Toppers is a solid pizza place! I got a pepperoni and bacon pizza and the garlic cheese toppersticks sticks, and it was hot, fresh, as well as super cheesy. The customer service is amazing inside the restaurant as well. This is my go to place for quick carryout pizza in downtown Indy read more

Toppers Pizza - Toppers Classic Pizza 3-Cheese Garlicstix Topperstix - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We had a delivery of pizza a few nights ago. Delivery came fast, and pizza was still warm. I had a medium pizza with sausage and pepperoni. There were plenty of toppings on it. The pizza is pretty average- nothing I would write home about, but nothing bad about it. I wouldn't go out of my way for it, but if others are ordering, I'd order again. read more

Toppers Pizza - Medium pepperoni and sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Just as delicious as when I first had it 4 years ago. We were just passing through for a night and I was excited to learn that there was a Toppers. I had the Vegan Spicy Italian and The VeganStix. I love that they gave such a selection of dipping sauces. I highly recommend for vegan options! read more

Toppers Pizza - VEGAN Spicy Italian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I ordered the plant based chicken pizza while in route to Chicago. It was great. Great prices. Parking can be tricky. Seating available inside read more

Toppers Pizza - Entry - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We had toppers delivered to our hotel room while in town and were blown away. this was the best pizza we've ever had read more

See all

Advertised gluten free pizza but was told that they don't have gluten free pizza. Totally unacceptable for a family that needs to be gluten free. read more

I placed on online order for delivery and the store took the money out of my checking account, but the store stated that they never received my order. The manager was extremely rude and would not take the same order over the phone without charging me a second time for the order that I already paid for. The manager then hung up the phone on me when I asked for his name. I have picked up many orders from this location, but never again. Do not place an online order here, as the manager outright stated that there is a glitch in their online order system. read more

Toppers is an after a night out pizza. Not that great but good enough to eat. Customers service has always been good. Moreover I've gotten the vegan cheese once and never again haha it's not good at all. Furthermore don't really recommend trying it out. Little Cesar's is way better. read more

Great pizza. Well I'm gonna BS my way through this review because I am required to put 85 characters so If you don't understand that the pizza at Toppers is very good so I would recommend making a stop for some great pizza. read more

This is the only Toppers Pizza in the Indianapolis area, and it's a shame! There need to be more Toppers. This is the best pizza in Indy, and since it's downtown, that means I have to drive 30 minutes to get it. But I do! Oh yes, I do. By the time I get home with my box of pizza, it's colder than I'd like, but I just pop it in the oven to warm it up, and it tastes even better than when I first get it. Toppers: It's great hot, cold and warmed up at home. Anyway, this location is very fast with making orders, and they do curbside pickup if you call them (there is a sign outside with the phone number to call). There are also tables outside if you want to eat your pizza outdoors, which I've done before because sometimes I can't wait and I need pizza right now. If you like great pizza with chewy yet slightly crispy crust, stretchy cheese, greasy (in a good way) pepperoni, that's cut into triangles like pizza should be, then you'll love Toppers as much as I do. read more

Ohhh Toppers. First the service was not really up to par the last couple of visits. This visit in particular I placed my order online and arrived at Toppers about 7 minute after the time that it said it was out of oven ready to go. I enter and am not greeted. Waited for a couple minutes and a gentleman approached the counter and just looked at me. Okay than. I said hello, I ordered online. He states the total. I pay and he goes back and says, it will be out the oven in a few. He then leaves the restaurant (I assume he was a driver). I stayed waiting for 6 minutes more are I notice the orders stacking up on the heat rack. Other customers come in and wait along with me. The lady at the oven after an additional 3 minutes after the other customers come in finally comes and starts searching for other customers orders. Though I'd been standing for quite sometime I donnot lose patience and await my order. She finally gets to me and give me my order. The food has been delicious for a while. But recently, it's been slacking off a bit. After I got my order, you can see the quality in the photos I post. Toppers did me dirty. Pizza small , bubbles in Crust visible with all the ingredients pretty center loaded as if it were slopped together. Horribly distributed butter/garlic sauce on oversized Crust. Toppers Is so delicious and I hate having to put a negative review on a place I've loved, but that is the trend recently. In hopes that it get better . read more

