Mai Tai are a 5 * We have come here a number of times. Great pizza and Mai Tai. Pizza not so much, reason for te 3 star. It use to be made next door and was great. It just was not the same. Crust was ok sauce over powered everything else. read more

We ordered a pizza. But of course when we walked in the tall blonde. Made sure she said. In a not so nice tone. We only serve pizza now. Is that okay. But of course we came here for pizza. 10" pie we ordered with pepperoni and green peppers. It was okay. Nothing for me to be wowed about. Just your ordinary pie. Nothing to write home about and definitely not something to bring me back. It's starting according to the menu 1963. Back then it was a hit. Today it's a the shit and not in a good way dump. Sorry but Chef Irvine would have a fit in here. He would throw everything in the dumpster. The nicest thing about the place was the bartender. She was sweet and nice. Not a place at this time I would recommend. read more

See all

This place is a hard pass people. In an otherwise island devoid of good food, this place is beyond bad. Please avoid as the food here is beyond poor. The frozen oven style pizza at Foodlands is Michelin star resto compared to this hovel. I feel for these guys as they have been around for 60 years per the hostess. Sad thing is, longevity doesn't equal quality. Find pizza somewhere else. read more

I am not sure how this pizzeria is still open. I had the most disgusting and expensive Pizza in my life there. Before ordering the Pizza, I asked how big the Pizza size was and they told me it's a 10" pizza that is sufficient for 2 person. I ordered the pizza to go and waited for almost 20 minutes. Of course they charged me upfront in case I complain. Once the pizza came, it was not even a 7" pizza and completely dry and burnt. I asked the barman, is that your 10" pizza and he told me yes what do you expect? I told him you guys should be ashamed of this kind of practice and ribbing off people/tourists like that and left the place. My advice specially to tourists, avoid this place. There are many other pizzeria places with much fair prices and better quality. read more

Can't say I was expecting much, but boy was I wrong. Delicious Hawaiian style pizza. Most pineapple and ham pizzas overdo it on the sauce. Not this place. Covered in cheese, a small pizza was enough for two people for two meals. Highly recommended. Plus, you can have the world's best Mai Tai at Tahiti Nui while you wait! read more

The pizza here is really over priced. Even more, the drinks are bad. The service was mediocre, and really didn't help their situation. Spare yourself the time and money and check out some of the island's other pizzerias. read more

By far the worst service I have ever had in my three visits to this island. Ordered an ahi sandwich with no bun (gluten free) its suppose to come with a salad and rice... there was a bun, no salad, no rice and about 7 fries. When we asked our waiter who was drenched in sweat, he did bring more fries and salad but said because he gave us a little more salad than what was usual, he decided that we didnt need rice. We also ordered a pizza. For $2.50 per topping, i would assume you could see the toppings. Unfortunately i assumed wrong. We also waited and hour and a half (no exaggeration) for this pizza. Finally when we tried to split the check, our waiter told us if we wanted to split it, we should have asked in the beginning. Never again. read more

The pizza place is in back of the Tahiti Nui, but you can order and eat in either location. We recommend dining out on the lanai of Tahiti Nui, especially if they have live music going on that night We had the pesto specialty and it was awesome! read more

We ordered the Kuala pork pizza with jalapeño, highly recommended! Fantastic pizza, great Mai tais, good music fantastic atmosphere! Fun tiki bar! read more

Tiki Man Pizza - Kuala pork pineapple and jalapeño, amazing pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Hanalei, Hawaii

I have never posted a 1 star before. But seriously, avoid this like a rabid dog. I think the box had more flavor and less grease. Perhaps the worst pizza I have ever had. I threw it out. Pizza in the trash can. How does that ever happen? It hurts my soul, but it is that bad. read more

We stopped by several times for drinks and music while vacationing in Hanalei. The live music both nights we stopped in was really good. If there had been a better spot for us to hang out, we would have stayed longer and enjoy more drinks while listening to the music. However, there really is no great spot to grab a drink at the bar (if there are no seats) without being in the way of the wait staff or other patrons. The drinks were pretty good but only after quite a wait to get the attention of the bartender. One night we did try the pizza, opting for Hawaiian and Bbq chicken. They were both good but not worth trying again or highly recommending to other visitors. My preference would be to enjoy a drink and music before / after dinner at another location. read more

