The Eccentric Bagel

166

252

5 months ago

To start, rosemary salt bagel for the win! Honestly all the bagels were delicious. Cinnamon Raisin, Jalapeño Cheddar, Everything. All of them were really good. We didn't get any of the breakfast sandwiches, but next time we will get them as they sounded so good! read more

Business owner information

Amy W.

We look forward to seeing you again !! Thank you for the wonderful…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mark S.

311

139

2 months ago

Fun local breakfast spot on the island with friendly service and good coffee. Bagels are up to standard and service is quick

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Vivienne G.

Elite 24

150

3 months ago

Great bagels made fresh. I could eat the rosemary salt everyday and not ever tire of it. The owner is a great guy. If you're used to NYC bagel prices you might be shocked. This is more of a high end bagel. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Toni B.

112

6 months ago

The Eccentric Bagel - Toasted sun-dried tomato and Italian herbs with cream cheese! WOW - Bagels Near Me - Shelter Island, New York

The Eccentric Bagel - Great place ! Upbeat and friendly. - Bagels Near Me - Shelter Island, New York

See all

Business owner information

Amy W.

Thank you for the great review! What you loved is our goal!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Matt M.

474

123

682

2 years ago

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

NV R.

3 months ago

So delicious, My fave is a toasted everything bagel with veggie cream cheese and a tall iced coffee with whole milk. Everything is fresh + homemade. Perfect for a great breakfast and the lunch sandwiches on freshly baked bagels cannot be beat. Try the chicken salad on a sesame bagel. Nice to nosh outside under the big umbrellas. Service is quick and helpful. Owners are locals who create a fun experience. Catering and tasty bagged bagel chips available too. Menu and bagel varieties change weekly, and their winter and holiday pot pies are exceptionally good. This is a must visit. read more

Business owner information

Amy W.

Thank you so much for this incredible review! You truly covered…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Brent D.

698

3 months ago

Amazing food, service, and staff. If you are in the area and looking for a great bagel, this is the place to go!

Business owner information

Amy W.

Thank you so much! We’re thrilled you enjoyed the food, service, and…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sabrina P.

765

782

1 year ago

Fresh and warm bagels -- worth the visit! I highly recommend the plain bagels but like that there is a variety of options to choose from. My friend liked the rosemary and salt bagel, too! read more

Business owner information

Amy W.

Thank you so much! We’re so glad the fresh, warm bagels were worth…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kelly C.

372

752

3 years ago

The Eccentric Bagel - Prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, roasted red pepper, pesto, olive oil on sun dried tomato & Italian herb bagel - Bagels Near Me - Shelter Island, New York

The Eccentric Bagel - Za'atar bagel with butter - Bagels Near Me - Shelter Island, New York

See all

Helpful 3

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Echo L.

446

131

2 years ago

I know you've come for the bagels but I'm telling you, try the Reuben sandwich on lightly toasted Rye. It's an incredible sandwich !!! Truly one of the greats !!! Their bagels are also pretty amazing of course and they are stuffed with really interesting fillings and flavors. The one thing I could kvetch about is, they could do better on the amount of cream cheese they shmear on a simple bagel with cream cheese order. It's such a light shmear you'd think they are rationing cream cheese. What's that all about ? Ask for extra. Their bagel chips are pretty fantastic too. The staff are lovely. And with an Israeli flag up in the window and a gay flag flying high outside, the eccentric bagel is on the right side of history and proudly gets my vote !!!! ‍ read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Caroline G.

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

111

289

308

3 years ago

The Eccentric Bagel - Jalapeño cheddar bagel with hummus and veggies - Bagels Near Me - Shelter Island, New York

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Noah D.

2 years ago

I ordered my first chicken pot pie from the owner today and it was amazing!!! Ready next day, and 40 minutes in the oven later it was ready to eat. Best pot pie I've ever had. Highly recommend the chicken pot pie! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

anabela D.

