Every time I walk past Upper Crust, I smell their fresh baked goods and I have to go in! I can't resist buying something either! Love that they have mini pies and pie flights! Their cookies are the best kept secret! My girls and I cannot resist their lemon sugar cookie! I don't know how you could possibly resist buying anything to eat there, but if you can, they also have the cutest home decor, baking supplies and little gifts! Their staff is also so friendly and nice! read more

See all

Love the pie there and ordered from them for Thanksgiving ! Pies are always yummy ! The service and staff are very accommodating!

Upper Crust is great for both pies and cookies. I LOVe the decadent chocolate cookie. It's amazing warm/heated up. We stop by basically every time we visit downtown OP. The staff is always welcoming and friendly. Definitely recommend if you are in the mood for a sweet treat! read more

Cute pie shop! We could smell the sweets from outside. We decided to go in and get a couple of cookies. They were moist and flavorful. The prices were a little high but great quality! The workers were very nice and helpful with any questions. read more

Was given a gift card and tried out a few things to mixed results. Had a very good blueberry pie. The key lime was a bit bitter and not my favorite, especially as it just had a traditional pie crust which didn't go as well IMO. Tried a couple of cookies also and it's hard to mess up a chocolate chip but this was dusty and dry, as was the peanut butter. Will try some more options with the rest of the gift card, but the average has been below .500 so far. Limited hours also a bit challenging. read more

Pie done the right way. I hosted an event that was center on pie, when choosing where I should buy from I wanted to make sure I got pie that people would actually want. When I told people there was pie I was first met with the classic "Oh that's okay I'm really not much of a sweet person" or "thank you but I'm not to hungry." That is until they saw upper crust pie... suddenly everyone was hungry and was a sweet person. Compliment after compliment on my pie picks, well worth the money spent! read more

Friendly service and a good variety of pie options. Tried the strawberry rhubarb slice. It was good. Really not a lot of options to sit so a better take and go kind of place. read more

This is a great spot for those who have a sweet tooth! The Upper Crust had many different treat options and I recommend that you give them all a try. My favorites are the mini/personal pies and their cookies. The pies are not only extremely cute but also very tastey. In addition to the mini pies, There are options to try their pies by the slice, or to take home one of their larger pies (a great option for sharing!) My favorite cookies are their peanut butter and snickerdoodle - although you can't go wrong with any of the cookie choices! There is no seating inside the shop so plan to take your treats with you! In addition to tastey treats, The Upper Crust also has cute housewares like kitchen towels, oven mitts, and aprons. I always find myself browsing as there is always something new! I highly recommend that you try out this shop if you are in the area! read more

See all

Stopped by Upper Crust to get a little sweet treat this afternoon. I had a hankering for coconut cream pie, but they didn't have any so I got a chocolate cream cutie pie instead. The pie is very yummy. I can't say it's the best I've had, because a place in Topeka has better. But it was the best I can get without going to Topeka. And their mini pies are just absolutely adorable! The bakery is super cute and they have lots of little gifts you can purchase on top of the pie and cookies. And the service was great. The women working were extremely sweet! read more

Upper Crust Pie Bakery - Chocolate cream mini pie - Bakeries Near Me - Overland Park, Kansas

See all

Hands down best pie in KC! Expensive and worth the price if you want a phenomenal pie that tastes like homemade, not like a mass produced chain bakery or grocery store pie! Quality ingredients and expertly made flaky crust make the pie what it is... amazing! The strawberry rhubarb, chocolate chess, coconut cream, peach, apple, sour cream blueberry, virtually every type of pie we have tried are incredible! It sounds like an exaggeration, but I really have yet to try a pie that is just, "meh", every one has been better than the last! The only complaint is the hours, I wish they were 24-7! They sometimes close early if they sell out of pie, which happens a lot, and that tells you how good the pie is! Highly recommend! read more

I stopped in on a Saturday afternoon after visiting the Farmer's Market, so I was admittedly visiting late in the day for a bakery - their pies were sold out, and I was told you have to arrive early Saturday morning to be able to snag one. So, learn from my mistake and drop by early if you want a pie! I did pick out several cookies to bring home which were thick, chewy, and absolutely delicious. Service was friendly and the shop itself is very cute. I'll definitely be making another trip to try some additional goodies! read more

They have some really good items and plenty to choose from, had several cookies and they are good. Had a peach pie and a corn quiche that was outstanding. Lady could be a bit snippy and prices to high, but really good products. Like the quiche and pies the best, cookies I have had better. read more

