I came to Tutta Bella for a birthday party, so we were working off a fixed menu, but I was honestly impressed with how good everything was. The pasta ended up being the highlight for me--really flavorful and cooked perfectly, not mushy or overly sauced. The salads were fresh, the clams and calamari were tender, and the chicken was nicely seasoned. With a group our size, I expected at least a couple of dishes to miss the mark, but everything came out consistently good. What really stood out was how smoothly the staff handled a big party. They were organized, attentive without hovering, and kept things moving at a comfortable pace. It made the whole night feel easy and enjoyable instead of chaotic, which isn't always the case with large groups. I'd like to come back on a regular night to try more of the menu--if the food is this good during a big event, I'm curious to see what they do when it's just a smaller table. read more

Came here for a birthday party and there was a fixed menu, but everything I had was great. I especially liked the pasta they served. Other dishes, including salads, clams, calamari, chicken were all great. To be able to serve so much food to a large group and maintain the quality was impressive. The staff were professional and made serving us all look easy. I'd love to come back and try it for a regular meal. read more

Tutta Bella - Italian Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

The food was delicious, steak was cooked perfectly, service was kind and helpful, and the ambiance is beautifulllll. read more

See all

This place might be jammed but they couldn't care less about your reservation. We had a 7:30 reservation and they made us wait over 20 minutes. When we first arrived, they said it would be a 5-10 minute wait. Then they just left us standing at the front. When we asked for an update, they started getting rude. They said they told us they would try and squeeze us in and that they do their best when you book the same day. Last I checked, a reservation is a reservation. They made us seem like they were doing us a big favor squeezing us in. They didn't say any of this to us ahead of time. Service was not the greatest tonight. Based on the Business manager's reply to my post, it shows some attention to service (which I respect). To the business's defense, they did start pushing people to the bar after 20 minutes. We would have probably gotten a table 30 minutes after our reservation. My previous 5 star reviews of this place are still valid. I just wish businesses would be more honest with their timing. Even if you make a reservation for same day. We were NOT A WALK IN!! read more

See all

Ate in East Chester/Scarsdale, for the first time in 30 plus years. Actually dined in the same building in the early 90s. But last night was good and fun. The food and service were excellent, led by our waiter Nitty (Nitty from the city) Beautiful place with great food! read more

See all

This place is good, real good. When you spend $30 on a dish, you expect good food and they deliver. I had a pasta with mussels, shrimp and lobster. Everything tasted fresh and amazing. 5 stars! read more

Tutta Bella - Italian Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

I was invited and had no expectations but was I pleasantly surprised!!! The food is absolutely delicious. Our waiter was friendly and demonstrated expertise about each selection. My friends and I chose different meals. Each and every one was truly amazing!!! Can't wait to return! I highly recommend you treat yourself to a divine meal! read more

The food was amazing and so was the service. Ambiance is very pretty. Dessert was decent, drinks are strong. read more

See all

The quality of their food and professional service were perfect. I Highly recommend this restaurant!

Servers were rude and food was great. Would avoid this restaurant and go to another'. Not worth the price

I heard good things so wanted to take mom for her birthday. We arrived and there's a flight of stairs to get in. Mom is handicapped and can't climb stairs. I went upstairs holding on to railing and they had added so much cluttered decorations there was no place to hold the railing and one of their glittered branches landed in my sweater and I had glitter and fake snow all over my clothes. So, it's fair to say that with no handicap accommodations and awful and dangerous entryway there's no reason to ever try getting into this place again sadly. Bring your place up to code and don't endanger your guests with ridiculously placed decorations and maybe people will be safer entering!!! read more

We chose Tutta Bella for our large family Christmas dinner. In good faith, we gave the restaurant a significant deposit when making the reservation, far exceeding what was necessary. Unfortunately, a major medical emergency forced us to cancel. When we informed THEO of the details of the emergency and cancellation, he claimed it was his busy season and that they would lose a lot of money. He said normally he wouldn't return any money, but out of supposed "generosity," he offered to return half of our deposit. This half ($750) is more than he should have received initially, and now THEO is profiting from our misfortune. There are far better options if you want a great place for your family to enjoy a night out or a large gathering. read more

Everything was amazing food was great staff was great the restaurant very nice and cozy I would go back and definitely recommend it to everyone. read more

2025 Aug 11: 1) Gnocchi 2) filet mignon 3) chicken Parmesan 4) seafood pasta 5) chicken and sausage. Caesar salad and fried calamari. Gnocchi had too much cheese in the sauce. read more

Tutta Bella - Receipt - Italian Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

Great specials Good food; good service and friendly staff. The wraps are delicious. Nice atmosphere too read more

