Cancel

Open app

Search

The Fair Restaurant

4.4 (21 reviews)
Closed • Closed
Updated 3 weeks ago

The Fair Restaurant Photos

THE FAIR RESTAURANT ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - The Fair Restaurant

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Braised short rib on, I kid you not, cut up angel hair spaghetti
Kyle S.

The Fair is a fantastic looking restaurant. Slathered in a modern interpretation of art deco with dark colors, crisp linens, and paintings of women with birds that are very upscale makes this an impressive remodel from its previous tenant. The new owners did not fix one of the major drawbacks of the space, however, and it is just as loud as Toast was. Sound baffling would help, but it wouldn't have made my experience all that much better. We were seated at a table in the back. Despite our fairly early reservation, we were next to an 8-person table that, when filled, got noisy. The velvet cushioned seats were nice. Booths looked good as well. Lighting is low and intimate. Drinks were meh. I wasn't impressed. I tried two and both were single note without much sophistication. The menu looked interesting, but I wasn't impressed with the execution. My scallops had good flavor but were overcooked and very soft. The braised short rib was good but it sat on a bed of spaghetti that was cut up; like you would for a child. The service was hit and miss. At times, our server seemed to be actively ignoring us to the point where one of our quartet jokingly asked if one of us had dated them and it had ended badly. The Fair is expanding, which is great, and I wish them the best, but a rating of "fair" is about all I could give my visit.

Asparagus
Melonie M.

Had a great experience tonight at The Fair. The staff were very friendly. The food came out quickly and everything tasted delicious! Will definitely return.

My wife's birthday and our 44th anniversary!
Jeffrey G.

From start to finish The Fair Restaurant did not disappoint! The food was delicious, and the service impeccable. The atmosphere was great with low lighting and had a very elegant feel. However casual dress was welcome. My wife and I both got free deserts. Lava Cake and cheesecake. Both were delicious. My wife had a filet mignon which very tender. She got the Brussels sprouts and she reported they were good, but could have been sautéed a little longer. I had the NY strip, medium rare. I was very good, with nice seasoning. I had au gratin potatoes, they were so creamy and delicious! All the stars for this place. Please check it out! We'll be back, it's in our back yard!

Erinn B.

A Hidden Gem That Redefines Fine Dining in New Albany From the moment we stepped inside, this new restaurant in downtown New Albany felt like stepping into another world -- where romance, artistry, and culinary mastery come together. The aesthetic is nothing short of magical: imagine Art Deco elegance meeting a moody French speakeasy, with high-back, richly colored booths and light fixtures that sparkle like jewelry above a spectacular bar. It's intimate, classy, and unforgettable. We began with appetizers that set the tone for the evening -- beef tartare, duck rillettes, and escargot served with the most perfectly charred bread. Each bite was balanced, thoughtful, and delicious. Our sommelier's recommendation, a J. Lohr red blend, paired beautifully with every course. For entrées, the lobster linguini--topped with shrimp and scallops--was indulgent perfection. The creamy vodka sauce had just the right kiss of spice, coating every strand of pasta with rich, decadent flavor. But the surprise showstopper? The half chicken with rice and vegetables. It was nothing like any roast chicken we've ever had -- tender, aromatic, seasoned with a unique blend of spices that felt both homey and elevated. I wasn't even the one who ordered it, and I can't stop thinking about it! The team made the night unforgettable. Emma, our waitress, was an absolute gem -- knowledgeable, passionate, and eloquent. She spoke about each dish with genuine excitement and made us feel like honored guests. Max, the owner and sommelier, shared stories of the restaurant's family roots and culinary journey, which added a personal touch to an already exquisite evening. We don't get to New Albany often, but this experience set a whole new standard for us -- even as we prepare to move to Las Vegas, a city known for world-class dining. Things might be bigger there, but this place will always be our benchmark for perfection. Truly a flawless dining experience -- romantic, refined, and absolutely memorable in every way.

Escargot and stuffed mushroom
Edward S.

It's the upscale restaurant of the same family that brought us Senor Iguana and a family of establishments. Food was definitely delicious and pricing was reasonable for an upscale place. Our server Shelby was excellent at her job. Chef Rosa was so sweet to come out and chat with us and tell us what a labor of love this business is to her and her family.

Frites!

Enjoyed a dinner for my birthday. It was a Saturday night and not too busy. We were sat right away and waited on promptly. I started with a wedge salad and we had steaks as our entree, my wife the filet and I the NY Strip. Steaks were delicious, the frites were good and Mac and cheese was a very sharp cheddar. Overall good experience, just very pricey as these establishments are.

Debra A.

I had seen and spoke to the folks at Harvest homecoming so I was curious to try them out. It was a week night evening. The restaurant was not full, but the restaurant itself was absolutely beautiful low-key very elegant , but the service was wonderful. I sat at the bar. I ordered up a Negroni to drink, wedge salad and a French onion soup. The bartender was very friendly, knowledgeable, and attentive. Definitely a place to try if you want amazing food, wonderful ambience, and attentive service.

Shrimp Cocktail Appetizer

See all

26 days ago

It was a nice clean atmosphere. The service was polite and attentive. The food was delicious and a good portion size.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 month ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1
Photo of Kyle S.
167
865
1033

6 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

27 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 5
Thanks 2
Love this 6
Oh no 1

1 year ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 3
Love this 6
Oh no 0
Photo of Zac T.
0
11
21

2 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 0

2 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 0

5 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Todd F.
35
37
3

7 months ago

We absolutely loved the bartenders and the drinks, some of the best we've ever had! We didn't eat, but the menu looks fantastic!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Art C.
7
10
0

11 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - The Fair Restaurant

You might also consider

The Earl - Relaxing galley layout.

