or Fish MV has arrived. The menu is clearly a cut above most other seafood restaurants in Vineyardhaven and so is the level of service and feel. The feel is upscale casual - certainly comfortable. To become the leader on fresh seafood, FISH will have to maintain a solid level of exceptionally fresh food for an extended period of time. The current champs being The Net Result and Sandy's. The staff is exceptional in every way. They are friendly, knowledgeable, welcoming, polite and professional The outside seating on the deck was brisk all day. It's brand new and huge!! The menu is interesting and large enough to offer something for everyone. Kids are welcome. Everything is done right, or done to order. The calamari for example was light, greaseless, and offered Rhode Island style which means hot peppers - unless you ask they not be included. Time to work my way through the menu. FISH definitely should be on everyone's must dine list! read more

Fish MV - Menu - Seafood Near Me - Tisbury, Massachusetts

See all

Fresh cocktails and food, highly recommend for a low key vibe, water views and good food.

Delicious surprise ending a glorious vacation! Comfortable patio setting, excellent spot to grab a quick lunch before heading to the ferry! We were served a bowl of clam chowder fit for a queen! Filled with seafood rich and creamywe left the island stuffed! read more

Fish MV - Creamy clam chowder filled with seafood. - Seafood Near Me - Tisbury, Massachusetts

See all

Fish is a great new dining experience in Vineyard Haven. Although it was early, they still had a fairly good crowd. Place is well appointed and the vibe is great. We stopped by for a last minute meal before leaving the island. The wine was crisp and cold and the clam chowder delightful. Service was stellar. read more

See all

Perfect location. Friendly staff. Beautiful food and drinks. Losing one star because while the food was good (and pretty), it wasn't GREAT and was short on flavor. I was disappointed in what I got and next time will get something different. The guacamole tasted like the avocados had been preserved/frozen. The ceviche was better than the guac, but still was missing a *wow* factor that I expected. read more

Fish MV - Guacamole Local Cod Ceviche - Seafood Near Me - Tisbury, Massachusetts

The ambiance of this place is super cute, and the patio with outdoor seating is great! The service was alright- it's the style where you order inside at the counter, and sit down outside and they'll bring it to you. The food was ho-hum. We ordered clam chowder, and it was more like stew than chowder- not much flavor. The lobster roll was a huge let down- super super dry and no flavor. The calamari was average. The fish tacos and sushi roll were actually pretty good! Might come back for those two things and the cute ambiance, but overall, with so many other great restaurants on the vineyard, this one did not stand out. read more

The new waitress service format rocks. We went with friends for an outdoor Father's Day lunch and had a great time. Everything was perfect from the beginning. The hostess was welcoming and let us select our table. Service was attentive and helpful. Food was excellent. Cottage City Oysters are a must! Calamari was done to perfection. Guacamole tasty. Chilled lobster tail a perfect size for a light lunch. Be a regular and join their frequent diner program. You won't be disappointed. read more

Food just bland and bad and expensive. Self service ordering and table delivery. Then they pretty much ignored us. Everything about this place was disappointing . read more

Nice place to dine and the food was delicious. Service was great too! I've added to my favorites.

We ate here on 09/18/2024. Loved it! Enjoyed happy hour on the outdoor deck. The tables are comfortably spaced, good ambiance, nice view, nice level of background music. The happy hour specials included crab cakes, fried oysters, ceviche, and shrimp cocktail, among other small bites. Everything was well prepared and delicious! Probably the best fried oysters we've ever had. Good wine selection. too. The bottle of pinot noir was very good and was a nice match for the food. The staff was super nice, too. Very helpful in figuring out the menu and making recommendations. Service was timed just right - not too fast or too slow. A special shout-out to Kat - terrific server, and we really enjoyed speaking with her. We'll be back! read more

Really tasty food and drinks! We hopped off the ferry and despite the inconsistent reviews, super happy we gave it a chance! Our server (Stephanie?) was so sweet. The chicken bowl was very good and the shrimp tacos were outstanding! Great frozen drinks too, hubby got the rum runner and I had one of the raspberry martinis, both excellent. read more

There is no better place on the Vineyard to sit on the deck, enjoy the ferry coming into port, sipping a mojito or margarita and eating some appetizers and watching the sunset! The addition of the overhead sails offer necessary shade and the later night after sunset heaters are perfectly placed to keep you comfortable. This IS the place for a cocktail and a bite to grab. Sit near the decks edge to be a people watcher of everyone in town that comes by!! I'll be back often!! My place for summer of 2022! read more

Here is review of a restaurant that is one "not" to experience. Fish Tales MV is the kind of resort place you find all over: over inflating all the prices. ($21 Dollars for tortilla chips and bland salsa and guacamole. And not a large sharing amount either. ) The ordering experience is weird... you order inside... but the wait time was crazy. We waited for an hour for some poke bowls and we were one of the last tables on a Monday Night. The reason I was given for the wait was they had a 16 top. I hate being told "we had a 16 top". Is this a proper excuse for 5 paying patrons to have a bad experience? We had to wait for our food with no word from the waitstaff or apology. No one offered my party of 5 any thing to make up for an hour wait. We were finally told the kitchen was closing so we said we have been waiting forever for our meals. We asked for more tortilla chips, the $21 chips. We were told we had to pay extra for extra tortilla Chips. Really? When the food came out, it was totally lacking in flavor. No seasoning. I am not a salt user. I had to beg for salt for my pork belly bowl. When the other people in my party asked for soy sauce, we were told that may be extra. Pay for Soy Sauce for bland food? The chef did not do his job. I so wanted to like this dinner. We were starved. The kitchen turned out the most flavorless food. Please someone send that chef on a culinary tour to find out about flavor. The food I had at the airport restaurant before I left this morning was so flavorful compared to this meal at Fish MV and cheaper. The pork belly bowl as a great concept. The quality of the ingredients shows that the chef knows something. But no flavor! The spicy mango salsa was one note and like an ice cream sundae topping. The poke bowls were bland as well. The fish was fresh, but the flavor elusive once again. . The manager gave us a $50 gift card after I told one waitress how horrible it was when I had to wait inside for the salt. The thought was nice....but who would come back to such an ungracious and inconsistent place to spend those kind of $$$. read more

