We drove around tried to find this restaurant and we finally asked a local person. He said the restaurant closed down a while ago.

absolutely adore sirens song for a fun night out:-) it's a real bummer the current location is coming to a close as it's a real magnificent spot for folks to get together and enjoy local bands do their thanggg! they also have a great bar with lovely attentive bartenders I'd like to add. I always love supporting this place when I'm in town. read more

Fun night out! This place is an eccentric, eclectic mix of locals, musicians, and colorful artists. We had a blast when we went there!

Old school punk/rock bar in downtown Eureka. Went on a Sunday afternoon and it was quiet. The barkeep asked if I was a veteran (I am) so they knocked off a couple of bucks from my tab. I liked the ambience and the beer. Sunday is board games until the live band comes in. read more

Great low-key hangout spot. Has a pool table. Bartender is an old hand (this is the best kind).

I really enjoyed my first visit to Siren's Song! While the tavern is small and intimate, I still felt like I had space to maneuver without feeling cramped. Bar seating is fairly limited, but there are a few tables on the floor as well as some couch/lounge areas. There is a somewhat classy, somewhat rustic industrial vibe to this place that with it's red drape curtains and bar set-up, makes one feel like they might actually be on board a pirate ship. I attended a special event here, and there was so much going on - live music, presenters, an artist painting in the middle of all the commotion. The liveliness of it all made me feel like I was at a bar in a much larger city like Portland or San Francisco. I was served fairly quickly at the bar, and my drink was great (an alcoholic ginger beer). I'd definitely come back as I'm curious to see what the ambiance is like when there isn't a special event going on. From what I've experienced, however, Siren's Song is a fun spot! read more

The Siren's Song Tavern - Ginger beer (available with alcohol and without alcohol) - Bars Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

Loved listening to jazzy blues music. It's a little hole in the wall hidden in the back alley right in the heart of Eureka. I'll definitely be back. read more

One of the funnest clubs in town! The bartender is super cool, Not over priced and extremely welcoming! Gigs there are an amazing good time, lots of comradarie between guests here. Fun times. read more

My wife and I enjoyed the vibe it had. We're from out of town visiting some family here. Marco was super chill and pretty friendly from point of view. We mentioned being from Indy and he gave us some suggestions on what to do here in this small town. He was very attentive and even gave us a live performance! Will definitely come back when visiting. read more

I had the best time of my adult life with my very good friends Tim and Marissa one night at the Tavern, we saw this crazy old town New Orleans band that night, we saw Albanie Falettra, just right before the pandemic on Sept. 11, 2019. I loved this place and that evening - the designer of the pub made it look like a sunken ship inside - you have to go in to experience it! It is off the hook - a must see place! read more

The Siren's Song Tavern - Sept. 11, 2019 at the Siren's Tavern, Eureka - Bars Near Me - Eureka, California

Unbelievable service! They support our service members and that's all a fella like me could ask for. The staff are extremely friendly and chill. Very accommodating. Loved the ambiance. I'd definitely go back for some brewskies read more

Love it!! Great music, friendly, chill vibe l. I really got taken in to the music. Welcoming to all ages. I think it's important to expose my kids to live music and this was a safe place to enjoy myself while my youngsters get to see what it's all about with live bands read more

A cool local beer pub/tavern located in old town. We happened in here one late afternoon after spending the day running errands around town. Siren's Song was just the ticket. Lots of choices to drink and a comfortable adult environment. This bar has a very knowledgeable staff, and the owner is often on hand during business hours. We sat at the bar and I had a couple cold brews while the wife found a glass of wine that she thoroughly enjoyed. This tavern has a really nice selection of both bottle and tap beers available from a wide variety of locales. Some interesting often obscure bottle beers can be had here, and they even have a nitro tap set-up. The afternoon of our visit I had an amazing nitro porter that was full bodied, rich and thick a great porter brew. From the signage all around this pub and on the windows and front door - they have a great variety of live music or live entertainment most nights as well. Worth a visit and one of the best import selections of bottle and taps around. a Solid 4 stars and definitely worth a stop. 00290 read more

The Siren's Song Tavern - Shot in the Dark, nitro Porter... - Bars Near Me - Eureka, California

For the super friendly guy that whisked us in to seat us when everyone else in the neighborhood was giving us a one hour wait at the least and not for nothing the menu here is sparse but there's music playing : D really relaxing atmosphere! We are content! Glad we found this unstuffy gem!! Down to earth!! The focaccia bread is soft and flavorful- the sandwich is hitting the spot and the salads are delicious too. read more

The Siren's Song Tavern - Outdoor seating with music - Bars Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

