After the week I was having I needed a cool new spot to get a drank!!! Not a drink but a DRANK! I found this place on Yelp and decided to give it a try! I was glad I did! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by the Owner Steve. I immediately feel in love with the place because of the New Orleans feel! The NOLA music took me on a mini vacation of sitting in one of the bars and enjoying the music and a drink. Steve asked what type of drink did I like...I told him I'm more of a Margarita girl and he quickly made me a champagne drink mixed with tequila....called the Escobar! Delicious! I can't wait to return to try some other drinks. It was be awesome once is gets warm as they have a large patio that overlooks Broad Ripple Ave! read more

See all

The vibe in Thieves is lit but chill at the same time. It's a small space, but my friends and I always have a great time. I'm more of a "shots" girl but the cocktails are delicious & reasonably priced (which is very important). We've gone 2 weekends in a row lol. Let's not forget the amazing staff, they're extremely welcoming and make sure we have everything we need. read more

Went here with my boyfriend and one of our friends for some early cocktails. Pricing is extremely reasonable. Vibe is cozy, darker and very comfortable. Owners seem very kind and personable. I would definitely recommend this place! They also have wifi and a few outlets for you to bring your laptop. Loving the vibe! read more

See all

I brought My friend here for her birthday because she said she just wanted to go somewhere for cute drinks and a nice atmosphere so I brought her here and Thieves gave just that! Me and my friend ordered multiple rounds of drinks and each one was just as good as the last! Our server Mikayla was so sweet and knowledgeable about the menu which was a big bonus! This place was really cute for taking pictures because it had a little selfie nook with a couch and good lighting. I didn't try all the cocktails but the ones I'm adding were all good and if you are a shots person ask for the Russian Cocaine! It goes down really smooth and it's different from taking a shot with just a lime and chaser :). Anytime I want a good drinking experience in Broap Ripple I will always suggest here. Plus, everything is top shelf without being overly expensive. I spent $50 for 4 rounds. read more

See all

Super cute and amazing cocktails! My girlfriends and I came in for my birthday. Had an amazing time! Bartender was extremely attentive and took great care of us! Super great prices on some amazing cocktails! Highly recommend it I'll totally be back! read more

Thieves - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Finally got stop in and get a drink at this cute, cozy little bar! I stopped by on a Saturday afternoon it wasn't as busy so this is the perfect time to go (to beat the crowds) the bartender was the sweetest and made a couple recommendations. Thieves offers a very classy yet modern vibe. Patio seating is available! read more

See all

Came here on opening night. Had the Apple cider mule which was sweet and refreshing. Then I had the salted Carmel martini which tasted like an orange tootsie pop. The vibe is upbeat and lively in an intimate space with neighborhood style seating around a large table in the center of the room plus a few individual tables closer to the bar. Service was friendly and welcoming. I'm looking forward to making this a regular stop, especially when the patio opens in the summer. read more

Thieves - Apple Cider Mule & Bourbon Street - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Glad someone took over this space. The screwball Manhattan was tasty and so was the Moscow mule! read more

Thieves - Moscow mule and screwball Manhattan - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Really great variety of cocktails. Not many cocktail places in broad ripple so it's a nice addition. Staff is very casual and the front patio is a plus on good weather days. I also appreciated that the mocktail we ordered for our DD (seltzer water with cranberry and lime) was comp'd. Only complaint is it's a bit pricey for the area ($16). read more

I'm a sucker for a themed cocktail bar, and the vibes here were excellent! We ordered an amaretto sour and an old fashioned. Both were delicious, albeit very expensive. Fun spot for a date night! read more

Great little joint, nice bartender, cool vibe on the inside. Lots of red really gives the place a cool aesthetic. Cocktails were well made, not overpoweringly strong but more than enough alcohol to feel you got your moneys worth. It's a good place to pop in for a cocktail or two, not the biggest building though so I could see it filling up on busy days. read more

Great hidden gem along BR Ave. Very old school vibe (relaxed, chill) and a nice drink menu. Service is top notch, and the patrons are usually friendly. read more

My first time at this bar was amazing! The atmosphere was perfect. The bartender was so great. The drinks were amazing. I tried a Mojito Gimlet and the Influencer Drink. Both were relatively inexpensive compared to other bars and mixed so well. We sat right by the bar and the bartender engaged in conversation with us while crafting up different cocktails. It was busy, but we were still able to have a private conversation. With COVID, there was limited seating and the place was full, but as it starts to get warmer they have plenty of patio space. Perfect place for a date night for good drinks and a great atmosphere. Will be going back! read more

Thieves - Mojito Gimlet at the bar - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Drinks were ok but needs to add more bartenders- they only had one and couldn't keep up with the amount of people. If your worried about covid avoid. No social distancing whatsoever with tables crowded and people all belly up at the bar. read more

Thieves - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

This is a small little bar on broad ripple ave serving up cocktails, wine, and beer. Their signature cocktails have super fun names like "hot girl summer" and "morning wood". I assume this is a rotating menu. I ordered mojito mule and it honestly had no flavor. Barely any lime and nearly no mint. It didn't even taste like ginger beer. Just super watered down. However.... All of my friends enjoyed their drinks - hot girl summer, screwball Manhattan, and thieves in the city. I would definitely go back and give it another try. read more

See all

This bar has a cool atmosphere. It was nice to sit there when it was later in the evening. Everything was open and breezy and you could see outside. The patio seating was full, so we were unable to sit out there. Next time, I would like to try to sit outside. I wasn't drinking when we went out, but everyone seemed to enjoy their drinks. read more