354

2 years ago

To bizarre owner of The Eccentric Bagel who likes to make up stories in her head and put them into Yelp. Your weird inappropriate response is just another GOOD reason to avoid this shop ! First, how would you know who left this review to be able to state you have me on "video" ?Unless Yelp gave you my private information which is ILLEGAL .And Yelp does not have my actual photo either. Second ,as stated in my initial review which was censored I did not purchase food there but my family /friends did. So I saw and tasted the food they purchased and also heard their opinion on it. They like I did not initially notice the flag until after entering.I was actually so unimpressed by bagel sandwiches on offer it was only when I left store and was waiting for their food to come out did I see flag. Third, we had zero interaction with staff except to order and to use bathroom . I SUPPORT workers so I am not about to harass folks just trying to pay their bills or harass them for the poor decisions of a miserable owner. Fourth , my review does not state bathroom is public. It states bathroom is CLEAN! While waiting for my family ,a nice lady hanging outside heard me wondering where could a bathroom be and she volunteered sometimes Bagel shop will allow you to use theirs. We asked a lady at the counter who said we could go to back of shop and use the bathroom which is located right behind the kitchen. A staff person opened the door and allowed us in. Fifth , if some other folks had such a strong negative reaction to your political statement one might think you would reconsider the wisdom of your choice. Anyways seems you are happy to serve mediocre food in a mediocre space and provide a mediocre experience . And then if someone writes you a negative review lie about everything reviewed. F- all around ! Prior review The food is basic NYC bodega /deli level . Line was LONG and not speedy at 10:30 am on a weekend. Bathroom clean. Space up front tiny. My original review was censored by Yelp. Apparently YELP doesn't consider a company creating a hostile insensitive and uncomfortable environment for many of their customers relevant to my food experience. I DO! It's very simple -don't shove your politics of hate against down my and other folks throat . Sometimes a bagel shop should just be a bagel shop. And by sometimes I mean ALL the time . read more

Business owner information

Amy W.

We have a video showing that you and your friends never actually came…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Alla R.

139

2 years ago

Delicious bagels! Great atmosphere! Great service and very friendly staff. Very clean inside

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Alexis R.

2 years ago

awesome place, yummy food, friendly people! it's sad all the antisemitic people out there. Go there if you want some great food which is all that matters read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Andrea S.

2 years ago

Absolutely LOVE Eccentric Bagel! The Rosemary & Salt bagels are out of this world--perfectly chewy with just the right balance of flavor. And don't even get me started on the bagel chips... they're completely addictive. The vibe of the place is so fun and cool, with awesome decor that makes you want to hang out all day. Everyone who works there is incredibly friendly and welcoming. I'd take the ferry over any day just to stock up--totally worth the trip every time! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Elena M.

2 years ago

The Eccentric Bagel - AM ISRAEL CHAI - Bagels Near Me - Shelter Island, New York

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Marissafaith 7.

2 years ago

Great food love everything about this place. What a beautiful experience, food was super delicious and place was super clean and well maintained. Service was really pleasant and efficient.. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Ava P.

2 years ago

Worth going to eat their ! Fabulous place and delicious food! wonderfuland and friendly.

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

D G.

2 years ago

My go to! The best bagels. Always fresh, always delicious, the service is phenomenal, and the owners are awesome. Will be back again and again! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Diane S.

2 years ago

recommended to all. reported negative comments to Yelp. Fresh bagels on Shelter Island--who could ask for more!!

Helpful 2

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Marissa P.

174

2 years ago

Owner is an angel. Food and coffee 10/10 am definitely returning. High quality energy and food

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Kathryn W.

4 years ago

When eccentric bagel opened I was excited but kind of sad to have lost a deli on the island... boy was I wrong! Eccentric bagel has brought it!!! Their number 5 roast beef bagel sandwich is all I've ever wanted. Perfect balance of meat to sauce, fresh vegetables and of course an amazingly fresh delicious bagel. Potato salad also a must! We also picked up great salad. Decor also funky and fresh, makes you just want to smile. 5 stars all around. Can't wait to see what this new company expands on next! read more

The Eccentric Bagel - Number 5 and potato salad... view not included! - Bagels Near Me - Shelter Island, New York

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Kathy H.

2 years ago

Everything at the Eccentric Bagel has been great. BEC sandwiches (try the jalapeño bagel for a kick), wraps, even the bagel chips are special. And their pot pies (I had the lobster, the priciest option but it easily serves two) are fantastic. Don't miss this unique spot, only a few years old but already a Shelter Island institution! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Andy H.

177

4 years ago

Excited to have a solid bagel purveyor on Shelter Island. The fixings are dense on the bagels (especially in my favorite, "Everything"...! Tip: Keep your dental floss handy!). The sides like white fish and egg salad are delicious but very pricey. The coffee offerings could be better but it may be the "off season effect". Love the 80's vibe too! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Sharon M.

2 years ago

This place looks amazing!! Love that they have savory and sweet. Can't wait to eat here when I'm in Queens!!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Becky B.

2 years ago

The food was fresh and served with a smile. I would definitely recommend this restaurant when you want an authentic and delicious bagel!

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Angela P.

4 years ago

Amazing bagel place, the recipe they use makes all the bagels taste absolutely delicious. The staff that work there are very polite and patient. It's a small store but the design details make it so unique. On Sundays they sell the Sundried tomato and herb (?) bagels which are my absolute favorite. I hope they can start making them more often. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Alex N.