Hallelujah - Humboldt finally has a great craft beer bar and bottle shop! PLUS, ciders (of the alcoholic variety), espresso, and good food (from what I hear). It's a nice departure from the (great) breweries that have dominated this region thus far. I am getting computer work done here at 7:30 on a Saturday evening (blah), and their latte is good, wifi fast, and atmosphere cozy and friendly. Everyone else is understandably drinking beer, and their selection is excellent - several varieties on tap and more bottles than I've seen in this neck of the woods before. I'd definitely recommend coming in for a visit - it's a sweet little place. Tall ceilings, exposed brick, couches, a nice bar, and plenty of decent sized tables. I'm hoping to get done early enough to enjoy an adult beverage ... I'd definitely meet folks here for drinks in the future. Hopefully locals embrace it as the opportunity it is! read more

The Siren's Song Tavern - Comfortable, cozy, plenty of light... - Bars Near Me - Eureka, California

It's a good little bar. Great selection of beers. Nothing fancy here. The cheese plate seems locally sourced but basic. Live music! I am glad I came upon this bar!! read more

The Siren's Song Tavern - Imperial stout - Bars Near Me - Eureka, California

Hello Siren's Song Any live music Tues 7/20 or Wed 7/21 or Thurs 7/22 ? Looking for classic rock or country read more

As far as local beer bars go, this is an excellent example of it being done right! The place is very committed to being an integral part of the community, and they make a solid effort to provide entertainment and services that everyone can appreciate. They only serve beer, cider, and wine, but they have a nice selection of each. The taps swap out rather frequently, so there's always something new to sample and enjoy. Small plates are available, check the chalk board for availability. Open layout space. Up front by the windows is the stage (to your right when you walk in the front door). Bathroom is by code only. Couple high tops on the side wall. read more

Don't be fooled by the high reviews on this page, they're all old reviews from when they previous owner owned it. This used to be one of the best bars in Eurkeka with a wide selection of great drinks and always a good chill vibe. Great music and events were happening all the time, you can catch some live music still but seems like paranormal mic nights by the so called comedian working there is the main event. The current guy and gal running it always make sure you feel unwelcome the moment you step up to the bar, whether its giving attitude over you wanting to pay with a card or asking for the code to the restroom which is for the whole public building it's in. You must hand over cash before you get the code. They offer snacks and food but are often "too busy" to make (they offer ramen packets and the bar can be dead when asking). They also don't pay attention to who was waiting first, I've seen people waiting for long periods of time while some person who just walked in gets helped first. Spend your money and time at any other bar in Old Town. read more

First off the decor is AMAZING! I go to a lot of Savage Henry's comedy shows and this is my favorite venue. It's so comfortable and clean. The artwork is FANTASTIC! They support local art and usually have some pretty amazing pieces up for sale. The owners seriously have an eye for detail because even their plants are super cool(they're carnivorous!) Also, for a bar, this place smells sooo much better then other bars. Might be that they only serve beer and cider but still! The surfaces are never sticky. They also serve cool soups and espresso drinks. They also have the fanciest beers and ciders. I see something new every time I come in, so if you're into trying new things in a really nice atmosphere, this is your destination! read more

My favorite place in Eureka by far. The local breweries of Humboldt do produce great quality trademark beers, but they become monotonous quickly as EVERYWHERE carries the same basic spread with little to no outside variation. Siren's Song brings fresh, obscure, and amplified taste to the connoisseurs with tuned palates craving stimulation that is much needed in this area, as well as always having something for everyone no matter what the stage of brew drinker. My mom, for instance, hates beer and yet manages to consistently enjoy a drink here, whereas I have been spoiled by dramatic habañero IPAs and extremely hard to find ales from Dogfish Head and Stone. Then there's my dad, who's a mid-level porter and stout lover who never ceases to embrace something off of their prolific draft and bottle list. Aside from how electric their selection of beverages is, this place offers a wonderful and unique environment in which to enjoy them. In the theme of a ship going down, in a building that watched the entire century take its first steps back in the late 1800s, with wonderfully vivid employees, it's a great place to step in and disconnect from repetition. Even if it's a routine part of your day, it's always refreshing. Also a venue for many live talents. As I work most nights they have music, I haven't been able to clock out timely enough to run down the road and enjoy as much as I'd like. But you can see anything from spoken word to local hip hop, twangy guitars to livid bands. The place as a whole is incredibly versatile. And you can get bottles to go :) So happy about Siren's Song b read more

Nothing but positive experiences! Great beer list, fancy soda selection & great espresso. Accessible all ages venue. Beautiful place. Everyone is consistently kind here. The owners have made it very easy for me to plan local events here. I recommend this place for gathering with coworkers often. read more

My husband and I went looking for some live music while staying in Eureka, and at first came to a bar (not this spot) that was PACKED with people ordering shots and a unremarkable, loud cover band. We looked at each other and knew at once that wasn't our scene. A quick Yelp search found us here... And it was MUCH more our speed. They had a great local band with a banjo, mandoline, and a stand up bass. The craft beer and cider list is incredible. Tons of taps plus a special bottle fridge. I said to my husband "I could spend the rest of my life drinking in this place". Great ambience, and helpful, attentive barkeeps. Two thumbs way up. We will absolutely be back next time we're in town. read more

