The Little Bakery

Best pizza in town, and the owners are great. You really can't go wrong here. 10 out of 10.read more

Brought my wife to Niagara Falls, had a problem with our rental car and the guy at the rental…read morecompany said "I'm pretty picky about my Pizza" - I knew that he knew. So to Broadway Pizza for lunch. He said the Dill pizza is becoming a thing around here and they have a good one. Walked into a true Pizza place. Line of locals waiting to order. The lady and her husband were taking the orders each local she hit with small talk. Great variety of pizza cheese, white, mushroom & pepperoni, Dill and half a dozen others. You could pick your own topping of you wanted but with this selection come on ... Tables and wooden chairs your typical pizzeria- you are not here for the furniture. Excellent place. Oh and they were making Stromboli's as well - maybe next time.

One side menu

Mild wings and pepperoni pizza

See all

Cheese Pizza w Onion Topping

Buck's Pizzeria

4.6(36 reviews)

0.3 mi

Food & Service 10/10…read more We were visiting from Hawaii and looked up a bunch of Pizza places near us and came across Buck's Pizzeria with amazing reviews. We had a great conversation with the gentleman working the front and he even gave us a test slice while we waited for our fries! Being tourists made it easy to feel out of place but the staff here made us feel 100% at home and we are very thankful for that. If I had more room to eat I would have bought more slices because this Pizza was the best Pizza we ate on this trip. We will definitely come back on our next trip!

Mike & staff were very accommodating / Prices were fair & The products were of the highest quality…read more I highly recommend this FINE LOCAL PIZZERIA for anyone in Niagara Falls NY (716) 215-6465 ... Ask for a "Test Slice" ... You won't be disappointed!

Apple logs, delicious dessert!

See all

Menu (pg 2 of 2) May 2024

Buzzy's Pizza

3.4(229 reviews)

3.2 mi

Joseph Martelli Niagara Falls, NY Review of Buzzy's pizza-Their food is really good and they make…read morethe best old fashioned pizza by far from any other pizza place. If you like that type of pizza you have got to try it

Craving local, Buzzy's was recommended by our hotel. Did not disappoint! Soup - good. Pizza - good…read more Calzone - good. Diet Coke - good. The lovely lady who served us was very helpful. She recommended the wings and/or pizza without hesitation! She was very attentive and made sure the soda glass was never empty. We sat outside and totally enjoyed the great weather and the amount of people coming in to pick up their takeout orders! Place was great!

Inside. Great ambience.

Medium wings

See all

Outside.

Leon's Italian Bistro & Pizza

3.8(130 reviews)

4.0 mi

I am absolutely in love with the pickle pizza. It has the right amount of everything and tastes…read moreamazing. It's funny because I don't like pickles or ranch! The service is average for a slice heat and take pizzeria.

Celebrated PI day with some pizza pie! Went to a friend's house in the Falls, instead of bringing…read morepizza in we ordered out there. They told me Leons is the best in the Falls. It was actually pretty good. I loved there crust and sauce. We tried three different ones, spinach and ricotta, cheese and pepperoni and hot honey. The hot honey was my favorite. I feel there could of been more toppings of cheese and like pepperoni, and I like my pizza sauce, other than that solid pizza, Id ordered again.

Spinach and ricotta

Steak and Cheese Sub

See all

Cheese and pepperoni

Pizza Oven

4.2(38 reviews)

0.7 mi

Having heard the nonstop rave reviews from LITERALLY everyone in Niagara Falls about this pizza I…read morefinally decided I should make the effort to try it. I say "make the effort to try it" because it certainly is a bit of a challenge to line the hours of this place up with your schedule. Friday, Saturday, Sunday 11:30 AM to 7:30 PM October to late June is their hours. The pizza is very good and holds a unique taste in and of itself. The crust is very thin and has a nice fluffy and chewy consistency, the sauce is very well seasoned and just a tiny bit sweet and the cheese well nothing special about the cheese honestly. The The best pizza in the world? I don't know about that claim but it is very tasty and worth making the effort to get your hands on a slice. No seating inside the shop so plan on takeout.

I was really excited to try this place and looking forward to the sweet sauce. I actually drove out…read moreof my way for it. I was let down. First off I will say, no complaints on the price or customer service. The woman was so friendly and personable it made me not want to leave a review since it's not a good one. She was a gem; the pizza: not so much. And judging by the reviews here, maybe it was just an off moment. The sauce wasn't so sweet as I wanted. But that's subjective. However, what I hated the most was my slices were soggy and cold. I mean so soggy I couldn't even eat my last slice. And cold it should not be, as I ate it in my car on the street because I live 35 mins away. I really wanted to love it here after my great customer service experience but unfortunately my experience with the pizza itself was not as great as everyone else's. If I ever happen to have it again (I go to Lewiston often), and have a better quality slice, I will update review but sadly it missed the mark for me.

