Pizza is great! Staff friendly and helpful. Ambiance can be loud when other patrons are celebrating.

Pizzas are usually not done on time or correct. The staff are young and not used to customers with problems or any way to resolve them. They used to be better, new management maybe. Not sure. But we don't go there anymore. read more

In our top 2 pizza places this side of Rainier. Our absolute fav - the veggie pizza plus jalapeños and chicken! This pizza is a treat, and we love it every time. Workers are always top notch!! Thanks ! read more

Just ordered two pizzas they were literally the most horrible pizzas I've ever had ordered a cookie for dessert. It is rockhard cannot eat it. This place is gone downhill for the last six months used to be the best pizza going around. I would never order from them ever again as I called the complaint today. The boy on the phone told me what do you want me to do about it? We have a new Manager is a lot of people complain. read more

Services were great I had a large pizza very delicious. Very clean. I wish they had more than beer and one kind of wine.

This place used to be decent, but not anymore. They have the tiniest wings in the history of the world. What breed of chicken is that small. It's like they're off a Cornish Hen. It's so bad it's funny. read more

Varsity Pizza - Smallest wings in the history of the world. 1 dozen for $15. Horrible value. They used to be decent, but OMGosh they've gone bad. - Pizza Near Me - Eatonville, Washington

THE supreme Pizza was delicious cheesey bread was yummy . Macaroni cheese bits where yummy We where recomend to come here by friends .Service extent read more

Horrible experience as a first time patron. They advertise a sports yet you can't hear the game.I had to ask four times to turn the volume up and the music down. Still, the music is overriding the seahawks game. We will never return to varsity pizza. Also, they charge six fifty for a draft courage.Life, yet four dollars for a sam adams bottle. Crooks. read more

I'm actually quite blown away. Food used to be excellent and portions were generous . Sadly just paid $14 for a chop salad that was barely a single serving! A year ago that same salad was $9 and $11 for three times as much. The grinder bread is half as big as before. So 2 grinders 1 small salad $75 . read more

Wonderful and amazing and delicious and comfortable and delicious and delicious and delicious and tasty

I would stop here again, I'll start with that. On our way to a state park, the pickings were slim for places to eat near this particular stretch of the Rainier area and after looking at reviews, we decided to stop here. I love the exterior of it being a roadside pizza joint with nothing around it for miles (it was pitch black so maybe there were things). The interior was clean and rustic with sports memorabilia appropriately displayed all around and the staff was friendly. We got the Supreme pizza and Caesar salad. Each slice of pizza was LOADED with cheese which we absolutely loved and the pizza sauce had a very nostalgic food service pizza sauce taste, which is to say it wasn't the best but it was good. It was a filling meal and we had quite a bit leftover. Great prices too. read more

The pizza, cheese bread, and chopped salad were delicious, and the people are super friendly!

Amazing eats in Eatonville! Pizza for the kiddos and a varsity grinder for the hubby! read more

Varsity Pizza - Varsity grinder - Pizza Near Me - Eatonville, Washington

Excellent speedy service, every time! I generally call in a few sandwiches for lunch with the team, and they're perfect every time! read more

I ordered two large pizzas was quoted 35 minutes. I called after 1 hour and ten minutes to find out where my pizza was. I was told by a female young manager that they haven't started my pizzas yet due to a large party. Durant make sense I told her so that means the party came in after I ordered and you chose to make theirs instead. She hung up on me totally rude I called back and asked her why she hung up on me she said because she was done I told her to cancel my pizzas and issue refund. I will never gone she sounded like she was 12 and very unprofessional read more

Always good food, great service and friendly environment! I've been here numerous times throughout the years and they're consistently pleasing. Pizzas are on point, salads are great and their beef rib tips are great! You can't go wrong! read more

Meh. Second time here and again, pizza over cooked with burnt edges, calzone just ok.

Yummy!! We were passing through to go to Mt. Rainier and stopped here for lunch. The mac and cheese bites were hot and delish! The garlic parm wings were crispy! The pepperoni pizza...mmmmm! The nicest lady took our order. Such a cute place to stop and eat! read more

This has to be our favorite pizza place! We decided to go grab some sandwiches to go and ended up staying this time. Hubster grabbed a beer and we also ordered dessert! Sat down towards the back and played a word game while waiting for our food, which didn't take that much time at all! One Varisty Grinder and a French Dip Grinder and dessert was... OMG clouds of warm dough, covered in cinnamon and sugar with an even better cream cheese dipping sauce!!! Always a winner for dinner! read more

