Wanted to love this but was very disappointed. Pizza was way too salty, over cooked and dough was tough. Yes they are priced high but you expect this on the island. Only good thing was the girl that took the phone order was very pleasant. read more

Seriously, probably some of the best pizza I've ever had in my life. Was not expecting to say that in Kaua'i I tried to order online multiple times, but the website said they weren't accepting online orders. I tried to call, but never got an answer. So I went down here one evening around 6:30pm and as I was preparing to order, was informed they were SOLD OUT! Wow! So a couple days later, we went back down there earlier and were able to order a half Hawaiian and half sausage only large pizza. My daughter got a Dr Pepper and I got an Aloha Pineapple Orange juice while we waited for our order. There's minimal parking in front and there's street parking as well. The place is cute with a decent amount of seating inside. The pizza was New York style, super thin crust! So flavorful and delicious! We also got a couple sides of ranch and their ranch is fantastic! Would definitely recommend giving this place a try! read more

See all

We found this place as we were looking for dinner and decided to go with pizza. Sure glad we did we because we found this awesome place. We ordered a large pepp pizza and a garden salad and it was amazing. There were two options for the pizza, New York or Detroit style and we went with NY. It was so good! It was thin and had a nice crisp to it. The salad was super fresh and the ranch was yummy. Aside from the food, which was amazing, the service was great. The guy at the front was super friendly and was nice to talk to while we waited for our pizza. I think his name was Josh or John? Anyways, he was a cool guy! The place itself was very clean and had plenty of seating. Highly recommend giving them a try! read more

See all

Pizza was burned. This is their plain cheese pizza. Looks like they threw more cheese on it at the end to mask the burned cheese. My kid wouldn't eat it and was the reason we ordered cheese pizza. my huz and I had a slice each. Mid. Good service read more

Pancho’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kapaʻa, Hawaii

Best pizza to have! Coming from Cali we have a lot of good pizza. This is the perfect sauce ratio and generous on the pepperoni! Perfectly light and filling all at the same time! Great service and very clean! Definetly would come back next trip read more

Pancho’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kapaʻa, Hawaii

We had a hankering for pizza, and stumbled upon this place in Kapa'a Town. It's in a rather non-descript building, with a very small amount of seating inside, near the bulk of the downtown shops. The pizza was surprisingly good. Good enough, in fact, we're likely to be back the next time we come to town. My girlfriend is vegetarian, and asked if we could have the Hawaiian, but substitute mushrooms and jalapeno for the ham (with plenty of pineapple, of course). The server happily accommodated. It's a "New York" kine pizza, thin crust but ample cheese. It was really good! We noticed other folks that day getting their Detroit deep dish, which also looked good. We may try that the next time we're by. Note: they do sell pizza by the slice. For the thin crust, there are only two options: pepperoni and cheese. For the Detroit slices, they'll make them to order, so there are more options. Also note: there is very limited parking out front, but more up and down the street. read more

See all

Awesome pizza!!! Never thought I would get a neopolitan style pizza in Hawaii this good! Would highly recommend, especially if you're eating in for a night! read more

Everything was delicious! We tried the New York-style pizzas--thin crust, generous portions. They sprinkle grated Parmesan on top, which I loved, but picky eaters like my kids might not (it brushes off pretty easily though). The cheesy garlic bread was amazing--loaded with flavor thanks to a garlicky sauce, and it's the size of a full pizza! Ranch was tasty as well. Online ordering was smooth, and our food was ready right on time, maybe even a little early. We did takeout and ate about 20 minutes later--I bet it would've been even better fresh at the restaurant. read more

Pancho's Pizza exceeded expectations for quality, flavor and customer service! The pizza was delicious. It comes well done, which our crew all likes, but if you are wanting less crispy toppings, you may want to request it be less well done when you order. We would definitely order from here again anytime we have a pizza craving while visiting Kauai! There is a seating area for eating in the restaurant or to sit while you wOne down side is they do not offer gluten free pizza options. read more

Great NY style pizza. It is delicious. Just give yourself little time. It takes few extra time. Worth it.

