Theresa's Cafe

Great Deli to have Breakfast in. Curtis and his staff are very nice and they make sure you are…read morecomfortable eating there food is great I recommend Lisa's Deli

Always amazing! The breakfast sandwiches and lunch sandwiches are all top notch. Must try!read more

Sloppy Joe

See all

Menu board. They also have a breakfast menu and daily specials.

Two Bros Ravioli

4.2(19 reviews)

0.7 mi

The food was incredible and plentiful, best subs in Flemington. i wish they didn't close so early…read more Staff was pleasant and helpful. Andy

Fantastic subs on delicious bread. I am enjoying the Big Joe, which is a fried eggplant sub , my…read morehusband really enjoyed Jimbos Italian and the Bernie. The subs are huge and they are well worth it. You have to try this place at least once you will definitely be going back. Enjoy!

Inside

Prosciutto & capicola - 1/2 pound of each

See all

Menu of Deliciousness

Flemington Deli

4.5(31 reviews)

2.0 mi

Probably once of the best cold subs i've ever had everything taste fresh and looks great! and…read morecustomer service was great!!

If I could give 10 stars I would!…read more I had Flemington Deli cater lunch for us, as my colleagues and I were doing volunteer work at America's Grow-A-Row. The owner, Tim delivered the lunch himself (I'm only sorry that we were still in the fields, so I did not get the chance to meet this wonderful gentleman). Everyone was raving about the sandwiches and the variety. They were absolutely delicious, including the bread. Oh, and the chocolate chip cookies were out of this world. Everyone on the team, a total of 44 people could not say enough about how delicious everything was. Thank you to Tim and the team who put together this delicious lunch, which was a welcomed treat for all of us who had just finished three hours of harvesting spaghetti squash!! I will tell everyone I know about how delicious your food is and your generosity. Kathy Nawojczyk

The meatless Cuban... only 11 dollars Ripoff

See all

Outside seating

Campania Pizza and Deli

4.7(29 reviews)

2.5 mi

Family-owned & operated

Takes reservations

Great customer service, delicious pizza, the restaurant is so clean and cozy and everyone is so…read morewelcoming (:

Stopped in for a couple slices, a couple of times recently, and I don't know what happened to this…read moreplace. I used to think their pizza was above average, but not anymore. The pizza slices were disappointing. They lacked sauce and cheese. Not good. Are they cutting back trying to save some $$? Sadly I'll be going somewhere else for my pizza. I hope they see this and go back to what it used to be or better.

See all

Two Brother's

4.7(6 reviews)

0.7 mi

The food here is amazing. However.... It's like going to the Soup Nazi. Don't expect anyone to be…read morefriendly or even slightly nice. Every time I go there, everyone working is irritable and a Lille rude.

This place really pissed me off! There Lasagna is better than mine and is going to force me to buy…read morethere's before even thinking about making my own. I am also hurt that I have been driving past this place for years and never knew. (Where is the flashing neon sign, Eat here first then go shopping.) There is no eating on premises, Good thing too! I might look for a room out back so I did not have to go so far to buy more. Keep up the great work you two!

Mel's Bagels & Deli

3.8(69 reviews)

1.6 mi

Place hasn't changed & it still slaps. Good work. Local atmosphere you can sit for a few minutes…read moreand eat if you'd like or take it to go. Good beverage selection - great bagels.

If you're expecting a real Italian hot dog, this isn't it! I ordered one from Mel's in Flemington…read moreand got a hot dog on a regular bun, not pizza bread. The hot dog was deep fried, but it was cut up and split, with barely any peppers and onions. There may have been a tablespoon total between the two halves. The potatoes were soggy, not crisp or hearty like you'd expect, and the whole thing felt skimpy for $8.15. Maybe some people won't mind it, but if you know what a proper NJ Italian hot dog is supposed to be, this was a letdown!

Inside counter.