This place gets 5 stars for the amazing atmosphere and above & beyond wonderful staff. However the food was bland and overpriced. I ordered the lobster tacos and they had more garnish than seasoning. The lobster was also over cooked because it was rubbery and chewy. The food looks much better than it tastes. read more

Fish MV - a variety of tacos on trays - Seafood Near Me - Tisbury, Massachusetts

See all

Was expecting a bit more from how popular this place seems/ other reviews. Got a fish burrito bowl and sushiritto and chowder.Chowddr was definitely the favorite. Burrito bowl was lacking flavor and all the salsa it had was just mango so I had to add my own to add in some flavor. My dad had the sushiritto and although pretty he said it wasn't very good. Online ordering was easy but did take about 40 min. read more

See all

Fun atmosphere, love the outdoor seating. Tacos are mediocre to good, menu selection is reasonably deep. Service is odd, order inside, pay/tip up front, then rely on someone to grab you things as they bring other guests food. read more

Hard to believe we were the only people in the place (semi rainy day) and the food took over 35 mins to come out. We asked where our order was and were told that broiled fish needs extra time. Huh? Broiled fish takes about 12 mins. Fish tacos were dry, cold and tasteless. Same for the broiled fish sandwich. Bye! read more

Dirty silver wear and bowls, bad service, terrible management. Not eating here again.

We were looking forward to trying this place out! Unfortunately it did not deliver. I'm not mad at the pricing but without the quality or quantity it's a definite bust. Fish Ceviche was flavorless, dry, forgettable. Didn't taste any lime. There didn't seem to be much else in there except the fish. We sent it back. Fish tacos had potential. But no salsa to speak of. The mango chunks seemed frozen and thawed and were not blended with any sort of salsa or other flavor. The tortillas were coldish as well. For the price point of over 10$ per taco each bite should be amazing. The tuna poke was not poke but more so sashimi with rice, sauce and few veggies. It lacked the classic poke teriyaki soy ginger sesame etc flavors. The tuna was just passable as sushi grade. The clam chowder was not chowder in that there was not a cream base to it. Very confusing. Call it something else and elevate the flavor profile maybe? The mojito was not strong enough and the club soda was flat making it taste even more watered down. For 16$. More sugar. More rum please. With tip we spent close to $100 and honestly nothing stood out. Everything was blah or disappointing. One star for the outdoor seating , which was great. Also the servers were nice and polite but had a weak menu so couldn't really get you excited about anything. They seemed to be hiding a bit. Hopefully they can figure out how to make this place work. Great location and potential. read more

Perfect place to sit outdoors and enjoy drinks and food! Service was friendly and fast. The new menu items are delicious! The crab cakes are amazing definitely recommend read more

Fish MV - Seafood Near Me - Tisbury, Massachusetts

See all

Incredible! Had a bunch of mediocre meals but was very impressed with this restaurant. We ordered fried calamari, crab cakes, poke bowl and a sushiritto. For drinks we had a cucumber water and tequila drink which was very refreshing, and an aperol spritz which was well made. Calamari was good, and came with 3 different sauces to dip in which gave a nice variety. An aioli sauce, a spicy sauce and a cocktail type sauce. Only downfall was it was all rings no tentacles. Crab cakes were made perfectly and were crispy on the outside but soft on the inside. The sushiritto is unique and filling. Came with your choice of fish, avocado, cucumbers and seaweed salad rolled up and then cut like a burrito. The outside was wrapped in soy paper to keep it contained and easy to eat. The poke bowl was the best thing, very large bowl of fresh fish, seaweed salad, cucumbers, avocado, spicy mayo and poke sauce. Also had some macadamia nuts which I thought was weird but actually complimented the soft rice nicely. One of the best places I ate on the island! Outdoor seating is great, and I actually liked the go up to the window, order your food/drinks, pay there and they will bring your order out to you system. To top it all off the servers were all extremely personable and friendly! read more

The food is subpar. we ordered a frozen pina colada which was the worst I ever had although it looked very good in presentation. we had Mexican corn which was soggy, half dressed in sauce and we left it uneaten. the wait for the food to be delivered was 1 hour after ordering and the entire experience was awful. stay away. read more

We had a delicious lunch here today by sharing ceviche & lobster bowl. Enjoyed the fresh & delicious flavors. Sitting on the outside patio on this glorious sunny day made our very first day on the island a wonderful experience. Friendly & helpful staff too! read more

We ordered the shrimp bowls and tuna poke bowls! Both were delicious and really filling. Great outdoor area and atmosphere!

Much improved over last year. Fish tacos and elote corn dish are delicious. Outdoor patio is really nice. Good service that has also sped up. Props to management! read more