2 years ago

The bagels are indeed interesting and tasty. They have all the usual things to put on them, plus sandwich fillings. All very generous. Great to have such a unique and high-quality offering in a small community. Clean and friendly inside. Definitely recommended! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Leslie S.

2 years ago

Food and service is excellent. Everything was fresh. Would definitely recommend to anybody.

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Skylar L.

2 years ago

I can't say enough good things about The Eccentric Bagel. We had a huge party and not only were they on time with the pick up, the bagels were the best we've ever had. And were true New Yorkers so we know bagels! Also try the chocolate chip cookies!! We will come here time and time again and again every time we're in Shelter Island. The staff could be more friendly too. Amazing bagels, amazing people, what more can you ask for! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Jeff E.

3 years ago

Lovely staff, sandwiches had little taste, over-priced, I'd say find another island spot.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kim R.

2 years ago

Delicious! We got a range of bagels and sandwiches here. The owner was so nice and the food was amazing. A must!

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Yaakov M.

2 years ago

Amazing bagels tast delicious and love there new product bagel chips and very friendly owners

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

La P.

2 years ago

Yum! The absolute best - don't walk - runnnnnnnn! You will be thrilled you did! Everyone was so great

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Bianca S.

2 years ago

Amazing service amazing food!!! Yum yum yum. Very nice owners and lovely experience. We love this place!!

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Aliza K.

2 years ago

Bagels are really amazing. They taste so good. The service is very good too. I highly recommend this plac

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Natalie B.

2 years ago

I love coming here for bagels! This place is on of my favorites. Always a must for the whole family!

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tali ..

2 years ago

The best!! I'm from NYC so I have very high expectations for my bagels and this place knocks it out of the park every time. Friendly staff, wide variety of non-bagel options too. Make sure you try the jalapeno cheddar - my mouth is watering just thinking about it. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Gabrielle P.

185

138

128

4 years ago

So glad they added this place on Shelter Island!! We desperately needed a place like this. Bagels are so creative and delicious. Place is run really smoothly. Will be back (every weekend at that) read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 1 of 2

See more reviews

More info about The Eccentric Bagel

25 W Neck Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Directions
(631) 749-5363
Call Now
Visit Website
http://www.eccentricbagel.com

Hours

What time does The Eccentric Bagel open?

The Eccentric Bagel opens at 7:00 AM on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Friday.The Eccentric Bagel opens at 8:00 AM on Saturday and Sunday.

What time does The Eccentric Bagel close?

The Eccentric Bagel is closed on Monday.The Eccentric Bagel closes at 2:00 PM on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Saturday.The Eccentric Bagel closes at 3:00 PM on Friday.The Eccentric Bagel closes at 1:00 PM on Sunday.

Mon ClosedTue-Thu 7:00 AM - 2:00 PMFri 7:00 AM - 3:00 PMSat 8:00 AM - 2:00 PMSun 8:00 AM - 1:00 PM

Payment methods

Does The Eccentric Bagel take credit cards?

Yes, The Eccentric Bagel takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does The Eccentric Bagel have catering options?

Yes, The Eccentric Bagel does have catering options.

Does The Eccentric Bagel have a drive thru?

No, The Eccentric Bagel does not have a drive thru.

Does The Eccentric Bagel serve alcohol?

No, The Eccentric Bagel does not serve alcohol.

Indoor Amenities

Does The Eccentric Bagel allow dogs?

Yes, The Eccentric Bagel allows dogs.

Does The Eccentric Bagel have TVs?

No, The Eccentric Bagel does not have TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does The Eccentric Bagel have bike parking?

Yes, The Eccentric Bagel has bike parking.

Does The Eccentric Bagel have outdoor seating?

Yes, The Eccentric Bagel has outdoor seating options.

Does The Eccentric Bagel have parking?

Yes, The Eccentric Bagel has parking options. Private Lot Parking, Street Parking

Other Amenities

Is The Eccentric Bagel wheelchair accessible?

Yes, The Eccentric Bagel is wheelchair accessible.

Does The Eccentric Bagel have free WiFi?

No, The Eccentric Bagel does not have free WiFi.

