Fantastic pizza and sandwiches. We had the pepperoni pizza and "The Jimmy Conway"sandwich. read more

The Sandwich Mafia - Wall art upstairs - Italian Near Me - Estes Park, Colorado

According to Google, The Sandwich Mafia is open until midnight on Fridays and Saturdays. The photos looked promising, so my husband and I decided to walk over and give it a try. We arrived on Friday, October 16, 2026, at around 10:40 PM, only to find the building completely dark with all the lights off. We were disappointed, especially since we were looking forward to some late-night sandwiches. With few food options available in Estes Park after 10 PM, we settled for McDonald's. That night I left a review on Google simply stating, "Not open when they said they were open." The following morning, October 17, at 7:22 AM, I received a Facebook message request from 'Lisa Machado Ferarri'. She sent three middle-finger emojis and made insulting comments about my appearance, saying she loved my "big giant gums" and "Ewwww." After a quick Google of both her Facebook name and The Sandwich Mafia, it was obvious that this must be the owner of The Sandwich Mafia. It appears that she goes by a few different names, Lisa Smith, Lisa Williams, Lisa Machado Ferarri. The business owner apparently took the time to look me up on Facebook just to personally insult me for leaving an honest review about my experience. How incredibly unprofessional and bizarre. To potential customers: Based on this experience and the way the owner handles feedback, I'd recommend looking elsewhere for food in Estes Park. To the business owner: Do better. Owning a small business isn't easy, but that doesn't justify harassing customers for sharing an honest experience. If your listed hours are inaccurate, update them. Customers are less likely to leave negative reviews when their expectations match reality. Looking at the owner's responses to other negative Google reviews, this behavior seems consistent with how criticism is handled. It's one thing to disappoint a potential customer by being closed during advertised hours. It's another to personally attack someone for pointing it out. A negative review is an opportunity to address a problem, not an excuse to bully a customer. This was a very strange and disappointing experience. read more

They report that they're open until midnight. That is...unless they decide to close around 9:30. Thanks, but don't waste my time. read more

The Sandwich Mafia - Alley entrance - Italian Near Me - Estes Park, Colorado

For a place called The Sandwich Mafia, they are clearly a pizza joint. Might have great pizza but if you're craving a good sandwich look elsewhere. read more

After a long day of travel we are so happy we stopped by this place. Best tiramisu I've had in a long time and the pizza was perfect. We almost forgot to take A photo! Our server was incredibly kind and inside was cozy. Will be back again read more

The Sandwich Mafia - Pizza and tiramisu - Italian Near Me - Estes Park, Colorado

Where's Uncle Tony when you need him? Honestly, someone call Nonna and have her send Uncle Tony over to politely break some bread--or maybe some legs--because The Sandwich Mafia is disrespecting the family... and the sandwich game. These sandwiches? Fuggedaboutit. Dry, flavorless, and thinner than my cousin Vinny's patience. If this is what they're calling a "hit," then it's a miss, capisce? We ordered The Uncle Tony, which comes with salami, pepperoni, mortadella, provolone, lettuce, tomato, pepperoncini, black olives, and oil & vinegar on a hoagie. This was, without question, the saddest sandwich I've ever had the displeasure of paying for. One flimsy slice of each meat and cheese, and the bare minimum of veggies they could legally get away with. If Uncle Tony knew his name was being slapped on this, he'd have made The Sandwich Mafia sleep with the fishes. Their Instagram? Fugazi. It's all thick stacks of meat, cheese, and toppings. But what you actually get is a sad, limp excuse for a sandwich. Check the photos I posted if you need the visual heartbreak. Do yourself a favor--save your appetite, your wallet, and your dignity. Go eat somewhere else. Heck, even Subway would've been a hundred times better... and that's saying something. read more

See all

This place has a fantastic location. As you walk down Elkhorn Ave, you'll notice a cool little sign at the start of an alleyway that says "Pizza." You'll also find a sign that points you through the alleyway and a menu. I give them credit for including the menu there as well; it makes it easier to decide to eat there without any pressure. Once you reach the end of the alley, you'll see the entrance. There is a second floor with seating and a bathroom, but you'll order downstairs. I will say, there isn't much seating, however, this place is more of a quick lunch before heading back to your stroll. The service was excellent - friendly and fast. The food came out fairly quickly. We ordered a pepperoni pizza, and something about their dough just tasted great. In my opinion, it was a very good pizza. We definitely enjoyed what this place had to offer. The unique location and delicious pizza make it a must-try! read more

See all

Fantastic Gluten free pizza! Sixes were perfect for the prices and I wasn't disappointed also very much fit the mafia vibe of the place!! read more

The Sandwich Mafia - Gluten Gluten-Free Crust Pizza (Personal) with onions, tomatoes, bell peppers, and mushrooms. - Italian Near Me - Estes Park, Colorado

When we walked in there was no line and right away we were greeted. You order your food fast casual and they bring it to you once you pay. The place has an upper level with tables that you can eat at and there are some condiments on the side. The place is cool with different pictures of mafia mobs. We got the pesto sandwich and the French dip and the pesto sandwich was our favorite! read more

The Sandwich Mafia - Italian Near Me - Estes Park, Colorado

This is my second time here and their gluten free pizza is genuinely amazing. Their employees are also very hospitable!

