It has taken me nearly 5 months since discovering Traif to write this review. WHY? So I could taste test almost everything on the menu and give an resounding 100% review that (as I expected with the very first bite I took here) that this is THE BEST RESTAURANT IN NEW YORK CITY. Not just in Brooklyn folks, you heard me right: IN ALL OF NEW YORK F*CKING CITY. There are several reasons for this, and I will address them in this order:
1. Phenomenal Flavor
2. Perfect plating
3. Superb Staff
#1. FLAVOR
I have tried nearly every dish on the menu here. In the first week alone after stumbling upon and taking a chance on Traif, I dined here 3 times. 3 TMES IN ONE WEEK. [You might look at the average 4-5 star rating I give establishments on Yelp and think "Ok, big deal. You like almost every place you go to." In actuality, I don't go to that many places which haven't already been vetted by fellow highly active Yelpers and/or been sung the praises of by a publication or critic I trust. So there! And I hadn't as much as read about, heard of, or even looked for Traif at all. The gas in my then shitty apartment went out and I literally wandered the streets looking for something that "called to me" until I couldn't stave off hunger any longer. Obviously I'm a little more than elated that I did.] Ok, back to the food. Ingredients are fresh, fun, and combined in exciting and unexpected ways. The overall concept is American new, slightly French-inspired, but with a "comfort food"
twist. I can't possibly get into detail about every dish ever had, because I've eaten menu staples and new additions or replacements each time and everything is always outstanding, and yes i DO notice all the potency of the flavors so I really mean that when I say it. Some things that stand out off the top of my head:
-strawberry-cinnamon glazed baby back ribs with pomegranate seeds
-veal sweetbreads with artichoke and asparagus
-brussel sprout, grape, and cucumber salad
-cinnamon cumin soup shot that comes complementary before dinner
-fricasse of escargot, chorizo, and giant white beans
-bacon maple doughnuts with ducle de leche ice cream
-brown sugar and chocolate budino
-day boat scallops in whatever new concoction they are playing around with!!
-thai spicy calamari
-suateed broccoli rabe with egg and toast
.... do I need to continue?
**Note, THE WAITERS WILL INFORM YOU THAT THE MENU IS DESIGNED TO SHARE, AND DISHES ARE LISTED IN ORDER FROM LIGHTEST TO HEAVIEST DISH. The menu is always evolving, but you will never see the cinnamon-strawberry glazed baby back ribs, broccoli rabe with toast, or veal sweet breads go anywhere. Same fores for the bacon doughnuts. Also, you cannot go wrong with the chef selection menu at $40 per person!!
#2 PLATING
One of my biggest gripes about food in New York in general is that, unless you're at a $$$$-$$$$$ restaurant then, you can't expect the presentation to live up to the taste. But at Traif, you can!! Everything looks beautiful on its dish. Nothing is overly complicated (where you feel you're paying more for presentation than for a true serving of food) but everything is constructed just so that you would think you're dining at a $$$$ restaurant.
#3. STAFF
The bartenders, hosts, servers, and chefs are all cheerful, pleasant, and (if you go as often as I do) treat you like its a place where "everybody knows your name." I've been treated with much kindness since proclaiming my love for Traif, but the story of my first dinner here must be told as the pointed example of the community that runs this place. While seated at the bar that first time, I had ordered a brussels salad to start and the baby back ribs for an entree, I noticed that the word "escargot" was written on a nearby paper menu in pencil. I asked a chef, standing at the small counter just next to me, if this had been a special that I didn't notice or hadn't heard from my server. " Escargot is one of my favorite things in the whole world!!" I proclaimed. Nope, hadn't missed anything. It was part of a short order ingredients list for some new recipes that they were testing for the menu. "Oh, darn" I said with a sad face. About 15 minutes later, the same chef (turns out he's the head chef) walks around the corner of the counter that divides the small kitchen and the bar and puts a fantastic smelling bowl of something soupy looking in front on me. "Compliments of the kitchen: escargot and white bean soup, cooked in a chorizo based broth with tiny chorizo chunks and assorted vegetables." RIDICULOUS!! It was so good I topped that off in addition to the dishes that were already getting me close to full. Since then, I've consistently seen this and variations of it on the menu. Maybe my positive feedback had something to do with it? One can only hope ;-)
So on top of all this praise I could also talk on and on about the wine, the ambiance, the romantic back patio.... but I've talked enough.
BEST RESTAURANT IN NY. read more