Cancel

Open app

Search

The Fair Restaurant

4.4 (21 reviews)
Closed • Closed
Updated 1 month ago

The Fair Restaurant Photos

THE FAIR RESTAURANT ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - The Fair Restaurant

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Braised short rib on, I kid you not, cut up angel hair spaghetti
Kyle S.

The Fair is a fantastic looking restaurant. Slathered in a modern interpretation of art deco with dark colors, crisp linens, and paintings of women with birds that are very upscale makes this an impressive remodel from its previous tenant. The new owners did not fix one of the major drawbacks of the space, however, and it is just as loud as Toast was. Sound baffling would help, but it wouldn't have made my experience all that much better. We were seated at a table in the back. Despite our fairly early reservation, we were next to an 8-person table that, when filled, got noisy. The velvet cushioned seats were nice. Booths looked good as well. Lighting is low and intimate. Drinks were meh. I wasn't impressed. I tried two and both were single note without much sophistication. The menu looked interesting, but I wasn't impressed with the execution. My scallops had good flavor but were overcooked and very soft. The braised short rib was good but it sat on a bed of spaghetti that was cut up; like you would for a child. The service was hit and miss. At times, our server seemed to be actively ignoring us to the point where one of our quartet jokingly asked if one of us had dated them and it had ended badly. The Fair is expanding, which is great, and I wish them the best, but a rating of "fair" is about all I could give my visit.

Asparagus
Melonie M.

Had a great experience tonight at The Fair. The staff were very friendly. The food came out quickly and everything tasted delicious! Will definitely return.

My wife's birthday and our 44th anniversary!
Jeffrey G.

From start to finish The Fair Restaurant did not disappoint! The food was delicious, and the service impeccable. The atmosphere was great with low lighting and had a very elegant feel. However casual dress was welcome. My wife and I both got free deserts. Lava Cake and cheesecake. Both were delicious. My wife had a filet mignon which very tender. She got the Brussels sprouts and she reported they were good, but could have been sautéed a little longer. I had the NY strip, medium rare. I was very good, with nice seasoning. I had au gratin potatoes, they were so creamy and delicious! All the stars for this place. Please check it out! We'll be back, it's in our back yard!

Erinn B.

A Hidden Gem That Redefines Fine Dining in New Albany From the moment we stepped inside, this new restaurant in downtown New Albany felt like stepping into another world -- where romance, artistry, and culinary mastery come together. The aesthetic is nothing short of magical: imagine Art Deco elegance meeting a moody French speakeasy, with high-back, richly colored booths and light fixtures that sparkle like jewelry above a spectacular bar. It's intimate, classy, and unforgettable. We began with appetizers that set the tone for the evening -- beef tartare, duck rillettes, and escargot served with the most perfectly charred bread. Each bite was balanced, thoughtful, and delicious. Our sommelier's recommendation, a J. Lohr red blend, paired beautifully with every course. For entrées, the lobster linguini--topped with shrimp and scallops--was indulgent perfection. The creamy vodka sauce had just the right kiss of spice, coating every strand of pasta with rich, decadent flavor. But the surprise showstopper? The half chicken with rice and vegetables. It was nothing like any roast chicken we've ever had -- tender, aromatic, seasoned with a unique blend of spices that felt both homey and elevated. I wasn't even the one who ordered it, and I can't stop thinking about it! The team made the night unforgettable. Emma, our waitress, was an absolute gem -- knowledgeable, passionate, and eloquent. She spoke about each dish with genuine excitement and made us feel like honored guests. Max, the owner and sommelier, shared stories of the restaurant's family roots and culinary journey, which added a personal touch to an already exquisite evening. We don't get to New Albany often, but this experience set a whole new standard for us -- even as we prepare to move to Las Vegas, a city known for world-class dining. Things might be bigger there, but this place will always be our benchmark for perfection. Truly a flawless dining experience -- romantic, refined, and absolutely memorable in every way.

Escargot and stuffed mushroom
Edward S.

It's the upscale restaurant of the same family that brought us Senor Iguana and a family of establishments. Food was definitely delicious and pricing was reasonable for an upscale place. Our server Shelby was excellent at her job. Chef Rosa was so sweet to come out and chat with us and tell us what a labor of love this business is to her and her family.

Frites!

Enjoyed a dinner for my birthday. It was a Saturday night and not too busy. We were sat right away and waited on promptly. I started with a wedge salad and we had steaks as our entree, my wife the filet and I the NY Strip. Steaks were delicious, the frites were good and Mac and cheese was a very sharp cheddar. Overall good experience, just very pricey as these establishments are.