The service was impeccable and speedy. The dining area has a clean well kept environment both inside and out. The sandwiches and pizza were delicious and they kept the beverages ice cold. All of us thoroughly enjoyed our meal. read more

Alicia's Chicken Pesto Panini 3 sourdough, bacon, mozzarella Johnny Roast Beef Panini 4 foccacia bread (baked w/ cheese), enough roast beef, provolone, lettuce, tomato, sour pepperoncini (pickled yellow chili pepper), raw onions, bacon, pesto, flavorful read more

Was a little bummed. The smells brought us but when we walked in, no pizza slices and they told us they were only serving two of the 13 sandwiches on the menu board. We ordered the Uncle Tony. It was ok read more

We are new to Colorado and are exploring different areas. We stopped in for lunch and OH MY was it good! We ordered a personal pizza (pictured) and the "Alicia's Chicken Pesto" panini. They were very kind and everything was made to order and quickly! The seating area is upstairs and is quiet and clean. We will definitely be back! read more

The Sandwich Mafia - Personal Cheese Pizza - Italian Near Me - Estes Park, Colorado

Stopped by The Sandwich Mafia for a quick lunch after a day of hiking in Rocky Mountain National Park. I was ravenous and in need of some carbs, and this place fit the bill. I ordered the Jimmy Conway sandwich - a classic turkey on wheat with Monterey Jack cheese and the usual fixings. It was delicious and I devoured it within minutes. It was clear that the bread was baked fresh in-house, the meat was of high quality and the vegetables had a nice crunch to them. Limited seating - this place is small and better for grab and go, but they do have some tables upstairs. read more

All the other places were either closed or would've taken too slow as there was a limited amount of time, so I came here to eat a late lunch. It's hidden and down a tight alleyway. There are restrooms here, so that's good. It isn't a fancy place, more like a hole in the wall joint. At least you don't have to worry about anything pretentious here. They have their menu up on the wall to choose from. Service was very quick, and they brought the food to you even though you sat upstairs. It's the run of the old mill and no frills. read more

See all

This place is great for a quick bite! The thin crust pizza with added toppings tasted great. Food was ready within minutes, so a major plus. The ambiance was very unique with Italian mob references everywhere, so if you're a big fan of The Godfather I highly recommend this place! read more

The Sandwich Mafia - Italian Near Me - Estes Park, Colorado

See all

Rat Pack personal sized pizza was just what I needed, hot, thin crust, good tasty ingredients. Small place but cute theme with Italian decorations, T shirts for sale. I like it. There is additional seating upstairs. read more

Skimpy sandwiches. Family got 4 sandwiches and only the Rubin was ok. Very little meat and mostly bread. Won't be back.

$20 sandwich and chips has one tiny piece of meat on it. Pretty disappointing overall read more

The Sandwich Mafia - Daniel's Italian French Dip Sub - Italian Near Me - Estes Park, Colorado

Come here every time we visit and the food is excellent the only bad part about it is that the restaurant is hard to find its in a alleyway however you can go on the backside of the restaurant they have great artwork on the second floor and the people that work there are friendly. read more

Good pizza. Thin crust and airy edges. Crust and sauce taste great. Even the gluten free crust was very good. The staff is friendly. Basic interior but clean. read more

Look, it's okay.. but it's not worth $16 a sandwich good. Sandwiches are pretty dry. Claim to have oil & vinegar on some. It was either left off or they put on a couple drops. Everything costs extra as well. Canned/bottled drinks, chips, $3.50 to add a slice of avocado. As far as bang for the buck goes, I'd go to the many other sandwich places in town. read more

Chicken pesto was good. Nice deli w outside seating too. Only one bathroom though, so had to wait a few mins.