Upper Crust is by far the best place for pie in the metro area. Hands down. It's not only got the best pie, but their cookies are delectable, AND they've got the cutest shop in their storefront. Key Lime is my favorite, but they've got great combo flavors like apple blackberry and peach raspberry. So good!!!! read more

Upper Crust Pie Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Overland Park, Kansas

It's a good thing Upper Crust is only open four days a week because it's terribly delicious and utterly addictive. I first discovered this gem in 2018 and I have never, ever been the same. Everything else dessert-related has grown basic, boring, and bland by comparison. Don't look back: you're not going that way. I haven't sampled everything here; however, I've never been disappointed by this place. My favorite is their strawberry rhubarb pie-- tart and sweet, even better with some vanilla ice cream on top. The classic apple is always a good choice--warm it up and prepare to die happy. Their caramel apple pie is rare and obscenely delectable -- DO NOT MISS THAT OPPORTUNITY! Their crust is flaky, buttery, and it pairs perfectly with the fruity goodness inside. The sugar sprinkled atop is their signature and what can I say? I never want any other pie again (don't tell my mom, okay?!). It's pointless. I can always count on sister-owners, Elaine and Jan, when I need to bring a treat to a get together. I have called numerous times at the last minute and they're always kind enough to set something aside or help me get a hold of the perfect little something. While pie is the star of the show, their pecan bars are equally delicious--salty n' sweet-- maybe just sinful! Also: did I mention they have the perfect hostess gifts? Tons of thoughtful presents for people you love, or just get yourself those darling oven mitts with dogs on them, you deserve it! I miss the days when I could come here with a friend and grab a cozy little table and enjoy a slice together. But you can take it to go and find a spot to sit outside-- or, if you're me, scarf it down in the car on your drive home. I love this place, I can't get enough, and it's always just what I'm craving. Go there immediately! read more

See all

Kind and helpful staff! Great quality of pies, I'd say the best in town when it comes to real flavors and enjoyability ( is that a word?) Ambiance has the feel of grandma's kitchen, referring to baking from scratch. Yes I recommend this business for everything pies! read more

Super happy people work there. They treat you special when you visit. The pies? MMMMMMMM! Got a slice of Cherry pie and highly recommend. Also got a version of a banana bread scone and it was also great. Took the two mini pies home and they were awesome. The fillings are wonderful. The crust is hard to describe. It is like thin layered Baklava pastry. Not exactly the same but in that area. Very flaky/pastry like. Quaint little shop. Sat outside to eat a slice of Cherry pie to enjoy the weather. A little pricey, but worth it. I will be back! read more

Upper Crust Pie Bakery - Raspberry Rhubarb and Blueberry mini pies! - Bakeries Near Me - Overland Park, Kansas

Grabbed a couple of mini pies to celebrate 3.14 day! We tried the bumbleberry, the chocolate and the lemon curd pies. They were all delicious!! The bakery is super cute and the staff was friendly and helpful on a very busy day! read more

See all

Banana cookie... is like fluff of yummy in your mouth!!! I cannot wait to try more delightful things from this establishment!!! Great service and super clean!!! read more

Upper Crust Pie Bakery - Banana cookie! - Bakeries Near Me - Overland Park, Kansas

Why are there not more pie shops in Kansas City? Also, why isn't anybody as upset by this as me? It's no secret that the Upper Crust is the the best pie shop in the metro. You may not know that they also make killer cookies. I stopped in the other day after lunch *just* for a cookie, got sidetracked by all the wonderful local goodies available for purchase and ended up taking way too long to decide on a cookie flavor only to get both and share with my family when I got home. Spoiler: they were both amazing. Just go here and eat pie. Just do it. read more

Cute little pie shop with some of the best pies I've ever tried. A bit pricey but the quality is amazing, totally worth trying. The butterscotch has to be my all time favorite, it's perfection. read more

See all

Let's shout out to a locally owned and operated business that has survived the cruddy show of the past two years! The Upper Crust Pie Bakery is truly a delight that Overland Park should make sure to protect and keep in business! These folks do the work, elbow grease and make a product worth of raving reviews. Call ahead and make it easier for their staff. Be helpful to a smaller staff that is keeping their heads above water while trying to keep the public happy. Let me be very fair, go back through my hundreds and hundreds of reviews. I do NOT like sweets, however, I am able to find things here that I can appreciate and they're always a crowd pleaser! Stop in, check them out, call ahead if you know what you want. Keep their doors open and lights on folks! read more

I can only tell you that everything we tried was delicious! It was from takeout but my Mom said it was a cute spot. Tried a strawberry rhubarb pie and some toffee chocolate nut amazing bite! read more

