I've been wanting to try this place for a long time but was always there during lunch, and Doughfellas is only open from 5pm to 9:30 pm. Finally, I hit the jackpot and was able to drop in. And jackpot it was. The Atmosphere: The outside looks like a place that's been closed for years but, don't let the outside fool you, this place is for real! The inside is also the bare minimum with two large (3-4 people) and three small (2 people) tables, counter service and a small accoutrement table. Bare minimum would be the words that come to mind. The Service: Although, as I previously mentioned, the only service is counter service, the service was five star. The young man was informative and, with the multitude of toppings, extremely helpful. Our orders came quickly in about 10 minutes. The Food: The sign says sour dough pizza which I've never had but, why not. And so, we ordered three small 14" pizzas; one Margarita pizza, one Calabresa pizza and one Spinach and Goat Cheese pizza. All were fantastic! Super toppings, great crust (my lovely bride never eats the crust and she not only ate hers but tried, unsuccessfully I might add, to finish off mine), everything totally fresh! The only issue... there wasn't enough goat cheese on the Spinach and Goat Cheese pizza. We let the staff know about the issue and it was rectified immediately! The Bottom Line: As with all my reviews, my bottom line or "customer so what" is would I come back? The answer is an emphatic yes! You'll enjoy one of the best pizzas around. read more

See all

Service 10/10 Service was amazing. We traveled here from Louisville, Kentucky for vacation. When we arrived they explained their menu to us. Going in the first thing I noticed was how amazing the smell of the pizza was. The staff were friendly and helpful in explaining the choices. Food - 10/10 My partner and I ordered a half and half Pizza. He's basic and just got cheese, while I guess I'm extra and got the Calabresa. It has the best and freshest ingredients by far on any pizza I've ever had. The sausage was so good and you could tell the pizza was made tender love and care. This pizza to me is smack your mama level of pizza! My partners only complaint was that a little of my ingredients got on his side of the pizza. (More on this below.) Allergy - 10/10 The staff was considerate of my food allergies and friendly. I'm not sure if they have gluten free options as I don't have this allergy but I'm sure if you call a head they can answer any questions you may have. Environment / Ambiance - 10/10 The place is cute, comfortable, quant, and cozy. We didn't feel cramped and there was a steady stream of customers throughout our time there. Restrooms - There didn't appear to be any restrooms / we also didn't ask. I would say make sure you use the restroom before you go or order it for pickup and take it home with you. This is probably my biggest gripe. Being out of town not sure how common this is. Sensory - 10/10 Sight - the light level was well lit and not overwhelming. Clean and not overwhelming with lots of unnecessary items. Smell - clean and fermented pizza smell. Touch - the chairs were comfortable with some cloth fabrics. Sound - below Noise Level - 10/10 Place doesn't have any music playing which is what I prefer. I don't like to not be able to have conversation with others. LGBTQ+ Rating - 8/10 Me and my partner didn't receive any stares or any harassment or feel uncomfortable. No support signage visible. Would Be Back / Would Recommend - we ended up going back the next day. My partner and his mom ended up getting a cheese by themselves and I got the same as I got before. I do which they had smaller / individual size options. I would highly highly recommend this place to others as it was the best pizza I've had by far in my entire life (40 years). Total Score 9/10 4.75 / 5 read more

The Doughfellas - Calabresa Tomato sauce, mozzarella, sliced smoked in-house calabresa sausage, kalamata olives and sliced onions. - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

What a treat! A friend and I met for dinner and decided to try this spot after seeing its impressive 4.8 rating on Yelp and it absolutely lived up to the hype. We actually had a funny start to the evening as we accidentally sat at the restaurant next door and didn't realize it until the waitress brought out a menu with rice dishes. That's when we knew something was off! Once we made our way to the right place, everything fell into place perfectly. We started with a fresh salad, then had two pizzas: the cheesy chicken and a white pizza (no onions). Both were outstanding-flavorful, perfectly cooked, and incredibly satisfying. Every bite was delicious. From the moment we walked in, the service was warm and welcoming. The woman at the front took her time explaining the menu, which made ordering easy and enjoyable. The restaurant itself is clean, organized, and inviting, with photos of the pizzas on display that make it even more appealing. I'm already looking forward to my next visit and this place is definitely going into my regular rotation. read more

See all

All we saw was the word "Dough" from the road and decided to try it because homemade dough always makes the best pizza. We were not disappointed. The pizza crust is more like flatbread than a typical pizza. It was thin and tender. We had the cheesy chicken which was delish. We even tried it with the hot honey on it to give it a sweet kick. It is a small place with only five tables with many orders for take out. We ate inside at a round table and watched part of the World Cup listening to blues(?) music. It was great. read more

