I'm not a milkshake person but I love the taste of these milkshakes! You can taste the difference in the quality of ingredients. I love this place and I don't understand the negative reviews surrounding their prices. I don't mind paying $5-6 for a quality homemade cookie. This place is awesome and the staff is kind too. read more

See all

The Yummy Cookie was the perfect choice for our wedding dessert. We have always loved their cookies, so we knew we wanted to include them on our wedding day, and they did not disappoint. The cookies were absolutely delicious, and our guests loved them. We had several people ask where they could get the cookies, and our wedding planner even told us she had never seen that much enthusiasm for a dessert bar before. That says everything! The Yummy Cookie helped make our wedding feel even more special, and we are so glad we chose them. Highly recommend! read more

Very small parking spaces. And next to the in and out so it gets crowded very easily. $9.74 for a chip cookie and a brownie/cookie, quite pricey. Interior is very small. Overall I wasn't impressed with the cookies. The chip cookie was quite flavorless and didn't really make it worth the price or the drive or the mess with the tiny parking lot. Was quite disappointed. Employee was very friendly and helpful. read more

We ate lunch at the Mexican restaurant next door and so glad we went inside cuz no regret! The Yummy Cookie is sure is yummy!! Love the service, Juliet is amazing!! She's so friendly and accommodating. The place smells so good. We got the marshmallow brownie and it was sooo good!! We also had the cookie sundae, and we devoured the entire thing. We highly recommend this place!!! read more

See all

The cookies here are very fresh out the oven, the best cookie I've ever had, The chocolate chip is the best one and the next is the fudge chocolate it's not overly sweet read more

The Yummy Cookie is a hidden gem of a bake shop and my favorite in the Greater Sacramento area! My partner recommended it, and I couldn't be happier that we stopped by for a six pack of cookies. When we walked in, I was immediately impressed by the smells wafting from this shop. We came on a weeknight evening and were warmly greeted. Customer service was very friendly and accommodating. The woman behind the counter went above and beyond to locate a double chocolate cheesecake cookie for us! The cookies came out fresh, warm, and soft. You can tell that they're made with love, and our favorites were the cheesecake cookie, brookie, and fruit topper. read more

The Yummy Cookie - Six pack of cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Roseville, California

Came here for three cookies but the friendly staffer convinced me to get the 6-for-5 deal and I don't regret it. All cookies were soft, flavorful and more importantly not overwhelmingly sugar sweet (I'm gagging at you crumblah!) Pecan Caramel Topper was hands down the unanimous hit in our household. Not to imply the other ones aren't as amazing but the PCT was phenomenal. I also fell in lust with the chocolate cheesecake. Ingredients are sourced local to Northern California with special attention to pasture raised eggs and dairy. Support small family owned cookie shops and forget about the chains! read more

See all

We paid $5 a cookie and our cookies were raw throughout the middle. Even the edges were raw. Not the yummy sweet cookie dough batter raw but like raw cake batter. Could not get past the first bite. Highly disappointing!! Will never buy again. read more

Good cookies and brownies. The staff always has good recommendations and it's always delicious. The store front is small and has a few seats, but they have outside seating so that makes up for the lack of seating inside. read more

The cookies here were amazing! They're carefully and thoughtfully packaged. Each cookie is bursting with flavor, buttery, gooey, soft, and melts in your mouth. We tried chocolate chip, double chocolate, peanut butter, snickerdoodle, and several more. read more

The Yummy Cookie - Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Roseville, California

My customers tried the cookies and really enjoyed them. I thought the chocolate chip was good. I will try more flavors.

Really great selection of cookies. The cookies had great flavor and baked perfectly. A little pricey but quality is worth it.

I truly do not understand how this place is still open. $9 for a brownie that is the size of a small cookie?? I'm shocked! I was expecting at least a thick brownie slice at the minimum but it was a thin small cookie. The price just baffles me considering what you get. If it was $3 then I'd be happy. But 9???? I'm shocked and so disappointed! Will not be ordering from here again unless they dramatically reduce their prices or up the size of their items read more

We got the cookie brownie with marshmallow on top. It was good, no complaints about taste. It's just hard to justify paying 6 dollars for a cookie. I know its inflation and cost of rent that probably raises the price for this bakery. read more

We had never seen this place before, so my daughter and I stopped by. The selection is vast, and they even have vegan options. Caitlin (not sure on spelling, sorry!) helped us and let us know the specials. We couldn't decide, so we opted for a cup of mini cookies. It was at this point I noticed they do milkshakes... but you can have them blend ANY of their cookies into it. Insert drooling sounds here. I went with a vanilla shake with a cookie that was half chocolate and half chocolate chip blended in. My daughter went with vanilla with a chocolate chip cookie blended in. The cookies are huge too. Both shakes were fantastic. If you've got a sweet tooth and love cookies, brownies, or shakes, definitely check them out. read more

See all

Love the chocolate chip and white chocolate macadamia nut cookie. Way better than crumbl!

