The Sandwich Spot truly stands out as one of the best places to eat in Valhalla. What makes it special is the consistent commitment to freshness, bold flavor, and genuinely high-quality ingredients that you can taste in every bite. The Moo-ffah is a must-try and easily one of the most memorable sandwiches on the menu. It's the kind of signature item that keeps you coming back again and again. If you're looking for a reliable spot that delivers great food every single time, The Sandwich Spot is an easy recommendation. read more

Last Sunday, I ordered the Aristocrat breakfast sandwich online after deciding to give this place another try. I had enjoyed their sandwiches in the past, especially the One Upper, so I was looking forward to it. Unfortunately, about two and a half hours after eating the sandwich, I became sick and vomited multiple times. The Aristocrat breakfast sandwich was the only thing I had eaten that day, and I believe it was what made me sick. The following day, I was dealing with significant stomach pain from vomiting so much. My mom called the restaurant and spoke with Marisa, who apologized and offered me a free sandwich. While I appreciated the apology, a free sandwich didn't make up for how sick I became. During the conversation, Marisa suggested that the issue may have been unrelated to the food. Given that the sandwich was the only thing I had eaten that day and I don't have any known food allergies, I felt my concerns were not fully addressed. It's disappointing because I expected the same quality I remembered, but this experience was the complete opposite. It will be a while before I feel comfortable returning. read more

The Sandwich Spot - Sandwiches Near Me - Valhalla, New York

Been meaning to come here for a while. Have nothing been good things. And good things abound. The Sandwich Spot is not a big spot. Very limited seating at a counter top. But vibes are pure sandwich shop. Lots of bottled drink options, plenty of Deep River chips too. A little coffee bar setup. I had the Cubano and a bite of the Grilled Chicken Supreme. Both excellent sandwiches. The entire menu looks fantastic. The service was nice. Fairly prompt too. I'd suggesting calling in orders ahead if time is tight, but if you're early, you're not waiting long at all. Enjoyed the visit- and will be back. read more

See all

Been here a few times, but it had been awhile and I honestly forgot how crazy their sandwich selection is. So many different options and everything sounds good. Finally made my way back and it definitely lived up to the memory. The sandwiches are packed, flavorful, and actually worth the hype. One of those spots where it's hard to decide what to order because the menu has so many good choices. Definitely a solid sandwich spot to keep in rotation. read more

The Sandwich Spot - Honey Bird - Sandwiches Near Me - Valhalla, New York

Meh. Just meh. My GF was craving a chicken parm sandwich so we decided to try someplace new. This place looked great from afar but fell really short. The chicken parm was on focaccia which was dry and spongy and the chicken was super thin but kind of chewy. Probably nuked it. It wasn't terrible but it didn't make you want it again. I had a Cubano which was even more disappointing, a Cuban is supposed to be pressed and it wasn't. The pork was very bland and the ham was 2 slices smushed into the corner. Whoever made this sandwich clearly doesn't have a passion for what they do. I wouldn't go back. There are better sandwiches in the area. read more

The Sandwich Spot - My "Cuban" and my tiny bit of ham smushed into one side. - Sandwiches Near Me - Valhalla, New York

See all

My colleagues and I have ordered from here for lunch a few times. There is tough competition with A&S in Mt. Kisco and Rocky's in Milwood, some of our other ordering spots, but TSS has remained in the rotation. I do wish they had some more vegetarian options. There are a few, the most memorable one is the one I ordered, something with eggplant. This sandwich was insanity. It was like a work of art. It basically contained a garden worth of eggplant. I'm surprised I was able to fit it in my mouth. It was very tasty and sufficed for a meal and a half tbh. My favorite thing about this place, though, is their fries. Possibly the best fries I've had from a place. They provide a ridiculously massive portion and they are incredible. We can't ever finish them in one sitting but they crisp up so nicely in the air fryer. They are exceptional. It will remain in the rotation for the time being. read more

The Sandwich Spot - eggplant - Sandwiches Near Me - Valhalla, New York

Was in town for work and decided to try them out for lunch. Was a group of four and all 4 of us were super happy with what we ordered. Staff was very friendly and helpful with the menu. They were pretty busy with a lunch crowd so we did have a little bit of a wait to get the order but it was well worth it and next time I'm in town I'm going back. read more

I'm completely spoiled by the BEC on brioche here! And sandwiches are inventive and tasty!