Toppers Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

They made a change and lets just say it wasn't changed for the better. They got rid of their tallboy style crust and added "pan" style, which is probably the same thickness as the hand-toss but at the price of the tallboy. I don't know if they changed their sauce but the sauce on our pizza tasted sour. I typically love Toppers but I won't be ordering from them again, if they keep these changes. read more

Toppers Pizza - Ragin Pepperoni Pizza- "pan" style crust - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Pizza is pretty good as well as prices. even though i am racially discriminated by staff member Meredith. Every time i have went in she just grabs my pizza and says no words to me after being smiles and cheers with white customers. i have also noticed that she doesn't not interact with black staff that work with her. I normally don't leave reviews but as a student, i have paid a lot of money to toppers due to their convenience and every time i go to get a pizza, without fail, it is eye rolls and zero speech from Meredith. if your a poc and she tries helping you at the counter, just ask for someone else. zero couth and respect towards others. debating going to one of the other 5 pizza spots on campus that also sells cheap and good pizza read more

We received a flyer in the mail with some coupons and decided to order pick up. We ordered some loaded breadsticks, pizzas, and ice cream. The food was ready really quickly, probably 15 mins. I loved the breadsticks that were load; and we even got a unique pizza with cheese curds on top. Overall, good pizza for a quick meal! read more

See all

Took advantage of the $0.32 pizza with the purchase of cheese stix (mind you were $15). This was my first time ordering Toppers and was really hoping to love it since I live nearby. However, this was one of the worst pizzas I've ever had, plus the cheese stix were literally just unseasoned pieces of bread with very light sprinkles of cheese. Considering the price of the dry cheese stix, I wish I could've taken my business elsewhere. One of the guys working was helpful in getting my order out asap, while one of the girls seemed irritated that I was waiting in the dining area (I was the only person waiting in-store). The overall experience was underwhelming :/ read more

It's sad the pizza is so good because the service sucks so bad. Delivery person forgot our drinks and ranch dip which isn't a big deal but they went back to the store to get it and never came back. Had me feeling like that fish off SpongeBob how am I supposed to eat this pizza without my drink?? But seriously tho....also so weird for a local pizza place to outsource to a call center for phone calls read more

We ordered the pick 2 for $11.99. We created our own pizza and got the wings. The pizza was good however when we got the wings; they weren't wings it was pretty much chicken nuggets in sauce. We were under the impression that these were bone in chicken wings. We still ate them because we bought them but just be mindful of that. I'll go back for the pizza. read more

The pizza that we had from here reminded me of frozen pizza. It wasn't bad, but it didnt stand out. However, for a close to midnight purchase they were reasonably priced and delivery was good minus the driver leaving the pizza in the middle of full hotel lobby. read more

All the ingredients is always fresh, everything is made to order wings always nice and hot out the oven great customer service...

If you like Cold, Overpriced pizza Delivered late, This is the place for you! Absolutely dissatisfied, dissatisfied and will never order again! read more

This was FIFTY DOLLARS. Apparently we need more words. This is after 4 skinny people got their slices. Five hundred dimes. A small and a medium. Doordash can go suck a fuck. I hope Yelp's algorithm doesn't delete this because I mentioned Doordash. read more

Toppers Pizza - Fifty US Dollars of pizza after 4 skinny people grabbed a slice. - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Great food, but would suggest only getting for pickup. Our food said out for delivery for 40 minutes. We live 10 away. When we tried to call the delivery man, multiple times after a 40 minute wait we received no answer. Finally when the pizza showed up they claimed we had "canceled" the pizza, when our delivery showed we had not and the pizza was sitting in the backseat. When we finally got our pizza it was cold. Normally we love this place but have been put off by this experience. read more

We ordered pizza/breadstick delivery for lunch at work today. I grabbed a slice of the sausage pizza and a few cheesy breadsticks. The food was still hot and delicious when it arrived. The delivery was prompt and the driver friendly. Considering it is a Friday and snowing, we were all really impressed that it arrived on-time still hot. I know we will order pizza from here again. read more

My favorite go-to pizza place in DT Indy!! They have such unique specialty pizzas, it's hard to pick just one! My favorites would have to be: the Nachostix(without beef), Mac & Cheese pizza, and the Loaded Tots pizza. You must try this over Pizza Hut or Papa John's next time you decided on a pizza night! read more

Pineapple and pepperoni pizza!! Don't hate! So good! Service is always delightful and prompt! A staple for the university area!

