This is the only place I will buy ice cream from in the area because the ice cream is great, they…read morehave a HUGE variety of flavors and you can bring a blanket and sit on the lawn if there's isn't a place to sit (there are umbrellas at the outdoor tables and a sheltered place to sit off to the side). This place is always so busy in the summer time and rightly so, who doesn't love ice cream on a hot day! The wait is never really that long even when it looks long, the staff keep things moving quite well. They're always so patient, friendly and polite, thank you guys for continuously doing a great job, you are appreciated!!! Sometimes I want butter pecan or a maple walnut sugar cone. Sometimes I need vanilla soft serve with chocolate sprinkles in a cup and sometimes I want lemon ice. My family enjoys their chocolate parfaits, banana splits and milkshakes but I'm telling you, you cannot go wrong. Also located in the immediate area are a putt-putt and golf range. In the fall, they sell pumpkins near the range. But listen, go get some ice cream! This is a nice little spot for a date/family night ride for a treat, enjoy!

I ordered two milkshakes; one chocolate and one Oreo chocolate. Both were delicious. The only…read moresuggestion I have is to give out sturdier straws that can handle the thick ice cream. The service was professional and friendly. I can appreciate this level of service. It was raining the day I went so the ambiance was a bit off but totally the weathers fault. Definitely going back for more delicious ice cream!

This was our second time ordering from Pam's. The Keylime pie is the best you will find in Western…read moreNew York. The homemade whipped cream is amazing too. We also tried their banana pudding which was fantastic and the cowboy cookie as well. Customer Service was also amazing! Next we will try the peanut butter pie.

Pam's desserts are so creative and absolutely delicious! Cookies, cupcakes, pies, and bread…read morepuddings, oh my! I loved her desserts when they were served at Kentucky Greg's on George Urban, and visited her location at Eastern Hills Mall every time I was out that way. Her new location on Transit Road (near Broadway), is welcoming and filled with cute and creative desserts. There was even a hot chocolate station with topping bar, and I had a sample of the hot chocolate and it was absolutely delicious! This time, I got two slices of bread pudding and a browned butter chocolate chip cookie for my birthday, thanks Pam! I can't wait to stop in again soon.

Great people, great custard, but the food to price ratio is becoming hard to justify. We first…read morevisited in 2022 and had a great experience...although the prices already felt a little high for a stand type of place. This recent experience with the food was a little less great and the prices are obviously going to be even higher nowadays. I ordered the same thing I got last time because I really enjoyed it...the fish sandwich. Matt opted for a Sahlen's Italian sausage with onions and peppers. No fries or drink for either of us, but we did get a pint of the Perry's peanut butter swirl in vanilla because we haven't seen it at the grocery store. The fish sandwich was kind of sad looking. It comes plain now, but they'll add tartar sauce for you if you ask. I added cheese, too. It tasted pretty good, no complaints really, but the quality to price ratio is off...it's $10.79 if you opt for cheese. It's just not worth that to me. Matt liked his Italian sausage, although the link was quite short. And of course the ice cream is delicious! The customer service was really great, too. The ladies there were very friendly and helpful. Our total for two items and a pint came to $29.71. Looking at it all together when I took the photo, I just don't feel like it's a good value. Overall, maybe we'll go once a year or so for some Perry's...but I think we'll skip the food. It's definitely not bad, it's just not good for the price. If that doesn't bother you, I recommend you try them out! It's just not for me.

Extremely rude owner. I was frequenting multiple times per week but won't be going here again.read more

Fast, friendly service and exciting flavors to choose from. They have a few tables inside as well…read moreas an outdoor seating area. It was tough to choose which kind of ice cream I wanted to try (because, really, I wanted them all), but I managed to settle on three of their specialty flavors: grandma's banana cream pie, carrot cake and marshmallow peep. They were all very good, but I enjoyed the banana cream pie the best with real pieces of banana in it and no fake, runt-like, banana flavoring. My dad hit the brownie mudslide and chocolate peanut butter. He said the chocolate peanut butter was really good and the best one he's ever had.

Cute inside, cozy. I used to go there all the time when I was a kid but now I can't have icecream…read morewithout it coming back up unfortunately. delicious here. great spot so you could walk around. service was always good when I went.

As always, my most recent visit to Oh Sugar was fantastic! The owner and staff were friendly, quick…read moreand helpful. They have something for everyone from a wide selection of hard scoop & soft serve flavors to rolled ice cream and prepackaged novelties to sundaes and milkshakes. At Oh Sugar, you get a really good value for your money! There is also seating available inside as well as an outdoor area with a small fish pond and sidewalk chalk.

I learned this place had rolled ice cream, so I felt obligated to go!! The rolled ice cream is one…read moresize only (giant!) for $9 and comes with one add-in and optional whipped cream. It costs extra to include more add-ins. I ordered cookie dough with whipped cream! I watched the staff make it, which was fascinating and when I asked, she told me she had a dehumidifier button that makes it easier to get the ice cream off the freezing mechanism when rolling. The rolled ice cream was good! I am taking off one star for the fact that the cashier talked my mom into getting their house-made waffle cone (which she spoke really highly of) and the waffle cone tasted like nothing. Great serving of ice cream, I'd just skip the waffle cone.