I stopped here last Wednesday, a few hours after they opened. I was in the area and they were finally open when I was there. I've been here before and have had a pretty decent time, and when their pies are made fresh, they are normally quite well. I got 2 chocolate chip cookies, 1 shortbread cookie, 1 banana cookie, and a piece of pecan pie. First off, they only had a few pies available to be served as a slice. They were not out, or presented to the public and they were sliced back behind, in the baking area. ThIere is a reason for that I feel, which I will get to. The whole pies, were over $33 a piece. THIRTY THREE DOLLARS for a whole pie.. Yeah, wow... Don't tell me about how pies are made, etc.. I make pies, cakes and cookies. That is too much for a pie, period. Especially when they can't serve a slice that is quality. People really need to get out more, taste things more and know quality vs cost. There are other pie places around KC where they are UNDER priced for quality, not here. The piece of pecan pie that I got, was old. This was a Wednesday. They had been closed for 3 days prior. When was this pie made!? Who knows, but they went ahead and charged me full price for the slice. The bottom crust was so saturated with goo, that it was non existent. Just paper thin goo that had melded into the pecan mixture. The pie filling itself had aged so much, that part of it had a toffee chewiness that could only be achieved by age. It had a slight off flavor as well. This was 100% not fresh baked pie, and was 100% full price. That is not okay. You are a pie shop, make fresh pies. The 2 chocolate chip cookies were not for me, but I tasted a bit. They were okay, with an odd over sweetness to them. The shortbread was thick and amazing. Super good and the best thing I tried there. Crumbly bite and soft texture. Really good. The banana cookie, was lack luster. I remembered trying it, as soon as I bit into it. The cookie part smells great, but barely has any flavor. The icing is too sweet with the sweetness being the over all flavor. I get it, the icing is supposed to "sugar up" the cookie, but it doesn't work. Flavor up that cookie and tame down the icing sweetness and you may have something. The cookie was so moist it practically fell part, and then the icing was near rock hard (sugar). I MAY go back sometime, but I feel "this place isn't for me" (as I can hear people reading this may say) .. And I'm 100% okay with that! FYI, staff did NOT have face masks on. This is in response to their posted policy on this page and a response to a customer that had an issue. read more

See all

Absolutely Delicious pies and cookies! They were also very helpful in describing the pies and cookies. However it was so difficult to make a decision. I'll definitely be back often! read more

Great pies. They make everything from scratch - which I really appreciate. I do think it's VERY overpriced. ($9.53 was my total for a single serve mini pie). The pie crust is almost pastry flaky, rather than a food pie crust flake. I didn't like that as well. The cherry pie filling was much too sweet (and I adore sugar so that's saying a lot). I had to buy milk when I got home just to cut the sweetness between bites! Still 4 stars for this unique little bakery. I ate every bit of the pie in two sittings. And I can't complain much about my personal preferences when this is still homemade goodness. And they compost! They also have a cute little shop inside to buy gifts and baking utensils. Adds something unique to this place compared to other bakeries. read more

Upper Crust Pie Bakery - Cherry pie - Bakeries Near Me - Overland Park, Kansas

The service is excellent, friendly and efficient. The pie is absolutely the best! Strawberry Rhubarb is fantastic read more

I definitely feel that I need to go back here for a full understanding of what they offer, so I will make that a priority. However, on the occasion that I visited, I got two slices of fruit pie. It's not that they weren't good, it's just that the crust was a bit more flakey than I would have liked. Also, they really didn't have much of a variety when I visited. It was just one or two different types of pie. No cream options and very limited. Additionally, the hours at that time (early 2020) were pretty difficult for me, as I work a 9-5 and by the time I could get there after work there they were almost closed. In some cases, they were closed and I had driven all the way there. In any case, I need to do some further research and get out there again. I've heard great things, my experience just wasn't what I had hoped at the time. read more

Pie crust good, clean and friendly service. No so good, fruit pies NEVER cooked fruit enough, ie.. Apple pies always undercooked. Strawberry Ruhbarb short on strawberries. Lastly expensive! $ 35.00 pie read more

I love Uppercrust but did myself wrong. I bought a miniature apple crisp pie, but should've bought a whole pie. Needless to say, my dog loves Uppercrust and enjoyed his peanut butter dog treat from there as well. Unfortunately I left without cookies! (What was wrong with me??) The shop is adorable. Several cute items available displayed. I will certainly return there a lot. read more