Thanks for always being closed. ;)

Inside Menu

See all

My overcooked/burnt cheese slices.

Donatello's Restaurant

4.4(425 reviews)

1.2 mi

Good food. Good prices. Good Guys. Ate pizza wings cheese steak chicken fajita pizza chicken…read morefingers fries. Fresh baked chocolate chip cookie and Reese peanut butter cookie. Not at tables but available condiments salt pepper Parmesan cheese. Crushed red pepper. Red Gold ketchup packets. Many more available behind the counter just ask and they take care of you. Next time I'm in town will have to stop by and visit. Yes they had a ninja turtle too.

Here on vacation and I had seen good reviews. It was a nice little pizza place. We had a personal…read moreItaliano pizza and 10 wings, medium. Everything was delicious! We asked for water and they brought us out a pitcher which was much appreciated as we were walking. Pizza had a nice crunchy crust which we loved! Toppings were great too! I want to go back and try another pizza while we're here! The wings were great too! Loved the medium sauce. Crispy and hot out of the fryer! We ate every bit of it! They were busy and I saw some huge amazing looking salads come out! Wish they were close to us! Highly recommend!

See all

$8 montepu ruby red

Mr. Ventry's Pizza on the Boulevard

3.7(107 reviews)

4.6 mi

Amazing slice counter with a huge variety to choose from, including steak & cheese, chicken finger,…read morecheese, pepperoni, and many other specialty slices. The pizza is always cooked to perfection with great sauce, plenty of cheese, and a crispy crust. The staff is friendly and welcoming, making every visit a great experience. I'll definitely be back!

This restaurant was conveniently located near our hotel, so it was nice to have something so close…read moreby. We were seated quickly, and got our cheese bread quite fast. When our situation changed and we had to rush out the door, the server was understanding and gave us our pizzas to go. The pizzas were huge and had some unique flavors that we liked, but we wish we could have stayed a little longer in the restaurant.

Entrance into dining room.

Stinger Sub - Large

See all

Mario's Pizza

4.1(121 reviews)

1.5 mi

I came here as it was highly rated on Yelp to begin with…read more The pizza is a New York thin crust, which is almost an art in and among itself. The sauce, cheese, and crust were the perfect blend. The smart play is to give it a minute to cool before that first bite. A pie this size came out *quick*! It was a lot less time than I was expecting. Staff is fantastic! There are only a handful of tables inside, but more outdoor seating is available. Giving this a 5. Should I be back in the area, this place will be on my repeat list.0

We absolutely loved Mario's while staying in Niagara Falls. We dined here twice while on our trip…read more(usually against our rules unless it leaves a lasting impression on us!) Mario's is a cute little spot you may dine in or carry out, located on one of the main drags in Niagara. The delicious slices were served up quickly with a smile, both times. ;) I love the cheese, but the authentic pepperoni had me wanting that meat! You must try Mario's, it's amazing!

Pepperoni by the slice

See all

Inside order area with the goods out in the open

Joey's Pizzeria

3.6(38 reviews)

4.1 mi

Wings were amazing!…read more Whoever answers the phone needs training in customer service. Delivery driver was very friendly

Used to live in Lewiston, NY then moved to the Syracuse, NY area several years ago. Loved Joey's…read morePizzeria and when back in the area stopped in with family and friends. I so miss this place. Best pizza, wings and the steak and cheese sub was to die for. Wish they could deliver to me in Central NY, LOL. Will go back again when I'm in the area. Will not disappoint you, if you have a chance to check it out.

Updated menu

See all

2017 Menu

Papa Johns Pizza

3.1(7 reviews)

2.9 mi

Whenever I order from here, the food is actually cooked unlike other pizza places. They have the…read moredough nice and crispy, the cheese is always melted, the seasonings in their food is amazing! I love everything I get from here. They even remember you too if you're a regular. Service is amazing. Never dined in so cant say anything about the ambiance.

just ordered two pizzas and took over twenty minutes for our order. we clearly ordered TWO pizzas…read moreand the guy just gave us one so we had to wait even more. on top of that we asked for regular crust, yet we got stuffed crust. can you not take a simple order ???

Things to do in Niagara Falls

Cheese, pepperoni, and mushrooms

These are supposed to be mild wings. Burned, and hot sauce just dumped over the top... cool.