There are not enough stars possible for the amazing cookie dough cinnamon roll I had here!!!…read more I've been on a huge cinnamon roll kick lately, and I've been trying any ones that use real vanilla icing (ain't nobody got time for that cream cheese icing monstrosity, lol) that I can get my hand on. This amazing place is located at the end of a large strip center that also houses an Aldi and Mighty Taco. The all glass windows and doors give it plenty of light and very open feel - something that we haven't seen much in this area with the beautiful intricate architecture (to us Floridians anyway, lol). The first day we went it was fairly empty and they were nearing closing time. Despite this, the lady who helped us was friendly and informative. She explained they make regular cinnamon rolls and pastries but also have a specialty roll of the week, which was cookie dough this week. They were out of almost everything except some of the day old rolls - which included a cookie dough one. Where we live, specialty cinnamon rolls are filled with the typical cinnamon and just topped with specialty stuff, so I assumed I would get the cookie dough one and try both their cookie crumbles and their traditional cinnamon roll in one. Boy was I wrong. Having bought far too many desserts in the last few days of this visit, I put the cookie dough roll to the side a few days, but when I tried it - OMG!! The center of the roll is COOKIE DOUGH AND NOT CINNAMON. When I tell you this is one of the best desserts and food inventions I have ever seen, I MEAN IT!! Nevermind the crookie or cookie dough croissant craze, these people have created heaven in a dessert. Needless to say, I had to go back again today for another, as they close on Mondays and change their flavors on Tuesdays. A different person was there, but she was just as helpful. And they had just one last cookie dough roll, which of course I had to get. If you ever get the absolutely divine timing that I did and find yourself in the Hamburg, Buffalo, or Amherst (I know of these locations specifically, there may be others too), and they are running the cookie dough rolls, you HAVE TO try them!

It's been a while since I grabbed a treat from Kaylena Marie's. I'm glad to say they're as…read moredelicious today as they were the last time I stopped in, even after the various changes they've had! On a Saturday, around 11:45am, I arrived at the Hamburg bakery, the newest location of the small franchise. There was plenty of parking in the HUGE parking lot as the bakery is next to an ALDI. I walked into a large space with plenty of tables and a bar along the window with stools, reminiscent of Orchard Park's seating setup - It felt warm and inviting, plenty spacious, very easy to converse with others. It was great seeing quite a few tables filled with people sipping on coffee, pastries, sandwiches, etc.! They do have a pretty large menu of breakfast items and sandwiches along with plenty of drinks, which are listed on their menu located at the counter. Walking toward their case of goodies, I was a little surprised at the limited selection, albeit they were definitely the more popular treats. The gentleman who took my order was very friendly, fun to talk to as I placed my order. All in all, a great ordering experience and a spot I wouldn't mind sitting down and having breakfast in. So what did I order? Fall 2025, Kaylena Marie's re-introduced their "Specialty Rolls" with the big change being the size being "mini" compared to their normal cinnamon roll, which is HUGE. I'll be honest, I was a concerned the "mini" would be a tad too small, but, after ordering two, I say they are perfectly sized. For the week of 11/03/2025-11/09/2025, the Hamburg bakery's "Specialty Mini Roll" flavor was cookies and cream, dubbed the "Mini Oreo Roll", which is Kaylena Marie's roll swirled with crushed Oreo cookies, chocolate, and creamy filling then topped with more Oreo cookies and glaze. I ordered two, one for Saturday and one for Sunday. :) When the "Specialty Rolls" were giant (i.e. Kaylena's 'normal' size), this was my favorite flavor, so I was really happy when the first forkful brought me right back! The roll was as soft as I remember and the creamy inside with chocolate and Oreo cookie swirled in was excellent. The "mini" size was perfect, albeit I did have a little ice cream with it. :) But truth be told, the "mini" is the proper size for these specialty flavors. Also, stick it in the microwave for 20-25 seconds, thank me later! As for the price, in 2025, this was nicely priced, certainly not as pricey as I expected, which was another treat. Kaylena Marie's of Hamburg is an inviting bakery/café! The staff working are courteous and friendly and the treats are on-brand with the original idea of Kaylena Marie's. I will certainly be back for another batch of "Specialty Mini-Rolls" or perhaps a 'Normal' (aka GIANT) cinnamon roll for old time's sake. haha

This place is the place the neighborhood needs. It's a great addition to hertel. The space is fun…read more And bright. And hip. The recipes are original. The problem? They've moved to digital ordering. So you don't get to talk to the person behind the counter. Now it feels more like McDonald's. Definitely not the inviting neighborhood place it used to be.

I don't want to give a bad review because the ice cream tastes great and I love the idea of this…read moreplace and will definitely be back to try something else. My husband got a cookie monster and loved it too btw. But I got The Samoan... Let me preface this critique by saying that I love coconut, real shredded coconut; toasted coconut; coconut chunks, anything coconut flavored; German chocolate cake is my favorite, etc. Churn was out of vegan coconut soft serve this night too which was sad so I had vanilla. I don't think that would have mattered though because the problem with The Samoan is the texture you get when you mix both toasted coconut and cacao nibs into ice cream. At first the texture was kind of an interesting experience and also kind of funny and then it became less and less amusing as I ate more of it. If you like eating literal mulch that tastes quite lovely get the Samoan. If not try something else.

We checked this truck out at a food truck rally in Olcott. They have a variety of cheesecakes with…read morewhimsical names, unique flavors and toppings. Today I tried the wolverine, a cheesecake with swirls of loganberry, and topped with raspberries, blackberries, and loganberry syrup. It was very good. Their cheesecake isn't as good as mine, but mine is absolutely amazing (just saying) and theirs is still pretty good. Plus there's many other flavors I still want to try so I'll be cyber stalking them for sure. The prices are a bit high, ranging from $6-8, but it's worth splurging on occasionally.

The menu is ridiculous, who knew there were so many amazing flavors to choose from?! If you see the…read moreCheesecake Guy, you HAVE to grab a slice cor a whole cake to bring home!