I just went to the Post Office it is 8:56 am . I had a notice Go to counter pick up package it is…read morelarge To put in box. The lady that works there was out in the lobby.I said, excuse me, is there a door I could knock on to grab this package? She looked at me and said , no ,you have to wait til 9. Now I have had post office boxes in port jeff and there was always somebody there to get your package. You just knock on the door to get your package.If it's 5 minutes before they open, they even tell you If you get there earlier , just knock on the door and they'll get your package because they are in. I have been with this post office for 2 years. I have a doctor's appointment so I couldn't stay there and wait for the 5 minutes. To me this is very poor customer service!

Mail boxes are so tiny. I tried putting a SMALL package through and it wouldn't fit. So it ripped…read moreup my envelope. The central islip collection box is much bigger. I'm mad

The Middle Island post office is one of the best around for top friendly service, cost-effective…read moremailing advice and cleanliness. Laura is the Postmaster and she can offer free advice on everything A-Z pertaining to business mailings and postal solutions. Her knowledge is exemplary and her willingness to help you is genuine. The front counter 'A' team consists of Tom, Maria, Joanne. Bob recently joined the team. It's a big plus if you do direct mail marketing and have many Packages going out on a daily basis. As a consumer, if getting your packages mailed on time at the best rate is important to you, then The Middle Island post office is where you want to do your business. --Andrew Linick, TopMarketingAdvisor@gmail.com Box holder and major direct mailer and mail order expert since 1973.

Very friendly at this post office. Nice and clean. I just wish they carried more of the flat rate…read moreshipping boxes.

Perfect time during the Holiday Season to say thank you for your service. I appreciate you all…read more You are very efficient with keeping the line moving while still answering questions and always helping with a smile. I don't think there's every been a time that I've walked in without hearing staff crack jokes and having the customers laughing and smiling. It's tough working with the public but you make it look so easy! Great job and God Bless!

The location is neat & clean and it's a decent size - but as for nearly every other aspect, not…read moregood - and that's being kind. The parking lot set up is awful, especially since no one in Suffolk seems to know how to drive or park in parking lots. Now counter employees- one lady is very nice. The two old men however - Andy and I forgot the other old man's name - let's just say his voice and personality is like that of Bert from Sesame Street - these two old men are creeps - Andy especially. Very, very rude. Each time I been in there and got stuck with him, he would make rude jokes about my business name, one day when I finally had enough of it, I smiled and corrected him for this - explaining the pronunciation of it correctly and why it has that name. His response was "oh i know i was only joking" - the other old man was helping him this particular day and he gave me a dirty look. I had 20 packages going out that day, all over the nation - every single package arrived to the recipients badly damaged - considering they went to 20 different locations in the USA - I know exactly where it started - and I'm certain it was these two old men who done it. Post Master took a report, but I refused to go back there - been going to the Selden Post Office - never a problem and all employees are very nice. Fast forward three years - I didn't have time to go to the post office, placed two small packages inside my mailbox for pick up - post office being, of course Farmingville - the packages were two small bubble mailers, light weight, well wrapped, under 2 ounces each and shipped via ground advantage. Two weeks after shipping, still haven't arrived to their destinations (two different states) - I get an email from my shipping service stating the USPS - - my local post office repackaged both packages in flat rate envelopes and up charged me $8 each because that also changes shipping class to priority...I call - Post Master isn't available and never called back. Two days go by, both recipients finally received items - inside these flat rates is the original bubble mailers - which appeared to have been cut open with scissors, items shipped inside were not inside, now my clients are fighting the USPS on their end as well, I finally speak directly to someone from the Farmingville post office about the situation, who said the packages were likely damaged so they repackaged them - here's the thing - besides the fact that one of of their employees cut open the packages, even if they were legit damaged- that doesn't give them the right to up charge me for their negligence, actually it means they owe me money - but now they owe me money and they also owe my clients the full value of the items they stole. Learned my lesson - will only ship packages with Selden Post Office. The only reason I gave two stars instead of just one is because my mail carriers who deliver are usually very nice.

Always fine, always a nice job. Never takes too long. Wish the parking lot wasn't so beat up. But…read moreall good

The Mount Sinai location is more convenient for me, but the Miller Place location is just better…read moreall around. So 9 times out of 10, I go out of my way to ship from this location. The staff is always friendly, there are plenty of parking spaces, and they always have the supplies I need. It's a lot bigger too, which is a big deal, especially when it's crowded.

Just want to start off by saying the staff is friendly here and I have no problems with them…read morepersonally. I ship a lot through eBay using this post office but the last order I had was somehow lost. I dropped it off in person and was given tracking information and it never left the location. This cost me a fair amount of money, and affected my eBay storefront. I will be using a different office as now I can't depend on my package being safely shipped out. To this day I have no clue where it went.

Great shipping help. Fantastic air delivery. Great service at the Mount Sinai office.read more

I wish I could rate zero. USPS tracking states my package is at this location. However no matter…read morehow many buttons I press on my phone for over 30 minutes each attempt, I cant reach an actual live human being to speak with about my package.

I don't know what it is, but every time I mail a letter from this post office.. it arrives much…read morequicker than if I sent the same piece of mail from another post office! It's amazing. The staff inside are kind and friendly, unlike other locations where they're crabby and snippy. Lines typically move fast. Location is clean.

Very efficient post office. Lines can be long at times but there's always enough employees at the…read moreregisters to make it go as quickly as possible. Staff is always helpful and courteous. 4 stars because place could be slightly cleaner. Sometimes I would wrap my packages on site but counters are a little dirty, so I just prepare my shipments from home now.

Possibly the worst Post Office in the country. Forget getting packages on time. You'll be lucky if…read moreyour package isn't lost.

Miserable employees. Especially the older woman with short hair and glasses and employee #20. Went…read moreto mail a couple of mother's day gifts and one of my packages needed a little extra tape to secure the bottom. I kindly asked the miserable employee with a puss on his face if he could put some tape on the bottom of my package to secure it and he replied "we are a no tape office " .....ummm what the f$@k??? He proceeds to tell me I can purchase packaging tape but he just sold the last one . Again WTF??!!!! He then rolls his eyes at me walks away and comes back with a big roll of packaging tape and secures my package. Now was that so hard? Why he had to make a production out of it was beyond me. I have been going to this Post Office for years and have come in contact with some nice and not so nice employees but he was the worst. Also, I have NEVER had an issue with a simple little thing called TAPE at a post office. And whatever happened to "how can I help you" when greeting a customer and when you are done with your transaction how about "have a nice day" . Apparently those words don't exist in miserable employee #20 vocabulary. I will not return to this Post Office again . Why go somewhere when you KNOW you are going to get treated like crap. It's a shame because the building itself it quite charming and one of the older Post Office buildings that you really don't see around here anymore.

The people that work here is the best so helpful always makes my life easier. The know their job…read moreSusan Kevin and Karl are the best. Thank you forever a customer.