Excellent wings. Got the breaded Option. Juicy with a very tasty sauce. The fries are fine, beer was cold read more

We had decided to try a new place tonight for fish. Glad we did! We did the double haddock meal for take out. The haddock was super tasty, loved the coleslaw. I also liked their tartar sauce and typically I hate it. Although it was busy when we ordered our food, it still came out pretty fast! read more

The Old Grog - Bars Near Me - Menasha, Wisconsin

worst fish fry ever! bones in every bite of the perch. Then to top it off they forgot my wifes and my baked potat. said we could come back for it. priced like a 5 star restaurant and they're a 1 star joke. DO NOT EAT THERE! you've been warned!!!!! read more

Been a resident of the Valley for 3 decades; however, last night was our first visit to The Old Grog. We had heard good things about their chicken and decided to give it a try with friends. It has an old school, Wisconsin neighborhood tavern feel to it. Standard bar with dining room setup. We were waited on promptly by our server. She was pleasant and helped make our initial visit a success. We started out with hand-muddled old fashioned drinks. Very good. Followed it up with their variety basket of appetizers. Also solid. Two of our party had the broasted chicken with broaster potatoes. Great taste and very good chicken. The other members of the group had steak sandwiches. Filling and also very tasty. Overall, a very good first experience. We will return in the future. read more

The Old Grog - Steak sandwich. - Bars Near Me - Menasha, Wisconsin

Best prime rib sandwich and wings . One of our go to places. Service is great even when it is busy

Food hit the spot - service was awesome by Sara and her cooks. Came to visit before hitting up Neenah block party- glad we experienced this 18th century style hole in the wall. Good dive bar to re visit! read more

See all

The old grog has the best chicken wings in the valley that's my opinion I always get chicken wings when ever we go out and I've never had any other chicken wings that taste this good I always get a double order so I can take some home read more

First visit at the old grog last night. Our party of 4 was in the mood for a fish fry so thought we try it out. The Bar setting is nice, bartender with the tattooed hands not so much. Asked for a vodka soda club with a splash of cranberry and a lime. No lime in my drink so I asked if I could have a cherry instead. I was instructed I was going to have to wait. Ok... I can wait... no big deal... the same thing happened to my dad when he asked if they had IPA beers. If I wanted to get treated like crap after a long work week id just go back to work. We were told they didn't have a table in the dining room 5 min later they did but we wanted to finish our drinks before sitting down for dinner. We ended up sitting at a table at the bar and the other bartender served us at our table. She was nice, smiled, and was attentive. Bluegill was good but I question if it was actually bluegill they were large fillets and a nice size portion of fish for the double my husband and I split. I suggest instead of telling customers they are just going to have to wait, just say I'll be with you in just a moment or yes we have an IPA I'll get you a list. We were in no hurry. It's too bad because the bar has a cozy old vibe but not a place to feel welcome or that your business is appreciated. read more

We Stopped by on a whim around 11am on a Sunday. Happen to have a great special going. Best Broasted chicken I have Ever had. Came with mashed n gravy, stuffing, cran sauce and a nice soft dinner roll. So much food that we both took home half for the next day. Considering it was 8.50 a plate...breaks down to 4.25 per meal. Cool, clean old building. Can't wait to go back. Can't wait the try the steak or Prime rib sandwich. There were the specials on other days. Great cheerful service, a little loud but that's easy to take when it's laughing and good fun. Staff busting butt but always with a smile read more

The Old Grog - broasted chicken special - Bars Near Me - Menasha, Wisconsin

We had wings which were delicious, both the naked kind and the type they breast like their broasted chicken dinner on Sundays. Service was great, the bartender and waiters were super nice and friendly which makes more a fun and upbeat atmosphere. Definitely a spot for locals but with it being our first time we were welcomed in and will definitely be back. The local folks were also welcoming which is always a plus when you check out a new place. read more

Ohhhh I could go on and on about the hot beef sandwich! A bit tucked away but definitely worth a stop if you're in the area.