From the Business

Specialties

Indulge in a whimsical culinary escapade at Eccentric Bagel! This vibrant spot seamlessly merges 80s disco vibes with Willy Wonka's whimsy, presenting an eclectic array of twisted bagels bursting with flavor. From beloved classics to inventive concoctions like cheddar burst or tomato sun-dried tomato and Italian herbs, there's a bagel to suit every palate.But that's not all – Eccentric Bagel elevates snacking with its unparalleled bagel chips, boasting flavor explosions that will thrill your taste buds. Whether you crave something savory, sweet, or somewhere in between, these chips are sure to satisfy. Step outside and enjoy the inviting outdoor seating, where you can soak up the island vibes while savoring your delicious treats. And be greeted with a warm hello from the friendliest owner, aka the Chief Bagel Officer, and their welcoming staff! As autumn and winter roll in, Eccentric Bagel starts creating their made-to-order pot pies, featuring savory delights such as short rib, chicken, or lobster, all freshly made and ready for your oven. With its lively ambiance and Instagram-worthy decor, this isn't just a dining experience – it's a visual feast waiting to be shared with your followers! And here's a little secret – Eccentric Bagel's bagels have been hailed as better than any NYC bagel! Get ready for an unforgettable experience that will leave you yearning for more. Prepare to snap, bite, and relish your way through this gem!

Ask the Community - The Eccentric Bagel

You might also consider

Marie Eiffel Market

3.4(94 reviews)

0.7 mi

•$$$

Excellent food. The croissants are luscious - right from the oven if you get there early and I…read morehighly recommend the cheese danish as well. Honestly, everything is good! All fresh and wonderful. If you want to enjoy a dinner take out, grab the fried chicken. It's not your usual highly encrusted breaded chicken but very tasty and light at the same time. The store has various fresh vegetables and seasonal items, along with expensive Eiffel t shirts ($60) and cute straw beach bags to buy along with a bank of refrigerators and freezers filled with drinks- some alcoholic. Pre made frozen food is available, as well as items such as tuna salad. All are pricey (pint of tuna salad was $16) but excellent. Smaller frozen thin pizzas (about $20) ranging from cheese to artichoke topped are available also. Great for dinner with a salad. Coffee is available in the back and delicious breakfast sandwiches are available to order also. You can dine outdoors either at tables in front of the store, or in the back on a small deck overlooking the harbor. Often lovely Marie is there, chatting with diners. All in all a wonderful place, with great food. Be aware you will be paying absolute top dollar, but worth it.

I'm giving you three stars instead of the five you deserve. My main complaint? No bathrooms. You…read morehave to go OUTSIDE to use a freaking bathroom after you pay astronomical prices for food that you can get in NYC easily CHEAPER. The food is good but my veggie burger was salty, the buns were over baked. Impossible to eat. The French Onion soup was decent but I have certainly had better. After all of this, we have to go outside for a piss.

Turkey Meatball Sandwich

See all

Outdoor seating

Pip’s Cafe and Provisions

4.6(19 reviews)

2.0 mi

Excellent coffee (love that they source their beans from Counter Culture)…read more Adorable shop, with comfortable indoor and outdoor seating. Free refills on drip coffee. And shockingly fair prices, especially compared to nearby shops (cough, Aldo's).

This is a great little spot for a quick breakfast, lunch or snack. I had the chocolate stuffed…read morecroissant. It was huge! The chocolate was chocolaty and delicious. The croissant was airy, flakey and buttery -- a perfect combination. I recommend and I would go back.

Cozy interior of Pip's Cafe & Provisions in Greenport on the North Fork of Long Island.

Pip's ready-to-eat summer kale salad.

See all

Pip's classic egg and cheese sandwich on a house-made milk bun.

Aldos Coffee

4.1(249 reviews)

1.9 mi

Locally owned & operated

Outdoor seating

Amazing place, great coffee!!! I love the people here and they are so sweet. I loooooooooove it…read morehere. Especially the barista named faith

Today, I was a first time visitor of Greenport. I was advised to stop by Aldos for a coffee. When I…read morewalked in, I was greeted by Josh (assuming the owner/member of staff) who shook my hand and we had a lovely yet brief chat. This was incredibly refreshing coming from the city. Josh, thank you!! If you are in town, please stop by!!

See all

House crafted Espresso Martini

Encanto Crepes & cafe

4.8(46 reviews)

1.9 mi

Very nice cute spot seems like a family establishment. It reminds me of Columbia. It's very good…read morethe crepes are very good coffee reminds me of Columbia it's nice right on the corner heart of green point. The girls was very helpful and friendly. I would definitely go back there just for this place. Very clean nice tables and affordable.

LOVE Encanto - visit Greenport every summer and visit Encanto every time. Excellent coffee, crapes…read moreand the friendliness owner and staff. Highly recommend

The counter where you order

See all

Macchiato Espresso Bar

4.6(12 reviews)

10.9 mi

I stopped by during my drive out east and ordered a Nutella toasted marshmallow latte. The cup was…read morelined with Nutella and topped with toasted marshmallows. It's more of a sweet treat than an everyday coffee, but they had many other options for everyday coffee. Along with my coffee, I ordered a corn muffin and a chocolate muffin. The muffins were big, not dry and perfectly sweet. All of the bakery items looked amazing. They also serve sandwiches which I plan to try next time. They have many tables inside, as well as outside tables during the warmer months. I highly recommend stopping here on your way out east.

