Order was wrong, ordered online and picked up, called to let them know when we got home and a teen who couldn't care less took the call. Don't think they understood the point, just kept saying oh sorry we're busy tonight. It's a Friday, there was 6 of them standing around in the pickup room, c'mon. Pizza is supposed to be a thin crust but is closer to dominos. Was really supposed to be Buffalo chicken pie for $20, but got a plain (priced at $13). Turkey burger is plain bad, and looks like some mystery meat. She tried it, I tried it, cat wouldn't come close. Got the fries wrong in the turkey burger. (Again from the app but they didn't want to listen) The burrata is just ugly, and unless there's a better way to package that for takeout, I'd maybe do something else. See pics. 4/10- wouldn't recommend. read more

See all

The remodeling is really great. Please can you get the pizza figured out. Some nights it's good some nights it's bad. This is been my experience for a long time here. I just ordered a small special pizza. It came out as I ordered well done. However, it supposed to have Sausage and peppers. Well it came out well done as ordered, but it had and I counted 7 pieces of sausage on it. Literally one per slice. How can you charge me 19+ plus for a pizza that has basically nothing on it. Somebody please take a look at the QC measures in this place!!!! The owners need to get this corrected! read more

We've always enjoyed eating here. We were excited to finally get back after the recent renovations. Unfortunately this will be an incomplete review since we never even got to place an order. It was a very warm night and although we preferred to eat inside we didn't want to wait so we sat outside. It was us and one other table. The other table was visited five times and we were totally ignored. Even made eye contact with the service. We sat there for 15 minutes and then decided to leave. There's no excuse. Just blatant bad service. Not sure if we'll go back. Too bad. We ended up going to the Victory Tavern and had a great meal. read more

Enough can't be said with how good Val's has gotten over the last year since its renovation. The addition of a new chef has transformed the dining experience. The old favorites (pizza, esp. the Surf and Turf; garlic puffs and wings) are still very strong, but it is the new additions that I go back for time and again. If you know the old Val's this may shock you; but some of the best tuna (tuna bites, tuna salad) in the area can be found at Val's. The place is so laid back and inexpensive, you might be reluctant to try a dish like tuna as it takes a great chef not to ruin such a delicate ingredient, but I suggest you try the Tuna Bites app next time you are there. While I don't care for pork, I am told by multiple people that the pork chop is to die for. Don't let the reputation from years ago or the newly renovated and very modern atmosphere fool you; this place should be on your regular route when looking for a friendly, delicious, economical and fun place to eat and gather. One of my favorites in the area by far. read more

Val's is a local for us, and it always pleases. Recently renovated and opened up. Food is always good. Tasty burger, great garlic knots, octopus and wings. reasonable prices and great bar service. Thin crust pizza is a classic. Richie does a great job managing the place and everyone feels welcome. Try it, you'll love it! read more

What an outstanding transformation has been made since my last visit before covid. The renovations are amazing and contact precautions in place between diners. The salad was fantastic, service attentive but was a bit disappointed in the lobster pie. I would've thought there would be more lobster it was skimpy for the cost maybe my expectations were too high after seeing pictures posted but mine definitely was not like the photos. Will definitely go back to try something different. read more

Very disappointing. Ordered the Bacon bleu burger and the patty was lightly charred and completely tasteless--a place like these HAS to have a great burger right? (My friend's pesto chicken sandwich was, as he said, "fair." Conclusion? Food here has a lot to be desired... read more

We have gone to Val's for many.years and have always been pleased with the the pizza and the service! Their upstairs dining offers a very pleasant atmosphere! read more

I just went to Val's this past weekend with my family to watch the Virginia Tech game. My parents just happened to stumble upon this bar a few weeks ago without knowing it was a Hokie spot! I loved the scene there - it's a little small, but they had plenty of TV's so I could watch the Virginia Tech game in addition to other college football games on. I got a buffalo chicken salad to eat, which was fairly boring, but my brother's margherita pizza was delish! We also got some wings - the mango tango was out of this world good! Overall great place and would definitely recommend if you're ever down the shore in the area! read more

Val's Tavern - Margherita pizza (no tomatoes) and buffalo chicken salad! - Pizza Near Me - Rumson, New Jersey

See all

Got takeout last night, a family local favorite that never disappoints. Great bar style pizza including a famous lobster pie, outstanding garlic puffs and crinkle fries. Everything was prepared perfectly and on time for pick up. Would happily support this local family owned business every week, looking forward to seeing the renovations inside once things improve with the Pandemic. Would give it 6 stars if it let me read more