See all

Papa Johns Pizza

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Marley S.

316

5 years ago

I love all that you do for the community. I really enjoy your old fashioned pizza. Recently I had your pizza from your LaSalle location. It seems like the dough was really chewy. Not sure if you changed your recipe or if it wasn't cooked long enough. Hopefully it was just the day I went! read more

The Little Bakery - pizza - Updated October 2026

Best of Niagara Falls

People found The Little Bakery by searching for…

People who viewed The Little Bakery also viewed

Pizza Amoré "The Wood Fire Way"

3.6

(69 reviews)

I am obsessed with Detroit style pizza and I love spicy. So the Devon's way pizza was a must for my…read morefirst time at Pizza Amore after looking at reviews. My pizza was made by Devon too which she told when I picked it up. This was the most delicious pizza ever, my daughter got a cheese personal Detroit style cheese pizza and she loved hers too! I will be back!

I paid $1.25 extra for mushrooms... where are they? One slice has them, maybe 2 out of the 4?? way…read moretoo much sauce, so the not fully melted cheese / too much cheese slid right off. Maybe don't get the personal size since it's not being cooked well, or maybe it's just young staff who doesn't care this time. Hate to leave a 1 star review...used to be good - back home for the holidays and was looking forward to this. But I'm disappointed.

Pizza Amore The Wood Fire Way

3.7

(19 reviews)

I got my pizza from the food truck when they were downtown! I chose the stuffed banana pepper pizza…read morewith no sausage and extra balsamic drizzle. Absolutely delicious! They make the pizza right in front of you. The pizza is stuffed with cheese and banana peppers and also topped with the same. The balsamic drizzle is the perfect touch of sweet to go with the pizza.

We had a coupon for Detroit style pizza so decided to give it a try. We got the one with…read morericotta...it was good but I found that i really don't care for Detroit style pizza...too heavy and doughy. Of course, that being said, it was good if you like that style pizza !!!

Favorite's Pizzeria

4.1

(50 reviews)

(This is from 5/11/26) Had a tremendous experience! We had 6 people and wanted to eat in. The 2…read moregirls working were spot on! We didn't have to wait to order and our orders came out fast and delicious! It's a pizzeria and it has pizzeria ambiance. Have gone back multiple times since.

Ordered a large Old Fashion Pie. I didn't check it before leaving. Took it to a friend at work. It…read morewas burned. I emailed company but no reply. Don't leave without opening the box.

Romeo & Juliet Cafe

4.0

(126 reviews)

Special occassion, brought home some of their Sfogliatelle pastry. Absolutely outstanding in every…read moreway. The very best I've ever encountered in WNY. Perfect texture, taste. A great indulgent treat.

2/14/26 - Valentine's Day dinner at Romeo & Juliet with my significant other. So fitting right!…read moreLove is in the air! And so is authentic Italian cooking! What a treat to come back to Romeo and Juliet. Warm cozy atmosphere in this small, family run restaurant. Mauricio is the real deal! The the owner is from Florence Italy! He was present in the dining room, visiting with some of the diners and directing traffic. Very personable nice man. We were served our dinner fast, considering they had a full house for Valentines dinner. Service was friendly and quick. I had a traditional Italian favorite- baked eggplant with pasta on the side. $24. Very nice and delicious. My partner was more adventurous in ordered the pumpkin ravioli with vodka sauce. $22. Vodka sauce with green peas, complemented, the sweetness of the pumpkin filled raviolis. A little pricey for not having any meat in our dishes. I'm used to ordering meat based dishes and paying similar a price. Yet the taste was incredibly good. This is a solid, very good Italian restaurant. Put this one on your list!

Sugo's Pizzeria

3.4

(30 reviews)

Julienne salad - excellent loaded fries - lots of cheese and…read morereal bacon! Beef taco - great Best takeout meal we've had in ages.

Buffalo Chicken Pizza 8/10 Really great pizza between the…read moreflavor and the toppings. But after having this pizza on two separate occasions, the dough in the middle is ALWAYS undercooked, photo attached. But, this is my bf's favorite pizza ever, so we will definitely order again when we're in the area.

Dr Pizza & Smoothie

4.8

(4 reviews)

Strongly considering getting gas at this station more often......The pizza at Dr Pizza & smoothie…read morewas delicious. Amazing pizza created by a wonderful couple. I love running into the places that make Neapolitan style pizza the right way. It was thin crispy cheesy. Convenient location and I could not have showed up there at a better time. I was hungry and I was able to eat at the table in front of the truck. Thank you again!

