Thieves Photos
Business Info
THIEVES ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
More like Thieves
Recommended Reviews - Thieves
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
After a very long and leisurely Sunday brunch at Cholita Tacos (across the street) our girl gang settled into the cozy and dare I say "seductive" lounge at Thieves. The decor left a lasting impression and is actually quite entertaining and made me want to take ALL the pictures lol. The server was very patient and professional with me and my heathens. I had my go to espresso martini and maybe more than one but hey who's counting right? Thieves is an intimate and cheeky cocktail bar perfect for date night or a night out with friends.
Thieves is a new addition to the Broad Ripple landscape taking over the old Starbucks. The ambiance in the evening is dark, comfortable, warm, cozy..great for a group of friends or a couple. For those just looking for a quick drink after work they also have a nice bar and really sweet bar tenders. The drink menu has so much character plus wine and beer. Their cocktails are fancy but also carry a very fancy price...this is definitely not a place for someone in a budget...not sure if they have a happy hour. Overall it's definitely a cool spot that has a specific clientle in mind.
Coffee was good. Liked the vibe of the place. Barista was nice but she could have used some help as it got busy but she was by herself. Will come back to try cocktails
I love stopping in here with friends for espresso martinis. I haven't been by for coffee in the morning yet, but have it on my list to do so. Cocktails are great and I love the bigger space from the original spot across the street. Service can be hit or miss, but it is a bar, so I guess that's kinda to be expected. We stopped in the other night and they were consistently busy, so we went to order another round. They said they had "already done last call," but they had 100% not announced that to everyone inside, maybe just the people sitting at the bar, and it was an hour to close. Still a great bar to visit when you're in BRipp.
Came to thieves when it was just a bar at their old location. Stopped into the new location for coffee. The vibes inside are very cool and the music is great. Came here with a friend for coffee, pastries and conversation. Got the cream pie latte and chouxnut. Latte was good and the chouxnut was okay - more so what I'd want as a dessert. Vibes are vibing Drinks are drinking
The new era of Thieves is bright! We've been going to Thieves for the past 3 years and last night was the most crowded I have seen it. It has fun seasonal drinks with complex flavors, a brighter interior, larger space, and the smell of coffee mixes nicely. I was initially hesitant hearing about their move from the dimly lit, intimate space just up the street, but wow, great move!
Such a cute spot! this cafe/cocktail lounge is a great spot to hang out with friends at anytime of the day. I had the Honey trap, it had a good level of sweetness without being too overly sweet. I do think I should have ventured out and tried something new, since its similar to other honey latte drinks. My friend had the Bloom Job and the presentation was so cute! It had a foam to with a dried edible flower. The inside is well decorated, but very interesting bathroom decor choies LOL
Thieves is always a vibe! I'm glad they opened the new space because it allows for more seating options. Service was great as always, our waitress was super attentive and we got lucky when we got there because we got a table right next to the bar so it was easy to communicate with all the bartenders. Since we were planning on just drinks, we didn't get any food but the food options do look spectacular so I do want to return for that. Honestly, this is my favorite cocktails spots in Broad Ripple so I will be returning soon!
Such a cute spot! They've moved into the old Starbucks location on BR Ave. That means more of their great decor. Many neon signs with great quotes. The bar is pretty. More seating. Drinks are good. One of the better smores latte I've had. Good service.
The gym I go to is always recommending this place so I stopped in after the Turkey Trot. It's so cool inside and they have a full bar. I got a hot chocolate and they offered to spike it. I accepted and it was absolutely delicious. I can't wait to go back at night and have drink there.
What a nice vibe in here. I stopped in to pick up materials for the Broadripple passport shopping event that happened here at the end of november 2025. The seasonal coffee drinks sounded amazing and I tried one that was a bit heavy on sweetness, but really made the shopping more enjoyable. I was impressed that this coffee shop was also a cocktail bar at night. The decor is stylish and the mood is comforting. Located on a busy corner where a starbucks used to be and across the street from there previous location. This combination of coffee and drinks should be a success! I know I will not hesitate to stop in here again.