Hands down one of the best pizzas I've had in my life! Francisco knows what he is doing! Much love from Las Vegas, NV! read more

Pancho’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kapaʻa, Hawaii

good pizza - delicious sauce, great crust, generous toppings. Definitely one of the best pizzas I've ever had

Phenomenal pizza. You can tell the guy making the pizza really cared about his craft. Fresh ingredients, crispy crust and cheese on top. The pepperoni was delicious. So happy the other pizza joint we were gonna check out was closed because this pizza slapped. Hit the spot. 10/10 read more

Pancho’s Pizza - Pepperoni pizza. So fire - Pizza Near Me - Kapaʻa, Hawaii

The first time we drove by, the name made us chuckle...(Poncho's Pizza is sorta like Guido's Tacos, right?). But one evening we were in the mood for pizza so we came to Poncho's. Wow, did we enjoy our pie! I've never had jalapeños slices on a pizza before, but I'm a huge fan now. I think our pizza was New York style thin crust called the Waimea. Anyways, the sit-down area is not the best Hawaii offers, so we drove our boxed pie directly across the street then turned left and parked 20 feet from the ocean. What a fine meal that turned out to be. And by the way, the other half of our pie became breakfast pizza and once again, it was outstanding (our test for quality pizza ingredients is how does it taste the next morning). It passed our test. read more

Pancho’s Pizza - No reservations required! - Pizza Near Me - Kapaʻa, Hawaii

Great pizza and wings. We had the NY style all meat and it had just the right amount of sauce and cheese. They don't fry their wings, they run them through the pizza oven and it caramelizes the sauce. So delicious! Josh, one of the owners is a super cool dude. Give them a try, you won't be disappointed. read more

Absolutely delicious. It's the best pizza I've ever had. Most pizzas these days are greasy and full of preservatives, sugar, and salt. I feel great after eating this pizza and can tell they use quality fresh ingredients read more

My sister and I are New Yorkers born and raised, and Pancho's NY pizza was right on the nose! We shared the GMO pizza and absolutely LOVED it! The seating is indoors and more than enough space (there are 2 high tables for six people each, a bar seating area for five people each, and three tables for four people each) Overall, we would come back! It was great to speak with the front of house who was from NoLA! read more

Pancho’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kapaʻa, Hawaii

Tastes amazing. I had a margarita Detroit style and my friend had a barbecue chicken and they agreed to make it the Detroit style. Service was fast and could not have been more friendly. The dining room is simple and clean, easy in and out. But oh my God how expensive. read more

I really wanted to like this spot... the pizza that we got was sooo salty- couldn't taste the crust or toppings or cheese as we were overpowered by salt read more

Good flavor, cooked right, ready when expected. A little pricey. We ordered a sausage and mushroom NY style pizza. Crust was crispy, toppings were generous. Staff were friendly. read more

Pancho's Pizza is hands down the best pizza in Kapa'a. . You can really taste the difference in the quality of their ingredients -- they use flour imported from Italy that's clean and free from all the pesticides you find in most U.S. products, and the flavor and texture of the crust are incredible. My husband and I were looking for something to eat before heading to the airport and we're so glad we found this. The pizza is truly next-level. If you're someone who cares about both taste and quality ingredients, this place is a gem!! read more

Panchos pizza is amazing! Their Detroit style deep dish is so tasty with high quality toppings! They put two types of delicious pepperoni and the cheese is stretchy yumminess. Even better than the pizza is the hard working family that puts it together. They care about what they do and about making the customer's experience a memorable one. They paid special attention to my almost 2 year old daughter and even offered her a balloon to celebrate cinco de Mayo! read more

Pancho’s Pizza - Detroit Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kapaʻa, Hawaii

