Cancel

Open app

Search

The Mainstay Inn

3.9 (21 reviews)
PriceyHotels

The Mainstay Inn Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - The Mainstay Inn

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Tom L.

We've honestly never stayed the night, but are very frequent customers of the afternoon tea service. They always have an excellent lineup of home baked cookies, pastries, and light snacks to go with the tea, and a wonderfully friendly staff. Zhana is an excellent server and baker, always with a smile on her face. We love sitting on the porch in the summer or inside the cozy Victorian sitting rooms in the winter with our teas. Of all the places in Cape May, this is probably our most frequent patronage. If their overnight hospitality is as good as their 3 pm tea service, I'd highly recommend staying here on your next trip to Cape May.

Front of the hotel
Mariel D.

Excellent B&B. Food and afternoon tea were both great, the rooms are very clean and the entire place inside and out is beautifully decorated. Service was warm and very helpful, and you can't beat the location. Looking forward to coming back next year!

Parlor in the cottage. This room is not air conditioned, and pales in comparison to the parlor in the main house.
Lee N.

Pros: beautifully decorated rooms, free (and good) WiFi Cons: pricey, mediocre food, main room in the cabin very disappointing We recently stayed in the Decatur room in the cabin. On one hand we enjoyed it: the room was spacious and roomy, and we kind of liked the privacy and quiet of not being in the main house. The room itself was beautiful, with lovely rugs and great furnishings. The Cabin was sold out and yet we felt like we had the place to ourselves. On the other hand, the parlor of the cabin (which is a house beside the main house) was exceedingly disappointing: no a/c, uncomfortable wicker furniture, a counter and sink area that looks like a Motel 6 (see pictures). We were stunned by how poorly appointed it was. Yes, you can go next door to the beautiful parlor of the main house, but you shouldn't have to do that at an expensive place. The breakfast buffet also was disappointing. The fresh fruit is lovely, but other than that its basically a glorified cheap continental breakfast with only one "hot" dish - which often runs out. Our first day there they had a delicious egg casserole, but they had only pan of it despite every room being sold out. People who arrived more than halfway through breakfast were stuck with rubbery, overcooked scrambled eggs like you'd find at a nice Comfort Inn. Again...the place was sold out and they had only one pan of their main dish. If you stay here I don't think you'll feel ripped off, and I MIGHT consider staying here again. But I think it has a few too many flaws for a place this pricey, so I'll probably check out other options first.

Best lights on town.
Sam M.

This is our third stay, but our first stay in the off season. The common areas are nice some of the rooms may not be a posh as I've seen some reviewers to expect. But I can tell you that this place has many loyal repeat visitors for many many years. The staff are great, Diane is very accommodating and knows how to keep people coming back. The owners very involved and personable, Pete puts alot of work in this place. Tea time is very nice. The Christmas lights are the best in town. Off season prices are good and their is plenty to enjoy without the struggle to find parking. Tomorrow it will be 62 for the high, looking forward to it.

Best looking b&b on the block.
Tom G.

I stayed in a few bed and breakfasts in Cape May over the years. New owners took over in 2014 and the place looks great. Diane was dynamite but found the owner Pete polite but unresponsive to desire to support his Inn. My room was the Clara Barton and it was perfect for my stay. Beautiful antiques throughout the two buildings, a wrap around porch that you could enjoy coffee in the morning or a quiet porch swing for you and your lady friend. I met a couple that got married there this past Christmas. Their favorite place in Cape May too The Horses and Carriage rides swing past and share stories about the 1900's and how this home was fully restored. For breakfast, I had Tomatoes and Swiss quiche, fresh fruit and home backed breads. I recommend this beautiful Victorian B&B to anyone.

zzzz on the Main Stay B&B porch

See all

18 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Ellen F.
103
30
3

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0
Photo of Tom L.
203
32
13

5 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Mariel D.
398
19
9

4 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Greg T.
359
1845
207

9 years ago

Helpful 9
Thanks 0
Love this 9
Oh no 0
Photo of Lee N.
56
76
3

13 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Peter S.