Great pizza and delicious red wine. Our server Alli was adorable and very caring. The garlic cheese knots are awesome and are given as a freebie. Yum read more

Really love what a the owners have done with the place. The decor is great staff is awesome but somebody there owner or manager should taste the meatball parm. Not sure what the mix of chalk and sawdust is but could be a lot better. read more

We ended up here by accident. We were trying to go somewhere in Sea Bright but we were about to literally run out of gas. My navigation said there was a gas station nearby. We were tight on time and Val's was right there, we had a party of eight & they could accommodate. My 8 year old son & friend's 8 year old daughter ordered the personal pizzas. The girl ate all but one piece and my son said it was the best pizza ever. My friends loved their appetizers- one had a shrimp one and I don't know what the other had but they were happy. However- my friend and ordered the "tender scallop risotto" special. First- it was only like 6p like ten min after we ordered, we were told they were out of risotto. I really hate when this happens. How do you have something as a special but it's gone by 6p? 8p, okay, I can see it. But 6p? And as soon as you're out of that, everyone on the waitstaff should be told before their party orders. Or something- because it's really disappointing when you were looking forward to it. I didn't know what to order instead so I just got penne with the scallops. Lucky I did because that's all I could eat. The scallops were hard as a rock. Definitely not "tender". Maybe I should've known not to order scallops at a tavern. But since it was a special I assumed they'd be great. I was also disappointed in the garlic puffs. "Puffs" denotes something light and airy to me. I LOVE garlic knots so I thought they'd be soft and chewy because they were also filled with cheese. They were slightly burnt and hard. The waitstaff was very friendly and we got our food in decent time. Down the shore on a Sunday evening in the summer, it's hard to find a place to eat that can quickly accommodate eight people so I was grateful they could do it. And my kid loved his food and I think my husband was also happy with his meal. Maybe being out of a special and not so great scallops was a fluke. I would try there again to see. *Update* - Kevin the manager wrote me a message which I appreciate. I haven't been back but I totally would try them again. His response was very nice, not defensive- which I really appreciate. He also explained that Sunday is their last day of specials - that's why they would be out of something at such an early time. I assumed that a special is daily thing, so they'd be chock full of something at an early hour. Now I know. I don't like to give a small business a hard time, I just felt like if the couple of things I had issue with were taken care of, it would help them to know & others would also have a better experience. read more

Great spot for beer and pizza. Tried the shrimp fra Diavlo, buffalo chicken, and margarita. Fra diavolo was my favorite. Pizza is a thin crispy crust, not traditional style. Stopped here on a Sunday afternoon, caught a live band and had a great time! read more

I've been coming to Vals since the drinking age was 19. Ok maybe a bit before that too! Menu is true to classic Val's form with some modern tweaks. Spicy Lobster pie! Holy cow. It's fantastic. Craft beer choices but Bud and Heineken still seem to rule. Great paisan menu. And that's fine with me. Always a crowd at the bar. Rumsons longest running meeting place. If you went to RFH from 1960 to 2018 you'll know someone in there. No 5 stars? Ok it's the band(s). Hey we have a stage, how about a band? The place is small and they cram a band into the corner "stage" And off they go. Just because you own a hammer doesn't mean everything is a nail. Ok maybe it's old ish man disease but most of the crowd seemed to wait for the breaks to actually talk to their friends. Which seems to be why everyone is there in the first place. Val's......go! read more

Went to Vals online to look at their pizza menu. Selected a pizza, called and placed the order, went to pick it up, it was about five dollars more than the listed price on their website menu. It's been a year or more since I informed them of their conflicting pricing. Since nothing has been done in a year I can only assume the worst, switch and bait. read more

My husband and I went to Val's for dinner last Wednesday. I ordered a cheeseburger and my husband ordered chicken parmasean. The burger was very greasy and the grease dripped through the too soft roll. The cheese did not melt on the burger. My husband's dish was tasteless. This was the second time we tried Val's since the Covid lockdown and both times it was a disappointment. We will not return. read more

Terrible service. Host was super rude. We had a large group, called in advance to see if they were busy. Said no, told us to come on in. We arrive 10 mins later and they said they were booked, another party just came in, didn't have room for us. Lame sauce. read more