Upper Crust Pie Bakery - Pies! - Bakeries Near Me - Overland Park, Kansas

See all

Cannot rave enough about this lovely little spot in downtown OP. With a warm and welcoming atmosphere upon entering, be ready to have your senses overwhelmed with baked goods joy. This initial trip brought me in for whatever lucky pie was available which ended up being blueberry. It was fantastic. Looking forward to getting back in for a cherry or their rumble pie. Couple other items I grabbed to enjoy were their peanut butter cookie and burnt sugar banana. I didn't get the enjoy the banana one, but everyone that's tried it has loved it. Looking forward to more pie in my future. read more

Pie. Need I say more? Looking for a dessert option? Want to satisfy your sweet tooth? Maybe just something to take home to the fam, or to liven up an office potluck? Yeah, you can reach the summit of any of your climbs by visiting this cozy bakery in downtown OP. Founded by sisters (Elaine and Jan) who know a thing or two about baking fabulous pies and pastries, Upper Crust is in its second decade of pie excellence in the surging downtown OP area. Always offering an array of usual suspects, Upper Crust also does an outstanding job of seasonal favorites and creations. This past fall, one of their masterpieces was a 'Wild Turkey' pie, which was a collision of pecan pie, chocolate chips, and a hint of bourbon (sinfully delicious). Apple and berry pies are almost always on the list of choices, and not just your everyday pies (raspberry/rhubarb?). Pies are regular size, and usually run $12-$14, or you can do a 'cutie pie', an $8 individual size (which theoretically could be shared, but let's be serious, that's not going to happen). Pie can be warmed and served ala mode if you're staying in, or wrapped to go if you have the requisite restraint. Fun fact: every third Friday of a month (except December) has an event called 'Flight Night'. What kind of pie magic is this? you may ask. Think samples on lock: a 'flight' is three slices of their current menu offerings, all for $10. Or you can get saucy and do a pair of flights (affectionately known as a 'round trip') and try the whole menu. Pro tip: get there *early* (Flight Night runs from 5-8 or earlier if sold out) because you will stand in line. For pie. Without shame. Also part of the framework is a great sampling of boutique-y kitchen and home items. Kind of like the entry of a Cracker Barrel, but with, uh, taste. Many items are locally made and one of a kind, so you are shopping and supporting local, and then socking back pie. [See also: winning]. It's a must try. And don't wait about. read more

See all

Love the fact they donate their tips to charities. Everything we ordered was tasty and the lady behind counter very nice and helpful.

Great pies, and slices are to die for! Hard to argue with the quality. Everyone there is also incredibly kind and fun to work with also

I found this bake shop about 3 years ago, and being a cherry pie aficionado, I thought I had found the perfect place. But unfortunately over the last year, the quality of this flavor of pie has really gone downhill. Their cherry pie now consists of a lot more goop than actual cherries. I thought it might just be an isolated incident, so I gave them a second and even a third try, only to find the additional pies to be of equally poor quality. When I called it to the attention of one of the owners, she just gave me a shrug of the shoulders and didn't really seem to care. I've officially purchase my last cherry pie there. On a positive note, their snooker doodles are still good! read more

Is the Upper Crust expensive? Yes. Do they use the best ingredients? Yes. Are the best ingredients expensive? Yes. I rest my case. Best apple pie I've had since my Mom passed away. read more

The pies are a 5 star, the prices are a bit steep. Love the pie flights, 3 smaller slices, so you can taste pieces you might not buy. I had cinnamon cream last week, delicious. Make sure to order ahead. read more

Loved that they are a small pie shop in the KC area. I love their pies, I've pretty much bight all small pies and tried them individually. I love all of them and I can't choose! read more

Wow just waking by this place will make you crave pie! You smell butter and crust the minute you walk past. My friends brought me here for a pie breakfast- lol. Ok I had a few bites of shared pie and managed to have some quiche also. (Also quite amazing!) we sampled the chocolate with meringue top, bumble berry, apple caramel, and pecan! (There was 5 of us!! So a "shared" experience!) Not much pie left... not for lack of trying. It's a small spot so hard to squeeze in - some room in front of it's not too cold. Run, walk, eat in- or out- but go! read more

My daughter bought me one of their cutie pies for my birthday. It was absolutely decadent! I got to go to this little ma and pa shop nestled in Downtown Overland Park a few weeks later to pick up a cutie pie for my daughter's birthday and also grabbed a pecan pie for a treasured rescue volunteer knowing it is her hubby's favorite. Upper Crust smells like heaven and the staff was so welcoming that I did not want to leave. The pies were a hit! read more

Best pie in KC area! Not the least expensive but my go to for those family holiday needs. Also have great home made cookies.