Not consistent. Called and spoke to Shane who said he would make sure the order is how it should be and send me UNCOOKED doughy pizza. It was disgusting and inedible. I called spoke to Shane to let him know it was uncooked and he said "I don't know what to tell you" . read more

See all

Hands down, BEST Pizza we have found in the area so far! Crust is perfect, sauce is superb and just the right amount of cheese. Toppings are abundant and priced right! Staff is always courteous and pizza ready when we order- what more could you ask for? We LOVE Upper Crust! read more

Amazing Pizza in Celebration Town Center. Carry out or outside tables. They have both thin crust and a very flavorful thick crust.

Great spot to stop for a quick slice. A little busier on the weekends but that's to be expected. Personally I'm a fan of the ricotta, tomato, spinach slice they make (aka the Diego). Also worth noting that they do accept Apple Pay. Enjoy! read more

I was there today with the family and got a slice with onions, tomatoes, olives, and feta. It was awesome. I'm usually a Chicago style pizza guy but their NY style pizza is great not greasy, crispy crust and fresh toppings. The subs and wraps are very good too. I always get the chicken Caesar wrap and it's great!!! The people working the counter are always polite and helpful. The outdoor seating it awesome. Great for people and car watching and it's a quick walk to kilwins for some ice cream. read more

A new pizza favorite has been found. This was my second visit to this fantastic whole in the wall establishment, nestled along the MainStreet of Celebration. This family operated establishment is a great place to walk in and grab a slice of New YORK style pizza and a drink or take home a whole pie and some garlic knots. I haven't had the pleasure of trying their sandwiches yet, but if they are anything like their hand tossed pizzas, then I am all over it. During my 1st visit which was during the nightly snows, sadly an entire year ago, I enjoyed their Teriyaki pizza. This year I decided to try one of the daily specials and this time it was the Hawaiian BBQ. Absolutely delicious. My mom was a 1st timer and she enjoyed her slice of Chicken Ranch so much we ended up leaving with an entire pie and a half dozen garlic knots. I look forward to my next visit and I know I won't wait until the snow falls next year to get back. read more

See all

Every time I go I always leave satisfied the pizza isn't like other New York " pizza their so crunch I'm constantly recommending this place. And their hero's just as goood read more

Loved the NY style flavor. Tried a few pizza places I'm the area and none of them had that NY taste I like. Eventually, Upper Crust had it. Pizza tasted great. The presentation was pretty off, though. One of the pizzas was sliced disproportionately, leaving half the slices small and half the slices super big. Looking past that; I'm hoping I can make it my go to pizza place. read more

Upper Crust Pizza - Pizza tasted great, but the slicing was way off. - Pizza Near Me - Celebration, Florida

Delicious pizza at fair prices. Loved having a margherita pizza with ricotta cheese! Crust was really good. Service was great and there were several tables available outside to enjoy it. read more

This place is awesome!!! Not far from Disney ! This is definitely my new go to after the parks. Prices are phenomenal food is amazing... and the staff was super friendly.. garlic knots a must ! read more

Upper Crust Pizza - Lasagna - Pizza Near Me - Celebration, Florida

Great Slice and good people. Was able to get in an out quickly and was delicious. Make this stop if you are ever in Celebration.

Upper Crust serves the BEST classic and newly created combo pizza! Attention is given to the freshness, quality and flavor of each ingredient resulting in pizza that will thrill your body--from your taste buds to the tips of your toes! LOL...Simply great pizza! The pizzeria is small, but has always had outdoor seating and delivery service. So, COVID-19 has not affected the Upper Crust so much. This is a family-owned and run business. Service is friendly and efficient. You will often find Mark (the owner) working in the kitchen. If you have ever thought of flying to Italy to get another pizza, just make the drive to Celebration's Upper Crust. Don't miss this jewel! read more

Tried this place while waiting for a diligent home. The pizza was delicious. Authentic NY pizza with quality ingredients. The price was also very reasonable. There is not many places to sit which is on. There is a park near by to go eat at. read more

Proximity and convenience along with better than average pizza sums up my review. We have taken out from this restaurant several times and find them better than the chain restaurants even though we can't eat it there. We will keep ordering pizza from them, but would like a crispier crust (it's better the day after). The sauce and ingredients are better than average, but the cheese could be better. The criticism I have is minor because everyone has their own preferences, so give them a try especially if you live close by. read more

I definitely would not recommend this place. The service was so horrible and the guys making the pizza were so rude. One of the guys told other customer will bring out their food and then I asked if they would it and he said I would not. So rude and unprofessional. The pizza and garlic bread with cheese were okay. NOT RECOMMENDED. read more

Upper Crust Pizza - 10 inch pizza with jalapeños and onions - Pizza Near Me - Celebration, Florida