One of my favorite places to have first date drinks. Casual vibes; lots of seating options, large drink menu. A must visit during the holiday season to try the festive beverages.
From the moment you walk in, it feels intimate, chill, and subtly inviting. The bartenders are friendly and welcoming, conversations hum throughout the space, and the red lit signs create the perfect backdrop for social worthy photos.
I went to Thieves last summer for a girls night out. It was a blast! Thieves is woman-owned, and one of if not the only cocktail lounge in the Broad Ripple area. There are silly neon signs all around the bar, perfect for a photo op! The deck probably doubles the size of the bar and is a fantastic perch for people watching, especially now that all the construction is done in the area. The drinks were dynamite, and if you get hungry you can always grab pizza or a snack from somewhere nearby! Also got great service from the bartenders! read more
I had heard of Thieves a few weeks ago and wanted to give it a shot. I happened to be in the neighborhood this past Saturday so we popped on over. The place is billed as a "speakeasy like environment." It has a decent cocktail menu. The draft beer menu leaves something to be desired, mostly macro brews. It's a small, dimly lit bar, with a few cocktail table and one long community table. There are a lot of uncovered windows which detracts from speakeasy vibe. My drink was ok. The bartender admitted she was out of luxardo cherries, but she used luxardo syrup instead. My Sazarec tasted pretty sweet, which was not great. My date did enjoy her French 75. I was mildly disappointed with Thieves. I would go back, but would not seek it out. read more
Y'all, I hadn't had a cocktail in nearly a year and if I was going to have one, I was going to do it right. Que in Theives. We came in around 930p on a Saturday night. All the tables outdoor were taken but we got some bar stools and set up inside at a window so got the outdoor vibes. I knew I wanted a champagne cocktail and both the booba and escobar caught my eye. After I told our server about my major life dilemma and that I didn't care for sweet drinks, she suggested the escobar (1800, orange liqueur, agave, champagne). That is a YES from me. It was perfection in a properly served glass with a dash of margarita vibes. We had such a great time and enjoyed the early 2000s music. I was also super surprised by the prices here. I'd expect to pay a lot more for a craft cocktail. Drinks range from $5-$10. Pro tip: I saw on their website that Sundays special is half price wine and champagne bottles. So make some plans for a bottle of rose for less than $15. You're welcome. read more
1 year ago
3 years ago
Came to Thieves on my birthday for a drink. The ambience is very comfy. Love the gothic modern feel - along with some European vibes. It wasn't full, but I think we should change that! They have outdoor seating as well and indoor seating along with the bar. The drinks were very good and well prepared- our drinks tasted very fresh. Our bartender was very sweet and made our experience a good one. Loved coming here and will definitely return! I was too shy to ask if they do anything for birthdays, but would definitely ask! We will be coming back again for drinks and to sit outdoors read more
2 years ago
A hot cocktail spot right on Broad Ripple Ave! While the space is small and cozy, it boasts a large deck great for catching up with friends or a date night. While they have AMAZING cocktails, they are also woman owned, so a double threat! The menu is expansive so even the pickiest drinker will be able to find something they'll love. From champagne to bourbon to tequila, there's something for everyone! read more
4 years ago
Love it. Friendly bartenders. Nice interesting menu ... the ambience was very cool / modern. Let me sub alcohols in an existing cocktail. Massive drink and I FELT every bit of it ... exactly what I want and don't often get out of a bar. I'll definitely be back. read more
1 year ago
4 years ago
I love a great cocktail and a place that never misses is @thievesindy ! The bartender Mac was so cool and friendly and was definitely a mixologist! We ordered a lemon drop and an Old fashioned for our first drinks. For our second drinks we had her do her thing and make us something according to what we like ! Try them out ! I like that they make all of their syrups in house and everything is Top Shelf = No headache ! read more
This is THEE spot for happy hour! My friend and I wanted to enjoy a cocktail outdoors and Thieves provided! They had themed drinks for the Barbie movie and were so yummy. The staff is always friendly and welcoming. The inside is dark and mood which is very on brand for them. A decent amount of seating inside for how quaint it is. If you've got nice weather, I strongly encourage sitting outdoors on the patio. There's so many cute photo ops to get content. The food menu is light snacks, but you're right on the BR strip so there's several options for food if you get real hungry! Can't wait to make this "our spot." read more
