Cancel

Open app

Search

The Eccentric Bagel

4.6 (49 reviews)
Closed Closed
Updated 2 months ago

The Eccentric Bagel Photos

You might also consider

More like The Eccentric Bagel

Recommended Reviews - The Eccentric Bagel

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, roasted red pepper, pesto, olive oil on sun dried tomato & Italian herb bagel
Kelly C.

A little expensive for bagels/bagel sandwiches but for shelter island, nothing out of the norm. Bagels are well worth it. They have some fun favored bagels (I tried the za'atar) and some unique cream cheese flavors. It can get pretty packed but they are pretty organized and get your order prepped quickly. Glad to have this addition to Shelter Island!

Jalapeño cheddar bagel with hummus and veggies
Caroline G.

The staff are accommodating and friendly. The place has a very community local vibe to it which I love. Also, there's lots of different market baubles to look through, which again, I love. The food is good. Lots of fun bagel flavors and sandwiches. Yummy large looking muffins. My bf got the jalapeño cheddar bagel with the hummus and veggies. I got the egg and bacon bagel with avocado on a poppy seed bagel. Both were delicious but I think my bagel was a little hard.

AM ISRAEL CHAI

See all

Photo of Toni B.
112
5
9

22 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of NV R.
0
40
0

10 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Echo L.
13
425
115

2 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Amy W.

Amy W.

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Alla R.
139
24
8

2 years ago

Delicious bagels! Great atmosphere! Great service and very friendly staff. Very clean inside

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Ava P.
1
21
5

2 years ago

Worth going to eat their ! Fabulous place and delicious food! wonderfuland and friendly.

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of D G.
0
33
11

2 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

recommended to all. reported negative comments to Yelp. Fresh bagels on Shelter Island--who could ask for more!!

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Owner is an angel. Food and coffee 10/10 am definitely returning. High quality energy and food

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

This place looks amazing!! Love that they have savory and sweet. Can't wait to eat here when I'm in Queens!!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

The food was fresh and served with a smile. I would definitely recommend this restaurant when you want an authentic and delicious bagel!

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Andy H.
0
167
50

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Leslie S.
51
35
11

2 years ago

Food and service is excellent. Everything was fresh. Would definitely recommend to anybody.

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Delicious! We got a range of bagels and sandwiches here. The owner was so nice and the food was amazing. A must!

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Amazing bagels tast delicious and love there new product bagel chips and very friendly owners

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Yum! The absolute best - don't walk - runnnnnnnn! You will be thrilled you did! Everyone was so great

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Amazing service amazing food!!! Yum yum yum. Very nice owners and lovely experience. We love this place!!

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Bagels are really amazing. They taste so good. The service is very good too. I highly recommend this plac

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

I love coming here for bagels! This place is on of my favorites. Always a must for the whole family!

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Lovely staff, sandwiches had little taste, over-priced, I'd say find another island spot.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Gabrielle P.
185
138
128

4 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Delicious and fresh bagels! A great addition to the island. Best one is the rosemary sea salt one.

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Bagel's on SI, how can you not like it. Sunday morning with coffee and a everything bagel and a smear all good.

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 1 of 2

Ask the Community - The Eccentric Bagel

Review Highlights - The Eccentric Bagel

BEC sandwiches (try the jalapeño bagel for a kick), wraps, even the bagel chips are special.

Mentioned in 2 reviews

Read more highlights

The Eccentric Bagel - bagels - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...