Taylor Ham (Pork Roll), Egg and Cheese on an everything bagel [Salt, Pepper, Ketchup]

See all

Bacon egg & cheese on egg bagel

TJ's Deli & Grill

3.8(5 reviews)

1.0 mi

Love their sandwiches here. Great local place to grab something quick. I love their bacon egg and…read morecheese on a roll.

It's the best shop ever the food there is the best deli food I have ever tasted the main worker…read moreOscar is really good cook

See all

Jersey Mike's Subs

3.3(58 reviews)

0.5 mi

Love the subs here. My favorites are club sub and club…read moresupreme. Since I can't have deli meat for now, I've been ordering the veggie sub but I make it mikes way, remove swiss, keep provolone, add pickles and mayo, remove salt with a note to add extra mayo and vinegar. It comes out amazing. People behind the counter are also very nice. 5/5

I love, love,love these subs! And the best thing is that you earn points easily and quickly for…read morefree subs! I recently got my whole order free, I only paid the tip to the driver as I had it delivered on a day with free delivery! It's the closest thing to a NY sub you can get! The bread is what makes the subs the greatest! Try it you'll love it too!

See all

ShopRite of Flemington

3.3(61 reviews)

0.6 mi

love love love shoprite. the sushi here is always delicious and fresh. i grab it for lunch a few…read moretimes a month, cheaper than other places and way better ! the cheese area of this shoprite is awesome as well and i love the bakery items.

What a crime in the cold cuts dept . Went Wednesday only 2 people working . I just stopped for…read more lunch meat . Waited 15 minutes to get waited on an another minutes to get it Also since some genius rearranged the store I'm savings money. Snack isle location is great location. I do not have any reason to walk that isle. The genius even rearranged the frozen food section Cakes now aside of breakfast foods . Probably done by a genius college grad who never had to grocery shop for a family... New lover of stop n shop

Things to do in Flemington

Fat from beef.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

6 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Joseph S.

14 years ago

The owner Theresa is a real bitch. I would not go here. It's kind of a dump. Dirty, staff not that attentive, and when you add the fact that Theresa hates the world on top of that, it's just not a fun place. I would go somewhere else if I were you. Viva Mexico is right next door and they have great food, are friendly and nice. read more

Anthony R.

9 years ago

My wife and I went there for breakfast, we LOVED it. In fact we went back for lunch, great grill chicken sandwich. I would say if you are in this area, you must check this place. read more

Phil E.

9 years ago

This place was great. Ordered each of the three breakfast specials, and our group was impressed with every one of them

Joseph H.

12 years ago

Great people with great food. Quality and substance is key to what this restaurant offers. Never disappointed.

GoodoleEats G.

5 years ago

Excellent place. Changed ownership. Nice cool hidden spot in Flemington. Get my usual breakfast.

Linda L.

12 years ago

Friendly service, homemade soups and wonderful panini specials. Sweet little local eatery.

Theresa's Cafe - delis - Updated October 2026

Best of Flemington

People found Theresa's Cafe by searching for…

People who viewed Theresa's Cafe also viewed

JS Shaker Cafe

3.3

(60 reviews)

Wow! This is definitely a great place to have a quick bite! I got the Full JS Platter and boy was…read moreit good! The service was amazing, she came to our table with a smile on her face and a wonderful personality! The cafe was warm and cozy with nice music. It felt as if you were back home, in a cozy cabin! Definitely coming back to the JS Shaker Cafe!!