Had a terrific dining experience last night at Tutta Bella. We were greeted warmly and seated at our table for 6. Genti came over and introduced himself as our waiter. He provided excellent service all evening. Apps included delicious zucchini flowers calamari and baked clams. Entrees included veal sorrentino, chicken martini, veal martini and buccatini ammatriciano. Meals were excellent. For dessert we shared biscotti, tiramisu and chocolate lava cake. Thank you Tutta Bella. read more

As many times as I have passed by TuttaBella,I have rarely been inside to eat. Before the other day, I had only been here once some years back for an educational dinner. That all changed last month when I learned that my family made reservations here for Easter dinner. I'll be honest, I had mixed feelings - excited because I was going to rediscover restaurant, but also apprehensive since holiday service can be a toss up. That being said, I decided to go in with low expectations and keep an open mind. TuttaBella is located off Route 22, near where Scarsdale meets Eastchester. I heard that this restaurant is owned by the same people who own Sergio's in Pelham - I recently dined there and had a good experience, so I was hoping the vibes continued here. We were seated upstairs in what looked like a space that could double as a private room. The decor was mostly bright colors with a somewhat contemporary aesthetic - we were seated lining French doors that went out to a patio which gave way to a ton of natural light pouring in. They had a special menu for Easter, but I wouldn't call it a prix fixe as there was a good selection of apps, salads, pastas, mains, and sides. The bread basket shouldn't be overlooked - they had traditional Italian bread plus these crispy flatbreads brushed with oil and some tasty breadsticks. I decided on pasta for my main so I went light with the app and got the insalate tuttabella which contained bibb lettuce, pears, and gorgonzola in a light dressing. For my main I got cavatelli with sausage, broccoli rabe, and cannellini beans. This is one of my go-to pasta dishes in restaurants, and TuttaBella did a great job - there was good flavor and the addition of the beans really elevated the dish overall. Service was good - there were two servers that were taking care of us and they both did a great job. Working a holiday is tough, so I really appreciated all they did to make the meal run smoothly. Overall, I had a great meal at TuttaBella. It's some of better Italian food I've had in Westchester, and I would definitely return for another meal. read more

Tutta Bella - cavatelli w/ sausage, broccoli rabe, and cannellini beans - Italian Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

See all

Food was very good, service was attentive. Ambience was very comfortable. I lived the veal and we had a fabulous Chianti. read more

Tutta Bella - This Chianti hit a spot. - Italian Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

OMG. What a wonderful dinner. Blendi our server made it spectacular! So attentive and courteous. We enjoyed all the staff and the food and the ambience!! Thanks so much !!! read more

Wife and I go here for special occasions like anniversary and birthday. Valet parking. Extremely well decorated and ambiance. Wait staff very knowledgeable and courteous as well as well dressed. Clients dressed properly. My appetizer was a seafood salad. Perfect mixture and spices. Their chicken Marsala is outstanding because the volume of mushrooms and the dense richness of the sauce makes it so. Of course their chocolate lava cake is unreal. Did I mention the variety of breads? Sticks, paper thin sheets and sliced Italian bread? It's a must go to for a 5 star quality meal in a beautiful setting. read more

Very beautiful restaurant. The cuisine is impeccable. And you will love the servers. Will recommend to all I know. read more

Excellent Italian restaurant with great food especially their seafood dishes. You have to try napoleon desert Staff are real pros great atmosphere read more

One of my favorite restaurants, great service delicious food , everything is amazing great ambiance. read more

See all

Attended a baby shower here. The upstairs room was very pretty with lots of floral accents draping the ceiling. Staff was attentive in bringing out the courses. I enjoyed the charcuterie and the appetizers. The chicken martini was delicious and perfectly cooked. The penne vodka was also very tasty. The upstairs bathroom was a bit small, and people from the party downstairs kept using it. Parking was also tough but there is a large lot across the street that was open for use. read more

Food was very good and service was attentive . The volume of noise seemed to be taken care of, since I did not have to talk over my guests. It was a pleasure read more

My husband and I are regulars because the food, and service, is so exceptional. No different this weekend--started with the clams posillipo and we each enjoyed the special, spinach spaghetti with shrimp, hearts of palm, and a delicate lemon and garlic sauce. Wonderful! The decor is fun and bright. read more

What a lovely restaurant! I often do a girls night here with a few friends. The food is always delicious and comes as described. The servers are very friendly and attentive. Can't wait to go back! read more

Tutta Bella - Penne vodka with grilled chicken - Italian Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

See all

The food was excellent, as was the service. It is very expensive, although most restaurants have gone up in price lately.