Great service and food was delicious. Drinks are good. terrific specials. It is nice to see someone running the old grog again with all the best traditions. It's a little noisy, but the background noises are all laughter and happy people so I'm good with that read more

This is just a great basic spot. Nice bar and atmosphere. Not fancy but comfortable. Great bartender. Great burger and fries. I just like it. read more

Great steak sandwich's. Locals have good stories Friendly staff Ne sure to go there soon, you won't be disappointed read more

Such a great spot. My parents went here when they were newly married, but I hadn't ever been. Drinks are great, and food is delicious.

Fish fry was very good. Haddock and perch. Bartender was really good. Cozy corner bar. Nice patrons.

I had looked up places to go for food and drinks before I left North Carolina, because the town of Menasha is super small in Wisconsin, and the options were limited. The reviews on Yelp are pretty good so this is where I decided to take my niece for her birthday. When we entered the bar the patrons and employee were nice which is comforting because we added "diversity" to the scene and I was slightly nervous. Many of the tables were "reserved" but we were able to still snag an unreserved one. We ordered drinks and food with the waitress. It became pretty packed quickly. The food came out in reasonable timing. I ordered shrimp and gill (fish) with a salad and my niece ordered a plain steak burger with fries and pretzel sticks. The presentation was spectacular and the taste matched. I was disappointed that chicken wings weren't available since seafood was being prepared. The waitress was stretched thin across the dining area so it took a while to get a refill but she did come back to check on us. I paid for songs on the "Touch Tunes" but the volume was so low that we couldn't hear the music. That was such a waste. Overall I would come back here to Old Grog & sit at the bar to enjoy food & drinks again! read more

See all

This is my second time here while visiting folks in Wisconsin. We appreciated that the staff is still masked and has diners distanced as much as possible. We were starving so we have no complaints about the food. But there was only one very friendly and apologetic server taking and delivering orders and a definite delay in service. Thankfully we got there just before even more peeps arrived. See ya again next time Old Grog. read more

The Old Grog - Chili was not bad - Bars Near Me - Menasha, Wisconsin

See all

Rude service when trying to place a call in order. Have had issues in the past with call in orders here among some successful attempts. If you are not prepared as a business to take call in orders in a friendly manner don't advertise it ‍. read more

Chicken is SO good. I can't even describe it, you just have to have it. Service is attentive and accommodating. This place fills up quickly and after having lunch here I can see why! This is a great spot to get a fresh hot meal-I can't speak to anything besides the chicken because that's all our entire table had! We will definitely be back! read more

Staff is great. Food is great. Drinks are cold . Wonderful neighborhood bar to saddle up to and sit a spell. read more

Steak sandwich was big, overflowing the bun and just what I was looking for paired with a mug on special.

The steak sandwich is just awesome. When I get back to Wisconsin this is a must stop The cheese curds are damn good too! read more

True Wisconsin bar with phenomenal food, served quickly and efficiently with the friendliness that never seems to get old. Highly recommended, it's like going to grandmas' but with the added bonus of perfect Old Fashions & great beer selections. read more

For many of us, The Old Grog has been a staple since our childhood! There is a lot of history in the building but that's no match for the great food. My go to is the Steak Sandwich but I certainly can recommend the burger, hot beef, stadium burger and all of the starters will please your belly! The soups are a delicious starter as well. The bartenders can also make for a fun evening. Good service and fun atmosphere! So much more than bar food! read more

this place was fire. They don't serve certain things on certain days (no chicken on i think thursdays?) But i highly recommend this spot. so so so good. and their kitchen is open late. read more

Absolutely great staff and food. Their mini tacos were my go to when I was pregnant! Will definitely be back.

Tried The Old Grog for lunch. Nice atmosphere, great food and the bartender was very personable and friendly. Looking forward to trying the Friday night fish fry! read more

My chicken sandwich was served on an old Bun which fell apart as I was cutting it in half. Nothing tasty about it. Very disappointing!