I had to pop in here with a couple friends after we had dinner next door because I had seen this place in my explore feed on Instagram and wow am I glad we did! It's a very small bar but the drink menu is amazing. I seriously wanted to try all the cocktails after reading the descriptions. I don't even like coffee and I tasted the Cold Brew Martini and it was unbelievable. So delicious! Tasted like a dessert! I ordered the Thieves in the City which is a cosmo and it was great! The drinks we're super cold which might sound silly but they were made perfectly! For my second drink (we decided to stay because we loved our first ones so much!) I had The Influencer off the champagne cocktails list. It was THE BEST! It was absolutely delicious and honestly I could see if being a dangerous one because it didn't even taste like alcohol! I would get it again for sure. Again I will just reiterate that this is a tiny bar. I would think it would be ideal for a couple or just a few friends looking for a trendy place to relax and enjoy an upscale but chill night out. Who knows post covid but I can't imagine this as a dance spot personally. I will be back no doubt! read more

See all

Our bartender Noah was amazing! We came in for a friends birthday and he made the best drinks and had good conversation all night long. Noah was very sweet and welcoming and helped make our night awesome. We'll definitely be coming back. Best service we've had in a long time! read more

Love the drinks here. We've gone here a few times now and every time our experience has been good. This past time the weather was great so we grabbed a table outside. Now, they have a very small staff but the bartenders have always been great. Their French 75 is great and it helps that we can bring our own food into the outside area so nothing hits better than some good drinks and Kilroy's breadsticks. Highly recommend you check out their cocktails! read more

Love that there is a cocktail bar in Broad Ripple. Service was great and so were the drinks! I thought they were priced well, too! Highly recommend. read more

Low key, quiet, nice, friendly we enjoy sitting in the velvet chairs and the ambience

LOVE this place. Has become my favorite on the strip. Great fun cocktails and amazing service! Love the outdoor seating and fire place as well! read more

Cool vibe, stylish space, and excellent drinks. A good low-key alternative to the busy bars elsewhere in Broad Ripple. There's enough room for a group, yet the bar still feels intimate. Highly recommended. read more

Cocktails and aesthetic were cute. But what was not cute was the horrible service of their male bartender. Will never be back.

Delicious drinks. However, I noticed the men's room had tasteful , soft-core pornographic photos but the women's room only had a "slay" light and some boring ass farm house decor. Totally sexist. read more

Thieves is great! They really take pride in making delicious drinks. I'm obsessed with their amaretto sour, the egg white takes it to another level. They are especially good at that; taking classic drinks and perfecting them. Awesome patio right on the strip and just an overall cool vibe. No food, but they allow you to order food and have it delivered! read more

Very small bar but adorable nonetheless. Drinks are tasty & they can even make non alcoholic versions of all of their drinks which I appreciated. Sadly, we wanted to sit outside but their outdoor heaters were down. It does tend to get loud when a larger crowd is there making it harder to hear the people you came with but the staff seemed friendly. Also, be sure to eat before visiting because they do not have a food menu. Overall nice experience, would recommend for a late night drink with a couple friends. read more

So amazing! The staff was great, always recommending great drinks and even come up with drinks they aren't on their menu. Would definitely recommend! read more

Noah was a pretty cool bartender. 10/10 recommend. Makes a mean green tea shot too and throws things around while he does it. Sends me back to my childhood and gives me nostalgia. read more

staff is always super friendly and nice. the drinks are very tasty and will have you feeling really good. the price is typical of any cocktail bar. This is where i go to have a nice tasty drink while catching up with friend, or as a pregame before a night out. they have indoor and outdoor seating depending on weather. very modern, sexy, and chill bar. read more

My friends and I love this bar. The bartender, Nate, is amazing and makes the best cocktails. To the guy that gave it one star review and critiqued this bartender and the staff- I was there that night. This large group was rude and obnoxious and making other patrons feel uncomfortable. The staff was in fact following COVID protocol. There were tables available outside. I can't wait to go back read more

Awesome place for drinks! Ask for Noah when you go in there! Best old fashioned in Indy! Definitely a place to check out in broad ripple!!!!

Oh my, delicious! Thanks, Nate, for serving up just what I needed! I enjoyed my French 75 so much, I followed it up with the slightly sweeter version, the French Martini, with a splash of Chambord. And thank you for the thoughtful zero proof cocktails my mate ordered. Also tasty! I'm so glad this spot on the strip is occupied again by a fun, very reasonably priced bar with my favorite bartender! read more

This used to be my spot when it was Triton tap. I'm really glad the guys that took this spot over came in. Good guys and a really cool space. Come grab a cocktail and people watch on the patio! read more

Awesome cocktail menu! Had great music as well. My friend and I really enjoyed Thieves and will be back very soon. Can't wait for outdoor seating to open up! read more

Walked in with my wife and 10 year daughter on March 26th at 4:00 from Michigan. One foot in door and bartender rudely says "Out" Thought he was joking and he says "Out she can't come in here." Would never recommend this place. A simple explanation about patrons under 21 would have been nice. read more

Great atmosphere and the drinks were great. We went midday, it was nice to be able to sit at the bar with only one more couple in there

Went last night for St Patrick's day and it was PACKED. Ally the bartender was absolutely amazing. She makes amazing drinks and she was so fast. I can't believe she was the only person there as the place was a madhouse. I genuinely felt awful that she was so busy with absolutely no help, especially on a busy night like St Patrick's Day. I don't think I've ever seen someone make that many drinks in a short period of time. They should really hire more bartenders and also give Ally a raise! read more

Fantastic cocktails- there's a lot of different options to appeal to all kinds of tastes. Our bartender was friendly and easy to talk to. I would definitely go back again. read more

Thieves has a great atmosphere and drinks! The owner really takes pride in the bar and it shows!