They always warn you (they being Yelp CMs and the like) about making sure to post those pics in…read moreyour camera roll. I really do take far too many photos, but it's helpful because then I remember there are spots I may have forgotten to write up like Macchiato Espresso Bar. I visited this cute Mattituck location back in late August and the results were pretty tasty. You see my wife and I were looking for some coffee and a place that's different than what we've often found on the North Fork and so MEB popped up as an option. Not a ton of reviews were posted, but from the ones on Yelp (and dare I say Google too) made it seem worthy of stopping. The worthiness is definitely there because Macchiato has a nice array of coffee options as well as pastries and more elaborate edibles (sandwiches, salads, etc.). You can find everything on their menus though you won't find too much else inside as the place is definitely small. A couple of tables, some fridge drinks and pre-maid foods, and an area of swag and other items is the entirety of the interior so don't expect any true cozy feels. But hey, you can't drink cozy (well maybe in the Fall/Winter), and so let's turn our attention back to the name of this place and focus on coffee. I went with an iced latte with vanilla while my wife tried the iced chocolate (as it was written on the menu). For me, I liked mine. Nothing negative to necessarily say about it as it had a good coffee kick, but when my wife felt like hers was a little too heavy in the bitter bang before the chocolate took over, I decided for us to switch drinks as I thought the iced chocolate was delightful (I do like my coffee a little stronger). Before finishing up, I do want to mention that we were a bit hungry and so one of the chocolate croissants in the display case made its way into our possession. The funny interaction my wife had with the friendly staff member ("Is that a chocolate croissant?" "You know it is!") added to our excitement and oh did it pay off as it tasted delicious. Overall, Macchiato Espresso Bar had a lot to like. Perhaps they're a little small, but they pack some good coffee and pastry/food choices in an area that really doesn't have a ton of options. I'd definitely return another time when out east and in search of my morning cup of joe along with a desire for a bite to eat. And with that I can now post some very belated pics with this review so the CMs stay off my back!

Order up area.

See all

Pastries and menu

The Café

4.4(88 reviews)

34.5 mi

Heading to an event at the United theater next door so we stopped in for dinner at The Cafe. What…read morea cute place! Dim lit. Gold trim. Enormous mirror above the bar. As we entered and did not have a reservation, we were seated at the bar. I can share- they did not fill up! We could easily been seated at a table but the bar was not an issue. Nice guys working the bar. We went very simple: tomato soup that comes with focaccia grilled cheese. The tomato soup was delivered with balsamic drizzle and anice grilled cheese stick. It was a great meal for a rainy day. It was good. We opted to share a dessert: sticky toffee pudding. It was soft and the caramel was sweet and smooth. DELICIOUS! Overall great experience. I would definitely return to The Cafe if in teh area again.

Visited for dinner without reservation after nearby troll trip. Enjoyed the ambience of the…read morerestaurant. It was yakitori night so we started with some chicken and pork belly. Took a while to arrive. The pork belly was exquisitely rendered with beautifully charred skin and tender meat. Lobster roll served warm was very good, the lobster was a little overcooked but still a highlight. Buttermilk Fried Chicken had super crisp skin and was executed and presented perfectly, great tasting together with the accompanied pickled vegetables and hot-honey butter. The best dish of the night. Sticky toffee pudding was as good as advertised: sticky, textured, with interesting mouthfeel offset by lightly whipped cream. Tequila based El Mariachi was tasty and balanced but not memorable.

Manchego croquettes

See all

Rumspresso & Tonic

Stone Street Cafe

3.8(28 reviews)

3.8 mi

Love everything about this place. Great layout and atmosphere, wonderful service team,…read moreindoor/outdoor seating, great coffee and barista drinks, and all fresh food. They have "everyday" food and also some fancy stuff, also really good grab-n-go premade stuff. I think their bacon egg cheese is one of the best you will find anywhere. Their homemade hot sauce is perfectly flavorful and not flexing heat.

Very cool spot with a specific menu. Everything we torres was absolutely delish…read more Something to note-they don't really customize menus nor orders. Try to know what you want prior to arriving at the counter if it's busy . Very fresh food Delicious and well presented. We popped in on a Sunday Am Around 11 and the food took a long while to come out but totally worth it! Had the choc cookies which were like a brownie. -they were fab and out of this world!