Peter S.

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Sam M.
30
106
125

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Tom G.
71
32
20

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

16 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of M F.
2
108
7

13 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Peter S.

Peter S.

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Peter S.

Peter S.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Aly H.
0
32
2

14 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Peter S.

Peter S.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - The Mainstay Inn

Review Highlights - The Mainstay Inn

“It was super clean, comfortable and welcoming, plus it's close to everything in Cape May.”

Mentioned in 2 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

ICONA Cape May - Kitchen area

ICONA Cape May

(65 reviews)

$$$

Very nice hotel. I've never booked a room from Priceline and got one this nice and on the beach!!!…read more Too bad it's not warm out. The tv is a little hard to work

My partner & I truly enjoyed this quick getaway to Cape May. Icona is on Beach Drive, right across…read morethe street from the beach (as the name implies). I've stayed at their Diamond Beach location, but this was my first time here. Let me mention the most enjoyable employees first. Chet was at the Front Desk when I checked out. He was by far the most friendly person I interacted with at the front desk. Some of the females were a bit...... unfriendly. If you chose to work in a customer service position it's probably best to have a sunny disposition. I think Cape May needs to address that. Tarik/Tajik? He was the young men who helped EVERYBODY get their chairs and umbrellas to the beach. He was WORKING! Yet, he always remained pleasant. And lastly, the gentleman driving the shuttle was very pleasant. He picked us up/dropped us off about 4 times. He was also servicing the Mahalo (and Icona resort) so he had his work cut out for him! We REALLY appreciated him as it was pouring one night and he came to pick us up and bring us back to the hotel. That amenity is CLUTCH! Overall, it's a nice hotel. Clean, a beautiful small bathroom, a cute little kitchen area, a small pool, and parking. Somebody mentioned the room was small, but to me it was a decent size. The balcony however, now THAT was small. Just enough room for the 2 of us to sit out there side by side and chill. I did see larger balconies out by the pool (facing the beach) so I guess you get what you pay for (larger room perhaps; suite). The AC however, is loud. It's not a window unit, but one of those wall units. I'm glad I brought my earplugs, otherwise I probably wouldn't have slept. And speaking of sleep, the bed is not what I am used to when I visit a hotel; especially a higher end boutique hotel. It was uncomfortable to me. My partner however, had no problem sleeping and did not feel it was uncomfortable. So.... roll the dice. The pool is tiny. Or shall I say, smaller than the size you will expect it to be. But it works. I chilled in the pool for 3 days. It's a good spot to people watch and break from the sand of the beach. And once we parked, we didn't have to move the car. Cape May is very pedestrian friendly. We walked and rode bikes every where we went. I love it. It was a great getaway. Check it out.

Lokal Hotel - Cape May - Room 201

Lokal Hotel - Cape May

(7 reviews)

The Lokal is a fantastic boutique hotel option within easy walking distance of the beach…read more The hotel offers beach chair service in season and a heated pool that's open even in the offseason, which was a great surprise. There's no front desk -- everything is handled by text -- but the staff was quick to respond and very helpful throughout our stay, even though we didn't have any issues. Our room (201) was large, clean, and nicely designed, with a full (albeit abbreviateD) kitchen, fast Wi-Fi, and plenty of space to hang out. The balcony had a beautiful view of the sunset and was one of our favorite parts of the stay. One parking space is included and it's a very easy walk to either the beach or town for shopping or food. It's probably (definitely) on the higher end price-wise during the summer, but for a fall weekend, it was ideal: quiet, comfortable, and close to everything.

This hotel is one of the best places I have ever stayed! It is a great getaway for a couple who…read morewants a clean, modern and cozy vibe. All of the amenities are great! You feel right at home! The rooms all have fun names and the free parking is also a perk. The rooms are large and modern. The decor is wonderful. They have a full kitchen, dishwasher, fridge and little oven. Each floor also has a washer and dryer that can be used for free. The porch has wonderful walking chairs. I also enjoyed the workout mats in room to continue exercise away from home. The heated salt water pool even in early May felt so nice. Wonderful relaxing atmosphere. The fire pits were also relaxing and easy to use. Lokal is steps away from the beach which is fantastic. Would love to visit during peak season to use the provided beach tags and service available. It is also close to many bars and restaurants that are walkable. We really enjoyed our stay here for the perfect Mom and Dad getaway!

