I was here to order a birthday cake. I was here only because of the beautiful pictures of the cakes I saw in Yelp and other platforms. I ordered a cake in the shape of a dump truck. I thought they noted down the order correctly. The day before pick up I got a call asking what decoration I want. And when I picked up the cake, it was just a plain round cake with balloons drawn on top. It was a big dissappointment. It was a vanilla chocolate cake. I thought the cake was ok, nothing to complain about. read more

Two Sisters Bakery - Chocolate vanilla cake - Custom Cakes Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Two Sisters made my daughter's birthday cake. I filled out a form online about a week in advance, and they called me 2 days later. My daughter wanted a "math" birthday cake, and they did a fantastic job with decorations (see pictures). I love the equations they used, including the joke equations (3-2=2). Tasted amazing too. Will definitely be using them again. read more

See all

I had Tim and his wife bake a special 50th birthday cake and it was absolutely spectacular and heavenly delicious! One of the best cakes we have ever eaten. It was a 10" 3-layered marble cake with buttercreme frosting, lots of colorful flowers as seen in the photos. The guests at the party were amazed at the quality of the cake and frosting. I would give them a 6th star. Awesome and many thanks! read more

Two Sisters Bakery - Spectacular 10" 3-layered marble birthday cake with buttercreme frosting. - Custom Cakes Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

I came here to pick up some sweets and some Vietnamese pastries and I'm so glad I did! The pâtéso (a traditional Vietnamese savory pastry that has a meat filling) was really flaky and crispy on the outside! The filling was plentiful and to my surprise with ground pork, but was still tasty. For sweets, I picked up some chocolate chip croissants, strawberry cupcake, Boston cream pie cupcake, and a cherry and apple turnover. Both cupcakes had fillings in them - very delicious and not overly sweet! Favorite was the Boston cream pie. The turnovers were also were flaky and delicious. This place definitely knows how to cook their pastries! The place is a little hard to find but you don't want to pass it up! Also the owners are so friendly and welcoming :)! read more

See all

I wanted to gift my son, who lives in Madison, WI, a birthday cake. After researching local bakeries (I live in Atlanta.), I chose Two Sisters Bakery and Cafe. The reviews were excellent for Customer Service and gorgeous, custom-made delicious cakes. The reviews are accurate. My son is a drummer, and they created a Snare Drum. It was beautiful and, my son reports, "delicious, not too sweet, perfect." I worked with Tim, and he was great. Helpful and friendly. I highly recommend this bakery. I look forward to ordering my daughter-in-law's cake! read more

See all

I've been meaning to try this bakery for months. It's on Gammon Road, but you access it on the Woodmans side of the building. One of the two sisters was behind the counter and her husband, the baker, took the time to introduce me to all the various bakery offerings. They had a larger selection of goodies than I was expecting! Cupcakes, cookies, tarts, bars, etc. My favorite purchase was a Carrot Cake and Cream Cheese Frosting sort of parfait. The cake pieces were moist and delicious, and the generous frosting layers not-too- sweet. Not to mention, the portion was enormous. This bakery is for you if you are looking for local, family-owned, scratch-made with care sweets. read more

Two Sisters Bakery - Yummy choices, but the Carrot Cake Cup reigned SUPREME - Custom Cakes Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

I ordered a specialty pina colada birthday cake. It was AMAZING!!!! Not too sweet, great coconut and pineapple flavors. The non-cake people even raved how they enjoyed this delicious treat! This cake was made from scratch. Great texture, moist, flavorful. Loved the frosting, not over whelmed with powdered sugar. Will definitely order another cake again! This is a hidden gem of a bakery! read more

Bakery and cafe right by woodman's! The parking is ample and the location is just right for a quick break between shopping. Apart from the customer cake orders, they have vietnamese savory snacks, coffee and beautiful cupcakes. This place has a centrally located open kitchen, so you can be sure there are no secrets when the owners say they make everything from scratch. Try the apple pudding which is moist, not to sweet as my liking and flavorful. They also have fresh bread and croissants iin interesting flavors read more

See all

I'm a long distance repeat customer Who enjoys spoiling her kids with this bakeries tasty desserts! I made my son an almond tres leche cake and his girlfriend a chocolatey chocolate birthday cake! Both, they claimed were fantastic! I just wish we could've had a taste! They looked beautiful and I will definitely be ordering again. Thanks for your help Tim! read more

Two Sisters Bakery - Almond Tres Leche cake. Special order - Custom Cakes Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

I had to order this birthday cake by phone from another city for my son, who attends UW-Madison, so I was stuck reading and depending on Yelp reviews, which proved trustworthy! The person at Two Sisters who took the call (I think he was the husband of the owner) was very kind and patient, made sure to get the correct spelling of my son's name, and delivered it himself on the morning of my son's birthday, which meant my son actually got it before he left for school, which was terrific! My son, who is a former pastry chef and knows whereof he speaks, said the cake (chocolate cake and frosting) was delicious. Couldn't be happier. read more

Called in a cake order for a Univ of Wisc student to be delivered. The cake was big, delicious and Badger themed. Made for a nice remote birthday party. read more

Randomly stopped in here and with a variety of options, I wasn't sure which one to try! I chose the Apple Crunch. There are real apple pieces in the middle. She has fruit tarts and coffee available. She's a custom cake designer. They're polite and helpful. read more

