Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    United Methodist Thrift Shop

    3.0 (2 reviews)

    United Methodist Thrift Shop Photos

    You might also consider

    More like United Methodist Thrift Shop

    Recommended Reviews - United Methodist Thrift Shop

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Annie S.
    90
    73
    37

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Savers

    Savers

    3.4
    (383 reviews)
    3.4 mi
    $

    Buy this place seems so busy but when you look closely the number of cars in the parking lot does…read morenot match the number of people inside the store so be aware that the parking lot is always which I understand I think maybe it's overflow parking for the apartment people that need to do something about that because and then you lost a customer or the store overall the store has plenty of selection is actually one of the largest Savers that I have seen pricing is well it might have been higher but there's some very very unique things sometimes they also have special days that offer discount special discount coupons for search for those

    Savers, you seriously NEED to reevaluate who you're hiring and how your employees are trained…read morebecause my experience with Rosa was beyond unacceptable. I have been a loyal customer since this location opened, and I have never been treated with such disrespect. I found an item without a price tag and did exactly what customers are supposed to do- I brought it to an employee to have it priced. As I was in the middle of checking out, Rosa suddenly took the item out of my hands and refused to sell it to me, claiming it was "not for sale" because she needed to "investigate" it. I calmly asked, "I'm sorry, did I do something wrong?" Instead of explaining the situation professionally, she spoke to me with a rude, confrontational attitude and began questioning me as though I had done something wrong. I remained respectful the entire time, yet I was treated like I was being accused of something simply because I wanted to purchase an item. The situation became even more disturbing when Rosa followed me outside of the store after the interaction. As a customer, that was intimidating, unnecessary, and completely unprofessional. No employee should ever make a customer feel that uncomfortable. I've shopped at countless thrift stores, including Savers for years, and I have never experienced behavior like this. I left feeling embarrassed, singled out, and deeply disrespected. The donation attendants have consistently treated me with kindness and professionalism, which only made Rosa's behavior stand out even more. If Rosa's actions reflect Savers' standards for customer service, then customers deserve to know that. If they don't, then management needs to address this immediately. No loyal customer should be treated with hostility, have merchandise taken from them at the register without a proper explanation, or be followed outside of the store. This experience has completely changed my opinion of this location, and unless something is done about the way Rosa treats customers, I won't be returning.

    Photos
    Ig @_athenaethreals
    Ig @_athenaethreals
    Love the drive thru line
    Love the drive thru line
    Electronic (Mar 2023)

    See all

    Electronic (Mar 2023)
    Bargain Box

    Bargain Box

    3.9
    (36 reviews)
    3.3 mi
    $

    A friend of mine who volunteers her time with the Assistance League of Arcadia at the Bargain Box…read moretold me to check it out and so glad I did... 5 stars!!!!! If you are a fan of the Huntington Collection in Pasadena, you'll be sure to love the Bargain Box. Just like the Huntington Collection, I can't call it a thrift shop since it's not like any thrift shops I've been to! Looks more like an expensive antique shop when you step inside. I was blown away by the quality of the available merchandise, especially the housewares and decor. It's very evident that all of the pieces on sale were meticulously cleaned and staged by the hardworking staff. All of the furniture and housewares are excellent condition, not to mention very well priced. Make a point to visit before Halloween! The store is all decked out with Halloween decor! The Bargain Box is managed by the Assistance League of Arcadia, and one of their worthy endeavors is Operation School Bell, which provides much needed clothing as well as school supplies such as backpacks and books to children in need in neighboring local schools. There's a small parking lot but there should be plenty of street parking available if needed. Also, be aware that the store has limited hours since it's managed by volunteers. It's only open two days a week, Wednesdays and Saturdays, from 10am to 1pm.

    I'm hesitant to leave this review because I don't want to share this place. Small and clean, it's…read moremore like a little boutique than a typical thrift store. Clothing, jewelry, books...they carry a little bit of everything here. I enjoy browsing the racks and shelves even when I leave empty handed. Good to know: They are only open on Wednesdays and Saturdays. I suggest subscribing to their email list so you know the weekly happenings before you visit. The lot is on the smaller side and it fills up pretty quickly. There is plenty of street parking on Live Oak, but that also fills up on Wednesdays. If you arrive a little before opening there is usually a short line outside to get in, but there is never a mad rush to get in or anything, so don't let the line scare you away!

    Photos
    Holiday Items 2024
    Holiday Items 2024
    Holiday Items 2024
    Holiday Items 2024
    Holiday Items 2024

    See all

    Holiday Items 2024
    Willie's Vintage Monrovia

    Willie's Vintage Monrovia

    4.4
    (26 reviews)
    1.2 mi
    $$

    Stopped by Willie's vintage on an impulse and was very happy I did! It is a lovely shop full of…read morecharacter and a wide range of items, all curated by the owners, Jeanette and Raquel. I am slowly replacing items we lost in the Eaton fire, and not only did I find some nice jewelry pieces, they had a lovely vintage Hawaiian dress that brought back a flood of nostalgic memories. On top of that, J and R were so kind and gave me some items to help us on our rebuilding journey. They showed remarkable kindness and warmth to a random customer, and they really were a highlight of my week! They took time out of their day to listen and make recommendations, and their store is a real oasis of treasures and positivity. It's well with everyone's time to stop by, check their stock and support a local business!

    My husband stopped by looking for a mannequin (don't ask:)) to put a t-shirt and hat on of a band I…read morehave been listening to on a loop for a very long time. I actually didn't know he even realized it. He stopped by this store just down the hill from where we live and they were so helpful. They were able to accommodate and found just what he was looking for. Now the problem is, I swear, wherever I go she is watching me. My dogs think so too as they peek around the corner to see if she's still there. He stopped by to thank them today and they asked him to pick out something for me. He walked in the house so proud with a new gift. It just happened to be Valentine's Day, so it worked out great for him. :) Thank you so much!! He enjoyed shopping at your store (he's the shopper in the family) as much as I loved the gift.

    Photos
    Willie's Vintage Monrovia
    We SOURCE everything! Nothing is donated in. We CURATE.
    We SOURCE everything! Nothing is donated in. We CURATE.
    Sold

    See all

    Sold
    Wistaria Thrift Shop

    Wistaria Thrift Shop

    3.9
    (18 reviews)
    3.8 mi
    $

    They are run by nice people and they do not accept all the time and when you arrive with your…read moredonation, they greet you and ask if you need a donation receipt. The shop is in a very good location. I will be back!

    A very limited selection of items. Clothes are lack luster and traditional, nothing eclectic or…read morefashion forward as you would find in Pasadena or Los Angeles. Prices are around $7 to $10 for items, such as the Size 6 Talbots women's work pants I picked up (my luck). The tableware and kitchen acoutrements are worth perusing if you like those things. Rather too many old books and not enough of the utility items that people want to buy second hand. In terms of service, the young woman is very pleasant. Otherwise I had a palpable sense of a frontier small town with a closed knit white community where non-white are treated as suspicious. History lives large in these parts, it's only a century ago that the Europeans came here from the eastern US. As well, this is attached to a women's club which is an organization reflecting the "settler" ethos. Anyway I wouldn't bother again, and would look through shops in Pasadena for more choice. Also I had a whole car load of things to donate but I decided to take it back to LA where the charitable causes seem more pressing (than a women's club in a white enclave city which participated until recently in U.S. apartheid) and the population is more diverse.

    Photos
    Wistaria Thrift Shop
    Wistaria Thrift Shop
    Wistaria Thrift Shop

    See all

    United Methodist Thrift Shop - thrift_stores - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...