Came during lunch, the service was quick and they brought the pizza upstairs to us. We sat at a little bar top along the back wall. Cute and quirky restaurant. Pizza looked great, but was pretty greasy and the crust was very soft and floppy - hard to hold without everything sliding off. A medium is plenty for two people, but just missed the mark a bit on the quality. read more

The Sandwich Mafia - Medium pepperoni pizza. - Italian Near Me - Estes Park, Colorado

The bread made the sandwiches dry, we got 3 different types of sandwiches; 1 missing items, all were dry, spent way too much for them and could of got something better else where. Basically it's priced for the tourist market. Go to king scoopers and make 12 sandwiches for the price of 1. read more

The Sandwich Mafia - Chicken avocado and roast beef. - Italian Near Me - Estes Park, Colorado

While enjoying a walking exploration of downtown Estes we stumbled upon the sand which mafia. It's tucked just off the street with a very small footprint. It offers a nice sand which selection and small pizzas. We were there at lunch time on a beautiful day. There was an hour wait for pizzas and twenty minutes for sandwiches . We placed sandwich orders then went back to shopping. Upon our return our food was ready. Everything was delicious We then went across the street and enjoyed outdoor music and beer at the slab Highly Recommended Slainte!,, read more

This place was the perfect post hike sandwich spot to fulfill our cravings. The pesto sandwich was amazing, service was fast and staff was kind and helpful, and we were the only ones there! It was laid back and comfortable. read more

The Sandwich Mafia - Pesto chicken sandwich, added tomato, and Uncle Tony's sandwich - Italian Near Me - Estes Park, Colorado

We used to go here regularly but the last few times over the last couple of months they haven't even served sandwiches and you can only get a whole pizza instead of just a slice. Disappointing. read more

My girlfriend and I tried to go to Bird and Jim but it was an hour long wait. We said f* it and decided to come here instead. The food was amazing. I got the guiliana it was so good I went back for a second one. My girlfriend started having a small coughing fit and they came up and brought her water and made sure she was okay. Love this place and I'd definitely come back again and again read more

Neat place. I went in for a to-go order, and saw a few others waiting on a to-go order too. Some employees came back from a break I guess and were quick to help the one girl behind the counter. Got my order in quick. Ordered a Giuliana and an Uncle Tony, (I should have ordered the Uncle Tony) with bottled drinks and chips. Planning on taking our order into the RMNP, and the To-go packaging was very handy and neat. Not nearly as messy as I thought, traveling with sandwiches. Friendly staff, good location. Took a good minute, but we weren't in a rush to the park so it was all good. read more

See all

Fantastic sandwiches! We came to this place for dinner because of their sandwich options and they did not disappoint. There was plenty of delicious meat, cheese, and toppings inside of some great tasting bread. We highly recommend getting a sandwich here... they also make pizza! read more

The Sandwich Mafia - Ham, provolone, lettuce, and tomato. So good! - Italian Near Me - Estes Park, Colorado

Our family really enjoyed the pizzas! They were able to accommodate a large order on short notice and the quality was still good.

First things first- you are going to wait for your food, plain and simple. They don't have a large volume kitchen. You can call and order ahead, delivery or pick up. Everyone's complaining about the wait. Inside seating is limited. It's upstairs seating. There is some outside seating available as well. Order, pay and seat yourself. They will deliver the food to your table. Clean up after yourself and don't loiter at the table after you ate- guarantee someone else wants to sit down too. They offer cold and hot sandwiches, pizza and calzones. The pizza is thin crust cooked to absolute perfection. A large fed my family of 4 with two large slices each. Some of the best pizza I have ever had. We arrived at 11:15 on a Tuesday morning and our food took about 30 minutes to make it to the table. They were getting flooded with orders already. If you order a cold sandwich it may be faster, but you still will have to wait. This isn't jimmy johns. Decor was simple and the place was clean. read more

The Sandwich Mafia - Cheesy bread - Italian Near Me - Estes Park, Colorado

See all

This hidden gem was recommended by a store worker from the sweets shop (lauras) Staff was friendly and the food was pretty good. The sandwich was toasted to perfection and so filling. I ordered the guiliana. It was spicy, and delicious. read more

The Sandwich Mafia - Italian Near Me - Estes Park, Colorado

They claim they are open yet they never answer the phone and a lot of times you get a busy signal I suggest you get a sandwich elsewhere cuz you are not going to get one here Let me know if I am wrong Good luck read more

First visit and I'll start by saying I'd come back. Kinda weird mend for a sandwich place, however our sandwiches were really good. Super fresh bread. Good portion of meat and cheese. Great flavor. Had the French Dip and the Fonz. I wish this place success especially during this rough time. read more

See all

Came in for the second time and was much happier with the visit. Everyone loved the food. The nana was a big hit. We called in a LARGE to go order to go eat in RMNP. I'll admit a sandwich was Forgotten but they made it right. Really excellent customer service. Large portions. Very filling. Pizza was on point. We will go back. read more

See all

We ate here twice when we came to Estes Park. Legit delicious sandwiches tucked away in an unpretentious little shop off an alley. Yum!

The food was great, we had the Aaron's, Jimmy and the fonzarealli. All great! The service was great, very kind. There is a second level with additional seating, the day we came it had snowed but also the option for outdoor seating. The decor is super cut with mafia members. It was a great experience. read more