Bacon egg cheese.

See all

Carissa’s Bakery

3.8(62 reviews)

12.2 mi

The pastries here are divine. My favorite is their raisin snail, I love how flakey it is and has a…read morenice sweet apricot aroma taste on the outside . Their baked miso chocolate chip cookies is an absolute die for as well-Tate's bakery can never! & can we talk about their Chicken banh mi its super savory, has the perfect crunch and a nice kick to it. The bakery is definitely more elevated compared to any bakeries in the Hamptons. I happened to take a glance of the kitchen when I was waiting to use the restroom and saw how serious they are when it comes to cleanliness. It was my second time there and definitely coming back again! I wish they had locations in NYC they would kill it!

Stopped in here to get a few bakery items and coffee. Everything looks great, but the taste wasn't…read more100% there. The pistachio chocolate cross ain't had artificial green dye and the taste wasn't great. Got a chocolate slice of some time of bread was a little dry and then also a raspberry almond tart which lacked flavor. Overall the breads looked good next time I will try those.

Pistachio chocolate croissant

See all

Matcha latte

Main Street Market

4.7(3 reviews)

13.2 mi

Main Street Market is a relatively new addition (as of June 30, 2024) to Main Street in the…read morecharming town center of Southampton. The menu offers a lovely range of sweet treats that can be paired with their coffee offerings as well as savory light meal options, which pair nicely with their wines-by-the-glass. Guests order and pick up food from the counter, then, if dining in, they can choose from ample seating both inside and outside. The inside is very casual, half first-come seating and half grocery store. Staff is friendly and efficient, making this a really nice option for a quick sit-down bite on Main Street without waiting for a full-service table, and prices are reasonable given the area. Shoppers can pick up gourmet pantry staples, including gluten free pasta. Special shout-out for the creative vegetarian and vegan options.

I loved coming to the business before, Second Nature Market, and was devastated when they retired…read moreand closed. However I love what they did with the place even more than how it was before. Healthy cafe type menu- avocado toasts, overnight oats, fancy sandwiches, salads... Pura Vida type, but for actually a very fair price for Southampton, considering the quality. And the coffee options are diverse and excellent. So much better than Starbucks, for the same price. The overnight oats were delicious. Almost like rice pudding. The staff were friendly and very nice (unlike the old lady who worked there before!) Takes cash.

See all

Coffee

Amber Waves

3.9(50 reviews)

13.2 mi

Love coming here when in town. Great selection of fresh produce and a small selection of dairy free…read moreand gluten free products. As a private chef, it's a vital part of my "ammo" when in town for work. Also, cool merch as well!

Very high prices, but the quality of fresh fruits and vegetables is hard to measure…read more I'd go more often if the staff weee more focused on providing some level of service. The only bathroom is a porta potty

Fresh herbs and veggies

See all

Shop interior

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

9 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Summer Y.

4 years ago

This spot offers the best bagels I have ever tasted. They're a gourmet bagel, and they have a great variety of flavors to choose from (my fav is Rosemary & Salt & Everything). Whether you're a fan of a classic everything bagel or you're in the mood for something a bit more adventurous, the Eccentric Bagel got you covered. But the bagels aren't the only standout item on the menu. The short rib pot pie is a delectable treat that I would highly recommend. The savory filling is perfectly complemented by the flaky pastry crust. It's the perfect comfort food for a chilly day. In addition to the great food, the staff at the Eccentric Bagel is really friendly and welcoming. The charming owner is always around to strike up a conversation and make sure that everyone feels special. And the 80s decor adds a fun and quirky touch to the whole experience. All in all, I would highly recommend the Eccentric Bagel! The food is delicious, the staff is wonderful, and the atmosphere is one of a kind. read more

J G.

2 years ago

So, I finally went to check out Eccentric Bagel to see what all the hype was about. And let me tell you, it totally lived up to it! Their Bacon, Egg, and Cheese on a rosemary and salt bagel was out of this world, and those bagel chips? Well, let's just say they didn't last long once I got my hands on them! Eccentric Bagel definitely knows how to do bagels like you never knew a bagel could be, and I'm already counting down the days until my next visit! read more

Mike G.

1 year ago

Wow! We stumbled upon this little cool bagel shop. The best bagels out east by far. The New Yorker is a real classic a must try! Cold brew is great too! Quality, delicious & friendly. A must go for your bagel cravings read more

Esther B.

2 years ago

the service was phenomena, staff was super helpful, the ambiance was great, and the food was outstanding. amazing experience over all, definnnnnitely coming back! read more

Ashley G.

