Quality fish sandwiches & home cooked meal vibe! Timely and appropriate service from all staff!!

Second visit and review here. Again a good, no frills, cooked to order, basic seafood and sides place. More than adequate parking. No crowd so plenty of seating. You order as you enter from options on the wall then find you seating. Service was accurate, prompt, and courteous . Food came quickly and hot was hot! Restaurant was clean. If you're comfortable with just good food in a laid back, non- glitzy, non-fast food setting, give here a try. Drinks are Coke products in cans, a plus for me. read more

Was in the neighborhood dropping off supplies, so figured since I've had Thimmes bookmarked for years, mind as well grab some lunch. Plenty of parking. Oldies music playing low. Lunch time on a Friday, school wasn't out for summer yet, so other customers were older retired folks. Inside's small but very fitting for Lancaster. Offerings are printed out on regular printer paper and taped on the wall. Everything's basic here, ambience isn't an issue, if you're into that. The older gal running FOH (wife?) was very sweet; guessing perhaps her husband mans the kitchen? I got the fish sandwich with cheese and tartar sauce and a side of shoestring fries. Both came fresh hot out of the fryer. The breading is thin - cornmeal, I'm assuming - didn't overpower the protein, the fish tasted good; no oil taste, a big bonus. Standard fries, very good. I passed on the bun, didn't want to fill up on plain bread. All in all, a very good lunch for cheap - you get what you pay for in the best way possible. read more

See all

Nice friendly place with great cooked to order fish, shrimp,clams, oysters and more. Service was quick. read more

Thimmes Fish Shack - Menu 08/2024 - Seafood Near Me - Lancaster, Ohio

Thimmes Fish Shack continues to be my "go to" place for delicious fish sandwiches, best battered deep fried oysters with cocktail sauce (my preferred method of finishing off THE TASTE ) Top it off with crispy French Fries. I maybe wrong but they look and taste homemade. The service would challenge any fast food delivery. By far faster than Mickey D's. Ambiance reminds me of their previous small building their parents served many years of great food across from North School . I don't have a picture th read more

Good food, service and prices! Love the fish deluxe sandwich! Friendly family ran business. read more

Old school fried seafood shack with good quality and value. I will definitely go back when I'm in the area. This is not a central Ohio 'seafood restaurant' with pretensions and cocktails. It's a paper plate fried seafood shack you may encounter on the NC shore. read more

Fish and fries delicious but small portions. The prices on online menu were not at all accurate. When i said it was so much less than the accurate price they said it was impossible to change the ad. Bet they dont get too many repeat customers. read more

Friday night of Lent, decided to grab a meal at Thimmes'. Did not disappoint! Walked into order and placing an order was a breeze despite how busy they were. Very friendly staff and helpful. Food was absolutely delicious! We ordered the Deluxe fish sandwich, cole slaw, clam strips, and mozzarella sticks. Cole slaw was creamy but a bit overwhelming in the cabbage taste department. Clam strips, Deluxe fish sandwich, and mozzarella sticks are a must do! Will definitely go back! read more

Look my reviews are for what the restaurant is. This place us known for its fried fish, well fried everything ar a great price. Family owned for over 50 years and very friendly You cant go wrong with the fried fish sandwich, fried mushrooms and bean soup under 8 bucks. Came back for a visit and tasted like it did from 25 years ago!!! read more

Very plain old school restaurant. Like a lot of the other reviews, I have driven past this place for 12 years and have never visited. Today I decided to change that. The interior is plain with the daily specials posted on the wall. What is unique is the restroom is located on the exterior of the building, like old gas stations used to be. I'm not a Lancaster native, so maybe this location was a gas station in a previous life? My canned coke had a weird flavor to it for some reason. My seafood platter meal was good, but nothing to write home about. Unless someone I'm with wants to eat here, it isn't going to be high on my list to return with the other dining options in the area. read more

I'm used to LJS (Long John Silvers) & Captain D's, for my fast food fish, and then I move to Lancaster, Ohio where there are neither, so I'm on the lookout for a good Fish-Fry, Fast Food Resturant and what do I find but, Thimmes Fish Shack and boy let me tell you, it would be easy for this Resturant to compete with the Bigger Chains. I mean their fish isn't as greasy as the Bigger Chains and their prices are more than competitive. let me suggest if you're out their way you stop by and give them a try, I don't believe you'll be sorry. read more

The place doesn't look like much from the outside, or inside for that matter, but the fish dinner I had was good. For the price I paid, the fish fillet was huge and not greasy. Did I mention that the fish tasted fresh? I ordered the onion rings - again, good portion size. Will I go back the next time I am in Lancaster? You bet! read more

A nice family restaurant with yummy fish served in a simple manner. A great place to go for lunch or dinner. If you like fish, you will enjoy this restaurant. read more

Small. Food is ok at best. Slow service they need help bad from what it looked like. Not much better than a LJ silvers.

