I stopped here to get a Steak and Cheese Sub. Wow, it was great, bread was perfect, so fresh and sub was so delicious. Not much atmosphere here, but staff was friendly. I would recommend if you want to get one of the best subs I have found in the area! read more

Good pizza. Very friendly service. What's not to like? Pizza is very very good. Location has a few tables for eat in service. Their desserts look good but I did not try. read more

Awesome restaurant and awesome service! Came in Wanting slices of Pizza but that was not available. Decided on a Gyro but it didn't come with fries. Ended up ordering a burger with fries. The guy taking my order was nice enough to give me the Gyro with fries for the same price. Everything that came out was fresh, hot and flavorful. The place is also really clean but the service here is great! read more

See all

Super great food and great service. Owner and family super nice. I highly recommend eating here!!!

I went to Two Sisters Pizza several years ago and after ordering pizza from them 2-3 times, I was underwhelmed at best. The bottom crust was always soggy, toppings were not top quality while the pizza always seemed like it was undercooked meaning, they put enough oven heat to the pie to just melt the cheese and brown the crust. After finding much better pizza choices in Williamsburg and staying away from Two Sisters for many years, I decided to give Two Sisters another shot. Well, my opinion hasn't changed and nor has the quality of pizza. The underside crust is still soggy (even after asking for an extra long cook). Ordering the "meat" pizza, the quality of ingredients was marginal at best. The pepperoni was decent but the other meats were lower end and the pie went downhill fast. Ham that was more like thick sliced ham that would be found at the grocery store deli counter and cut into pieces, ground beef that was poorly "seasoned" sprinkled over the top along with sausage but, not the standard Italian sliced or pinched sausage normally served on pizza. Two Sisters use sliced kielbasa as their sausage of choice. Disgusting. I also ordered the garden salad which included chopped iceberg lettuce, a couple slices of tomato, cucumber and red onion with a 1 or 2 oz small side of dressing. Average at best. So I gave Two Sisters another opportunity to satisfy my palate and earn my business. They fell short...again. As much as I enjoy patronizing local ma and pa pizza shops, and as much as I wanted to like their pizza, I won't be back to Two Sisters. Their prices are reasonable but, you get what you pay for. Their pizza might satisfy hungry kids who don't have a discerning palate but for someone who knows what good pizza should be like, there are better options around town. read more

Excellent food, and very friendly service we had Margherita pizza which was very good and tzatzike and pita bread

Had to wait for our order - we were a walk in - but so very worth it! The basil on the Margherita pizza came from a small garden right out front! The salad was crisp and just great! Tiny place - more of a counter than a restaurant - but worth it! read more

See all

Visited Two Sisters Pizzaria during our trip to Virginia. We loved it. The owners and staff were more than helpful and very courteous. The pizza was hand made and very tasteful. It was very hot which is the only way to eat great pizza. This was a quaint little place with seating for about 12-16. A sort of little entry feel. The guys there talked with with us about where we are from and the difference in areas. Try the carrot cake, very tasty! Definitely recommend!! read more

Two Sisters Pizzeria - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

During thanksgiving break, we gave this local family owned restaurant in Williamsburg, VA a try. They carry Italian dishes, subs, pizzas and wraps (gyros). We ordered; lasagna, beef gyro, chicken fillets & fries, and hummus and pita. Everything was mouthwatering and freshly made. My husband and I both enjoyed every bite of our appetizers and the entrees. I encourage everyone to support this local business and try out their amazing flavorful dishes!! The family will give you a pleasant feeling and make you feel right at home! read more

See all

Decent, kid-friendly pizza. Toppings are extra! The base price on the pizza is cheese only. The dining room is small and seats 12 people. Order: Garlic bread with cheese Large pizza with ham/pepperoni The garlic bread only had cheese on one side (I removed the plain pieces from the pic). The dipping sauce was tasty. The pizza is sliced into large pieces that are reminiscent of NY style pizza. The pizza was very plain tasting which makes it kid-friendly. Our daughter went nuts over it. The pizza could use more flavor. The pizza & breadsticks were ok. read more

See all

My family and I were traveling from New Jersey to Virginia. We saw this restaurant and it is family based. The owners are Muslim and everything is HALAL! The food is so delicious that my family and I ate it two days in a row for dinner. The service is wonderful as the owners check up on us and the food comes out quick. Before my family and I leave to go back to New Jersey, we are going to go once more to indulge in the wonderful items on their menu. Whoever is in the Williamsburg area in Virginia, please do check this small family run business! You will be satisfied that you would want to come back again and again! read more