5 years ago

I cant count how many times I've been here, it's so good. I've had rosemary sea salt, jalapeño cheddar and black & white sesame ..: they were all AMAZING . read more

Amy S.

5 months ago

Delicious bagels. Overstuffed sandwiches. Really nice owners. Great place for breakfast or lunch. Also best coffee on the island !

A A.

1 year ago

Great for breakfast & lunch!! Shelter Islands best addition We went for brunch is was sooo good! must go and eat the best bagels

Marsha M.

2 years ago

Proud to support a business that supports Israel! Terrific food, excellent service, and a moral compass. A winning combination!

Naomi O.

2 years ago

Food is phenomenal! Great service! I plan to go back again the next time I'm in the area.

The Eccentric Bagel - bagels - Updated November 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Shelter Island, New York Restaurants near The Eccentric Bagel

BEST of Shelter Island, New York Things to Do near The Eccentric Bagel

BEST of Shelter Island, New York Coffee near The Eccentric Bagel

BEST of Shelter Island, New York Breakfast near The Eccentric Bagel

BEST of Shelter Island, New York Desserts near The Eccentric Bagel

BEST of Shelter Island, New York Cocktail Bars near The Eccentric Bagel

BEST of Shelter Island, New York Pizza near The Eccentric Bagel

BEST of Shelter Island, New York Shopping near The Eccentric Bagel

BEST of Shelter Island, New York Thrift Stores near The Eccentric Bagel

People found The Eccentric Bagel by searching for…

Restaurants in Shelter Island, NY

Bakeries in Shelter Island, NY

Coffee in Shelter Island, NY

Breakfast in Shelter Island, NY

Delis in Shelter Island, NY

Sandwiches in Shelter Island, NY

Lunch in Shelter Island, NY

Gluten Free Bagel in Shelter Island, NY

Hip New Restaurants in Shelter Island, NY

Dog Friendly Restaurants in Shelter Island, NY

Clam Chowder Bread Bowl in Shelter Island, NY

Chips and Salsa in Shelter Island, NY

Fancy Lunch Restaurants in Shelter Island, NY

Family Friendly Restaurants in Shelter Island, NY

Vegan Birthday Cake in Shelter Island, NY

Sunday Brunch for Large Group in Shelter Island, NY

Late Night Study Spots in Shelter Island, NY

Iced Tea in Shelter Island, NY

Places to Study in Shelter Island, NY

Places to Study Free Wifi in Shelter Island, NY

Food and Beer in Shelter Island, NY

Holiday Lunch in Shelter Island, NY

Latte Art in Shelter Island, NY

Cozy Coffee Shop in Shelter Island, NY

Best of Shelter Island

Things to do in Shelter Island

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed The Eccentric Bagel also viewed

Goldberg's

3.6

(169 reviews)

Goldberg great breakfast place, foods good and fast but the problem is it takes so long. There is…read morealways a line out the door, but overall it's fine. Good ambiance.

I like Goldberg's but the lines are unbearable. Call ahead always. The young man who works the…read morecashier at the East Hampton location is the best. Overall good food but not worth the wait if you don't call ahead.

Goldberg's Famous Bagels

3.9

(8 reviews)

Wow, lots of choices! Quite a place. Can only imagine the crowds in season. Not much activity this…read moremorning. Very good bagel sandwich but not the best I've had. Good spot along the highway. Lots of parking and inside/outside dining.

My husband's breakfast sandwich was cold, so we had to ask them to reheat it. Since it was a…read moremorning rush, we told them to just stick it in the microwave to not cause trouble. But why would a breakfast sandwich be cold anyways? Like you can see the cold cheese unmelted in it. My husband surmised that since it was a holiday weekend and they expected crowds they precooked everything (precooked egg, precooked sausage) and threw it together. Then to top it all off, we found a piece of plastic in his sandwich. Easy enough to pick it out, so it was fine, but again - why? 3 stars because mine was good. Would give them another try on a non-holiday weekend. They might have just been busy.

Goldberg's Famous Bagels

3.6

(128 reviews)

Good selection of bagels. Got the "Hobo" breakfast sandwich on Egg Bagel. Fantastic…read more Would definitely recommend / return Nice prompt service even on a busy morning. 5/5

Moments after I placed my order, I noticed the flat bagel sandwiches and started second-guessing my…read morechoice. When I heard another customer order one, that sealed it--I decided to change mine. I asked the woman who took my order if I could switch; she hesitated, likely because my bagel was already toasted, but then quickly agreed and handled it. It felt a bit awkward for a moment, but customer-service-wise it was the right move. This is a legendary bagel shop and worth a stop if you're nearby. The bacon, egg, and cheese I ordered was a bit dry--being toasted without a smear made it come off a little crusty. Next time I'd definitely get a smear, or maybe not have it toasted at all. The highlight, surprisingly, was the heavy-duty sweatshirt I bought as a souvenir--honestly felt even heavier than Carhartt. Tip: Go for the flat bagel version and don't skip the smear.