Debra A.

I had seen and spoke to the folks at Harvest homecoming so I was curious to try them out. It was a week night evening. The restaurant was not full, but the restaurant itself was absolutely beautiful low-key very elegant , but the service was wonderful. I sat at the bar. I ordered up a Negroni to drink, wedge salad and a French onion soup. The bartender was very friendly, knowledgeable, and attentive. Definitely a place to try if you want amazing food, wonderful ambience, and attentive service.

Shrimp Cocktail Appetizer

See all

1 month ago

It was a nice clean atmosphere. The service was polite and attentive. The food was delicious and a good portion size.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

17 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 month ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1
Photo of Kyle S.
167
867
1033

6 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

1 month ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 5
Thanks 2
Love this 6
Oh no 1

1 year ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 3
Love this 6
Oh no 0
Photo of Zac T.
0
11
21

3 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 0

2 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Todd F.
35
37
3

7 months ago

We absolutely loved the bartenders and the drinks, some of the best we've ever had! We didn't eat, but the menu looks fantastic!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Art C.
7
10
0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - The Fair Restaurant

You might also consider

Cast Iron Steakhouse

Cast Iron Steakhouse

4.3(586 reviews)
5.3 mi
•$$

Service 10/10 Cheyenne was amazing! Super attentive. Explained everything and all her…read morerecommendations were wonderful. Made my 30th birthday special. Food 10/10 I mean literally my boyfriend and I were overwhelmed at how wonderful everything looked, how delicious it was. Multiple times we brought it up in conversation. The food felt like an experience. Steak 10/10 (I know I said food but this has to be in its own category) oh my gosh. Please go get the Delemonico cut, medium. It melts in your mouth, no need for A1. This cut was recommended by Cheyenne and she got it spot on! Ambiance felt like home, everyone was friendly. The manager even came to our table so we were able to compliment them personally. We definitely found our favorite place to eat in Louisville. Thank you Cast Iron for a wonderful night!

I first visited Cask Iron Steakhouse during the pandemic, and at the time the experience felt…read moreunique -- steaks arriving sizzling in cast iron skillets gave the meal a little extra character and charm. Returning recently, the food was still very good, but now everything comes out on regular plates, and some of that original magic felt lost. That said, this is still a solid local steakhouse. The staff was attentive, the meal was flavorful, and the prices were fair, especially compared to many of the more famous steakhouses across the Ohio River in Louisville. It may not have the prestige or polish of some of those places, but that's also part of its appeal. This feels more like a neighborhood restaurant serving happy locals than a destination fine dining spot -- and honestly there's something refreshing about that. Good food, good service, reasonable prices, and a comfortable atmosphere without trying too hard. Sometimes that's exactly what you want.

Photos
Cast Iron Steakhouse - We have something for all tastes

We have something for all tastes

Cast Iron Steakhouse - Peach Cobbler

Peach Cobbler

Cast Iron Steakhouse

See all

The Exchange Pub + Kitchen - The Voodoo Pasta 2.0 with blackened chicken

The Exchange Pub + Kitchen

4.2(661 reviews)
0.2 mi
•$$

The Exchange is a must in New Albany!…read more It's an upscale pub at its finest. This has been the best place for American cuisine with a flair of authentic style. The service here is the best. Our latest visit was on Halloween. Everyone was dressed in costumes. We were seated and did not even need a reservation. The exchange has some of the best food and with all sorts of unique ideas. The blueberry jam preserves and bacon grilled cheese with balsamic drizzle is delicious. Let the exchange begin your evening and open your mind to new possibilities in food. Are you getting hungry yet?

Usually the Exchange is always a great time with amazing food but this last visit did not live up…read moreto our expectations. We were in last week for dinner, for a dual Birthday celebration and had a larger group of about 20 people. We sat in the front room, and it was rather warm in there, but it was an unusually hot day for mid-September. There was only one other couple there when me and my husband arrived and it took a while for the server to come over and ask if we wanted drinks. By the time he did, several other people had arrived, and they all got their drinks before we did. It even took forever to get our drinks; we could see them dying at the bar waiting to be ran. I'll be honest, the service wasn't the best, it was obvious the server might have been newer in the sense of experience with a large party. He was very friendly and had a great demeanor but was extremely forgetful, which he mentioned several times. Once everyone was settled, we started with Appetizers. The Goat Cheese Fritters, with Bacon Date Aioli, Honey and Parsley are always my go to. They are small little goat cheese balls deep fried to perfection and delicious every time. For dinner we shared the Bone-In Pork Schnitzel that has a Tonkatsu Glaze, Sauerkraut, charred lemon and Japanese potato salad, and a side of mac n cheese. The Pork was extremely dry and flavorless and there was no glaze on it. The mac n cheese was just okay. One of my friends got the Braised Short Rib Adobo (brown beech & crimini mushrooms, creamy risotto) and let me have a taste. Let's just say I was extremely jealous I chose the wrong entrée for dinner, it was so good!