Congress Hall - Congress Hall -- Thanksgiving 2023

Congress Hall

(274 reviews)

$$$

Along the shoreline of New Jersey's Cape May, one'll encounter Congress Hall, a historic hotel. It…read morebegan life in 1816 as a simple boarding house for summer visitors. Made of brick and painted a buttery yellow, it is distinguished by its L-shaped silhouette, 32-foot colonnade, and mansard roof. Five presidents have stayed inside its hallowed halls, along with other musicians, writers, and more. The property has transformed and renovated over the years, evolving into the grand hotel it is today. The property itself was beautifully decked out in its autumn decorations and well maintained for such a historic establishment. For us, the most captivating aspect of our visit was the history and photographs in the hallway surrounded by various Stars and Strips leading away from the lobby, where the shops are. One of my favorite touches was the row of rocking chairs outside by the portable heaters. They are perfect for sitting back, relaxing, and taking in the vibe. My partner and I enjoyed our dinner at the Blue Pig Tavern. What not to love?

Spent one of many 60th birthday celebrations with a stay at Congress Hall. Have dined and visited…read morespa in the past, but never for an overnight. Our room was well appointed with views of the ocean! Including views from the glass enclosed shower! The Brown Room is always a favorite spot to relax and the cocktails were spectacular. The Blue Pig never disappoints, and we love your napkins, thanks. I remember the Boiler Room long before the pizza place took over, when it truly felt like a speakeasy. Today, too casual and too many children. Always love visiting CM and Congress Hall!

The Queen Victoria - Queen Victoria's parlor

The Queen Victoria

(75 reviews)

A bed and breakfast, often abbreviated as B&B, is a business that accommodates overnight guests and…read moreoffers a breakfast menu. They traditionally take the form of a large family home with a limited number of rooms and offer hospitality services on a personal level. Located in the historic district of Cape May, the B&Bs are upscale accommodations, mostly Victorian houses. Situated off of Ocean Street, the Queen Victoria is very popular, decorated with period antiques and furniture. They feature AC for the summer and a gas fireplace in winter with delicious breakfast and afternoon tea. My partner and I stayed at the Hampton Court suite in the Prince Albert Hall on the Queen Victoria's grounds as first-timers this weekend. It definitely did not disappoint. The room was clean, cozy, quaint, at the right temperature, and had everything we needed. It was conveniently within a walking distance of the beach, shops, and restaurants. Bikes, beach chairs, and beach towels were provided to all guests. The staff were very nice and helpful, especially Samantha. We had arrived late after the front desk closed. She greeted us Saturday morning and was very informative. This establishment is an ideal choice for couples, weekend getaways with friends, and families with well-behaved children.

HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO ME !!!…read more My Sir (yes, I literally call him that because he is such a sexy Sicilian gentleman and always dresses to the 9's!) is taking me away here for my birthday. It's my first one with him in my life :) I was blown away when we walked up to the main house, toured inside of ours, had tea, a cozy night and breakfast. He breakfast was nithing shoet of amazing! The star was the Blueberry Stuffed French Toast casserole - like OMG insanely delicious!!! I kind of had three servings! Many other perfect choices too, like English muffins, fruit, yogurt, granola). Our room is done in dark reds and boasts cherrywood. Also, beautiful prints and furniture. We had a romantic evening with the jacuzzi, (gas) fireplace and cloud cozy King sized bed! Stellar service from all - Sam and Amanda in particular. They do A LOT here! We MAY leave the room today, lol. Walking Washington Street is a possibility. MAYBE the Zoo... I lived in Cape May many moons ago. A definite place to visit- you will always have somewhere to go and somewhere to eat! Splurge on the decadence of The Queen Victoria!!! You're worth it!!!

The Mainstay Inn - hotels - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...