I grew up across the street from Val's as a child so I'm sure whoever is running that place remembers me as I was hard to miss. 25 years later it is still overpriced, full of the same loudmouth locals and still has a softball team. One thing that is still good- the pizza. Nice and thin, not too much sauce, and great with beer. My mom would make me go over there every Friday night and pick a pie up from the kitchen. That's one memory I miss about Rumson as a whole. I have to give credit for consistency as this place is an institution. Keep on truckin'. read more

I've always gotten pizza at the bar before but ordered four dinners to go the other night and they were amazing off the hook amazing. Pork chop, 1/2 chicken, penne with sausage and an amazing lobster roll read more

Val's, to me at least, is like two different restaurants in one. One side is the bar, which has a jukebox, darts, and an awesome staff. The other side is the restaurant, which while safe to bring kids and comes with decent food, is entirely run by buffoons. Overall I really like the place. Usually I'm just stopping for a couple beers and a bar pie, so take my word for what it's worth. They do have great pizzas...although I think the toppings are a bit steep in price. Otherwise, try the Miller Lite. read more

This place is a local gem! We recently Moved to the area and we were having a hard time finding a good pizza spot... And then there's was Val's... All the times we have come here we sit in the bar area... Bartenders are always friendly fast and professional.. The pizza here is amazing!!! This place is the prefect spot for a relaxing night out. The garlic puffs are really good and the wings are definitely a good way to start you meal. And did I mention the pizza is amazing? Our favorite pizza is the buffalo chicken which can be made grilled or fried chicken it's really good... The pizza dough is perfect!! read more

Val's is my favorite place to be. I love the atmosphere here as it is staffed by very friendly people and it seems that most people that go there are regulars who will strike up a friendly conversation if you happen to sit next to them at the bar. From the owners to the wait staff to the people who regularly go here, nobody is shy and they all make you feel more than welcome to be there. They make some really great pizza here. My personal favorite is the Buffalo Chicken Pizza, but every once in a while I try something new like the Fra Diavolo pizza, the White pizza, Reuben pizza (which I think they make special on St Pattys Day), the Lobster pizza, and I've never been disappointed. They also have really good pasta dishes and give a really generous portion size. The wraps and burgers are also very delicious. Garlic knots are a must. read more

Been ordering here for decades.... The pizza today is awful. It's no longer thin crust and the "famous" lobster pie is horrible, as is the fried calamari. Not what it used to be. I will not be ordering again. Terribly over priced and a complete waste of money. read more

Not what it used to be! Time to look elsewhere. Ordered two chicken parm dinners and garlic knots for takeout. Went to pick it up and the order was wrong. Waited for them to fix this, which took a long time with barely an apology. Asked for extra sauce for the garlic knots, and they gave me a tiny container filled only 1/3 with sauce. Did not provide proper packaging to get the food home easily. Finally got home to find that they only give you one small piece of chicken per order (used to be two large size pieces). Two tiny pieces of bread were poorly wrapped and completely stale. (they used to give you to large pieces of warm bread) Chicken parm sauce was bland. Garlic knots were cold from the long wait for the order mixup. read more

Val's is where it's at - staple spot. Love the people, food, atmosphere. Thanks All! read more

My wife and I have been going to Val's for about three years now. Hell when my wife gave birth to our daughter she requested Val's Pizza and non other. If that's not a testament to how good their pizza is, I don't know what is. A friendly establishment that boast a local crowd and great conversation during lunch at the bar, full dining room at dinner. Staf may seem stretch thin at times but do their damnedest to make you feel like you're a regular. Good variety of beers on tap and in bottle. Homemade sangria in the summer, which is a very nice addition to any bar. The lobster pie is to die for and Val's is the only place I have EVER had a decent Buffalo Chicken Pie. I could live off of both day in and day out. A welcome addition to the menu since the new owners have taken over is the garlic shrimp pizza. Just be warned, the garlic will stay with you! Not the best choice for a first date dinner! Rest of the menu is nothing too crazy, simple salads and sandwiches, dinner gets a bit more lavish. Never had a terrible meal at Val's. Night life varies, DJ, Band, jukebox it varies from night to night. The building has been recently renovated and they did a brilliant job bringing Val's in the 21st century. read more

For as long as I can remember every family mile stone has been celebrated with my extended family at Val's.Unfortunately with such a large family reservations are a must and recently we were told no longer taken.With family that comes from near and far for the amazing service, food and atmosphere I can't stress enough bringing back the option of placing a reservation. I would think allowing large parties to place reservations would be lucrative and good for the establishment. read more