Very disappointed they should've told me that they didn't have the pizza a total rip off then waited a super long time read more

Toppers Pizza - Supposed to be Vegan Buffalo Chicken-less Topper Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Call Toppers for a Terrible Time About 15 minutes outside downtown after a busy day of travel, toddler nearly asleep in back, we call Toppers for a quick carryout. Life is good. Twist: a recording greets us. But -- hurray! -- we hear a voice, surely a capable Topper will take our order. "Please hold." Major bummer, but it's a busy night, no? We'll be patient but we're zooming closer to downtown, making a carryout order problematic. But we're patient, because Toppers sounds good. Our wait pays off - we hear another voice; this is good. "Please hold." We realize due to Topper's apparent exclusivity and Michelin Star-level wait time, we should have contacted them sometime last Thursday to have any chance at a pie tonight. Our mistake. If you wish to enjoy a delicious Toppers pizza by next month, call now. read more

Open til 3am......say what!!! This place has specials every day and the pizza is pretty good. Get it cut in squares (party style) and you won't be disappointed. Toppings are decent proportion....so you won't be disappointed. Get the toppers sticks too those are the "topper". Must have is the garlic butter for the pizza and sticks. Don't be stingy get more than one of the garlic butters and just work it off the next day. Sorry no pictures on this one but it's worth it. read more

Three stars my ass! This place is the bees knees. The guy working the front tonight had it down to a science. He was super nice to EVERYONE and no one waited longer then ten minutes for their pizza. The store was clean as well. read more

I ordered a large pepperoni pizza & the cheese topperstix with a coke. The topperstix were the worst out of my order. The marinara that came with it tasted so bad and bitter, I just got the one out my kitchen. Thought it'd help the topperstix but it didn't. Barely any cheese, nothing like the pictures they show!!! It was so hard and difficult for my kid to eat. Decided to not even finish it. Threw away. The pepperoni pizza was decent & warm. Wasn't the best & didn't stand out to me personally. Something close to a frozen pizza I could buy at Walmart. It was a little greasy but it was alright. I wouldn't order pizza from here again unless I absolutely had to, like if everything else was closed. The best part of my order... the bottled coke. read more

I just moved downtown, three weeks ago, and have been to Toppers twice now! Both times our food came out in a timely manner and was great! The cheese sticks are my all time favorite! Toppers is also right by campus, for any IUPUI kids looking for some good pizza! They are also open pretty late most nights so when you get hungry late at night it is open, and they deliver! Will absolutely be back! read more

I got stuck ordering another Pizza from here! I got called in to work the overnight shift and about the only place open and the pizza was cold and greasy the driver could not read the directions. The toppings were so sparce. It looked like a cracker with a very few pizza ingredients on it. The pizza itself looked like someone played Frisbee with it while it was in the box! This time I only spent $35.00! And I tried" DMing" the store on Facebook and did not see anyway to contact them as suggested in a previous review. Next time I get called in I will make sure I stop at White Castle and just deal with the it!! NO MORE TOPPERS I HAVE BEEN BURNT TWICE NOW!! read more

