The Old Colonial does not disappoint. The owners and staff are always friendly when we see them…read more The food is fantastic. Whenever we are in the area, we always look forward to coming here with friends.

The Old Colonial Inn is a charming restaurant perfect for a date night, special occasion, or just…read morebecause! The restaurant is located in the town's restored old hotel right near the town square. Upon entering, there's delightfully cozy seating and a candlelit interior--we were seated in the library room that contained a few intimate tables. The service was amazing. Jill is attentive yet gave us space for conversation. She recommended the tenderloin special, which paired with the blueberry gastrique and parsnip purée was a nice mashup of flavors. The soup of the day was a rich, creamy lobster bisque. My husband ordered the salmon grilled and said it was well seasoned and cooked to perfection. We ordered a dessert to share (turtle cheesecake), and they thoughtfully plated it with a starburst of whipped cream for each of us! The owners came around and checked on everyone briefly. They were very kind and hospitable. Overall, the Old Colonial Inn was a delightful experience and a hidden gem.

We stopped by last night and we surprised by this little gem. The food was fresh and delicious!…read more Our server Noza was very attentive and knowledgeable about the menu. It was a great value as well. We will be going back to this great little restaurant!

This time we each got 1lb of snow crab. My wife enjoyed the medium spicy level. They no longer…read moreallow corkage but they do a generous pour of the glass of Pinot Grigio wine.

The service was at the highest level then the food I took my daughter and boyfriend and my wife on…read morea Friday night everything was done to perfection for being in the middle of Illinois being raised in south Florida it's amazing I have to say this is my favorite place to eat

What is not to like about a bar/restaurant on the river with a bunch of young enthusiastic…read moreentrepreneurs trying to make killer drinks and straight-up delicious bar food? Absolutely nothing!! Huck Finn would have been a regular at a joint like this.

We just moved back from NC and have had chicken at 3 places and this was, BY FAR, the best. Tender…read moreand juicy chicken and it was a nice size portion. The cashier was friendly and the cook was as well. The little shop is simple and the food speaks for itself. Highly recommend.

used to love this place! But NOT any more. Got a two piece catfish dinner and 10 piece fried…read moreoyster, every thing so over cooked it was burnt! We could not even eat the catfish because it had so much salt on it that you just spit it back out !!

Fresh, sizzling hot food. Best server!!! The ambiance is…read morealways the best. All employees nearby welcome your party into the dining room.

One of my favorites in Michigan City. I really don't have anything negative to say. The bartenders…read moreare great, the patrons are great and the food OMG! Let's not forget the location.

Went out for a birthday dinner for a sibling. The service was quick although it was an empty dining…read moreroom. I had some of their cajun pasta and calamari, both were quite small serving sizes for their price. What put me off was adding shrimp to the pasta for 5.99 only to be given exactly five pieces of shrimp. The pasta had nothing cajun about it and served on a big plate to look bigger than it is, far too big for the small table! The pasta itself was nice, however it tasted like grocery store jar alfredo sauce. And the restaurant had far too loud music for so little people there, couldn't even talk properly to the server or family despite sitting so close on a tiny table. Would not recommend

Great place for seafood boil! I was craving a spot that does seafood boils/ seafood by the pound. A…read morelong time ago, in my mid to late 20s era, we would order seafood boil for Father's Day so this was very nostalgic for me. I've seen the sign for Sea Shack from Route 59 and finally got to try it when my sister was visiting Naperville. I called in an order and it was ready in 15 minutes. What we ordered for 3 adults: 1 lb peeled shrimp, mild, + corn + potatoes 1 lb black mussels, mild, + corn + potatoes 1 lb clams, mild 1 corn on the side 1 sausage on the side onion rings chicken tenders and fries 2 orders of rice We had plenty of food and enough for leftovers. My favorite part might be the cajun butter sauce with white rice... even more than the seafood. I love white rice with basically any sauce. The food was fresh, the sauce was mild as requested, still flavorful and not too salty. If you order the clams on its own, no sides, the bag might seem a little small but that's just because the clam meat is so small. For takeout, your seafood will come double bagged so it was leak proof. We decided to empty the bags into bowls since we were doing family style, and it was a hearty meal. I can't comment on the ambiance since it was a takeout order, but we enjoyed our food. We'll be back!

The best tasting lobster roll ever!!! Fresh, juicy, succulent and seasoned to perfection. And what…read morewas very pleasing was the fact that the lobster roll was plentiful. The bread was soft with the perfect toast, just enough butter and seasonings to make it all come together in perfect harmony. I was so impressed with the lobster roll. I ordered a half a pound of fried shrimp to go. Service was on point. They paid attention to me and was always available and checking on me. Reasonable prices & great food. I'll be back again soon.

The food was wonderful. My aunt had sweet spicy shrimp and loved it. I had the grouper sooooo good…read more Husband ordered the mussels and peel and eat shrimp, both amazing. Will be going back!!!!! Wonderful

Hubby and I went here a while back and served Tasha was amazing! Food was also delicious. Really…read moreenjoyed the alligator.

The place is a dive and not in a good way I like dives but…read morethis was not a nice place. It was cold and very worn looking. I ordered grilled tilapia and the wife got a lobster roll. Both were quite bland and inferior to other similar meals we have had locally. Not sure where the positive reviews come from to be honest.

Wonderful restaurant tucked away in a serene wooded area, right alongside the Wabash river. I…read moreenjoyed my drink, soup, and steak here very much! Such a pleasant supper club feel.

Really a cute place in a fantastic location on the Wabash. Your expected steak house menu. Prime…read morerib was delicious. Also had the catfish which was good but not great. Service was good and friendly. 4 stars due to the fact it just wasn't quite enough for the price and a good example was the bar. No mojito and no big old fashioned ice cubes which leads to watered down drinks. Still a great place to celebrate something or enjoy Lafayette