The Sandwich Spot is a name that insists upon itself. The word THE means that this should be THE spot within a 30 min radius. What does THE Linguini B think about this? I'd like to shout from the highest roof in White Plains. Make a speaker announcement at Rye Beach. Address the crowd at the Croton Dam. Do it Loud and do it proud, this is THE Sandwich Spot. When you open your mouth to spew nonsense, when you want to talk about the great sandwiches of the great four five and the nine one four, this HAS to be in the conversation. I see all these bots on the gram showing themselves to be scams. This spot should be the hot top but never gets the Bada Bing Bada bop. And that's gotta stop, which is why I finally decided it was time to take my talents to da Yelposphere to make the message clear. In Westchester in particular, this is the sandwich king. No doubt, giving them full clout. From breakfast through lunch you'll get the crunch you crave. I've tried over a dozen of these delicate designs and each is better than the last. The monthly specials are so gargantuanly good that you wish each would be full-timers. But then they'd be less special. Similar to why Linguini B can't post everyday. I know you miss me, but baby I kinda want you to miss me. Anyways, bread is baked daily and you know it to be true when you bite into these, boo. Never really get full on sog, they just soak up the succulence of the interior ingredient. The cutlets are thinnn and the breading is real real real good. Reminds me of Nonna's cutlets these things are unbeatable. Idk how they do it outta this small shack, but they can make that duck quack. Porchetta - pleasurable, plentiful and picky licking good. Have had special cheesesteaks that make the earth quake, the one upper... one upping your spot. Marisa's Way? Anyday (sup Marisa *wink* *he's so charming* *wish he'd wink at me*). The long hot, the focaccia based sandwiches. The brekkkky boyzzz, underrated but MUST. Would prefer these to a BEC on a bagel anyday of the never ending week. Life is long, learn to love it. I still think the star of a studded cast is the chicken fig burrata. But I'd never admit it and pretend you never saw me say it. Ya never choose a favorite child. Get a dessert too, all yum. Oh man I'm getting H talking about this all. IF WE TALKING BODDDDIES, YOU GOT THE PERFECT ONE.... SO PUT IT ON MEEEEEE! I'm gonna move on and pretend that I meant that lash out. That I didn't just lose control and that I never let it go... Well. Now ya know. This is it, this is my sandy spot. Not gate keeping, but instead leaping... with you loves into shared appreciation for greatness. Witness Greatness. Witness Me. Witness 160 Legion Dr. If you can catch me, and that's a tough task within itself, Valhalla atcha boiiii. LB laying back, loving life, banging baddies which is shorthand for these sandiessss. read more

See all

overall food was delicious, personally could have used more sauce, other than that, very happy with my meal and plan on ordering both sandwiches again marisa's waybuffalo chicken cutlet, pepper jack, lettuce, tomato, buttermilk ranch delicious, swapped the lettuce for onion to help it out for left overs in case i didn't finish. loved the bread and homemade ranch dressing, could have used a little more dressing. the long hot chicken cutlet, burrata, arugula, long hots, sun-dried peppers, basil pesto, garlic aioli, pressed was really good, found myself adding a little mayo at home. caesar saladromaine lettuce, homemade croutons, mozz, grated parm, creamy caesar dressingadded chicken cutlet i did not try but my wife enjoyed. she felt the mozzarella was unnecessary read more

See all

This is definitely one of the best sandwich shops north of NYC. The sandwich had me moaning with every bite and as you sit on the stool you realize you wish you had enough stomach space to devour 4 more of their specialties. Everything just blends well with their bread leaving you satisfied and happy to continue the day. I am definitely going back this week for the steak sandwich read more

See all

The best sandwich I've had in years. Super sweet employees, clean cute place, great drink selection, the best deli salads you can find, and cute outdoor seating. 5 stars. read more

They outdone themselves at the Parenting Conference. I wasn't able to attend but heard rave review and wonderful feedback about the food and service that was presented by The Sandwich Shop. The attendees were grateful for their support and would highly recommend them for any future events. Outstanding Food & Service! read more

Outstanding sandwich shop ! Scones are good too! Call ahead to just pick up and go.