The Tiki Man Pizza located inside the Tahiti Nui restaurant and from what I can tell they don't have a phone number. The pizza tastes very basic with a thin non-memorable crust. Lots of creative topping offerings. Pretty quick from order to ready. read more

I was excited to try the prosciutto and mozzarella pizza, and it was... okay. Not amazing, not terrible, but okay. Cheers for being one of the only pizza offerings on the island, though! read more

I went off reviews early in week and didn't come here earlier....my son LOVES the pepperoni pizza! We've tried pizza everywhere on the island and this was his favorite. read more

Best pizza ever! We got the Da Hawaiian and it was great! Real ham, fresh pineapple, and hot right out of the oven hand made crust. Definitely coming back! read more

Tiki Man Pizza - Da Hawaiian large pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Hanalei, Hawaii

The pizza has no taste. blan, does not taste like Pizza crust or pizza sauce, oily gross cheese on top. It was awful! read more

Tiki Man Pizza - The oily gross cheese pizza from tiki man pizza. Yuk! - Pizza Near Me - Hanalei, Hawaii

We called to place a phone order and were told to hold, then the woman put the phone down and I waited for 27 minutes before hanging up. I heard background noise and talking and no one ever picked up. We then called to place an order through Hanalei Bay Pizzeria where they immediately picked up, promptly took our order, gave us a reasonable wait time and thanked us for the business. read more

Aloha! I am the owner of Hanalei Pizza (Formerly Pizza Hanalei). When you type in "Hanalei Pizza" in Google, TikiMan Pizza pops up. TikiMan Pizza has a great chef for both regular dining and Pizza. We (Hanalei Pizza) have a very different style of Pizza. (Both places are good) So if you are reviewing Pizza in Hanalei, please make sure you are reviewing the right place. It's a small town and everyone knows everyone else. We all work hard to get along. Hanalei Pizza is in CHING YOUNG VILLAGE and Tiki Man Pizza is behind our favorite watering hole in Hanalei "TAHITI NUI" (Best Mai Tai on the island). Enjoy both places, just make sure you know where you are. (Hard to do after the Mai Tai's). Aloha. Karlos deTreaux Hanalei Pizza read more

Store bought crust, cooked in a conveyor. The top was cooked, the bottom was undercooked. Added Tabasco to the pizza. Tabasco makes shit food taste good. read more

As far as I could tell, this place is really just the pizza menu for Tahiti Nui. We followed the signs for Tiki Man Pizza and entered the restaurant from the back, but ended up walking through to the front of Tahiti Nui and sitting on the porch. That's fine, just initially a little confusing. Order a cocktail because the pizzas take about 35 minutes. I highly recommend the coconut margarita. Also, they advertise "the best mai tai in town" and I wouldn't disagree. We had the Hawaiian Pizza for $23 and it was pretty good. Overall, a nice dining experience with a lovely view. Try to sit outside if you can. read more

My daughter enjoyed dancing in the front with Aunty who was playing Hawaiian songs on her ukulele all night. This was the best part of the evening. Sadly, our pizzas took forever to arrive and then arrived burned on the edges all around. The seating wasn't very comfortable either. I hate to give bad reviews, but I feel like they could have done better. read more

Amazing pizza!!! Based on the yelp reviews we were skeptical but we thought we'd give it a try anyways and it was delicious. We will maybe come back again while we're staying here otherwise we'll definitely be back the next time we come out to Kauai. read more

After hearing so many great reviews this was an ultimate let down. Our service was beyond slow. Our waiter was covered in sweat and we presumed it was from running around catering to people's requests. But apparently it was from running back to the chefs to correct all the orders he imput incorrectly. The pizza itself wasn't bad, but the toppings are nonexistent. If you have 3 hours, money to burn and no standards for service, than by all means this is your choice spot on the island. read more

Let's be real here. 150.00 for limp pizza. Bottled ranch. Music was enjoyable. Front and eat pizza BEFORE you come. Pizza Hut where are u!!! read more

Went here for Pizza after searching for a while. Many of the places in Hanalei were either closed or were too far away. We got a pineapple and pepperoni. The pizza itself was solid, but nothing special. It fulfilled our craving for Pizza, which is why it's getting 3 stars. read more