The Meatball Parm Sub is excellent! The bread is high quality and comes perfectly toasted. The beef, sauce and cheese are full of flavor. It's also served nice and hot. read more

I would post a photo of the Pizza Margherita but we ate it all before I could. I don't normally like tomatoes on pizza but I loved this one! We ordered from Two Sisters twice in one week. It took about 20-25 minutes from placing the order for the pizza to be ready. It seems like a small family run operation. We've tried every non chain pizza shop in town, and this is our favorite hands down. read more

We found this place during our 123 Dating Series. 2 is for Two Sisters Pizzeria. It was an absolutely wonderful experience. To start while placing our order, customer service was excellent: Kindness with proper manners being modeled and also accommodating my dietary restrictions. When the pizzas arrived, they were delicious! You can taste just how fresh all the ingredients are, including the crust baked to perfection. Also, the baklava was the perfect dessert. Lastly, we just warmed up our leftovers, and it tastes just a good a couple days later. read more

We had a great takeout order of lasagna and a meatball parm sub. The food was great and happy to know all the meat is halal. Be sure to ask for plates, napkins and utensils. read more

Decent pizza and garlic cheese bread, very kid-friendly, but I've definitely had better. The seasoning on the bread was not quite standard Italian seasoning. The pizza could use more seasoning. read more

Two Sisters Pizzeria - Garlic Bread with Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

Worst pizza ever. I ordered delivery an hour before closing. They delivered it quickly, but it was only half baked. I tried to call and inform them of the situation and they refused to answer. The pizza was cold and totally uncooked in the center. It inedible and was hungry from 8 hours of driving and they ruined the entire evening. read more

It was good and all but I ordered a margherita pizza and got plain. I ate it bc what else am I gonna do? Thanks anyway

It's a nice small place, run by a Pakistani family. The service was good, food was ok. I ordered Adana Kabab, it was dry and on the hard side. My son ordered Philly chees stake sub, it looked like a foot long and was very good. read more

We stayed at the Historic Powhatan and ordered pizza and pasta from here. Very close to resort. Food was good and service was friendly.

Amazing food, quick very friendly service! We were with a bigger group the hummus, falafel salad msny beef gyros and cheese pizza! Excellent, if in Williamsburg worth the stop for lunch or dinner! read more

Two Sisters Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Alright, shame on me for ordering pizza on Christmas night but our plans fell through and we were looking for something easy. Pizza sounded good, Two Sisters was open. The crust and the sauce was nice, as were the pepperonis. My big hangup is that they are calling kielbasa "Italian sausage". I can't get past it. I don't like it. Reminds me of a pizza place I ate at in Colon, Panama that was slicing hot dogs onto pizza and calling it pepperoni. Not a fan. Real Italian sausage would have changed this experience entirely. read more

Food!!!! This is not the type of place you would normally stay and eat your meal. BUT, if your looking for fantastic food To Go then this is the place. We ordered a large deluxe pizza and it did not disappoint. I normally order extra sauce but had forgotten. When we started eating the pizza it was clear there was no need for extra anything. read more

Food was great, delivered on time and wasn't too expensive. Beef pepperoni is my favorite so glad i found a spot here that had some! Will definitely order again! read more

We always order the cheese pizza adding pepperoni, mushrooms and onion. Our favorite pizza. Haven't ordered from any of the national stores in over a year. read more

No offense to Little Charlie's or Sal's by Victor, but this pizza is the one to get in Williamsburg area. This pizza is very unique. I've eaten pizza all up and down the east coast, but this is different. I can't help but think the sliced sausage is very reminiscent of sujuk. Very flavorful and fresh. I always order my pizza well done and try to compare similar pizzas, but this is difficult. It's truly a unique meat pizza that stands out from others. It's similar enough that die-hard NY style pizza fans will embrace it, but unique enough to satisfy the most discerning foodie. No doubt this is a family run pizzeria. The father and son were working up front and both were helpful while making natural conversation. As far as atmosphere... Well, you can't eat ambiance. No one goes to a pizzeria for the atmosphere anyways. We go for the pie and the staff/service. On those notes, fuggedaboutit. These folks will be embraced by all of us Paisans. read more

See all

Good spot for a quick(ish) lunch. Very nice people working here (the owners I assume). I had the lamb kebob sandwich and a side salad with oil and vinegar dressing. Both very good, the meat was a little over cooked (almost charred) on the sandwich but it was still very good. Nice little place to pop into for a quick bite over fast food. read more