See all

I went here for a Yelp event and will be back. Here's why: 1. Their banh bao are simply amazing. A tiny quail egg is wrapped in a pork/onion meatball, then enveloped in sweet bun down and steamed to perfection. The packet is about the size of your hand and it is DELICIOUS. 2. This is truly a man/wife and sister operation--all of the baked goods are made by hand by some truly lovely people. Each cake and confection is truly one of a kind, and you can feel (and I daresay taste!) the love in each bite. No, I'm not drunk. I'm serious. If you need a birthday cake, get it here--it's affordable and right next to Woodman's--you can't lose! 3. Just because they have "bakery" in the name doesn't mean they don't have some main course treasures hidden away in the menu (see #1). Be sure to ask what they recommend for the day--you won't regret it. 4. As I said, they're right next to Woodman's, so it's pretty easy to stop over and grab half a dozen banh bao on your way home from work. Just sayin'. 5. You won't find nicer people manning the counter. The service is top-notch! PRO TIP: Park under the light and cross the parking lot aisle to avoid the 5-o'clock busy-ness. It gets a little hairy closer to the building. read more

Our son is a student at UW and we wanted to send him a birthday cake since it was his first one away from home. They went above and beyond what a mother couldn't do many states away!! Cake was awesome and son said it is delicious!! I would definitely recommend them!! Thank you so much!!! read more

Such a great experience! We ordered a birthday cake from out of state to surprise our daughter. It was delivered on time and was kept a surprise...thank you! Best of all the cake was beautiful and delicious!! I would highly recommend. read more

After enjoying the bakery and savory items at their opening, I returned to pick up a nibble or two..or three. The lemon, and strawberry cupcakes were fabulous. The flavor and texture of the frosting and cake were spot-on. The beef pastry was the perfect size for a midday snack, and the flavor is unlike anything I have found in Madison. I was happy to support a small business during lockdown, and enjoy some delicious food. No pictures, I already ate everything lol read more

Combination Vietnamese and American bakery, also house made coffee. I tried a caramel iced coffee. It was easily as good as the big names and less expensive, although it was a little smaller. I had said "extra cream" but I think they thought I meant whipped cream. Still, I loved it. I tried a German chocolate cake sample. Amazing. Moist and great flavor. My friend bought some baked goods, everything looked great. I'm excited to try the Vietnamese banana bread! The owners were very friendly and charming. I will definitely be back. read more

They are very customer friendly. I live in another state and sent a cake to my daughter at school there. They were very helpful and really took care of everything. The cake was beautiful and very delicious. read more

Came here for the first time, unfortunately the chicken puff and cupcake I chose were not impressive at all. Chicken puff was kind of pricey, $3.99 .The crust was soft. It will be much better if it's fresh out of the oven. Cupcake was just average, I personally don't like the sugar frosting. read more

Last minute decision for bakery birthday cake vs. store bought. Had freshly baked 1/4 sheet cakes on hand. Waited while they frosted & decorated. Awesome job, and yummy. Very friendly. read more

This lady told her her store because I am black I was going in her store sit down wait on my bus because it's cold the Chinese havey set lady told get out . While her white husband was trying his best to be nice it's show many people can't be rasict if you want a cake made and color do not go here they rasict read more

I ordered a cake for my son's birthday. I live on the east coast and he is at U Wisconsin. They were wonderful to deal with made a beautiful cake which was very much enjoyed. The delivery person called me when he was having difficulty reaching my son. He was very kind and considerate, read more

This is a new small family bakery. I love the fruit tarts and turnovers. Phuong's custom cakes are beautiful and she uses real buttercream which is not super sweet. Friendly staff and long hours. Can't wait to go back! read more

Not much of a cafe, only in the sense that they had coffee there. That said, the bakery selection was pretty decent and each piece had a great presentation, so much so that I couldn't decide what I wanted. The guy working there suggested the bread pudding, which was pretty good. It carried a mild sweetness and the flavors were well separated, the serving size was also very large for the price. Definitely worth checking out if you're in the mood for sweets read more

Unfortunately, it is out of business. (Yelp says my message is too short, I need to keep talking...)

The lady owner is really nice. The cake itself is way too much frosting and not enough cake. If you like cake like that I guess this is your place. read more

Great assortment of baked goods, made fresh on a daily basis. I stopped in to order a cake and although there was a misunderstanding with my original order, the owner made a brand new cake right away. The cake itself had great texture and flavor. Most importantly, the owner called the next day to ensure I enjoyed the cake and it was what I was looking for. Great customer service! read more

While the cake looked beautiful, it was dry and the chocolate pieces on top and around the side tasted like wax/crayon. :( My Brother even grabbed a little carrot cake cup at the bravery while we waited and it was also dry and not great flavor. I wanted to like Two Sisters but unfortunately won't be back for more. :( read more

We came to Two Sisters to order a Moana cake for our one year old's first birthday party. The owners were friendly and took the time to talk to us about what we wanted, both the cake and the decorations. Everyone at the party complimented us on the cake- how moist it was and how beautifully decorated it was. Decently priced too. I'm sure we'll be back the next time we need a custom cake :-) read more

Have been using Two Sisters for birthday cakes, for about a year now. They make great cakes and are always on time. Prices are reasonable. read more

Needed a specialty cake with just two days notice. They nailed it! Delicious cake and cupcakes! The cake was gorgeous!! Kind people who really knew what they were doing and how to help me. Get there if you can - they have delicious offerings and getting to know them is fun and worth your time. read more

Have had the cupcakes and the turnovers and both were amazing! I ordered the turnovers the day before, said I would pick them up at 7:30, and when I got there at 7:30 they were done being packaged and still warm. Fantastic service and a great little gem! read more