The Earl

4.0(32 reviews)
0.1 mi

If you're looking for a unique and welcoming bar in New Albany, The Earl is definitely worth a…read morevisit. It has a great atmosphere to enjoy a quick drink or settle in and enjoy the evening. The drinks are well made, the bartenders are friendly and attentive, and the overall vibe makes it easy to stay longer than you planned. It's a great spot whether you're going out for a casual night or meeting friends for something a little different from the usual bar scene. What really stands out is the personality of the place. It feels cozy, well put together, and genuinely enjoyable. We've had consistently good experiences and would absolutely recommend giving The Earl a try if you're in New Albany.

I've been to The Earl a couple of times and I still don't quite know what to make of it. Each time…read morehas been because The Earl is open after all the other bars close. If this place were called "Steve's" or something and had more mundane lighting, I'd wrap my head around it more easily. The bar itself runs down the center of the single room with some four-ups against the wall. Each time, drinks are poured into plastic cups. Prices seem reasonable but portions are smaller than you'll get elsewhere. There's a few on draft, some alright cocktails and a limited food menu. I opted for the pretzel bread and pimento spread and was pleasantly surprised with how much I enjoyed the freshness, texture, and taste! Music selections fluctuate both genres and volumes. Clientele is pretty relaxed. Its a go-to spot after 10 p.m.

Photos
The Earl
The Earl - Ruby Bloom Amber Ale

Ruby Bloom Amber Ale

The Earl - Inside left picture of menu

See all

Inside left picture of menu

The Exchange Pub + Kitchen - The Voodoo Pasta 2.0 with blackened chicken

The Exchange Pub + Kitchen

4.2(661 reviews)
0.2 mi
•$$

The exchange has always been a solid dinner spot. We have never had bad service! I will admit…read moresometimes I am sad to see a favorite rotate off the menu but the new selections are always just as good. Great spot for indoor or outdoor. Even a good "in between" section where it's covered but they can lift up the doors. The bun on our burger did come out hard a rock but they immediately took it back and remade it as soon as we mentioned it. Great drink selections for beer, wine and cocktails. A New Albany gem for sure!

Usually the Exchange is always a great time with amazing food but this last visit did not live up…read moreto our expectations. We were in last week for dinner, for a dual Birthday celebration and had a larger group of about 20 people. We sat in the front room, and it was rather warm in there, but it was an unusually hot day for mid-September. There was only one other couple there when me and my husband arrived and it took a while for the server to come over and ask if we wanted drinks. By the time he did, several other people had arrived, and they all got their drinks before we did. It even took forever to get our drinks; we could see them dying at the bar waiting to be ran. I'll be honest, the service wasn't the best, it was obvious the server might have been newer in the sense of experience with a large party. He was very friendly and had a great demeanor but was extremely forgetful, which he mentioned several times. Once everyone was settled, we started with Appetizers. The Goat Cheese Fritters, with Bacon Date Aioli, Honey and Parsley are always my go to. They are small little goat cheese balls deep fried to perfection and delicious every time. For dinner we shared the Bone-In Pork Schnitzel that has a Tonkatsu Glaze, Sauerkraut, charred lemon and Japanese potato salad, and a side of mac n cheese. The Pork was extremely dry and flavorless and there was no glaze on it. The mac n cheese was just okay. One of my friends got the Braised Short Rib Adobo (brown beech & crimini mushrooms, creamy risotto) and let me have a taste. Let's just say I was extremely jealous I chose the wrong entrée for dinner, it was so good!

Photos
The Exchange Pub + Kitchen - 08.28.25 indoor open seating

08.28.25 indoor open seating

The Exchange Pub + Kitchen - Goat Cheese Fritters

Goat Cheese Fritters

The Exchange Pub + Kitchen - Smoked Old Fashion

See all

Smoked Old Fashion

Recbar 812 - House Salad

Recbar 812

3.8(106 reviews)
0.1 mi
•$$

Still a solid establishment - though they've done some updating particularly downstairs. They've…read moreunfortunately slightly downscaled their collection of arcade games (including getting rid of my favorite one Galaga - which is unfortunate because that should be a staple of the place) but added extra seating and beautiful lighting. It's very low lit and romantic and very atmospheric downstairs and I love that. They've also added several vintage TVs that you can play a variety of video games on (including Xbox) and they've got a tv playing the rugrats movie apparently too hahaha. I like that aspect. Just wish they would add a few more arcade games down there. Including Galaga and Joust (which they also removed). They have a tabletop version of Galaga but it was broke... speaking of broke a couple other games didn't work either. The dig dug stick got stuck a couple times. But most of the games worked fine . I got one draft beer that was 7 dollars - overpriced in my opinion but decent tasting. It's still a super fun place to visit. Drink, have fun, chill out, eat. It's novel atmosphere very welcoming and colorful and enjoyable. Exactly the wholesome kind of spot for young and old alike.

Pretty rude about "being in their kitchen area" for a place that's kitchen area is wide open and…read moreright next to where people walk in and out of the bathroom. I mean, add a curtain or something if you really don't want people to step even a tiny foot inside the hallway that's LEADING to the kitchen and not even anywhere near food. Food is good for the price.

Photos
Recbar 812 - Upstairs pinball machines, (off camera is skeeball, basketball, arcade games, a bar and dining area)

Upstairs pinball machines, (off camera is skeeball, basketball, arcade games, a bar and dining area)

Recbar 812 - Cool Kids Club

Cool Kids Club

Recbar 812 - Recbar 812

See all

Recbar 812

The Fair Restaurant - bars - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...