Photos
The Exchange Pub + Kitchen - 08.28.25 indoor open seating

08.28.25 indoor open seating

The Exchange Pub + Kitchen - Goat Cheese Fritters

Goat Cheese Fritters

The Exchange Pub + Kitchen - Smoked Old Fashion

See all

Smoked Old Fashion

Repeal Oak Fired Steakhouse - At Whiskey Row's only oak-fired steakhouse you'll savor steaks cooked over a fire stoked daily with American Oak bourbon barrel staves.'

Repeal Oak Fired Steakhouse

4.4(632 reviews)
4.3 mi•Downtown, East Main
•$$$$

I had a Smoked Old Fashioned & the Crab Cake app when I stopped in casually. The bartender, Clay…read morewas very knowledgeable, friendly, and professional. I've never had a bad experience here. It's top-tier drinks and eats. They also have a Valet, so parking doesn't have to be a headache. The Old Fashioned was one of the best I've had. The crab cake had virtually no visible filler & was encased in a light, crunchy panko crust. It seemed to be a higher price-point at $25 for one crab cake, but buying a jar of good lump crab at a grocery store is about the same price and quantity. I also had some of my newly befriended bar-neighbor's Sweet Potatoes, at their instance, and I was blown away. Clearly they're slow roasted, blended, and then topped with pecans, toasted marshmallows, and some kind of crunchy corn flake magic. Money can't buy love, but it can buy perfectly crafted Bourbon drinks and food you will be dreaming about for years. 10/10 You get what you pay for. Fantastic service. Fantastic food/bev. Fantastic ambiance. This place is pure "cool and refined."

Disappointing Experience for the Price…read more I was really disappointed with my experience at Repeal Steakhouse. I sat at the bar for dinner, and it took quite a while for someone to come over and ask me what I wanted to order. The French onion soup was just okay, but the homemade bread was extremely dry and stale. It honestly tasted like a roll that had been sitting out for a couple of days. The service was even more disappointing. A gentleman sat down at the bar after me, placed his order, and managed to receive his salad, steak, and side dish before I even received my steak. Eventually, someone came over to check on me, and I had to ask where my food was. When my steak finally arrived, a woman sitting next to me -- who appeared to be affiliated with the restaurant -- had to point out that I hadn't even been given silverware. Unfortunately, the experience didn't improve when it came time to pay. After spending over $100 on dinner for one, my check was essentially dropped in front of me without a thank-you or any acknowledgment of my visit. When my credit card was returned, it was placed in front of me just as casually, again without a word. At a restaurant at this price point, I expect more than just a meal. I expect attentive service, food that reflects the quality the restaurant is charging for, and basic courtesy. Sadly, none of those things came together during my visit. Louisville has plenty of dining options, and this experience did not live up to what I expected from a steakhouse of this caliber. For the price, I left feeling overlooked and genuinely disappointed.

Photos
Repeal Oak Fired Steakhouse - Brush Creek Ranch Tomahawk Ribeye

Brush Creek Ranch Tomahawk Ribeye

Repeal Oak Fired Steakhouse - Fred Linz Heritage Filet Mignon

Fred Linz Heritage Filet Mignon

Repeal Oak Fired Steakhouse - Seafood Plateaux & Iceberg Wedge

See all

Seafood Plateaux & Iceberg Wedge

Steak & Bourbon - Scallops

Steak & Bourbon

4.5(135 reviews)
4.1 mi•West Main, Downtown
•$$$

A friend recommended this restaurant. We had hoped to get into The Brown but they wouldn't open for…read moreseveral hours. I enjoyed our meal. Liked the decor and vibe. The staff were great. We shared a large filet mignon with creamed spinach and shrimp cocktail. Everything was delicious. We got cheese cake to do and a sweet potato for my mom. It was very nice meal for about 1/2 the price of the Jeff Ruby restaurants. Ohh forgot to mention the bread ... it was yu.mmmy and came out with a butter beef tallow candle...never experienced that before. Liked it.