We have tried this cookie place a few times and are frequently disappointed. The brownie cookie tastes like poor quality cocoa and the sugar cookie has an odd diluted milk taste. Compared to crumbl, the flavors just aren't as bold and sweet. The staff is always friendly though! read more

We tried the cookies 3x. Didn't like them. Just not good. Especially if you compare them to the cookies at insomnia. read more

Great presentation, unfortunately no taste. I almost feel like they don't add sugar .

Terrible customer service. We ordered cookies for an event where day late on picking up. They threw them out according to them........? and we still paid for them with no refund or willingness to help us out. In fact we found them on display so they planned to resell them and double dip. Not a honest place to do business with. read more

The yummy cookie walked so crumble could run. If you're looking for the best cookie spot in the Sacramento area, then look no more! With a wide variety of rotating flavors, this is the spot to go! They also have a buy 5 get 1 free deal which is amazing! read more

The Yummy Cookie - Christmas came early - Bakeries Near Me - Roseville, California

Lack flavor. Expensive for what they offer. I wouldn't recommend. Also in a busy shopping center

Me and my friends came in and the smell was amazing. service 10/10. the milkshakes is the go to order!

My mother ordered cookies for the holidays and she was never notified that the owner will throw them out the next day and keep your money and will not provide something in exchange or notify you that this is her practice. This woman should not own a business! Such a bummer I really love to support small businesses in Roseville! read more

Save Your Money--This Cookie Shop is a Total Rip-Off! I have a serious sweet tooth and was excited to try this place, especially since I'm not a fan of the usual chain spots like Crumbl. Big mistake. If you're considering trying it, read this first. The cookies? Just all right. My wife was harsh--she thought they were downright horrible for the price. I got a few regular cookies, and honestly, they looked like something a toddler might bake, not a legitimate cookie shop. They weren't even round--more like little cookie mountains, as if someone just carelessly slapped a glob of dough on a tray and tossed it in the oven. I really wish I'd read the other reviews before wasting my time. So many people had mentioned being disappointed with both the price and the cookies--and now I see why. I dropped over $25 on just 4 cookies, and the quality didn't even come close to justifying the cost. I felt completely ripped off. If you need any more proof that these cookies aren't worth it, my kid--who devours anything sweet--didn't even finish hers. That speaks volumes. Definitely stay away and save your money and time. I really wanted to like this place, but the price-to-quality ratio is way off. I won't be back unless they make some serious changes. read more

This is a very cute little cookie shop with lots of options. They have vegan, paleo, and even chipless cookies. Along with cookies, they also provide milkshake where you can choose the ice cream flavor and a cookie to blend with it. The worker here was super friendly and helpful. When I came in, they had just finished baking more cookies so I was able to snag a fresh crinkle cookie. It had a crisp outer shell, soft center, and a good amount of powdered sugar on the outside. I would definitely come back to try some of their other cookies. read more

See all

1st time visit here, my daughter was a craving an ice cream sandwich and I ended up getting the buy 5 and get one free! We didn't realize the ice cream sandwich would be so HUGE! No wonder it's $12 lol . I do prefer the flavor of this cookie batter over the popular Cookie Crumble that many rave about. The gourmet cookies have good flavor and not overbearingly sweet. I would visit this cute little cookie shop again. read more

The Yummy Cookie - Crinkle Cookie, White chocolate macadamia, Almond Crumble, Chocolate Chip Cookie, Snickerdoodle Cookie, and Marshmallow Stuffed Cookie! - Bakeries Near Me - Roseville, California

See all

Friend and I went here the other day because we were craving cookies. Went in for one, and ended up getting 6 because they looked SUPER good. Ended up throwing all 6 away after one bite because they have absolutely NO flavor to them. It's almost like they forgot to add sugar or vanilla or something, because it literally just tasted like dough. My friend and I even googled the place because we thought maybe we stumbled upon a "healthier" cookie place where they serve healthy cookies. Sadly no, they just bake cookies with no flavor. Was really disappointed because they really do look delicious and wasted $30 . Overpriced for bland cookies in my opinion. I'm very surprised at all the nice reviews saying they taste "AMAZING". Makes me wonder if these people have never actually had a REALLY good cookie to know the difference or if I caught the shop on a wrong day. There are way better places that serve cookies with actual flavor at a WAY more affordable price! read more