We have lived in Pompano and didn't know this gem was located here this whole entire time! We were recommended to come by our neighbors who raved about the pizza/people and were really glad we were finally about to come and try it. The dough of the pizza is so fluffy and airy, very delicious and not overpowering with the sauce or toppings. We had the Margherita pizza and their garlic bread which isn't your typical kind buns/knots. It's large enough to share (6 pieces). The people are genuinely so kind and helpful when looking at the menu while trying to decide what to order. We of course, now crave their pizza and don't want pizza if it's not from Doughfellas! There are so many other items (salads, focaccia, pizzas etc) that we would love to try!! read more

The Doughfellas - Margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

See all

Found The Doughfellas randomly on Google Maps, and just like Bob Ross would say, what a happy little accident that was! Came in the evening, and thankfully it wasn't too busy. It is definitely a smaller place, and there are only a handful of tables. Since it was our first time, and they have a sizable menu that all looks delicious, a super nice woman at the counter helped us make a few decisions. We ended up getting two canned drinks, the burrata focaccina, a 12" spinach goat cheese, and a 12" white pizza. First things first, you are definitely going to have leftovers! The focaccina was surprisingly huge. The cold burrata, on the hot focaccia was sensory heaven. The olives and drizzle of olive oil added such a nice rich, salty, subtle flavor that elevated it so much. The spinach goat cheese was good, but it was really really wet. They serve them on these little cardboard type pizza placemats. And the cardboard was ripping because of all the moisture. I dont know if I would get it again, but it was delicious in the moment. Hands down, the best pizza was the White pizza. One of the best white pizzas I've ever had. The pizza is definitely floppy, and wet like I mentioned, because of the ingredients, and the pistachio added such a nice texture to the softness of the pizza. The truffle was not at all overpowering, which tends to happen a lot with truffle dishes at other restaurants. It also had these little roasted onion petals on it which was unique to me, I've never seen that before. The sourdough crust even had such a light, but crisp wonderful flavor. Highly, highly recommend this pizza. Because of the wetness of the ingredients and the floppiness of the pizza, I would say that this is pizza that you would want to eat fresh, at the restaurant. Though I'm sure you could pop it in the airfryer to firm it up a bit. It is certainly not a cheap meal, but it is 100% worth it. With two canned drinks, the focaccina and the two 12" pizzas, the total was a little over $60. Because of the priciness, it's not some place that I would go regularly, but I will definitely be back and take my friends and family here for those one-off dinners. read more

See all

Stopped in for a quick bite on a Sunday night - small and quiet spot in a small plaza. We were greeted by the owner herself who explained a little bit about the menu and offered up the most popular pizzas to try. We did half-and-half (greatly appreciated option) and chose the chicken catupiry and the calabrese. Both were good but the chicken catupiry is something special! I had never heard of catupiry cheese and was very excited to try it - delicious! I agree with another reviewer who mentioned the slices are floppy - the dough was a little soft and could benefit from being cooked a little longer. I'll likely request that next time. Overall, would highly recommend and will definitely be coming back. read more

The Doughfellas - Half and half - top is chicken catupiry and bottom is calabrese - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

Great find! We were in the mood for pizza and I remembered I had been wanting to try this spot. Parking was limited but we found a spot on the side next to the deli. When you come in, you order at the front and then have a seat while you wait for the food. There aren't many tables available but we were able to get one. The service was amazing. The entire staff is so friendly and helpful. After a few recommendations we knew what we wanted to try. Our food came out very quickly. We loved their pizzas, we ordered two 14 inch pies. - The pepperoni, which was everyone's favorite. 5/5 - For the second pie we ordered 1/2 white pizza (Fresh Mozzarella, Ricotta, Roasted Onion Wedges, Pistachio, Basil + Truffle Oil) this was very tasty, the whole pistachios were very different but pleasant. I seemed to be the only one in my party to like this one but I'm fine with that , more for me lol. 4/5 - The other half was Chicken Catupiry (Tomato sauce, mozzarella, shredded rosemary chicken, catupiry cheese and Grana Padano Parmesan). This was good as well but a bit soggy. 4/5 All in all this was a pleasant experience. We had great food that came out quickly along with excellent service. They provide a nice warm atmosphere and I for sure would come back! read more

The Doughfellas - Pepperoni pizza - excellent - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

See all

The BEST pizza!!! We come here every week and it never disappoints. No pizza anywhere in the area even comes close. The dough they use is NEXT LEVEL. Trust us! read more

The Doughfellas - 14" Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

I love this quaint, local pizzeria. They're perfect for Takeaway or dine in as there are a few tables in their location. They use amazing ingredients on everything it's always so fresh. This is the closest I have come to Italian style pizza outside of Italy. Their product is a testament to their Italian heritage! The staff is sweet and will give you great recommendations your first and every time! read more

Best pizza I've ever had. Just everything perfect about it. Look no further, buy from here.

