Quality artisan Italian fare , very high prices and a little bit of an attitude. This place would…read morebe perfect in East Hampton or Manhasset but most Sayvillians are priced out of this market. If I hit the lottery, I would shop here every day, but until then I must say goodbye after years as a loyal customer. Guys behind the counter seem to make up the prices as they go; poor customer service. Farewell my friend, I will miss your your crab cakes most. Very clean store and perfect for high end catering. Minus 3 stars for unreasonably high price points.

Wow 60 bucks for 2 sandwiches and 10 ceaser pasta salad. This place was once a true gem, sorry to…read moresee new greedy owners take over and ruin a great thing. Glad we have new options around

One of the worst meat farms. Produce isn't great. A couple of times I've went to get a few quick…read morethings and at least one of fruits/vegetables I was looking for was all inedible. The meat is okay but I only buy it if I have to since if they don't care about their produce, I'm weary about how they care for the meat

Meh. Not so good. Why does the deli have the numbers to take…read morewhen they never use them and why is there a sign in the store that says no marijuana smoking is that usually a problem inside the store and sometimes the quiche's look like they were a third grader science project gone wrong Who does quality control and what are they doing? Why do you serve rainbow bagels? It's just bagel with food dye. On a positive note, the prepared stuffed mushrooms are probably the best stuffed mushrooms I've ever had in my entire life +2 stars for that

The restroom are very dirty and stinky, was about to pass out, they need to focus more on…read morecleanliness

insanely over-priced. items are shelves frequently…read moremis-labeled. You must read the labels , buy 2 get one free. ridiculous .Must buy 3 to get the sale price. almost 8.00 for a quart of heavy cream. go anywhere but here.

Everything was delicious. I highly recommend it. Service was wonderful. The atmosphere was really…read moreenjoyable

Best seafood around. Always fresh and cooked to perfection. You HAVE to have the lobster rolls!read more

I came here today, Memorial Day, to buy flowers for the family grave. Stop and Shop has a Floral…read moreDepartment that sells gorgeous and reasonably priced floral arrangements for holidays and special occasions. I bought a bouquet for a reasonable $9.99, which is considerably less than what I would pay at Home Depot. Customer service representative, Shari, showed me how to assemble the urn. Lorin found me a plant food packet that was missing from my bouquet. Staff is always courteous here. Visit stopandshop .com to clip and dowload coupons to your discount card. Cards are obtained at the Customer Service Center. It is worth it to take the time to clip coupons because some of the coupons give you up to $3 off. I will be using one today to buy a gallon of laundry detergent. The store has a hot bar, too. Gone is their hot café, in adherence to Covid-19 guidelines. I have been coming to this location for years, and it never fails to impress me, especially now that the store is fully renovated. I will continue to Stop and Shop at this location.

There A Unionized Store And They Have A Lot Of Good Things To Buy Coca-Cola Is Plentiful…read more Prices Are Low Progressives Are Everywhere.

Hungry man breakfast had 2 pieces of bacon - SKIMPY!!!! - Cheese was stuck to paper that sandwich…read morewas in - other items I bought were not up to par with other delis - I guess dinner must be better - will NOT go back .......P.S. I brought home the Philly Cheesesteak and it WAS PITIFUL !!!!! How long has this place been there ??? It's a miracle they are still open.

Crosstown Chef is a new deli that opened on Montauk Highway, right before you get into the main…read moretown of Sayville. Its the next street over from the restaurant "Off the Block". I live a few streets over and I've never been happier to have such a quality deli this close. I have had breakfast and lunch multiple times from here. I have had egg white wraps, breakfast burritos & french toast for breakfast. I have also had a couple different sandwiches for lunch (El Guapo is so good, it's a must have), along with their iced coffee. Everything I have had has been 5 stars. The quality and portions of food is amazing. They have a very nice store, with a handful of tables to dine in. There are "to go" sandwiches freshly made that come with a bag of chips. Super convenient if you are in a rush and don't have the few extra minutes to wait for them to make a sandwich. Service is fast, and the staff as well as the owner are super friendly. I have had a couple of nice convos with the owner, you can tell how much he cares about his store. Go check it out!

Deli Was staying…read moredown the street at the HGI and needed a NY breakkie - found this deli and popped over. A little out of sight the way it is situated, I managed to find it and headed in. Two ladies working there were cheerful and got me going with my breakfast order. While they were cooking, I roamed the store- everything you expect to find in a deli was pretty much there. Got my goods and paid up while still chatting with the people working there- they are just extremely nice - and that is a good thing early in the morning. Prices were average. Parking in front.

Super easy to order online (DoorDash storefront) and all of the notes, modifications were done…read moreexactly as requested. Very friendly folks inside. The order was ready within 20 minutes of ordering. Not a very large space but a decent menu. Nice variety of chips and drinks. The macaroni salad was quite boring. Cole slaw was solid. My chicken Caesar wrap was quite good. My wife was not a fan of her Chicken club hero. The cutlet was super thin and dry/hard. Nothing but chicken, bacon and cheese. The menu states this but she must have overlooked this and was expecting a typical "club" type sandwich. Not MJ's fault.

I love the oils and vinegars here. You can taste the different varieties in small cups or dip bread…read morein them. I wish they had plain gluten free crackers to sample the flavors. My favorite oil is the white truffle. It's expensive but worth every penny. I enjoy it on grilled vegetables. Some of the sweet vinegars are nice over berries or ice cream. Go in around the holidays for their lovely gift baskets.

The Crushed Olive is the newest addition to Sayville and a welcome addition to Long Island's…read moregourmet food scene. This new location on Main Street is in addition to their two existing Long Island locations in Huntington and Stony Brook. Offering an unmatched variety of premium olive oil and balsamic vinegar you will be sure to find the perfect fit for your family's taste. The Crushed Olive offers everything from your basic Extra Virgin Olive Oil to more complex infused oils, bursting with flavors from Tuscan Herb and Persian Lime to Wild Mushroom & Sage and Herbs de Provence. I was also pleasantly surprised to find that many of their oils are certified organic! Not sure where to begin on your mission to find the perfect oil or vinegar? Fear not! The warm, Tuscan appointed décor invites you in to sample each and every oil and vinegar there is to offer. Feel free to peruse the many offerings, reading about each product and pouring yourself samples until you find and old favorite or an existing new selection. Besides, who doesn't love dipping pieces of crusty bread into the perfect olive oil or vinegar?