I cant believe my luck trying this place. I can honestly say this is the best restaurant in…read moreLouisville. From the food to the service to the atmosphere, it could not have been better. The interior is beautiful and comfortable. We were given some bread at the start that had a beef tallow candle. Yes! It was a super cool start to the meal. And I know, I know, its not the most socially acceptable item to order, but I hardly see it any more and it is so freaking good, so we started with an order of Foie Gras (bacon jam, seared foie gras, toasted baguette, amarena cherry gastrique) My entree was the 7oz filet. I got the horseradish creme fraiche for it, but it really needed nothing additional, it was that good on its own. My side was the Caramelized Brussels Sprouts (fried with bacon, candied pecans and finished with aged balsamic). If i had anything negative to say about our time here, it would be this dish. I adore brussels sprouts and this was too heavy on the balsamic and oil. I probably would not get this again, but thats OK! There are like 10 other options to choose from! Anyway, get in here for your next holiday or special event. Its worth it,I promise

Photos
Steak & Bourbon - Bar seating

Bar seating

Steak & Bourbon - Steak & Bourbon Meatballs

Steak & Bourbon Meatballs

Steak & Bourbon - Lobster bisque

See all

Lobster bisque

North of Bourbon - lamb noodles

North of Bourbon

4.7(298 reviews)
5.9 mi•Germantown
•$$

Second time in 3 years dining here (out of towner) and it's just as delicious and happening as it…read morewas the first time. While Happy Hour has some great values (esp the grilled oysters), you're going to want to save room for some main menu items. In the wide ranging menu, it's hard to choose an approach. Whatever you do -- Flavors pop, portions shareable (if you order at least 2 items per person or are on GLP-1 drugs), cocktails are inventive, thoughtful wine /beer options. Great service. Wish there had been 4 quail halves. Beet and barley salad was generous. Dirty mushroom rice not a true table share if more than 2 people. Boiled peanut lagniappe was perfect while perusing the menu. It's a little dark (in a good way !) with super cute booths tucked into giant bourbon barrels as well as table and bar seating. New Orleans style jazz versions of modern songs surprise over the speakers. For sure a forever stop for us when in the area.

Had a really fantastic meal here. The bar had a beautiful display of whiskey, and the booths were…read moregiant bourbon barrels. Goes without saying we had bourbon drinks with big rocks. 4 of us split an Asian inspired oxtail noodle dish, some fried chicken gumbo, a rice dish called 'burgoo' ( I think...basically a really nice jambalaya situation), collards, and a crab dip. Kind of a flavor explosion one after the other. Server coursed things out super nicely. For sure, recommend.

Photos
North of Bourbon - Interior

Interior

North of Bourbon - Seafood special

Seafood special

North of Bourbon - Roast beef po boy. Wow

See all

Roast beef po boy. Wow

The Red Yeti - Truffle Fries

The Red Yeti

4.1(644 reviews)
4.5 mi
•$$

As far as the restaurant, this is a really great place to go in downtown Jeffersonville. I do not…read moreknow the story of the building, but it is a tall brick building, kind of rustic. It definitely has an old-world vibe as far as the interior. Chef Mike has won numerous awards and his team has been extremely consistent. If there are a few things I would suggest, it's that some of the things that Chef Mike shows on his sites or does, he brings to the restaurant. It seems the menu really hasn't changed much. We tend to go to Just Brunch now, on Sundays, maybe twice a month. I enjoy all the food there. I would say the only problems are, honestly, the customers. One old dude picking food off a plate that a server was trying to refill the bar was disgusting. Then another moron licking his fingers and touching the tongs so you could not use them after him. It's really just people not knowing how to act in public. But the restaurant does address it to make sure people are not contaminating the food.

The red yeti is a staple. It's one of those places you just have to experience, expose and explore…read moreat least yourself once in a lifetime. Food is tasty, made out of a mixture of southern hospitality and outstanding mixtures of flavors that all come together to bring you a classic small, yet dive-bar feel with the charm of a 1980's diner. Every time I go to the yeti I try to sit by the windows to catch a glance of the beautiful sunset and epic views of Indiana that could come through with a few vintage cars. Hence, needless to mention that the customer service is top notch here and is a good alone reason to come back for more. (Not to mention the eccentric decor and wall color adds personality to the place) Always, happy to go to the yeti then head for an ice cream to pearl's by the bridge.

Photos
The Red Yeti - Bar

Bar

The Red Yeti - Buttermilk Fried Chicken

Buttermilk Fried Chicken

The Red Yeti - Chicken salad

See all

Chicken salad

The Fair Restaurant - bars - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...