Delicious pizza, fresh lemonades, clean and friendly atmosphere and service! Everything was fresh…read moreincluding the just picked basil on the pie.

Pizza Oven

3.8

(78 reviews)

Great pizza been a customer's forever ... consistntly good ...: woot... have to try the wingsread more

Updating a review from many years ago because some things simply don't change and Pizza Oven is one…read moreof them. I still willingly drive out to Lockport just for this pizza and I honestly wouldn't have it any other way. I *always* order a sheet pizza and it never disappoints. Whether it's hot out of the oven or cold leftovers, Pizza Oven's signature sweet sauce is everything... maybe even a little addictive. I know sweet sauce isn't for everyone but for me it's pure perfection. I can (and do) eat way too many slices in one sitting - all with zero regrets. Pizza Oven is consistently delicious and I get the consistency every single time. The service is fine, I usually call ahead to place my order. The ambiance of the pizzeria is, maybe a little run down but it's like a good dive bar - the greasier, the better. Whether it's for a game day, a family gathering, or just because, Pizza Oven is always my go-to when I'm in WNY. Some spots are worth the drive, the calories, and the nostalgia and Pizza Oven is absolutely one of them. Never change, Pizza Oven!

Lock City Pizza

3.9

(68 reviews)

This place is super popular in Lockport. My father-in-law and brother-in-law live in Lockport and…read morealways wants to get pizza from Lock City. The lobby looks like it was assembled in the 80s and hasn't changed much since. There is some seating for about 20 people, but most people don't eat here they just waiting for their often slower then estimated pizza. The pizza makers are middle aged and look like they have been doing this for years, which gives me confidence. The employees are also super nice, which is for some reason rare in Buffalo! The pizza and wings are good, not mind blowing, but good. At least the pizza isn't sweet like most pizza I have had in Lockport. If the phone is busy when you call to order just keep trying, these guys are busy and not super up to date when is comes to tech. Speaking of which, as far as I know they don't have a website which would be nice for their menu and knowing their prices. So far this is my favorite pizza in Lockport, check it out!

To me and my family, Lock city has the best traditional sauce pizza in Lockport. The pizza is…read morealways cooked well with spots of crusty tan cheese and lots of toppings. The service is good as in pizza is typically ready at the time they give you. Cash only.

Good Guys Pizza

4.2

(193 reviews)

Craving a dense, thicker-style crust pizza, I knew I could count on Good Guys Pizza to satiate it!…read more I placed and paid for my pizza online around 4:15pm for a 5:00pm pickup on a Saturday. I arrived closer to 5:15pm to a packed parking lot. I wish the parking lot was a little bigger but, somehow, I still managed to find a spot! I walked in and was next in line and after giving my name, my order was brought out and I was out of there, quite literally in and out, which was probably a good thing as I had a good parking spot. For my order, I ordered a small (13", six slice) cheese, pepperoni, sweet pepper, and mushroom pizza. This pizza was just as delicious as I remembered. I really love how Good Guys Pizza cook their pizzas with more cook time on the bottom, making their pizza a bit sturdier and golden on the underneath. And that thick, crispy, crunchy crust, *chef's kiss*. Good Guys Pizza is VERY generous with their toppings, each slice I pulled out had awesome cheese-pull, and there was plenty of red sauce. A note about their red sauce, if the typical-Buffalo "sweet" style isn't your favorite, I think you'd be good with Good Guys Pizza's red sauce as it comes across a bit more balanced, with maybe a slight lean towards "spicy". There was plenty of pepperoni buried beneath the heaps of mushrooms and sweet (green) pepper slices! I added a drizzle of hot honey and I thought it was an awesome complement! Good Guys Pizza cooks up a thicker-dough pizza that satisfies the biggest appetites, which this pizza was no different, but I appreciate it not being greasy, it sat well. The price I paid for my pizza was very reasonable, especially seeing how much prices everywhere have risen in 2026, a nice treat for my wallet. Good Guys Pizza retains one of the top spots in my favorite pizza shop list! They've been a favorite of mine since 2018 and it really impresses me how consistently good, they are - The quality, the portions, the prices, the customer service, all of it is great! The only reason I don't come here more is the fact it's so far from my house, but, once in a while, I have to just make the trek and get my Good Guys Pizza-fix.

Made a stop at Good Guy'S pizza. We ordered various pizzas and also a fish sub. Delicious food not…read moreskimpy on ingredients, not cheap but I guess you get what you pay for.

Gino's NY Pizza Elmwood

3.9

(182 reviews)