Two Sisters Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Neighborhood take out and we had a small pizza with peperoni and mushroom. The small was large enough for 3 or a modest 4. Peperoni had a little spice, well sprinkled on the pizza and the mushroom were decent slices as opposed to bits on other competitors. The pizza was well cooked and not burned. We had plenty left over for lunch the next door warming in a frying pan with a touch of olive oil. Will order again for take out. read more

The cheese pizza was excellent and I really liked their fries, but the baklava. wow. baklava was superb. It was the best I've ever tried. And to think I almost never found this out. I ordered it last minute when, paying for take out, the owner casually motioned to the display "want a couple pieces of baklava?" I glanced, they glistened, so I said sure. It's amazing melt-in-your-mouth quality. Highly recommended it. read more

I have been here in Williamsburg for two years now. I live right down the road and I have put this business off due to a lack of faith in good pizza here. The pizza was excellent to say the lease. The sauce is phenomenal, the crust is perfect and cheese is delicious. These people know what they are doing and have me as a regular. Sold! Good job guys! read more

We ordered Two Sisters Pizza while in Williamsburg for the night. We ordered a pizza with Italian Sausage and were delivered a pizza with kielbasa on it which was absolutely disgusting. We also ordered hot wings....which were literally dry fried chicken wings with three packets of Texas Pete hot sauce provided on the side. No ranch or blue cheese just hot sauce packets. Total waste of money read more

We have been Two Sisters customers for years. The pizzas were made with real cheese and the owner had fresh basil in the sauce. The new owners don't seem to be following in the same footsteps. We tried it twice just to make sure it wasn't a one time thing. Skip this place, you can get the same at little Caesar's and pay less. We are so sad to have to search for a new pizza place. read more

Great, great, friendly family owned restaurant. Food always fresh & taste good. We visit everyone we come to town. Highly recommended! read more

Got a medium Hawaiian pizza. The crust was so hard that it was inedible. The actual pizza was so bad that even my two year old, who spent the better part of the day saying, "PIZZA! Pizza!", only took about two bites. I've seriously had frozen pizzas that were way better. read more

The food is amazing here and also the the customer service. The owner came out to check on us and to make sure we were enjoying our food. We love this place and so happy we found it. The burgers are made fresh, chickwn wings are very tasty, gyros are very delicious and fresh. We will come back to this place every time we visit Williamsburg. *They serve all halal food. read more

A 10 minute walk from our house. Local pizza joint next-door?! Awesome! Sort of... There is nothing implicitly wrong with two sisters, other than it being a little overpriced. A greek salad and a 3 topping pizza was $30! Not unheard of, but still steep. We also tried the subs... stick with the pizza. It's by far one of the more superior products on their menu. ***TASTE*** They use cheap meat on their subs and are stingy on the ingredients. The sub was thin and light so if you're expecting that hardy New Jersey sub look elsewhere. You get more food and more for your dollar at the likes of Jimmy John's. The pizza tasted great, but if you're looking for top notch, try Daddy-Os, or if you're looking for a great price, do Brick House. They sure are convenient though... we'd probably stop back in again due to convenience alone, but were we driving by Brickhouse or recommending something to our friends we would gloss over this place. I'm all about supporting local, but I think we were a little disappointed in Two Sis. I wouldn't disway people from going though - give it a try for yourself! ***DINING IN??? Don't. This is more a carry out joint as suggested by other Yelpers. It's small and not particularly warm. read more

Huge servings for a really decent price. Paid less than $10 for an amazing calzone that will last me another dinner. It was my first time here and the family that runs the place was incredibly friendly. Their selection of food is incredible and beyond what I expected, especially for a relatively small restaurant. I never had baklava before and tried some they made earlier that day -- it was sooo good and I definitely recommend it if you have never tried it before. As a side note, they have a nice variety of cold canned sodas (carrying both Pepsi and Coke products). I would definitely recommend this place for tourists and locals alike. read more

It's a good place. I had the manti and it's the best one I've had so far in the US. The pizza was ok. The place is a hole in the wall type of place. It has a very family feel to it. The service was prompt and polite. read more

We love this pizza place! They make great pizza- big ones! The dough is good, as is the sauce and cheese! They also have homemade baklava that I get every time. It's clear this place is run by family and they make their food with love. read more

Over priced bad food. But good service. Nice people running it. But food was no bueno.