1 year ago
6 years ago
I've been following Thieves for a long time since they opened up, *during the pandemic* mind you. I finally was able to go check them out with the 70° weather this past weekend and enjoy some drinks on their patio! Prime location on Broad Ripple Ave WITH a patio, a concise menu of NOLA inspired drinks, and a well decorated bar... ya gotta stop by this summer. We saw some people bring food to their patio spot so we ended up grabbing some Goodfellas across the street to pair with our cocktails. read more
2 years ago
My first time trying Thieves was just OK. My partner and I arrived at 7pm on a Friday night. They blast a mix of metal and emo music pretty loud, and so people talk louder, and soon enough you're yelling across the table to have a conversation. Service was slow, only one bartender working. You have to go to the bar to order, they don't come to take your order. We realized this after waiting a long time. The space is very small. Their drinks and selection were really good though! read more
How exciting to see a new bar open in the face of bars and restaurants shutting down everywhere! Thieves is emerging a literal beacon in this dark time with its bright neon red lights that light up the dark and refined bar. The look of the bar is very sleek and intimate, yet somewhat gives the vibe of almost an adult frat party. The music and atmosphere is very hip and trendy. With a strong social media presence and even stronger drinks, Thieves is starting off on the right foot. Their social media advertises a variety of fun and unique specials that are branded to a young adult audience such as today's post of Tinder Tuesday where if you bring in a match they will pick up your third drink. These fun and quirky branding initiatives combined with their imaginative and fun cocktails make for a fun and interesting date and night out scene. read more
Great signature cocktails and chill vibe for a Saturday night. The bar is rather small so it could be challenging to accommodate a larger group but is great for smaller groups. The staff is kind and funny. Would highly recommend! read more
This spot is just what Broad Ripple needed! The vibe here is amazing and is exactly what my wife and I were looking for. The music was on point and the drinks were expertly crafted and reasonably priced. They definitely hit the mark as "a hood-boujie-spirits-lounge" with a bit of a New Orleans twist (most drinks and some decor nod to NOLA inspiration). Our server/bartender was awesome he really made us feel welcomed and even offered to take our pictures in front of the dope neon sign that features a classic hip hop line from one of the greats. My wife and I both ordered the NOLA Sazerac, which can be made with either Bourbon or Hennessy. We both agreed that the Hennessy version was our favorite but both taste great. We will definitely return and would recommend this to our friends/family. Also, Sunday Fundays are good day to go for 1/2 off almost all bottles of wine & champagne! read more
This is a new bar in broadripple. Kinda small inside so seats are limited. But if you are able to stop in please do.. the atmosphere is amazing, the music is great, overall vibe is great. They have a great bartender there that makes great drinks. I was very impressed read more
5 years ago
Nate, the marvelous bartender was so kind to make me a great cocktail! He loves making something new! Give him a direction to go and he will make you a delightful surprise! This place is small and quaint. Some seating outside. It will fill up quickly so find a spot before it fills up! read more
A hidden gem right downtown broad ripple! Visited this place for this first time this past weekend and got super lucky with great seats. As reviews have mentioned before, the place is small and with Covid, very limited seating so get there early or just hope for the best! Really neat place and the drinks are probably the most reasonably priced in the area. Their drinks are fun but simple. The mojito mule was super tasty and they don't skimp on their pours! This is a great place for a girls night out or even a date night because it has a very intimate feel. Their menu is huge and next time I go back I need to try one of their champagne cocktails because YUM! read more
6 years ago