See all

Rude, entitled, incompetent young gals at the register ruin it for us every time which is why we now make it a point to order from Posto Pizza even though it takes longer and costs more. Service in this place is shameful - they clearly couldn't care less about the locals (but they're rude to the tourists as well) - Of course the clueless owner is never there to know what's going on - Too many orders messed up. The food is a-ok but overrated - certainly not worth having to put up with the obnoxious staff. Locals are treated as 2nd class citizens (in fairness, they're rude to everyone not just locals). read more

Really really bad pizza. The cheese is yellow, extremely salted and not properly melted. There is a lack of marinara sauce on the pizza. The crust is burnt and stale. The entire pizza was drenched in oil and grease, in the worst way possible. Garlic knots were decent, but you can probably make frozen ones from Walmart that are better. My boyfriend and I immediately got an upset stomach after eating their pizza. Either all the ingredients are old and that's why they taste off-putting or their "chefs" simply don't know how to cook. read more

Terrific little pizzeria. Affordable slices, great service and delicious product. I do wish they had more of an array of available flavors, but what's here definitely hits the spot. A must-stop! read more

Had a 12" meatball parm sub that my wife and I split. I'd give it an 8 if 10 rating. Not superb but exactly what you'd want if you're in the mood for a hit sandwich. At $8 inclusive of a tip, you can't beat this! read more

Celebrations okayest pizza. Not bad, just not great. A little off, like everything at Disney.

My family was at Celebration for a walk around the lake. We all got super hangry and before we realized it we were at each other's throats. After looking around locally we spotted Upper Crust! A quick 10 minutes we had an absolutely delicious pizza in front of us next to the lake. My daughter never eats pizza and absolutely demolished it! Thank you Upper Crust! read more

Upper Crust Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Celebration, Florida

5 stars for location and 5 stars for the pizza. Always looking for good New York style pizza since moving down to Orlando. Not disappointed read more

Upper Crust Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Celebration, Florida

We had the best time at our roundtable while enjoying a very good meal. Food was delicious and service excellent. Highly recommend.

We ordered takeout. The pizza was hard and not very tasty. You get better quality at Dominos Or Pappa John's. Very disappointed.

Ordered sausage, pepper and onion pizza. It was delicious NY style pizza. The crust was perfect and it was very tasty indeed. Yummy!

Great spot and on the Main Street in downtown Celebration, Florida. The pizza was fantastic. We are from PA and haven't been able to find good pizza and this pizza was fantastic. My wife, my daughter, and I all got lunch here for $17. I would recommend upper crust to anyone who wants to grab a quick bite for lunch and is in the area. read more

See all

Delicious food. The by-the-slice pizza is quick. The other food is delicious. I liked the white pizza. And the lasagna. And the garlic knots too. read more

We got the 2 Large Cheese Pizza for $24.99, which in my opinion is a pretty good deal for 18" pizzas... read more

See all

We used to go there all of the time. However, there is no concern by the staff to show that they are taking any additional precautions during COVID. No face covers worn by those preparing the food. In fact, you can very easily see the cooks not wearing masks, gloves or any type of hair nets. Pizza was always our favorite, but we can't go back until they make significant changes. Would be appreciated if there is a response from UC management. read more

We have been eating at Upper Crust for years, and now that we are less than a lock away, it will become a regular part of our diet. The quality of the pizza is good and pretty consistent. Aside from Al's, this is one of the better pizza joints in the area. They are great for a quick slice, but a bit pricey if you make a regular habit. Two slices and a soda will set you back about $8-$9. If you find a big slice, one will do just fine. The sandwiches are alright and the calzones are also pretty good. Staff is almost always friendly, but it is a pizza joint. Set expectations accordingly. read more

Awesome pizza! The taste is fresh and toppings are quality ingredients. Similar to NYC pizza and one piece will fill you up. The staff is very friendly and have been great the several times I've visited. Go here!!! read more

Upper Crust Pizza - Yumm! We got lots of slices. Hawaiian, Cheese, Diego, and the one with a bite is olive oil sauce with onion, herbs, and mushrooms! - Pizza Near Me - Celebration, Florida

We can say that we have tried Hawaiian pizza in many place in the world and I can tell you that the best one is at Upper Crust in Celebration. The crew is super friendly and the pizzas are good and they are very tasty. No fuss but just crazy pizza!! read more