I am profoundly grateful for the delicious sandwiches you provided. A special thank you also goes to Nicosia Bakery and Musco Foods for their assistance in creating such wonderful food. On behalf of Ronald McDonald House and Maria Fareri Children's Hospital, thank you sincerely. My daughter, who was diagnosed with AML leukemia in March and continues to fight for her life, enjoyed the chicken parmigiana and happily shared it with the nurses--an act that reflects her natural desire to please others. It offered her a chance to do something kind for those supporting her on her journey. I believe the other families also had the opportunity to enjoy your expertly prepared food. As a former restaurant owner and a parent witnessing her own daughter's battle, I understand the importance of kindness and support during such critical times. Your generosity and thoughtfulness mean the world. With gratitude, The Pesello Family read more

The sandwich shop sponsored The shared parenting event this past Sunday. The pasta was great especially the pesto pasta. My daughter enjoyed the chicken cutlet sandwich and the steak and cheese was supreme. Can't wait to go there to order my own. Thank you guys again read more

I recently had the joy of eating multiple sandwiches from the Spot! The food was fresh, well put together and delicious! They catered a parenting conference I attended can't wait to check out their store location! Yum! read more

Everything from delivery to freshness to delicious was well received. Special care went into each order of preparation. I've ordered several times to make sure everything was consistent. AND each time it was. I will order from this place again and again. read more

The sandwiches and pasta were amazing. The Standard Sandwich went so fast and the Moo-Ffah was equally as good and went fast. The pastas were all amazing with the penne vodka and pesto penne bing the favorites. Plenty of food for all! Highly recommended for your next function! read more

I had the pleasure of attending an event this past weekend that The Sandwich Spot provided food for and the sandwiches were top tier! Bread was soft and delicious. I selected The Standard and I must tell you I will be going to The Sandwich Spot to have it again. If you are looking for a GOOD sandwich this is the place to go! read more

So good. Fast service, reasonable prices, and super fresh ingredients. If you're looking for a GOOD Italian deli to get your sandwiches, this is it! I'll be a regular here. read more

The Sandwich Spot - The Standard - Sandwiches Near Me - Valhalla, New York

This place was fire, and I got the angry chicken, which was also fire (spicy). Very attentive staff, quaint little spot that is pumping out flavorful sandwiches. I'll be back! read more

One of the best sandwiches in a while! I got the Cuban and the porchetta was amazing! Makes such a difference. I got the "half" & could only eat half of that! Going for the chicken fig next! read more

Definitely not a deli or a deli sandwich. I ordered a simple roast beef, mozzarella with a little mayo on a roll. I was the only person there other than another guy waiting for his order. Wait time was longer than expected. The roll was a brioche bun, something you might use for a hamburger. A sandwich spot should know the difference between a roll and a hamburger bun. read more

The Sandwich Spot - Roast beef, pre-sliced mozzarella with mayo on a roll (hamburger bun) - Sandwiches Near Me - Valhalla, New York

See all

Shared two of the best sandwiches I've had in a long time at this quaint standalone sandwich shop in Valhalla. They are open 6 days a week Monday through Saturday and it took a day off for me to finally get there to eat. One of this week's special is the -The Chicken Vodka Breaded chicken cutlets, smoked mozzarella, bacon and lots of home made vodka sauce on a toasty piece of ciabatta. The cook toasted the bread under a salamander which gave the bread a nice crunch and melted the cheese well. The sandwich looked mouth-watering and tasty as good as it looked. It was so hearty I took half home. I believe most of their specialty sandwiches are served on either ciabatta or focaccia. You can order 1/2 or a whole sandwich, either portion is a hearty sandwich. My husband ordered a signature special (regular menu),. They made a very robust Cheesesteak, sautéed peppers & onions on garlic bread, thin-sliced house beef and melted cheddar. It was filled with an ample amount of beef. He exclaimed it was one of the best beef sandwiches he's ever eaten. With both have 1/2 sandwich left which we can enjoy for dinner. The establishment offers onsite parking in front and on the side of their shop. Outdoors are a few tables and chairs as well as a picnic table on the side. We opted to eat inside on the stools with a table bar by the window. The staff is super friendly and welcoming. Aside from their regular menu they have specials listed on a black board outside before you enter as well as updating their weekly online menu which highlight their specials. We will be back. read more