JS Shaker Cafe, located right by the Hunterdon County municipal complex, has that classic,…read moreold-school diner vibe that works well if you want a quick, reasonably priced meal. However, my recent Sunday visit was a vaguely "meh" experience due to some disappointing service. We found out the hard way -- only after being seated, handed menus, and perusing our options -- that they strictly observe their "Breakfast Only" rule on Sundays. I was really craving a sandwich (having already eaten eggs earlier in the day), but when I asked for an accommodation, I got a blunt "No, we can't do that. We only serve breakfast on Sunday." I mentioned I was lactose-intolerant and almost all of the breakfast options (omelets, breakfast burger, etc.) were made with milk or cheese, but our server said the kitchen doesn't like making substitutions. This felt especially draconian considering there was only one other party seated in the restaurant at the time. To make matters worse, once I settled on a two-egg breakfast platter, the server informed me they were out of my first two meat preferences. My dining companion's omelete was served without key ingredients she added (and we were probably charged for). Our server never dropped off a check, so I walked up to the counter to pay after finishing our meal. Our server seemed genuinely surprised when I handed her enough cash to cover what she said our total was.. plus a ~20% tip (which I paid in spite of the service issues because I'm not a barbarian). The food itself was alright once it arrived, but the service just felt disjointed and "off" the entire time. It's a decent enough spot for the basics, but between the total lack of flexibility and the service hiccups, I'll say 2.5 stars rounded down to 2 stars and definitely won't try again next time I'm in Flemington. PRO TIP: They don't offer complimentary tap water with your meal, but they are happy to sell you a 16 oz plastic bottle of Poland Spring.

Flemington coffee shop

4.3

(7 reviews)

Delicious EGGS! The freshest I've ever had. Superb…read moreBreakfast Celebration with my daughter for Mother's Day. Cute, cozy seating. Clean as can be. Attentive, friendly, skilled staff. 5-Star. Spinal Tap 11. A must-stop on 202; Strip Mall/watch for can't miss Staples' sign.

Was very surprised to see how big this place was. From the outside, it looks like it could be a…read moresmall bagel / coffee shop. However, when we went inside, it had a little old school diner vibe, which I enjoyed. Server was friendly and attentive. Checked in with us time to time and filled coffee as needed. There were many options for food - breakfast and lunch/dinner! We both got the breakfast/brunch type - poached eggs with hollandaise sauce and poached eggs with sausage gravy. Also got coffee and cappuccino. Food wasn't the best ever but still tasty and good portions. Would return.

Market Roost Catering, Restaurant & Bakery

3.9

(72 reviews)

Rainy day desert. Irish breakfast tea and pistachio roll …read more The owner is so friendly and I'm happy to hear about some of the special things that she baked today. I took home some walnut cookies and a rhubarb pastry and it was wonderful. I look forward to coming back!!

The quality of the food at the Market Roost is superb. Poached eggs in Eggs Benedict were cooked…read moreperfectly. Baked goods are freshly made in-house. Don't miss this Flemington gem!

Whitehouse General Store

4.3

(35 reviews)

My wife and I stopped into Whitehouse General Store for a casual lunch after running a few errands…read morein the area. It has that old-school general store feel when you walk in. Small, cozy, and not trying to be something it's not. There are a few tables if you want to eat there, but it definitely feels like more of a grab-and-go spot. I ordered a half cheesesteak sandwich with peppers and onions while my wife chose a half cheesesteak without. The sandwich was a good size. You have to be very hungry to finish a half. My wife was only able to get through half of her sandwich. Since we were bringing the sandwiches home, we chose not to get any drinks or sides. Prices are reasonable for what you get. Service was friendly and efficient. You order at the counter and they call you when it's ready. No long wait, even with a few people ahead of us. If you're looking for a quick, solid lunch in Whitehouse Station without the chain restaurant feel, this is a good option. We'll definitely be back when we want something simple and well made.

Love this local breakfast place. It's really affordable and has a lot of options and ability to…read morecustomize. The chocolate chip pancakes, omelette and potatoes are phenomenal! The egg sandwich was a bit dry so wouldn't get that again. But love this place and everyone is so kind and attentive! A great local place

Flemington Deli

4.5

(31 reviews)

Probably once of the best cold subs i've ever had everything taste fresh and looks great! and…read morecustomer service was great!!

Lebanon Plaza Deli

4.7

(17 reviews)

I decided to try this deli which was a little further away for me I live on the border of…read moreBranchburg and Whitehouse. I am so glad I did. It was delicious. I got two sandwiches that were daily specials because I couldn't decide. I had one for lunch and one for dinner. They were so fresh and delicious. I will definitely be going back.

