New favorite. Too…read moretired with the baby on the way to write a long review but veryyyyy good. We've been getting takeout here a lot lately and have had at least like, 8 different pizzas, all YUMMY. Very happy mommy and baby. (And daddy, too ) Crust is chewy, not too thick, sauce is just the right amount of chunky, ingredients are fresh overall. I'm not sure if I'll ever order from another pizza place in Madison ever again. Sorry but like, Ian? I don't think I know that guy?

We got delivery to a downtown hotel around 7pm on a Saturday. We got a beet salad and 3 pizzas. A…read morepepperoni, a bufala, and this margherita. The pepperoni looked fine, and the salad was good. The other 2 pizzas, however each had something wrong. The bufala was missing some toppings and had pepperoni instead but was at least cooked well. My margherita was more or less inedible. It was so burnt the crust was like charcoal on the raise and burnt leather on the inside. The cheese has turned into plastic and the sauce was basically reduced into a tomato paste. Topping it all off was burnt basil that was the most edible part of the pizza. Based on this experience I would recommend thin crust Papa John's or Domino's over Pizza Brutta. Way cheaper and at least some good garlic butter.

We went here last night to celebrate my daughter's graduation. I had made a reservation in advance…read moresince the holiday time is their busiest time of year from what I hear. I was absolutely stunned when I walked into this restaurant and saw all of their holiday decorations. It was beautiful! We had to wait about 15 minutes for our table, then headed up the stairs to be seated at a half circle booth for eight people. It was very tight, so we asked for a chair to be placed on the end which definitely made the seating arrangement better. However, the one spot on the end seemed as if the cushion part was missing from where people had been sitting, so that was not comfortable, and it should be replaced. The service was outstanding and I'm sorry I forgot to note our server's name. I ordered the chips and salsa, which was delicious. I had to question whether the salsa was indeed vegan since it seemed creamy. Thankfully it was vegan! For the entrée, I ordered a vegan mozzarella cheese pizza with mushrooms and spinach. It did not disappoint! The crust was amazing; I appreciate that it wasn't too salty. The tomato sauce was incredible. Everybody had a great time and Lucille's was the absolutely perfect place for this special occasion.

Made reservations figured must be a nice restaurant. Took my family there. 1st timers, will never…read morebe back. We decided to order the steel pan pizza. I'll tell you im 57 years old and this by far is the WORST PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD. It was burnt, cheese was only in the center, most of this was just warm burnt bread with little sauce and basically no cheese. Our bill was over $70 dollars. They took off $10.00. What a complete joke. Do not go unless you eat crap like that waste of money. VERY DISAPPOINTED manager wouldn't even come to talk to us about our 1st and last ever experience at Lucilles

Birds chirps Sunsetting…read more Food Good Giggling Chic Ambiance 10/10 Sexy bartender Free cigs and this place would be heaven

I just want to start by saying the service and ambiance was great. The drinks were wonderful. Hence…read morethe three stars. But the reason we're here is for pizza... and I was disappointed as most of the bottom of the pizza was burnt. From above it looked fantastic. But the taste was burnt, and it didn't settle well in my stomach which I dealt with when I got home. I tried to have a couple slices on the inside but when you ate any of the pieces, there was a heavy bitter burnt taste. The pizzeria did offer to replace my pizza but i've always been fearful of something coming back that maybe worse with spit or something. I just feel food should have been looked at by the head chef before sending out of the kitchen. We may comeback next time, but it would just be for drinks and appetizers.

Got takeout from here on a Friday night, which is definitely the way to go. The space is pretty…read moresmall inside and they were packed with a wait, but our order was ready ahead of when it said. Super easy pickup. We ordered the tik tik boom and the not on the first date pizzas, unsliced so that the toppings stayed on better. It's nice that they make this recommendation when ordering. It's a good Detoit style, which we likened to a focaccia with toppings and a nice crust of cheese around the sides. The tik tik boom was our favorite, as the toppings paired well together and it's a unique flavor. The not on the first date had my favorite sauce of the two as even though it didn't say it, there seemed to be a little lime in the crema. Overall, would recommend!

Madison's best! Great pizza with a friendly, professional staff and a cozy atmosphere…read more I loved the heatonism bot specialty pizza -- It was the perfect combination of spicy, acidic, sweet, and savory flavors. The dough was cooked perfectly -- crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. Seating is limited and first come, first served, so come quick!