The Sandwich Spot - Sauteed peppers & onions on garlic bread, thin-sliced house beef, melted cheddar on ciabatta - Sandwiches Near Me - Valhalla, New York

See all

This sandwich was amazing! I love the burrato on a blt with balsamic vinegar! Definitely the best sandwich I have ever had. read more

The Sandwich Spot - Burrata BLT - Sandwiches Near Me - Valhalla, New York

I don't find myself in Valhalla a lot, but I do have a buddy who lives there. When I asked him where I should eat, The Sandwich Spot was his immediate recommendation. Also, it was Yelp's first recommendation. Turns out both of them know what they're talking about (I knew this already), as this is a good sandwich shop. So far, I've only had the porchetta (roasted in house) and a chicken cutlet bacon thing, but both were bangin', and the care they take in putting them together, and the quality of the bread and the ingredients leads me to believe that those things would extend to everything they make. The shop itself isn't much, mostly just a counter, but the guys were friendly, and I don't care about ambiance if the sandwiches are all this good. read more

Prelude: if you're looking for thoughtless sandwiches with american cheese, this ain't it. However, if you have that hankering for a sandwich hooked up with Italian meats and Italian cheeses, then, you've come to the right place. This little, reddish house-looking Valhalla Sandwich Spot on Legion Dr, is its own stand-alone spot I've seen driving to and from on Rt100 while taking these back roads. But they've also popped on Yelp- so when I noticed their Vegetarian sandwich online, that was enough for me to venture. Since hubs worked at the office the day I stopped in, coming here early afternoon during my summer break, was perfect. Considering my husband is the carnivore, grabbing one of these meaty sandwiches next time around, will be right up his alley. Their biggest ticket here are their sandwiches of course- so I'm sure whichever option you go for, order with confidence- you'll be in good hands. There's a Daily Menu featuring Signature Sandwiches, Salads, Soup(s), etc. Their weekly specials switch up regularly (I think) but their sandwiches always remain. There are other things too like Nutella EVERYTHING: Nutella shakes, they have Nutella Empanadas- which I ordered and were scrumptious, Nutella croissant (sounds heavenly) and other Nutella treats. My 'Meatless Sub' with roasted veggies+Burrata spread+balsamic glaze on slightly toasted ciabatta, was genius. The only thing my sandwich needed were thinner veggies. Other than that, my 'Meatless Sub' tasted phenomenal and felt like a warm embrace. The ciabatta itself has the perfect balance between soft and chewy, and crisp and flaky. Service was great from the young lady to the guys in the front. Gracias! The Sandwich Spot created something wonderful in these neck of the woods between two pieces of bread- not to mention, they've been featured in the prestigious Westchester Magazine. Hubs will have a field day with their Italian meat selections- but I'm a fan for their creative spin on non-meat items also. read more

See all

It's a small little spot right off Grasslands Road down the hill from WCC. Before entering I was greeted by the owner, Sam. He was very cool and truly believes in what he is doing. I really like it when owners get involved. The inside is small but decorated very nicely. The sandwich wasn't too big and wasn't too small. I got the cheesesteak and it was one of the best I have had in a long time. I'm not sure if they make their own bread but it was extremely fresh. The steak was juicy and the red and yellow bell peppers added the perfect amount of sweetness. I am eager to try their other sandwiches. I love supporting local businesses that are passionate about what they do and make great food. This place is a little pricey but it is too notch quality. I definitely recommend the sandwich spot. read more

The Sandwich Spot - The Cheese Steak - Sandwiches Near Me - Valhalla, New York

See all

First timer and quite possibly the best eggplant parm wedge I've ever had. Sauce was absolutely perfect and staff were lovely. Can't wait to take my kids here. read more

Awesomely big sands. Really good food. Good location. Big menu. Hit them up twice since moving back. read more