Hampton Bays Bagels

3.7

(38 reviews)

This is an amazing place with fresh food, an extremely varied menu, a clean environment (&…read morebathroom) and managed by the owner and staff who are both hard working and go out of their way to make you feel welcome...they'll bring your order right to the table for you! Don't miss it!!

Trust the reviews on this one. On Long Island we have some of the best bagels. Unfortunately they…read moreare not at this place. Bagels are subpar. Cream cheese is a little off and I ordered a toasted bagel with butter and as you can see by the picture it is barely toasted. The staff was very friendly and nice, but the processes of how they operate are not efficient. Not yo mention it took almost 15 minutes for a toasted bagel with butter and a bagel with cream cheese. To note, there was no one waiting ahead of me. Just 2 people who had ordered prior to me walking in. They offer many other sandwiches , smoothies and other things that might be good but this is not a good representation of bagels on the island. Maybe travel a little further down the road for a bagel.

Bagels N Brunch

3.7

(55 reviews)

I recently hosted a post wedding brunch and could not have been happier with the food and service…read more Kathy was very helpful, food was delicious. It was packaged nicely and was ready when promised. Highly recommend.

Yesterday,October 31st, my wife and I went to Bagels and Brunch for breakfast. Great sunny morning…read more As I got to the counter, I order BLT on rye. I've done many many times before in last 34 years leaving in the USA. Nasty respond from the lady at counter "what?". I repeat, "BLT ON TOSTED RYE BREAD PLEASE". Same nasty attitude and then finally the lady looks at me an in a load voice saying " I don't speak foreign languages". Writes the order, throws panicle on the table and leaves. I look at the other lady staying next to an observing the "comedy" and ask what just happened? The answer was , you have an accent. I cancelled the order and left, never again I'll come back to the place.

Black Sheep Bagles - Cutchogue

3.9

(26 reviews)

As someone who has been gluten free for 6 years - this is the best gluten free bagel I have ever…read morehad. So fluffy and moist - I would have been nervous it wasn't gluten free had I ordered this without 2 of my friends getting gluten full bagels & seeing what theirs looked like - THATS how good it was

Great little coffee, bagel, and lunch spot in North Fork-specifically, Cutchogue…read more My friends are North Fork residences and hosted us for a long and lovely weekend; Black Sheep is their prefered bagel spot in the area, so we ordered breakfast pickup for five of us. The order included a handful of the *must-try* breakfast bagels, tofu bagel, and a gluten-free bagel for moi. Topped it off with OJ and iced coffee.

Sean's Place

3.8

(5 reviews)

Perfect take out food place in south Hampton. I love my egg wraps with tomatoes and mushrooms very…read moredelicious and the ice coffee is strong and bold great way to start the day. Seans place establishment is very clean and the service is excellent!!!!!!!

Pretty decent deli to get a good egg and cheese roll. I…read moreopted for a croissant and was thrilled the eggs were cooked to a nice firm center and the cheese A traditional American yellow slice was ooey gooey melty!!! Didn't need and salt just a Lil' black pepper and hot sauce!

Country Heroes

4.1

(49 reviews)

My family has been enjoying food from here for over 15 years!…read moreIt's our favorite location for heroes, lunch and dinner platters! Service is always friendly and the food is always fresh. Some of our favorites are: - Turkey hero with the works - Chicken cutlet hero - Chicken tenders platter with seasoned waffle fries. - Onion rings - Honestly, any hero with your favorite filling will be yummy!

A must when you're in the area. They've been here forever. Incredibly diverse and creative sandwich…read moremenu. They can make you anything. Old school vibes, and very welcoming, friendly staff. People might complain about the price increase, and I can understand that, but you get a massive meal and I'd much rather give them my money than any of the bougie places in the area.

Grindstone Coffee & Donuts

4.3

(255 reviews)

Loved this coffee place!! Went back twice since it was so good! The workers were very friendly &…read morehelped me order my drink. Both of my drinks were delicious! This place also has donuts that look amazing, I would try them as well.

There are no prices listed anywhere. Living out here has become so surreal. Is it that hard to add…read morea price to the huge board that lists doughnut flavors? I guess I'm the first person to actually ask how much the doughnuts cost. They're 5$ a pop, btw. That said, not a bad doughnut.

Bagel Lovers

3.8

(32 reviews)