The Yummy Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Roseville, California

They have the best cookies around! They have a deal right now by 5 get the 6th free. Total was $30. My favorite so far has been the marshmallow Carmel chocolate chip and my husband's favorite is the brownie cookie with walnuts and chocolate chips. I also like the lemon curd. You can't go wrong they all taste good. read more

See all

Super good cookies!! The texture and bite is soft with a slight crunch and the creativity with the flavors is really cool! Can't just pick one when you go, they all visually look so good to try. Sweet tooth satisfied! read more

The Yummy Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Roseville, California

See all

Located near In N Out Cute little spot No indoor seating Very few outdoor seating Visit: Sunday, Monday, Friday in August 2023 around mid-late evening Each visit, inside was empty but a few customers always came by after They bag the cookies and one time they boxed the cookies Cookies Ordered: -Chocolate Chip (regular) A lot of chocolate chips in each bite, soft, taste good, decent size -Vegan Chocolate Chip Chocolate chips in every bite, soft, tasted delish & better than regular however little smaller in size, fave cookie so far - Vegan Brownie Crinkle Soft, tasted great, chocolatey, good amount of powder, good size -Paleo Chip Kind of hard, lacking flavor, least fave Service: -Staff is polite read more

See all

I wanted to love these but was so underwhelmed! I tried the chocolate chip, peanut butter, shortbread, white chocolate macadamia and snickerdoodle - and they were all very mid. Could use more chips and overall flavor. Hopefully this is helpful feedback!! read more

Omg cookies! I felt like a cookie monster coming here. My bf decided to break out of keto to enjoy these with me and said it was so worth it! These were as good as many places we went to in ny aka cookie city. Our most favorite was the cheesecake cookie. Super moist and I loved the caramel chocolate chip. Even though it didn't have enough caramel it was still amazing. Frosted cookies were delicious , super sweet but that's to be expected. The coffee cake cookie was also good but our least favorite just because all of the others were so amazing. Service was also really nice, I think whoever gave them negative ratings definitely need extra sugar in their lives haha. If I'm ever In roseville again i will definitely be back! read more

The Yummy Cookie - Cookies! - Bakeries Near Me - Roseville, California

See all

Fresh and so soft! Great customer service. I make my own cookie dough all the time for friends and family, but some days you just don't feel like baking... this is a great place for a sweet tooth! read more

The Yummy Cookie - 10/10 - Snikerdoodle, everything but the chip, cookie brownie. - Bakeries Near Me - Roseville, California

Big thanks to the reviews that mentioned these cookies aren't overly sweet--you've won over a new customer! This is exactly what I've been searching for: QUALITY cookies. I've seen some comments calling these cookies "tasteless," but those people are clearly used to overly sweet, processed treats like Crumbl, which are loaded with artificial ingredients and way too much sugar. These cookies are a true standout, made with real, high-quality ingredients and packed with genuine flavor. As a parent, I'm always cautious about what my kids eat, and I'd gladly pay more for a cookie made with thoughtful, high-quality ingredients over cheap, junk-filled treats from places like Crumbl or even the processed stuff you'd find at Winco. My three boys could enjoy up to half a cookie without that sugar rush or headache that usually comes with other cookies. If you care about real ingredients and flavor, this bakery is a gem. Totally worth it! read more

I am a baker myself, but love to try other places to see what creations they come up with. I have to say me and my family love the sugar cookie, its absolutely the best one!!! I highly recommend it. The atmosphere is great and when we go the service is fast. read more

Tried this place for the first time tonight. Came in around closing time and the girl working was so sweet. She was closing up and still so helpful and nice. The cookies were very good as well. read more

I'm a foodie! Please believe me when I say this is the BEST cookie place! I've have tried many different kinds of cookies, this is the BEST so far. read more

If you Reese's like I do, than I would absolutely recommend "The Yummy Cookie's" Peanut Butter and Chocolate Chip Cookies They are absolutely amazing I am also leaving this review in honor of Katelyn who took it upon herself to have my favorite cookie's baked while I go to a Doctor's appointment because I live in North Auburn, and only get to have these when I visit Roseville. Thank you Katelyn for your remarkable customer service, and I hope to see you soon. read more

Zero stars! Cookies have no flavor and the way they treat their employees is even worse! This place is trash!