Came here yesterday and drove 10 + miles. I could've easily gone to Myles Pizza Depot and walked. But I wanted "wings" and "pizza". Just like any other patron that goes to a pizza place. I've been here numerous times and this was absolutely the worse. We walked and looked at the menu... I wanted a pizza and the lady in the front said they are out or "cheese" with a smile on her face. I asked her if they had enough cheese to make a small pizza? She said no. I looked at my friend and kind of shrugged my shoulders and thought about going to Myles. I guess let's get the 2nd thing a normal person would want with their pizza.. what about wings? With a smile on her face she also replied and said we are out of "bone-in" wings. Again I looked at my friend in disbelief. Mind you not, this all while the phone is ringing for people wanting to order pizza and people "driving" wanting to eat pizza and just to turn around and leave. At this time, I might as well order something since we both have not eaten all day!! We ordered boneless chicken wings, family size ceasar salad and for appetizers some bread sticks. We proceed to our seat and just to stop by the bar to order drinks. No one was to be found. I heard a girl tell the other patrons that the "bar tender" was in the back washing dishes. We waited and no show for the bar tender. My friend ended up going to the front register to order 2 drinks. We waited and waited just to be approached by a girl. I asked her that we were waiting for our food and we told her what our order was. She told me that they were all in the oven. I asked her about the breadsticks "the appetizers" since I wanted it beforehand. She replied again with a smile on her face and said " you are all getting them together!" And she walked away. Minutes later slowly food started showing up. The bread sticks were swimming in melted butter and 1/4 portion of the bread was all soggy because of the butter at the bottom of the plate. Let's talk about the boneless wings.. the chicken nuggets size tenders were crunchy and had burnt spots all over them. The only reason why I saw burnt spots is because I ordered them dry with sauce on the side. Just like how I order my bone-in wings. Now the salad.. salad was served on the same bowl that it was mixed in and same tongs used to mix it with the sauce all caked in on the tongs. This is not normal, I have ordered salad here plenty of times and have never been served in the same bowl it was mixed in, in the kitchen. Almost feel like they were avoiding having to do more dishes. I counted approx 10 cars full of customer drive up and hear the phone ringing and just to watch all of them drive away again. I don't normally write reviews but whose fault was this? If there was a manager there, then they have failed to look at inventory and if it was running low, they failed to notify the owners to get more. It's just like McDonald's running out of fries. Poor inventory prep by the opening manager and poor communication by the staff to let owners know they are running out. We just wanted wings and pizza just like everyone that has called and drove to the place and to just drive away.. it was not even worth taking a picture of.. Believe me, I have thought about it.. read more

We checked this little spot out recently and the pizza was spot on! Fun toppings, and fantastic crust! It's a bit out of the way, but if you're in the area, it's worth a stop. read more

I love Varsity Pizza - by far the best pizza in the area. The service is always great. Their salads are good and so are their chicken wings. They also sell local sourdough and it is delicious! I am so glad Varsity is a part of the community! read more

Not very good pizza, and too pricey for mediocre pie!! Do yourself a favor and continue on to Eatonville and go to Myles!!!

This place is oooooold school. The menu, the food and the atmosphere remind of being a kid in the 80's. If that's what you are looking for...you'll enjoy it. read more

Far below average, for Varsity. Toppings (Supreme) were sparse, over the whole pizza. I'm used to getting more toppings than this, at ANY pizzeria. My pizza had about 2 pieces of salami and pepperoni per slice. We asked for extra sauce and this was also lacking. The tomatoes were okay but the mushrooms were few in number, as well. We won't return to this location. This was a 24 dollar pie that most any frozen pizza would've easily competed with. Didn't know I needed to look into the box, before taking this home. Never needed to, before now. read more

Varsity Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Eatonville, Washington

See all

Always a good source of pizza. The pricing in a little steep but they support local youth sports teams. Their pizza is often times way better than a chain, and they deliver to those who may not receive delivery. The locations are easy to get to and convenient. If you live in the rural parts is quite a drive to get some good pizza, Varsity provides good pizza and locally. read more

Best pizza in the area that why we don't mind driving from Eatonville to go get it. Trust me the Taco pizza is the BEST!!