What I appreciate most about Upper Crust is the quality of service you receive and the delivery. I had not ordered from Upper Crust for a while due to a very bizarre experience with the owner at the time. But, since ordering from them again, it has been nothing but good things. When I called last night, I was greeted with a excited and happy person on the other line. Took my order, understood what I wanted (which can be challenging sometime) and promptly took care of me. The delivery is to Celebration wide only, so living in Celebration has it's perks for sure. Only knocks I would give them, if I had to, the website online ordering looks ready, but doesn't look functional yet. Pizza wise, it is always good. But, if it was a little thicker and not so pliable, might make for a better pizza. But, other than that, love the pizza, love the service, keep it up! read more

I went to "Upper Crust" a couple of weeks ago for a quick lunch. Reviews suggested the price and product were good for me so I took the worm. I walk in and it's busy, which is a good sign because people must obviously like it. There isn't a real line, it's more like a mass in front of the counter and you just kinda go by the honor system to when you're next. Finally it's my turn and let me just say, I love it when the person serving me treats me like I have half a brain and that they are doing me a favor by taking my order. Oh wait, did I say love? I mean, strongly dislike. So I order a slice of pizza that looks like it's under a heat lamp and he hands it to me. It doesn't feel hot through the paper plate and then I stick my finger to it and it's actually cold. So I asked him if he could through it in the oven for me because it was cold and you'd think I asked him to give me a shoulder massage. He rolled his eyes and took my pizza to the oven. Then at the register I ordered garlic knots and a small Caesar salad to go with it because this is my meal for the day. I think the best part about this meal was the croutons that the other man working there made fresh for my salad. He cut up the bread, tossed it in oil and garlic and stuck it in the oven to toast. Also, that small salad was huge. I wonder how big the large is, probably family sized. So on to taste. Again, the salad was good but not fresh dressing or anything. The pizza was alright but no real flavor and it was just kinda floppy crust, also make sure you ask for it to be hot. And the garlic knots, usually my favorite part of the meal were just meh. They were rolls with oil and raw pre-minced garlic on top. Like you know the kind you get in the jar already? Ick. In the end, don't judge a pizza place by it's fancy Downtown Celebration name. Just accept the fact that downtown orlando is home to waaaayy better pizza by the slice. read more

Upper Crust Pizza - Looks better than it tastes. - Pizza Near Me - Celebration, Florida

Got delivery from here - pizza and wings. Wings don't appear to be fried, perhaps grilled and baked? Good char flavor - our sauce choice was hot, but was a mild medium at best - quite tasty! Pizza likely was awesome when they made it - all of the cheese shifted during delivery, and we didn't receive until 2 hours after ordering (not Upper Crust's fault - delivery glitch I believe). Pizza was half extra cheese and mushroom, half plain crust with cheese... regardless, was pretty tasty! read more

Incredible pizza in a beautiful area! They offer a wide variety of New York style pizza at a good price. The staff was extremely friendly and provided exceptional service! We are definitely going back! read more

Ok, this is my new favorite place for pizza. I like that I can buy a slice or a whole pie, I have to say though, it's a little disappointing if you want to eat it there and you'd like a glass of wine or a beer to go with your slice you'll have to improvise as they don't have adult beverages (so I held back a star). What they do have is the ratio of sauce to topping and crust figured out. I like a crisp thin crust which is exactly what they have. Just writing about it makes me want a slice, ugh....guess where I'm going tomorrow for lunch.... FYI- the pictures below do not do it justice read more

I always enjoy stopping by Upper Crust whenever I'm in the Celebration area. The location is easy to find and looks welcoming; with tables and chairs outside for people to sit. Depending on the time of day, the wait varies from walking in and placing an order with no wait, to waiting ten minutes or so to place your order. If you're in a hurry and don't mind picking the pizza up at the store, just place an order over the phone about fifteen minutes before you arrive! They have a variety of pizza and sizes but my personal favorite is the pepperoni. I'm also a huge fan of getting a slice of white pizza to go. Delicious! The pizzas are enough to feed up to six people depending on how much each person likes to eat. Overall, the atmosphere is nice, the store is clean, the employees are helpful, and the pizza is wonderful. read more

Well 2 years later and they still get 3 stars. The pizza has gotten a little bit more consistent, and I come here now exclusively as I am boycotting D'Antonio's and do not like the chain places (Papa John's Domino's, etc). A new addition to the menu since my last review are the chicken wings. They are actually excellent for a pizza place. They do have daily specials which include various items such as soda or wings for a lower price. The service is now hit or miss. I do not think that the "younger" staff should take call in orders. My order has been lost a few times and I had to wait an extra 15 minutes. #Yelp100 read more

Upper Crust Pizza - Take out - Pizza Near Me - Celebration, Florida

Visiting Disney from the NY/NJ area. For those as picky as us about pizza, this place surprisingly delivered. Passable plain pie, very reasonable, and delivered to our room at the resort as requested. They could have brought us some paper plates with the pie, but otherwise no real complaints here. Recommended. read more