Toppers Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Hmm, so I had no idea this place was a chain until after I had committed to giving it a try. Interestingly the locals from my workshop seemed to down on the place while I find it to be one of the better chain pizza delivery places I've had. I tried the macaroni and cheese pizza based on the recommendation of the person at the counter. Overall the pizza is a four and a large pizza could easily likely feed three people (it was my dinner and then breakfast for the next three days).. I took off a star for a combination of the price and since the counter clerk failed to inform me of the specials. Since I was buying a large pizza at regular menu price there was a coupon for free breadsticks on the back of the flyer sitting right in front of me. Perhaps I should have known that there was some special somewhere (most chain pizza places always have some special going on) but since the counter person knew I was from out of town (we talked about it) I was pretty disappointed in that lack of customer service. $20 for a pizza is a little pricey, but for pizza and bread sticks I would have been happier with the price. Pro tip for the locals... Check online, as I said, seems that there is always some sort of special going. read more

Toppers Pizza - Mac & Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Toppers Pizza - not quite top notch. I happened upon Toppers Pizza quite by accident. I was planning to visit another "newish" spot (http://www.yelp.com/biz/blaze-fast-fired-pizza-indianapolis?hrid=BVKe1oPjHbbBuBs1yvtq2A), but the line was snaking its way out the door. My companion and I decided to stroll across the street and ran right into Toppers. The pizza was good. Nothing to celebrate with a parade in the street, but certainly worth a try. There are a variety of menu options and topping choices. The space is very small with only one 4-person high top table, about 6 bar stools, and a couch/conversation nook. I assume Toppers wants you to take your treats to-go. I would recommend Toppers if you just want something quick, easy, and relatively reasonably priced. But, don't make a special trip. This is definitely a "because I was in the area and kind of wanted pizza" spot. read more

Toppers Pizza - Artichoke on a pizza? I think, YES! - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I was nervous ordering pizza at 2am after we finished with my sons band competition but the pizza was delivered quickly and warm and it was awesome. Cheesy and crisp. Great experience! read more

THE BEST PIZZA PLACE IN TOWN! Toppers is my Go - To, I can't count how many times I've had it. Their Nacho Stix are one of the best menu items I've ever tasted at any pizza place, have it with Spicy Chipotle Ranch dip and thank me later! My two favorite pizzas are their barbecue chicken pizza ( I add onion) and their cheese pizza with extra cheese! Craving pizza that'll have you drooling? Toppers is the place to go! read more

ordered pizza and wings for the first time. Online ordering was easy to navigate and always a convenient way to order your food. They are doing curbside pickup, and that's nice as well. The pizza was decent and so were the boom boom wings. Nothing too special. Just taste like your average pizza joint. I thought it was weird that you had to order your dipping sauce with the wings and that one didn't even come with it. With that being said, I am glad that I did give them a chance. They do have great deals if you're ordering a lot of food. I know that a lot of their clientele is college kids since they are practically on iupui. It'll probably be awhile before I do order from them again, like I said. Nothing to special, but it gets the job done. read more

Toppers Pizza - Boom boom wings - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I get it. It was super late at night and they know they're one of the few options available but GEESH. I was super excited to try their Nashville hot chicken pizza. I was recently introduced to it and love it. This pizza was literally thrown together and so sloppy. The presentation was horrible. The chicken looked like Tyson frozen nuggets. It tasted like they just took a regular chicken pizza and threw a bunch of peppers on it. And we ordered a large and they gave us one communion size cup of pickles.... I'm not giving up on the concept of Nashville hot chicken pizza but never again from there read more

The most underrated pizza place out there. Not too many people know about this place since they only have 2 locations in the entire country but for sure the most unique and best pizza I've ever had. They have a lot of unique stuff most other places don't offer like the Mac n cheese pizza and cheese curds. Everything I've had here has been great. Hopefully they expand and open more stores read more

Oh Toppers. My long lost friend. I lived above Toppers for 4 years and visited at least once a week. It's a staple for the community around IUPUI. PROS: - It's usually pretty fast! - You usually get the right stuff with your order (like sauces etc.) - Most of the people are pretty nice and it's a good environment when waiting or hanging out. - Open super late! CONS: - This is the single most inconsistent place I've ever eaten. You could order two of the exact same pizzas and they would come out completely different somehow. You never know what you're going to get, even if you order the same stuff. - If it's not fast (which it usually is) then it's SOOOOO SLOW. There's no in between. Try the tator tot pizza, it likely will be inconsistent of what I got, but it's always dang good! read more