I really want to like this place, but my experiences have just been so-so/average at best. I am not a bike snob, don't belong to any club, ride by myself and am not part of any bike scene, as it were. Avid bikers I know either love or hate this place. I fall in between.
I was supposed to get my bike back on Wednesday at the latest but it was not ready until today. (They charge a storage fee if you don't pick it up in a timely manner. They might consider deducting an amount each day that they are late!). I took my bike in for two broken spokes, and agreed to a tune-up at 85.00, that then got increased to a possible bill of 235.00 of things that could be wrong with the bike. Note that the bike rode perfectly for me as I rode into the place, except for the spokes - and I knew it needed the tune-up, but I was emphatic that if they found I did not really need the other stuff after cleaning the old part (derailleur) they should not replace it. I was emphatic that I needed to be called in advance if the derailleur needed to be replaced as I was having no trouble shifting when I rode the bike to the store just then - only the spokes were broken. So, I get a call today saying that the derailleur they had ordered was the wrong part and it would be next week to get the right one in. I noted to the tech who called me that in my previous convo when dropping the bike off that I was emphatic that I be called if that part needed to be replaced. I noted that the person who wrote up the work order said the part was very dirty and possibly when cleaned would work. I never received a call and the tech said he saw no indication on the work order that I had requested that the old one be cleaned and then determined if it would work. So . . . I instruct him to at least be certain that the old part does not work before ordering another one to replace the incorrect one that was ordered. So . . . he puts the old derailleur back on and I get a call saying the bike is ready. I rode the bike home and it shifted without any problem. So I saved $40.00 because they ordered the wrong part and called me to tell me that. Had they ordered the right part, presumably I would never of had the option to find out if the old part worked because the work order was not followed through.
As I was leaving, I noted my speedometer still did not work - something else I noted when I dropped the bike off. Long story short - they decided the sensor was bad, it would cost maybe $30.00 to replace but would not be ready till next week because they would have to order the part. No thanks.
So here is the deal - as an isolated incident - no problem - everybody screws up occasionally. Over the past few years I have gone to the Peddler maybe once a year for something and my experiences are similar - whether buying supplies or service work. When my wife went there a few years ago to buy me a mountain bike for my birthday, she was so turned off by the sales folks that she walked out and went to a nearby competitor and bought the bike there.
I read the other reviews here and they are generally all positive, so the Peddler must be doing something right for a lot of folks. However, I would simply be remiss if I did not reflect my reality. I really hate writing unfavorable reviews, particularly for local folks. I hope they improve. read more