This time it was disappointing. Service was brusque.... Chicken was tasteless.... Hard to get around - lots of different levels ... restroom up a flight of stairs - not handicapped accessible or friendly. read more

This restaurant is a gem. The food, service, atmosphere is better than many restaurants in Westchester on every level. I find that the reviews less than 4 stars are absolutely ridiculous in their reasoning. The handicap accessibility May not be ideal for most but that has to do with the physical building, not the service, staff and or food. This restaurant is often busy as a direct result of their food, bar, service etc. ... the front of house has ALWAYS been accommodating in honoring reservation times. I have not ever noticed anyone waiting excessively. To be honest, most people would be happy to wait so they can go to the bar and have a drink with their amazing barmaid! I can't recommend this place more highly for a great all around experience! read more

Sadly I had wanted to come here for awhile, and after trying- I will never be back. We were treated quite differently than those who appeared to be regulars. All tables got a simple antipasti plate and biscotti with dessert- we received neither. Also, when you charge $6 for each soda, you really should advise the customers. We ended up with $30 worth of Diet Coke. I was feeling sick, and took maybe one bite of my food. Servers never inquired if anything was wrong, and never asked the rest of the party if their meals were ok. I'm only giving 2 stars because my friends enjoyed their meals, but they also felt service was quite cold and not welcoming at all. read more

Delicious food but service could have been better. Would otherwise be 5 stars! Had to ask multiple times for simple requests (drink refills, bread, butter). Lovely decor and layout. Would definitely return while anticipating possible service issues. read more

Very nice clean professional staff polite and service is good. Food is very good only thing is crowded and noisy but it's all part of the fun. Neighborhood stop... always good read more

First, let me start off by saying that the service was impeccable, and the food was delicious. This restaurant is absolutely not handicap accessible as it says in yelp. My mother, who uses a walker, had to scale three sets of stairs to get into the restaurant and then to reach the only bathroom which was on the 2nd floor. This was a huge ordeal. It is inexcusable in this day and age not to have a bathroom that handicapped people can use. We almost had to go home on Thanksgiving because we didn't think we'd be able to get her up and down the stairs safely. Get with the program. read more

This place was a little hard to find and it was definitely a hidden gem. The foods and services are both dupe! I appreciate that we can order half portion which is perfect size. Their clam appetizer with white sauce is amazing. read more

Tutta Bella - Italian Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

See all

Went to Tutta Bella for a second visit last night. Started with a party of 6 that escalated to a party of 9. They graciously accommodated my last minute change. Once again they did not disappoint! Good was spot on delicious, hot and tasty. The service is amazing and always welcoming! Can't say enough. read more

See all

Best restaurant in Westchester. Food is outstanding, everything is always fresh. Food quality and ingredients are exceptional. Service is very friendly and extremely accommodating, they go above and beyond. The restaurant's decorations are great, perfect for special occasions. I've been a customer for many years. Birthdays, anniversaries, wedding rehearsal dinners - all outstanding and memorable. If you want to have a perfect dinner or perfect party, Tutta Bella will go above and beyond to ensure it is perfect. read more

Tutta Bella was recommended by a close friend for my Birthday celebration. I had a party of about 40 guests and I booked the upstairs party room with a one of their party packages. The room was decorated beautifully, the service was exemplary and the food and beverages were top notch....I have received nothing but praise from all of my guests and the event was handled in a most professional way....Definitely a return visit and now on the short list for future events. read more

I have eaten there a few times and never had a bad experience. The food is great, although the last visit , the portions did get smaller from the time before. The cavatelli broccoli Rabe and cannellini beans dish is one of the best I've ever had and so is their homemade Napoleon cake. Service is good but a little inconsistent ...overall an excellent restaurant and I will go back. read more

Had what started as a wonderful night for my best friends 30th. Unfortunately finishing the birthday dinner in the beautiful wine cellar was spoiled by the cake. We brought the cake from contes bakery that cost $150. Birthday girl was not looking forward to her 30th but excited for cake. Cake was definitely dropped at the restaurant and staff tried to fix it before serving it looking like this. We understand that mistakes happen -- but the way the manager and staff handled this was appalling. They placed the cake on display without acknowledging the accident. Even more disrespectful was after bringing awareness to the situation we were told we "we received the cake this way and were furthermore, not welcome back to the restaurant " . The hostility was unnecessary, but also exacerbated when the manager felt the need to come face to face with members of the group to attempt to prove a point, and without a mask. We asked that the restaurant just own up to the mistake, but they backtracked and insisted that the staff responsible would be reviewed on tape and then fired. We asked that no one was fired but the manager continued to insist this was the measure to solve the issue, which is not what we felt would make the situation right. Food, good but not great with HOSTILITY .... EXTREME SUPER UNCOMFORTABLE AND UNPROFESSIONAL. We are reasonable people and 20% tippers, but the management here is appalling. read more

Tutta Bella - Cake dropped and I acknowledged by staff. Told basically to go F yourself . It was great - Italian Near Me - Scarsdale, New York