The reviews at Thieves speak for themselves, this place is great! My friends and I first tried to go to Thieves a few weekends back, but weren't able to because they were at capacity. We even checked back at two points during the night, they were still full. Fast forward another week and we tried again. This time, they had the exact number of seats to accommodate my three person party. When you first walk into Thieves, you can tell the place is small, hence the greatly diminished capacity with Covid-19 regulations. The size of the establishment creates an intimate atmosphere that reminds you a bit of a swanky speakeasy. The only downside to the size is that you are cramped next to the other patrons which, when the other patrons are extremely noisy, hinders your own party's conversation. Looking past this downside, the drinks are fantastic! They have a full menu of Mules, Champagne Cocktails, and other Cocktails. Each of our party tried at least two drinks and not one of them was bad. I cannot wait to go back here and try more! Pro-Tip: With the diminished capacity still in play, try to get to Thieves a bit earlier in the night to get a spot! Otherwise, you could be waiting for a while to get a table which isn't ideal in the middle of winter. read more
6 years ago
Formerly Triton Tap, I am so glad someone took over this space! They did a bunch of upgrades inside to give it a fresh face lift. They just opened on Friday the 13th to the public and are a cocktail bar. They have servers that come to your seat too- so no getting up and ordering at the bar. Not sure if this is a covid thing or if they will continue with it always. Lots of cocktail options! I especially enjoyed that they use the proper types of glasses for each type of drink. There is a champagne drink section, a mule section, draught beers as well as signature cocktails. Also the prices are SO reasonable for the effort they probably have to put into the drinks, cocktails $8.50 and under. I tried the moscow mule- as good as a mule should be. Also LOVED the screwball manhattan. Screwball is a peanut butter whiskey so you need to be prepared for that. I definitely ordered more than one! NOLA sazerac - you can choose hennessy or basil Haydens. Tried with henney... 100% not my taste but my fiance enjoyed it. The absinthe comes through with a big licorice taste that is not for everyone. One last thing...the music SLAPS. I was feeling all sorts of nostalgia for my college days with some old hits from the 2000s. It was the owners playlist and was well curated for my millennial taste...I need to get a copy of it! 10/10 glad this is joining broad ripple ave and will be a place I frequent. read more
Tried Thieves for an after work cocktail and had the opportunity to enjoy the deck space. My first cocktail was the Booba... it's on the sweeter side, full of flavor, and part of the champagne cocktail menu. My second cocktail was the lemon drop. Normally I wouldn't come to this on my own, but our server gave the recommendation and it did not disappoint. It was the perfect balance between sour and sweet. I could have had multiple lemon drops and not batted an eye. Definitely am looking forward to going back and trying more cocktails! read more
This new hidden gem in the Broad Ripple area is nothing short of great vibes. I found myself having great conversation with the bartender, sipping a delicious drink and dancing in my humming a known song. Great any night spot rather solo, date or group (no more than 4 I'd advise! read more
4 years ago
2 years ago
What a fun spot for a good well-crafted cocktail! Located in the center of Bripp, this trendy bar is perfect for photo spots and happy hour. The staff was super friendly and they have an awesome deck. It felt very New Orleans voodoo. The drinks were not overpriced and they were delish!!! I wouldn't spend my whole night here, but I'll definitely stop by anytime I'm in the area. read more
5 years ago
This is a really cool spot right off of Broad Ripple Ave right next to the Sushi Bar and across the street from Brothers. This place was dark (walls black) and had red fluorescent signs on multiple walls, making for a very mysterious or intimate atmosphere. It was a pretty small- only a few smaller tables with one longer table that can accommodate multiple parties. The bartender was very attentive and came up to us very shortly after we sat down and got situated. I loved how they had an entire section of the menu dedicated to mules. I just ordered my go-to Moscow Mule and it was delicious. We only stayed for one drink because we had dinner reservations, but this is definitely some place that I would go back to. I would probably just try to avoid high-volume times as this place is very small and has 1 men & 1 women restroom. read more
4 years ago
3 years ago
4 years ago
Was having a good time until a possum came out and came under our table. Nothing was done about it. It kept running around the patio. Gross ASF!! No accommodations from the restaurant read more
4 years ago
Cool little cocktail bar on the strip. Good cocktails with legit mixers, good tunes, friendly staff. read more
5 years ago
Such a cool spot in broad ripple! The staff is so friendly (we had Noah as our bartender/server and he did everything to make sure we were enjoying our drinks) and the drinks are delicious (I got a French 75 martini, one of their champagne drinks)! Will 100% be back here again read more
2 years ago
5 years ago