Went to The Old Grog and had a steak sandwich. It was really awesome, the best thing I had while visiting family back in Wisconsin. Recommend getting some extra butter to put on. read more

The Old Grog - Bars Near Me - Menasha, Wisconsin

Extremely good boneless wings with lots of sauce choices. Love the hometown pub atmosphere. Very friendly staff.

We stopped on our way to the airport, and this is a gem for sure! Food was AMAZING, and service was excellent. Yellow cheese curds, Sunday chicken bowl, and roast beef sandwich- all excellent. Highly recommend. read more

Passed through town on a Sunday afternoon. We wanted to try another well rated "grill" for burgers, alas it was closed. So, I Google nearby restaurants for a good burger and "the old grog" came up. We stopped. The atmosphere is genuine WI grill and bar, updated facilities with super friendly service. Burgers and ground sirloin steak sandwiches are cooked to order, almost as big as the plate (which are meant to be folded over in your bun), loaded with raw or grilled onions and pickles. A true WI burger! Bloody Mary's and made to order with the right balance of spice and tang. Do not pass this place by! read more

Good chicken diner on Sunday's. Actually anything on the menu is a good choice. Service has been a bit slow lately. Limited people in the bar, so that shouldn't be the reason. Just be sure to plan extra time when going to eat. read more

Old pub charm, warmth and atmosphere. Nice place to meet friends to catch up and watch games. Staff hustles and aims to please. Unfortunately food is less than stellar. Flavor is there but overcooked. Suggest eating before you go or after you leave. Enjoy the games and beverages. read more

Typical Wisconsin neighbor bar with great service, good food, and a friendly NE Wisconsin atmosphere. We will definitely go back next time we're in the area. read more

I have been to The Old Grog 4 days in a row now. The goal here is to complete the menu in its entirety. That is, unless, I am let down. So far so good. I started out with "The Grog Basket". It contains a plethora of deep fried foods such as jalapeños, mozzarella sticks and onion rings. It was really good. You get the choice of two sauces, these are located next to the wing selection on the menu. For what you get, it's a touch pricey but not terrible. I then ordered a pizza burger to boot. I left full. The second day I had the Prime Rib sandwich. This thing was fantastic. Filled me right up! Totally worth trying out. The third time was a Friday. I could not pass up the fish fry! I chose the pike. Though in the back of my mind I was thinking bluegill. The Pike was on point! It came with rye bread, tarter sauce butter and fries. I would do that again if it it didn't set me back a day. Which leads me to the fourth visit. They only serve fish on Fridays, as a heads up. The fourth time did set me back a day. It was Saturday. Guess what the special was? The prime rib sandwich! And yes I did order it again. Who could pass up that sandwich for 7 bucks. About the Prime rib. You will need to fold it over the bun. It's not a small piece of meat. It is served on a Manderfield bun, choice of raw or fried onion and is served with an au ju dip. Today will be my fifth day. I figure by the end of next month I will have completed the menu read more

This place is fantastic. I have spent weeks trying to make this new town my home, and it's been hard. Especially coming from Chicago. The small town, friendly vibe hasn't existed, and I get along with everyone. I stopped here after an exhausting weekend/ day at the park to rest my feet and my mind. They not only served the most delicious $8 chicken I've ever had, but treated me soooo kindly and welcomed my baby. (Not the most ideal location for a baby, but no one flinched). Joe is fantastic and such a kind, hard working guy. It's always the dives that pleasantly surprise me. And I'm thrilled to have a neighborhood place for very good, cheap food. read more

The Old Grog - Bars Near Me - Menasha, Wisconsin

See all

I love this place. The food is great and so is the service. I get the fish fry almost every Friday. If you want a great fish dinner go here. read more

Second time around. Tonight's meal consisted of an appetizer of nachos ( not worth the 4$) a generous helping of perch, and a generous helping of pike. The fish was nice and hot! The coleslaw was creamy and fantastic! The fries were plentiful and tasty. Cold beer at a decent price. My vodka diet was weak :(. All in all the best reason to come here is because of our server Megan. read more

The Old Grog - Ok ok. Tonight's delicacy was haddock - nice amount of food! Piping hot! - Bars Near Me - Menasha, Wisconsin