We enjoyed our dinner at Pancho's! We ordered one Detroit style and another New York style and neither disappointed. It really hit the sport after an activity filled day. There is seating inside, but not a whole lot so seating a large party could be challenging depending on how busy it is. The owner is very friendly and welcoming. We had a nice chat with him while we were there. Definitely worth a visit if pizza is what you're craving while in Kapa'a. read more

We stoped here after a hike while on vacation on the Pride of America Hawaiian cruise! We had the Detroit Style Pizza and the Margarita Pizza! Both were absolutely DELICIOUS . No pictures cuz we eat it all up! lol read more

Great New York-style pizza! We loved the fresh shredded parm on top. Super close to our condo and a hit with the whole family. We'll definitely be back next time! Aloha! read more

Great food & service. Unassuming looking place, but Detroit & New York Style pizzas were delish! The cheesy garlic bread was so good, highly recommend! Staff were very friendly and also recommended local attractions to visit while visiting Kauai. read more

Pancho’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kapaʻa, Hawaii

We did takeout and tried the Wailua pizza. It was delicious! The staff was super nice and gave us togo utensils and plates.

By far, the best pizza in Kapaa...possibly the best on Kauai. Mine was truly an Artisan Pizza Pie! Highly recommend this easy to miss joint right next to Bank of Hawaii. I went with my version of sweet and spicy, pepperoni and pineapple. Their pepperoni is fabulous! read more

we got the The Wailua detroit style and it was INSANE!!! so so so delicious, we're going to be dreaming of this pizza when we go back to california my boyfriend is picky with pizza and said this may be the best pizza he's ever had. the owner was so nice and helpful! 1000/10 recommend read more

Pancho’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kapaʻa, Hawaii

1 size. Good flavor. Thin crust only took about 10 mins and had perfect amount of toppings and flavor! Good service.

Hands down my favorite meal while visiting here. The pizza is absolutely delicious and the service was great. Super friendly owner and a beautiful view. No tv's needed just peace looking at the ocean. Perfection! We will be seeing you again at our next visit from Sacramento! read more

Alright, here we are--Kauai. You're thinking beaches, sunsets, maybe poke. You're not exactly expecting top-tier pizza. But then you find a little spot like Pancho's Pizza, and boom--game changer. First bite: really nice crunch on the crust, thin but not flimsy. Good undercarriage, well-cooked, no soggy center. Sauce is flavorful--sweet, a little tangy--clearly homemade. Cheese is high quality, good pull, not overly greasy. Everything is balanced. You can tell there's pride in this pizza. read more

Oh my - fabulous pizza. We ordered the margherita and it delivered. Salty, fresh basil, yummy crust. Also delicious for breakfast the next morning! read more

Delicious pepperoni pizza! Definitely would order again. The best! Ordered the round pie. Simple and easy to order. Done right on time.

We had the Detroit style pizza. it was wonderful. I love the crunch to the crust. We had a good conversation with the owner. Very friendly.

DETROIT PIZZA IS THE BEST !!! DJ music WAS awesome!!! very Innovative and eclectic , ahead of his time!!!!' Thank You !! read more

This was a great little pizza shop on Kauai. We came in on the way back from the North Shore. My wife and I split a Detroit Style pizza that was fantastic. The service was great and the staff was very friendly. We had a great conversation with them while waiting for our pizza. Would absolutely go back! read more

When nothing else is open, this is the place to go! Seriously, really good pizza. Everyone loved it.

We were on Kauai on vacation and recommended this place by a local, so you know it's good. We got the New York style pepperoni and it was fabulous. Hot and fresh. Chees was melty and had the perfect pull. Nice big slices, perfect thin crust, with fresh shredded parmesean cheese on top. The owner was there. He talked to us about places to see around Kauai, even showed us pics on his phone! read more

A little pricy but probably in line with this area. Great quality pizza. Had the margarita pizza and cheese bread. Both were phenomenal. Prob the best pizza in Kapaa. Did have an issue with not answering the phone. Thought it was because they were busy but there wasn't really anyone there when I got in. They also tried to ask my wife to pay again after I already paid but we got it figured out. read more