If your looking for a fancy restaurant this isn't it. If your looking for large portions. This isn't it. If your looking for restrooms accessed from inside the restaurant this isn't it. However, the fish sandwich was very good as well as the waffle fries and bean soup. Soup needed salt and pepper but that's available so no biggie. Service was polite and fast. The place is super clean. It's a walk back in time. I eat out alot and I seen someone say something about people not getting out much who had positive reviews here. Well I will say I have been to alot of places. Fancy and not fancy. Local owned and chains. And I was more pleased with the meal at Thimmes than I have been at some big known places. Wish the meal was a tad larger but the prices are reasonable to really we all probably need portions like this. I know it wouldn't hurt me. I was content and that's all I needed to be! There was no one at the restaurant when we got there and was second guessing our decision to eat there. However we were early for lunch. By the time we left the restaurant was filling up with customers. That made me feel better to see. read more

See all

There is legitimately a sign on the door that says "Open Saturday's 10:30am till 4:00pm." Saying they have limited business hours would be an understatement. read more

Thimmes Fish Shack - Limited business hours would be an understatement... - Seafood Near Me - Lancaster, Ohio

Sadly, the Cod fish was delicious as well as the fries, Oysters. The old man who owns this place will stand outside the door and complain how you have parked. This last time, last week, (2nd time) there was not another customer parked in lot on both sides of restaurant. Danny always gave me wonderful service, but old guy would tear him apart while I ate. Ridiculous. The lot where the stripes are so faded you cannot see. This was the second and last time I will EVER go into his restaurant. Someone needs to learn respect for their customers. Always from now on, Madison's Fish on Madison's Avenue. Last night at 6pm, I drove by Thimmes' and lot was empty. Apparently NOT best fish in town and Parking Patrolman was on duty. Learn respect for your customers who have repeated your business over the years. read more

Thimmies isn't a fancy fish restaurant. However, it is the best fish you will have. Fresh, simply prepared as it has been at this family establishment for over 50 years. Try the home style onion rings. read more

I've been coming here since I was little. Family owned fish sandwich (and more) restaurant. I really like the sandwiches because they are NOT greasy like some places. Good service and quaint and they finally accept credit cards. Not fancy but good food and prices. read more

After driving past this restaurant for seven years, I finally stopped in. Just over $36 for four fish sandwiches, two with onion rings, a fried combo with onion rings, four fried mushrooms, and three cheese sticks and an order of fried clams. Price is comparable to feeding a family of four at an average fast food restaurant. Kids did not like the fish and did not eat it. Breading is bland and flavorless, no added salt. Ends of the fish filets dry and/or rubbery. Onion rings not bad, they were a bit salty, all of the broken ones(over half) were burned on the ends they became. Mushrooms were bland and soggy as were the majority of the clams. While the clams were gigantic, only two of the seven were thoroughly cooked. Cold slimy clams in a mushy fried breading is not something I enjoy eating. Soda is canned soda, great if your eating lunch on the go, not so good if your dining in and eating the salty onion rings. Unless someone in the family specifically asks for food from Thimmes during Lent, I won't be returning. read more

Late lunch mid week. I always drove past going to the Lancaster BMV and decided to stop. This place is a blast from the past. Old time food, not over-seasoned or over-salted. Excellent classic coleslaw. Clean place. The muzak was endless 80s power ballads that was pretty funny considering I was the only customer there without white hair. Only knock is the portions were smallish. On the 3-piece fish meal the fish planks were the size of large chicken tenders and the waffle fries were 8-10 pieces. Even though I prefer the coleslaw...that portion size for $10 is not swaying me from driving back to Rusty's Wharf in Pataskala for my fish and chips fix. read more

I love the fish sandwiches !!! the downfall is their operating hours and also the prices. To me it is way overpriced for what you get.