Great selection of craft brew and cider. Lots of good shows. Drinks can be a little on the pricey side but worth it for the selection and atmosphere. read more

We totally took a chance in Eureka to go out to Old Town on a weeknight! I thought that surely everything would be closed. Much to my surprise, there were a few places open for hanging out and having a drink. I ended up at the Siren's Song Tavern for Poetry Night. It was amazing--so inspiring and fun, full of locals with lots to express! The ambiance was perfect, chill and uplifting--full of genuinely nice people. My only complaint would be that they only serve beer and cider for drinks. I had water and took in all the poetry. It was great! read more

They were killin' it in 2013 when I first reviewed them, and they are still killin' it today--still have the rare beers and other refreshing libations, but now they've added great food to the mix like tamales...and those are delicious! And because of that, and several other reasons like they're live music and events, I had to move my rating from 4 to 5 stars...thanks for all the tasty treats and all the good times, Siren's Song! read more

It's a good place to try new drinks, but the selection can be hit-and-miss. Two things I really liked: the banana bread beer and the selection of lambics. I ended up with one really strange "smoked porter" that smelled and tasted like ashes from a campfire. Another time, a wheat beer that tasted like nothing. So, if I were going to go try new things, I'd probably look them up on a review site first. The acoustics could stand to be improved. During a live show, the three-piece band with small speakers dominated the cavernous room and made conversation difficult at the far end. The decor is lovely, the staff are helpful, and the regulars seem really nice. I will probably continue to go back, but not as a regular thing. read more

Great strawberry cider on tap! Cool interior. They host goth night occasionally and that's pretty fitting for the spooky interior.

Great atmosphere! Loved the eclectic crowd too! Wish they had cocktails but the beer and cider selection was great.

The atmosphere is this place is amazing. Its comes off authentically trendy as opposed to cheesy and trying to hard. I love sitting in the dark corners drinking moderately priced and unique selection of beer and wine selections. The staff are hipsters at best and definitely not bartenders or any sort of aficionados. Also, they don't have ice and serve their white wine at room temperature, who does that? read more

Took the kids on a bike ride on the new homeless highway , down to the eureka summer concerts. Well children being children of course they had to go to the bathroom. Stopped in at the sirens song, they let the kiddies use he restroom which was separate from the bar itself. They had good music the kind that makes you want to dance. Had a brew. Regular but they serve the live stuff you can drink. I had a blonde ale something or other and it was good. read more

Disappointingly dead. St Paddy's day 5pm and no atmosphere or engagement. This place has invested too heavily on the appearance and forgot about substance. While this is a quiet town the staff were nice but there was no real energy going on. Food menu is limited also but good and fresh. Nice beers available also but with a little more effort this could be a fab venue. read more

I love that they have live music here often. The decor is amazing and they have a great selection of drinks. The room setup is cramped and the tables take up a lot of space. If you go with a a big group, 5 of more people, you're going to find this place very difficult to socialize. read more

I'd rate them much higher, if you could get some service. The building is beautifully decorated, rich colors while still being comfortably dark and bar like. Plenty of tables and seats. They do have a great selection of beers and ciders. If you don't like what's on tap check the bottle selection. There're a few gems. All this is assuming you get the chance to order. Lower your expectations considerably if the vacant-eyed woman is working. She'll wander by aimlessly, ignoring your attempts to get her attention, then be startled by your presence a few minutes later. Or just be on her phone with her back to you despite the fact that you're one of the only patrons in the bar. I'd want to like the Siren's Song, but since they seem like they can hardly be bothered to serve people, I can hardly be bothered to go. read more

Came here lat year around Christmas time and forgot to review it, probably because I got thoroughly canoodled after a few glasses of here. Fantastic selection; it was the only time I've ever seen Old Rasputin barrel aged on tap. Awesome ambiance in a historic building! read more

Love going here. Always have good beer choices and good prices. The bar tenders are always nice and patient for those who take a while to decide what they want. I admire the décor every time I visit. Can't get enough of the skewed hanging lights and the crooked wallpaper. Look for the varnish on the floor near the doorway. It looks like water is coming into the bar due to the sinking ship! Great place! I am very thankful they are here in Eureka! read more

Sweet people and great coffee! Love the selections, lots of local and organic options. Fun decor

Sexy bar, they onyl have beer/wine, and the drinks are a little overpriced. But Ithink you go to Siren's song tavern for the ambiance, their specialty them parties, and to pick up some tail. Dark wood, red drapings, it's an intimate and mood-lighting kindava bar, almost vampiric! read more

Delicious revolving door of beers and some top notch ciders. The environment is both comfortable and out of this time leaning towards the early Victorian era. Great place to see music as well. read more

Incredible disrespectful to the neighbors playing music past 1:30, there's no reason your business shouldn't have sound boards in your building. read more