I remember moving out of madison I'd never tried ians and when my friends would talk about it I'd…read morethink to myself dang I wish i'd gotten to try some of these crazy pizzas. Then I moved to seattle and I got whiplash when I walked past an ians. I looked it up and lo and behold, a random ians in seattle. Perfect I though, I'll finally have a chance to try. And then I never went and it closed down. WELL now i'm back in madison and I wasn't about to pass this ip. So yeah we got a bunch of crazy slices (never would I ever have thought I'd have ravioli on a pizza and probably never will I again). We so so thoroughly enjoyed the craziness of it all and left so stuffed. My fave was the macho nacho but I liked them all.

Great place for lunch - right in downtown Madison - to get a slice or two for a quick meal. Many…read morechoices; can get "standard" pizza or "gourmet". I got one of each. Easy seating; drink machine; fast service. Inexpensive and lots of choices. Has a little bit of that college spot feel.

The interior of Novanta is clean and bright, with a fair number of seating options for dine-in…read morecustomers. When you walk in, you place your order at the counter, and bring an order number to your table. I'm on the search for the best pizza in Madison, and Novanta made it pretty high on my list. The ingredients tasted fresh, and the flavors were simple but delicious, like most Neapolitan pizzas. I'm a huge fan of pizzas baked in stone ovens, and I was not disappointed by Novanta's ovens, which were imported from Italy. The staff was very friendly! They greeted us warmly and made sure we had everything we needed when the pizzas were served. I will definitely be back soon!

The Neapolitan pizzas were just amazing! It was our first time in this restaurant so we requested…read morethe server to give us recommendations. We just went with the ones he suggested to us - a red sauce version & one within the sauce. You have to grab your own seat and own left over boxes. It was a very casual dining setup. At 6:45 on a Friday night, it was pretty full. The portions of pizzas were probably enough for 1.5 persons. We ordered 2 pizzas, and 2 of their desserts. We absolutely loved their no sauce BUFALA version - just delicious to the last bite.

Good pizza, pricey but good Also has deserts that are great…read morealso Delivery person very friendly and nice. Arrived hot.

Glass Nickel never disappoints. We had not been to this location before; we stopped because it is…read morevery conveniently located near our destination for the evening, the Barrymore Theater. This location is in an older building, it's a bit rustic, but nicely decorated and clean. We ordered the pizza of the month, the "Italian Stallion", and it was very good. Server... well, I really liked her. So it was the usual Glass Nickel job. Two thumbs up.

Good pizza (I had the Buffalo Chicken personal pan size) in a rather unfriendly atmosphere…read more The BIG turn off was to be asked if we wanted Parmesan cheese and when we said yes to be served with very tiny little individual packets of rock hard Parmesan in individual sealed packets. Would it kill this place to serve it like ANY OTHER Italian or pizza joint... in a glass shaker?

Quite possibly my favorite pizza in Madison?…read more Tucked along Midvale in Sequoya Commons on the west side of Madison, Luigi's offers high-quality pizza with a great thin crust and a good variety of different options. The Maximus, Il Capo, Fugetaboutit, the Margherita - I have yet to be disappointed. It is a little more pricey (when compared to Novanta, for example), which is the only thing keeping Luigi's from five stars. I have yet to dine in person (that COVID thing), but the takeout/delivery experience has overall been pretty good, although they do get busy on Friday evenings, so there may be a line for pickup. As far as delivery apps, they are on Eatstreet, Doordash, and GrubHub.

This IS the place for late night eats when finishing up at bars... (esp Ivory Room Piano Bar!)…read more We love the hot & ready to eat slices (HUGE) and that they offer gluten free crusts! The cheeseburger pizza legit tastes like the best burger I've had... without a bun!

Service at this establishment is wonderful and it's an easy place to walk to down town or if you're…read morestaying in a hotel near by. Pizza was good and we ended our night full and happy!

Super exciting to have an Indian-Italian fusion spot in Madison! The dining area here is very…read morelarge. The restaurant is located upstairs in a complex and can be a bit confusing. I had the butter chicken pizza which had a really nice, thin crispy crust. The Chicken 555 was also really good and would highly recommend this dish! I'm excited to come back here again and try other things of their menu, including the saag paneer pizza.

I was pleasantly surprised by the food here, everything was really good! The restaurant is located…read moreinside of a hotel on the second floor, there are stairs and an elevator. The stairs take you up to the bar and you have to walk through to the host stand, there's a clear sign. I had the masala chicken parm and my boyfriend had the zafferano chicken curry, both were very good. I wish there was more masala with the chicken parm. We shared the sesame chili gobhi and the fried calamari for appetizers and I really enjoyed the butter chicken sauce. We were seated in a corner table that was weirdly right next to the dish area....wasnt a huge fan. Still, I will definitely return!