We just moved into town and this deli was very highly recommended. So we decided to visit for…read morelunch since we are still moving in. We ordered the Reuben special sandwich prepared on rye bread. Delicious and we washed it down with a freshly brewed coffee . The 2 ladies were very friendly and the service was exceptional. A traditional deli look and feel.

Sabrina's Coffee Deli

4.3

(12 reviews)

This was a small spot next to a gas station with a few tables inside. The menu had mostly deli…read moreofferings as well as breakfast dishes. The prices were very reasonable. Ordering was done at the counter and the food was ready in a timely manner. I ordered a turkey club, an Italian hot dog, and a chicken Caesar wrap. Both sandwiches came with a salad and pickles. One came with macaroni salad while the other one with potato. The potato salad was definitely the better of the two. I really enjoyed how small the potato pieces were. The turkey club was okay. I needed to add some type of condiment as it was a little dry. The Italian hot dog was excellent. It was a good quality hot dog with plenty of filing in between the long roll. My favorite was definitely the wrap. The chicken was seasoned and cooked nicely while there was a nice crunch from the lettuce. There was a perfect amount of Caesar dressing where it was not too much or little. Overall, I really enjoyed this little place. Will I go back? Definitely.

OVERPRICED AND CHARGE FEES- Im not one to leave a bad review but their prices have gotten crazy…read more Started going when the first opened. Many of us would since it is close and convenient to our office. Chicken ceaser wrap $8.80! Deal. Then it went to $10 ok. Now its $13. Today I went to grab a ham and cheese on a roll. Nothing special - its ham. $14+Seriously? I asked the nice girl at the counter if the price was right and she said "yea. Its on a roll"..what does that even mean?? Then they charge a 3.95% service fee AND SPIN THE MONITOR AROUND FOR A TIP. You're a small place in Flagtown. Your food is good but your prices are ridiculous. I'll take a ride down the road to another small business - Just Subs - and get a bigger sandwich without the fees for $8.15

31 South Grill & Deli

4.7

(28 reviews)

Just stopped in 1st time had the all American burger and fries…read more ** fries were so crispy yum! And the burger amazingly excellent cooked to perfection! A must go!! ** the owner Mike what a nice man!

Mike (owner/chef) is THE best! He makes everyone feel like they are special and welcome there, he…read moreis quick to greet in a fun manner and get right to your order, which is always great! Good people are drawn to come back here and Mike's regular customers are easy to hang with and have good conversations with. I would give more stars to this review if allowed. Thanks Mike- we need 31 South and you!

Golden Star Diner

4.0

(107 reviews)

We stopped there at 7:00 p.m. on a Saturday on the way home from New York. I had ordered stuffed…read morepeppers and my partner ordered a chicken souvlaki wrap. The service was good but the food was mediocre at best. The stuffed peppers were overcooked and soft and tasteless. The chicken wrap was a bit better but didn't have much flavor either. The french fries that came with the wrap were quite good as was the apple pie for dessert. The broccoli that came with the peppers was overcooked. My recommendation for anyone who cares to try this restaurant is to keep it simple. Hamburgers, maybe a sandwich, but I would avoid anything that requires real cooking.

On a road trip to an out of state wedding and randomly pulled into the parking lot here…read more The menu is extensive and I love that at 10am you can order breakfast, lunch, or dinner. Service was excellent. Old school diner servers with personality and the ability to have fun with their customers. Being Polish it was a surprise to find potato pancakes, kielbasa, and pierogi on the menu. We shared the potato pancake platter and the 2 eggs platter. Added side of scrapple. Where do I start? The potato pancakes were moist, sweet and full of fresh herbs. Definitely better than I ever made. You can choose sour cream or applesauce. I ordered the eggs over medium and they were cooked perfectly. The only thing is that they come with hash browns and toast. The only substitution for the hash browns was French fries. No fruit or vegetables. The reason we shared was because the egg and potato pancake platter with meat was only offered with bacon or sausage. I wanted scrapple. No complaints on any of the food at the table. It was a random stop but I definitely recommend if you're in the area.

The Bridge Cafe

3.5

(109 reviews)