The Sandwich Spot - cutlet parm - Sandwiches Near Me - Valhalla, New York

This place is a little out of the way for me but totally worth it. It's a cute take out spot that's brightly lit. All the breads and sandwiches look enticing. I went with the full size porchetta sandwich and an order of hash browns (comes with 2). I had the hash brown immediately but I found it to be oily and soft. I like them crispy. I ate the sandwich about 40 min after but the meat was tender and the jus kept the sandwich juicy. Half was enough for lunch. I will definitely be back for this sandwich and to try others! read more

The Sandwich Spot - Porchetta sandwich- full size - Sandwiches Near Me - Valhalla, New York

We stopped by today for lunch after being recommended from a friend. This place does not disappoint. The shop is small with some outside seating on the front and side of the building. The service was friendly. The sandwiches were phenomenal. Hubby got a custom today beef sandwich and he really enjoyed it. I got the Cubano and it was very good. While it's not a traditional Cubano (it's on ciabatta bread and not pressed), it was delicious. The pork and ham were both most and extremely flavorful with just the right amount of mustard, pickles and cheese all warm and melted perfectly. Now that we live in Valhalla, this week be a go-to place. read more

Yes! All of the other posts that say this place is killin it -- 100% true! I got the cubano, totally delicious & balanced. Portions are huge. I got the whole sandwich thinking I would eat half that day and half the next cause I had to drive for several hours. I wish I had it cut in quarters. I have only gone this once, but the small parking area was packed. I was lucky to not be in a super hurry, but that was at almost 3pm, so maybe best to call in ahead. The staff is SO nice! Idk how they juggle so many customers(?) actually I think there was a help wanted sign in the window! Noticed that they have a catering menu -- to me, that would be a massive hit for any office event, ur employees would never leave the company!!! Unfortunately I don't live in the area, was doing a follow up w my orthopedic surgeon at WMC. Can't wait for my next appointment!!! read more

I've been coming here pretty much every month for the past year and it's always so good but this last time was really bad. I ordered the ragin' Cajun, truffle fries, and my bf ordered the cheesesteak. My ragin' cajun looked nothing like the online photo. It was mostly lettuce and had so much sauce it was overwhelming/soggy. My bf couldn't get the garlic aioli on his cheesesteak because he's allergic to eggs so it was very dry. The fries were the worst part. I've ordered just the truffle fries plenty of times because they are my favorite in the area usually but these were nothing like what we usually get. They weren't cooked fully and quite soggy. This all comes after I called to order several times last week and couldn't get any answer. I know they can do better but very very disappointed lately. read more

See all

A shout out to my favorite local spot... The Sandwich spot!!! Love this place been a frequent flyer for years, the cutlets are always on point. Today I want to give an extra shout out the "The Hogfather" because I have a special spot in the cockles of my heart for this sandwich. Love this food line this spot cannot praise it enough. Mangia!!! read more

Amazing! Such a great spot! I was craving a sandwich and had been wanting to try this place for awhile. It opened several months ago. They have a variety of sandwiches, drinks and specials. I stopped by for their tuna melt after they posted a picture of it online. I knew I needed to try it. The employees were friendly and helpful. They made my sandwich (and tuna) fresh, so I only had to wait a few minutes. It as incredible! I definitely will stop back in to try more of their options. I'm glad this place is here! read more

See all

First time there! They have a great selection of sandwiches. Ordered the Porchetta whole wedge, as well as a tuna on a roll with lettuce and tomato. The gentleman behind the counter was very friendly and nice. He recommended that I get the long hot peppers to go on it. He said it makes it! I agreed and took home the two sandwiches. The Porchetta was amazing. Extremely tender meat and delicious garlicky flavor. The peppers packed a punch along with the sharp provolone, it was perfect! The tuna salad was extremely fresh on the brioche roll. Another Wonderful sandwich. I can't wait to try the others on their menu. They have a lot of amazing looking sandwiches. read more

See all

Grilled chicken salad was yummy! Worth the purchase always friendly service too! Nice place to order lunch! read more

The Sandwich Spot - Grilled chicken salad Ha ate half of sale before I took pic;) Yes it was good and yes all fresh ingredients ! - Sandwiches Near Me - Valhalla, New York

The food here is delicious! Get the Moofahh special. So delicious! They don't skimp on the meat and flavorful. Staff is polite and the service is quick. I noticed a lot of people order ahead. Very busy! read more