Experience as a whole: As for the murder mystery itself, that was fun. Unique theme, easy to follow story that was engaging. It was a sold out evening, as I imagine is usually the case, especially with the great deal I got for it on Groupon. This, however, made it very difficult to talk to the suspects (12, I believe?) when all guests (the room capacity sign said 160 and as I said, it was full) were invited to do so all at once. Not only was it almost too crowded, but we couldn't hear well. We were at the Old Spagetti Factory and frankly, the acoustics suck. The actors had a couple microphones they were using, but even listening intently, I missed at least 25% of what was said. It was nearly impossible to have a conversation with my friends across our far-wider-than-necessary table. Also, if you are remotely shy, don't count on getting any necessary information from the suspects because others will talk over you. I am guilty of this and sorry for anyone who's interrogating I took over, however I get really into these things and really want to solve the mystery. I can't wait for you to stumble over the same type of questions for the brief period of time we are given to talk to suspects. You are given "bribe money" to help loosen the suspect tongues, but the suspects do not necessarily have all the information or answers you want yet--it is reveled to them over time in their folders. If you have ever been a suspect at any kind of mystery (i have a couple friends who have hosted at their house), you would understand. Luckily, they do a final line up of suspects and make sure to get you all the necessary info to solve the case before you are given the sheet to fill out your answer (however, see the microphone issue). You are expected to work with everyone at your table as a team and share information, but again, it is practically impossible to have a conversation and it doesn't help when the other half of the table (strangers you don't know if you didn't come with a group big enough to fill said table) are mainly concerned with drinking the night away. But ultimately, the mystery made sense (though our table got it wrong) and the acting plus some improvisation was fun. I did feel that some actors in the company did not do well getting to everyone in the room, but that they just kept to one area, which I felt was unfair.
A note on dinner: no one should go to Old Spaghetti Factory expecting a gourmet meal. It was par for the course, but if I wasn't going for the murder mystery evening, I wouldn't go just for the food. You do get a choice of three entrees. Everyone gets a salad and a ice cream dessert (bleh, the mint neopolitan thing) included. Bread and water is served to each table. It is a while before you get the main course, and though our waiter warned us, I got really hungry and a little hangry because I had come straight from work.
A note on our particular evening: they got started really late. They tell you to be there 20 minutes before hand, which I assumed was for check in purposes. But despite arriving promptly at 5:20, we weren't checked in or seated until 6:25. Start time was supposed to be 6pm. I felt there was likely some seating issues? Not sure. But a couple of the actors did come around to talk to guests in their character while we were in line, setting a nice tone. Unfortunately, my friends and I got stuck in line for at least 20 min. in front of the kitchen entrance where waiters were coming and going like mad. At least twice we almost got run into by a platter of drinks and I would have been very upset if any of my party got beverages spilled on them over something we couldn't control. ALSO there were WAY too many young kids. This was likely happenstance, but at least 15 kids under 10 were running around, taking away from what I thought would be a strictly adult evening.
One other note to the company: I personally did not like that the costume of the night went to a kid dressed in a firefighter Halloween outfit. It had NOTHING to do with the theme of magician or magician assistant that we were encouraged to dress up as. My husband was dressed better than many of the actors--he even had people trying to question him as a suspect periodically even though he had no name tag. So while I don't care who gets the little certificate, please choose someone who is actually engaged in the show and made an obvious effort to stick to the chosen theme. There was a good handful of ladies who really pulled off the assistant look that could have gotten the award too. Heck, there were 3 kids who at least had a play smoke pipe, a monocle and some magnifying glasses that tried harder than the firefighter did. Come on.
To conclude, it is worthwhile to go, at least once. Go with more than just your spouse--take another couple or handful of friends. We were a group of five and it was perfect. Snag a deal on Groupon! Dress up! That is half the fun. Snack before if you will be hungry soon. And have a great time! read more