There is likely no better cost to value proposition for Kaisen style Japanese food on the island. Big words I know, but it's true. Totoya offers relatively high quality, fresh seafood at a price that is incredibly hard to compete with. You just have to deal with an occasionally epic line. Yes, this isn't the top tier quality seafood, but look at that price and show me something that can even hope to play in this food league with Totoya, the heavy hitter.
Anywho, my partner and my friends were first in line at 4:30 PM on a Sunday afternoon. Every time we have tried so far to go, the line has been so long it is stretched nearly to Koa Pancake House and we ain't got time to wait in line for that, especially when hungry. So we committed to grandparent style eating by getting in line early bird style and were rewarded with the first to be seated prize with at least 18 people behind us when the doors opened at 5 pm. Totoya only has around 14 seats, all bar style, so commit to going early if you want to eat without a long wait.
We ordered several Nishiki, Nagomi, shrimp head miso soup bowls.
The Nishiki comes with negiotoro, two large pieces of tuna, two to three scallops (depending on the size), two large pieces of salmon, three pieces of uni, snow crab, a spoonful of tobiko, and an extra large scoop of ikura. For $33. I'm not sure they are profitable on with this quality and quantity at that price. And everything was delicious. The fish, while not melt in your mouth, was still fresh and delicious. The scallops tasted very fresh and firm. The negitoro was nothing amazing, but a good filler. The snow crab wasn't the sweetest crab, but it had good texture and good taste. I'm not a huge uni fan, but I liked the fresh taste of the sea that good uni is supposed to taste like. And that ikura? So much spread all around the bowl.
My friend got the Nagomi, which is similar to the Nishiki, but it has a sweet red shrimp, but fewer pieces of fish for a reduced price of $25. They also go the shrimp head miso soup and devoured all of it, leaving just exoskeleton.
The miso soup that the Nishiki came with was perfectly balanced, not so salty, but with the right flavor.
We also got the egg shoyu add on, which was different in a rich sort of way, but I'm not sure it made the experience any better. I did enjoy their house made shoyu, which was already on the table when we sat down. I should note that the wasabi that they placed in the bowl seemed to be of better quality than most sushi style places.
Staff seem to be replicating the boisterous nature of some Japan eateries where they get all loud to greet and say goodbye to each guest. Quite different from how many Japanese eateries present themselves in Hawaii. Parking in street or in the two paid nearby lots. The restaurant is clean, well light, with professional, polite staff. The place is credit card only, but they do take American Express.
We will be back, but hopefully the lines won't be so bad. read more