Pizza was poor quality, service was worse. Arrived at 11:37 AM, sign said restaurant opened at 11:00 AM - was informed we would not be served for 20 minutes because they were not open, despite other customers already eating. When wife and I only ordered water to drink, waitress let out audible sigh. Waitress attempted to charge more than menu listed price for pizza. Not worth it. read more

Loved the pizza here! If you're looking for a good pie on the North Coast of Kauai and you're in Hanalei town, I recommend Tiki Man pizza. Love the Kailua Pork they use in place of traditional ham / Canadian bacon. read more

Went here with the family after a long day at the beach. None of us were expecting much, but were all hapily surprised. We all eat a lot of pizza and we don't mind spending some extra bucks for good food. This was some of the best pizza I've had. read more

no complaints here! we ordered da hawaiian and it was delish!! excellent crust and pizza- it was cool how they serve their hawaiian with smoked pulled pork. Drinks were tasty as well- this was our first stop and we were completely satisfied- and stuffed!!! go ahead and order the large- for only $3 more you really do get the most for your money. and who doesn't love leftover pizza?!?! read more

People feel very strongly about pizza, and reviews are usually love it or hate it. Someone left a post-it note at the house we rented saying "BEST PIZZA! REALLY, GET THIS." We trusted them and were not disappointed. The crust was thin (I prefer that), sauce is good and not applied too heavily, cheese was yummy and tasted like parmesan was mixed in. At first I was taken aback to pay $44 for 2 pizzas, but then I did the math on eating out or grocery shopping to feed 9 people and it turned out to be a bargain. I was sad we never went back during our visit. You can even order here and eat it at Tahiti Nui! Service was a bit indifferent but it's not like they're waiting your table or asking for a tip. read more

Tiki Man Pizza seems to be a myth. We attempted to eat there twice, but without success. It doesn't seem to exist, although there is a sign with an arrow. It appeared to be linked with a bar and lounge, but when I went in to inquire, no one even acknowledged me. So l left. We wanted to try it out but instead found Hanalei Pizza. I recommend them! read more

We've gotten pizza here a dozen or so times over many many trips. The past few years the pizza has really tasted so so and this last time it was down right bad. The crust had to be frozen and was not good; the sauce was bad; and when I am spending nearly $30 on a pizza I expect some toppings. We had #5 the Da Hui, but there was only a few blobs of pork (some slices had none) and very little pineapple. read more

Decent pizza - very good service and friendly staff.

So good. Best Hawaiian pizza I've had in a while, really good crust. Perfect spot for after a day at the beach. Mai tai was best I've had. They were even open on turkey day when we went. It's a dive and small seating area but worth it if you're in Kauai north shore! read more

Had the Da Hui pizza...yummy! We sat on the porch of the Tahiti Nui and listened to great music, enjoyed the atmosphere and our delish pizza. read more

Had the #5 Da Hui pizza. It was super fresh and super good. Only downside was the speed of the service. Would definitely come back. Seemed a bit pricey (for a Californian) but probably on par with island prices. read more

I don't write many reviews here but I wanted to point out this little place. I would have given it 5 stars because the food and drinks were out of this world. The service is not the fastest and not in any hurry to get to you. We first arrived and not quite sure where to sit so we got seated near the stage by the window which was kind of fun definitely felt like I was in a tiki hut. We sat there for about 5 min before they even brought us menus. Then is was about another 10 mins before they came to take our order. Finally we got ordered and the drinks did show up right away and the mai tais are amazing. The food came out and we had the pizza and I was blown away at the flavor. After we were finished we kept waiting on a check which finally showed up and we were going to run a credit card but our server never came to collect. We finally decided to give cash and had to find our server to get out. Food is amazing if you have time to wait. read more

We are here for our last night in Kauai. We were immediately greeted at the door and sat. Someone came over and introduced herself and took our drink order right away. There was pleasant live music . The whole place has character . We loved our experience and the food was awesome! All 3 of my kids and husband loved it ! Thank you ! read more

Quick service, friendly staff and great pizza. It was no nonsense ordering and quality food. I got a pineapple &hawaiian pork pie. It has been one of my eating high points on this island. read more

If you are a vegetarian, do NOT order cheese pizza by the slice. They only make one pizza to sell by the slice (half pepperoni, half cheese) - and I got plenty of pepperoni with my slice. Yuck! My husband ate a slice of the pepperoni. It was really greasy, the crust was thin, but dense. He is not picky and loves just about any pizza, but liked nothing about this one. read more