I am new to the area and went to Val's for the first time. I will never go back! The bartender was the rudest most obnoxious individual I have ever come across. Didn't smile once and took forever to ask us what we wanted. Never came back when our glasses were empty to find out if we wanted anything else. Never asked us if we wanted to see a menu. Any comment he did have when asked a question was an obnoxious answer. He went outside several times to smoke, even with a crowded bar and being the only bartender there. We left and went to Tommy's in Sea Bright and had a great time and even more importantly, we felt welcomed. Not at Val's!!!!! Never again!!!! read more

I've always liked the bar. The staff is friendly (at the bar). And most of the customers at the bar have always been friendly. Tonight the food was disappointing. Onion soup was "fair" at best. And the "chopped salad" was a small portion with only a little meat and cheese. If there was an ounce of each, that would be alot. So I paid $9+ for a bowl of lettuce. But I'll go back. I enjoy their "Tequila Chicken". read more

Great place, amazing food! Mike the manager came to our table to greet us and made some suggestions from the menu. The meal was great, and we ordered their house special lobster pizza to take home. We will definitely be back! read more

This place is the best and the food is really good and it's a fun place to go with your friends and just hang out to discuss life. Our waitress was awesome and we totally related to her. I like like 6 hours away but I pray I can come back here some time soon. I got a blt turkey wrap and my friends got burgers and pizza and it was such a vibe. read more

Had a horrible experience here with two staff members being blatantly rude to us. One of them actually scanned us from head to toe before answering our request and then proceeded to slam the item down on our table and walk away. I have never had an experience like this one. They made it pretty clear that we were not welcome in the restaurant. Point taken, you don't need my money. What an awful way to treat people, regardless of your beliefs/values. I would never go back. If you don't look like everyone else in the bar I would suggest that you leave and find a more welcoming place. No one deserves to be disrespected in that way. Shameful. read more

Went here for brunch last weekend. Staff was very friendly and atmosphere was comfortable. Good beer selection. Wings were tasty and crispy. Menu was somewhat limited but my panini was pretty good. My wife's salad was 'OK'. All in all a good neighborhood bar. read more

Got pizza and a couple salads delivered. An hour and a half later an obviously stoned teenager stumbled up to the door with half of the order, a couple of ice cold pizzas. We had to wait another hour for the oven to preheat so we could reheat our "fresh" pies and for him to bring the salads. We order from this place often, probably will not order from them again. read more

Horrible....stuffed shells...menu description does not detail any meat..came w sausage which was served to our vegetarian guests. Additionally...shrimp app cost $12.95 and only included 4 medium sized shrimp. STAY AWAY!!!!!!!!!!!! read more

Hands down some of the best pizza I have ever tasted. I do beer promotions part-time and the owners and bar tenders are the friendliest I have ever encountered at an account. The atmosphere is laid-back; it is mostly locals and regulars. I always enjoy going here! read more

I'm biased. This place is where I fell in love with thin crust pizza. It tastes like childhood to me. I used to demand going to Val's for my birthday every year even though it was out of the way. I think the sauce-to-crust-to-cheese combo is great. The crust is thin but dense. I love it. Adding parmesan cheese is a must to bring out all of the flavors. I cannot say enough good things about the pizza at Val's. read more

This place used to be great not anymore.then last time I tired to order dinner for delivery from the flyer they sent .I ordered 4 dinners. They informed me that the entrees don't include salad or side with a to go order but that if I paid extra they would add the salad and side..huh? On top of that the last time they delivered they over charged my credit card and I had to call for three days to get it removed.. This and the fact that the staff who answer the phone are rude and act like they are doing you a favor means no more of my business. This used to be a great but they are cocky arrogant and act like they are doing u a favor to eat there.in today's business climate ,I won't stand for it. this and the fact i emailed the manager and got no response says it all. They send out there mailer and change the rules when you order. Its too bad as they do have a couple items i like.Its also where i spent the first date with my girl and her friends.The new owners have made it a disappointing expierience. read more

Was there Monday evening, Val's Steak Bruschetta is really an incredible appetizer we get it every time to share- excellent marinated flank steak(I believe) always cooked to temp over lightly toasted French bread, perfectly dressed tomato 'salad', with blue cheese chunks Worth a visit just for that steak always nice cold draft beer, good quality wine by glass, would love a few more IPA's but every time I go their list gets better Pizza always great and Jeff is by far our favorite bartender always makes us feel welcome Got to put this spot back on the weekly rotation read more