Weird vibe. I came in to order a pizza to go. I noticed that they now have a small full service bar. I thought that I sit down, enjoy a cocktail and watch the ball game while my pizza was prepared. Another customer came over and sat near me to watch the game and an employee came over and went on a strange rant stating that she would not serve alcohol because "she has a friend that is in jail for 9 years because of abusing alcohol". After chatting and sitting there for quite awhile, I wondered what was taking sooo long to get my pizza. (There were only 3 patrons in the restaurant and 6 workers in the kitchen). After standing at the counter for awhile, finally one of the employees acknowledged me and said "have you been helped"? I told her that I wanted to check on the status of my food. On a counter behind her was my pizza. Nothing had been done to keep it warm. I asked her "how long has my food been sitting there"? She shrugged and said " not too long!" I asked her why she didn't tell me it was ready to go. She said she "called out" that the pizza was ready. By then, the gentleman that I had been sitting with had arrived at the counter. He stated that he never heard anyone "call out". We were sitting perhaps 10 passes away! There were only 4 patrons in the entire house! My pizza was old and luke warm. Why does a restaurant install a bar but the employees will not serve drinks? Why, especially when they have more staff than patrons wouldn't they bring someone their food or, at the very least tell the customer that their food is ready? Very poor customer service. read more

Pizza, calzones, wings, and salads have all been great when we've been here. They have Mill Haus cider on tap, which I love. The fresh baked Sourdough is so good. My favorite pizza is the garlic chicken with white sauce, plenty of sauce, cheese and toppings. read more

We moved here a year ago and their pizza was amazing. Yesterday we ordered 5 pizzas and they were all burnt and looked like they were 2 days old. Very disappointing because we have always loved their pizza. read more

Kinda expensive but worth it. Most of the food is delicious. The wings are amazing. They do have some stuff like the gluten free chocolate cake that I'm sure is shipped frozen and looks nothing like the picture but is nice for anyone who needs gluten free stuff and doesnt look fancy but is still pretty good. We go there frequently and usually get wings, sandwiches, pizza, breadsticks or any of the desserts and it's all good so far. read more

So many challenges. First, they had a promo code online for cheeses breadsticks, tried the promo code everyday, didn't work. Came into the store to order, the cost of my order, 1 grinder, 1 small salad, 1 burnt ends was $45.00. The prices on the reader board said it should have been 35.00. When I asked, the girl says, there is a notice in the bottom corner. Indeed there was, saying prices change without notice. Ok. The burnt ends were little bone in ribs with tons of boranes and absolutely smothered in BBQ sauce. To the point of drowning. And the customer service was rude. They argued with me about the pricing. Argued with the next customer about special orders. Will not be going back. read more

One of the few places that deliver in a small town and it's wonderful pizza prices are a little steep but that's what you get for great service read more

Recommendation to everyone who does the regular routine of pizza. Lived in the area for 18 years finally came to varsity pizza and it was great read more

The pizza is great, unless you live like NEXT DOOR leave to go get your pizza right after you put in your order because it's usually ready in hardly anytime at all! You can get Pizza, Grinder Sandwiches, and Pasta. They make their own bread! They have Read To Eat Pizza (but it's really hot so you have to let it cool a bit) take it home and cook it Pizza (save you some $$) and they have a Military Discount on ready to eat items. We just moved here and found Varsity Pizza though a co-worker's recommendation. They have 3 locations; Eatonville, Mc Kenna, and Roy. We have used the Eatonville Location. Really Great Pizza! read more

I won't go back!! The person working told me she couldn't hear me through my mask!!!!!! State mandate and some employees were not wearing masks. If we all would have handled Covid like they told us in the first place, we would not be in the mess we are right now! read more

Pizza is definitely better than your average large scale pizza chains. Not the best pizza I've had in the area. I believe their priced a bit on the high side for their pies. I do like their crust, but their sauce was a bit bland for "my" taste buds. Wouldn't say I'd go there everytime but definitely in the book as an option down the road. read more

Varsity pizza is probably the best pizza in the area. The salads are good. Service is fast and it's a perfect little night out. The beer selection is ok. The overall atmospheres is clean and inviting. read more

Awesome pizza! Spendy but delicious. For adults due to price (just get the kids Dominoes or Papa Murphys) Ton of youngsters working so expect the occasional screw up (and a dirty look if you don't tip--) lol kids these days! Watch out for manager in Eatonville...RBF is more than just an expression when it comes to that one! I order all the time and she's never been nice to me and I've tried to engage tried big tips and gave up. No conversation and no tips anymore. Been thinking of trying the other store, actually. Afraid she might spit on my dang pizza one of these days! So grumpy that one! I'd sure hate to work for her! Maybe it's all the entitled millennial teenagers...who knows. What ever it is - I sure didn't do it! Damn, they have the best pizza around and the meanest manager! Maybe we can get her a vacation? Lol read more

This place is crap! The only reason they survive and I've given them way to many "second chances" is because there are NO OTHER OPTIONS. Service is always terrible. Slow, wrong pizza, greasy pizza, forgot to cut the pizza and said "don't you have a knife?"...the list could go on. read more