We recently discovered this place on Yelp and are thrilled we did. We drove all the way from Coral Springs to try it out, and it was worth every mile. The highlight of our visit was meeting the owner, Andre, whose warmth and passion for pizza truly enhanced our experience. His enthusiasm was contagious and added a special touch to our meal. He greeted us when we walked in and was so nice and explained everything to us. He also treated us with a nice chocolate mouse desert. We tried the pizza at Doughfellas, and it was absolutely delicious! The crust was perfectly crispy, the sauce was unmistakably homemade, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. Overall, it was a fantastic dining experience made even more memorable by a wonderful owner. Here's what we ordered: 1. Focaccina Rosemary with a side of pizza sauce. 2. 12" Half Pepperoni and Half Margherita and Prosciutto pizza. So delicious! 3. 12" White Pizza with Truffle Oil, Fresh Mozzarella, Ricotta, Roasted Onion Wedges, Pistachio, Basil, and Truffle Oil. Amazing! 4. 12" Prosciutto Pizza (to go - AMAZING!). 5. Taramasu 6. Chocolate mousse Thank you Andre for making Ashley's and I's visit the best, we definitely will be back. read more

See all

I wasn't in the mood to cook last night and found this place. The ratings were really good and the photos were appealing. After picking them up and getting home I took a bite of the margherita first and, to be honest, the flavor was great. Normally this pizza is good but theirs was fresh and, although it was originally purchased for my wife, I enjoyed a few slices myself! The pepperoni was very good but wasn't as tasty as the margherita. Their crust was extremely soft and it wasn't overly filling, it was just right. Very enjoyable pizza on a night when I did not want to do anything. read more

The Doughfellas - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

See all

The food here is unbelievable. Not sure we can bear to eat pizza from another place. Brought the leftovers home and ate every bite. It's very casual in here and the staff is down to earth as well. And you can't not get the chocolate mousse. Best we've ever had in our lives. read more

Phenomenal experience. What a fabulous local spot. Food was incredibly delicious, and Lilia is such a hospitable staffer. Will def be back! read more

I feel comfortable saying The Doughfellas is the best pizza in South Florida. Ok, a bold statement but let me tell you why I think. The Doughfellas is situated in a little plaza in Pompano right off of Federdal Highway. There a few designated parking spaces which is more than enough for the quaint interior. There are no more than 5-10 tables inside, which you can choose to enjoy your meal at or if you're like me they serve as a great resting spot while they box up your order. I always call ahead and have never had to wait longer than 20 minutes for my order to be ready. Quick and delicious?! Sign me up. Ok, on to the things that matter. We always start with a burrata salad. You get two fresh burrata balls, sliced in half and topped with freshly slice small tomatoes, black olives, fresh basil, olive oil, and balsamic glaze. It's always perfectly seasoned with salt and pepper. The simplicity allows each ingredient to shine. Next, the pies. We feel strongly about our choices so we always order two. A margarita and the calabresa, which we get well-done. The margarita is generously topped with fresh tomato sauce, mozzarella, basil, and a drizzle of olive oil. Crispy and classic. The calabresa is an unexpected combo of thinly shaved sausage, onions and olives. I have always added hot honey to the pie, which is now an option to have them add in store! It's savory, salty, and the hot honey just makes this pie next level! The crust on any of their pies is light, perfectly fermented to allow for chew, air bubbles, and crisp! If you're still hungry, they offer homemade desserts, tiramisu being our go to. The perfect size for one, or two if you're stuffed but need a little something sweet. The Doughfellas has become a Friday tradition for us, and something I look forward to start the weekend with. The fresh ingredients and care that is put into each and every order is wonderful. The owners are caring and so friendly, and part of what makes this restaurant a true gem! read more

See all

This place was incredible! Everything! The food, the service, all of it! The most delicious pizzas and desserts. Seriously amazing!

The best pizza in town!!! Super nice people and warm casual atmosphere. Great salads and fresh burrata, and maybe the best homemade chocolate mousse anywhere. We come all the time and recommend to all our friends. read more

Great little place for Artisan style pizza, all are made to order, no slices available. Not many tables but we ordered for takeout and it was prepared very quickly. read more

So we ordered a fresh pie and garlic bread for dinner for delivery. When it got here everything was COLD, not even warm. The garlic bread isn't cut so it's just a giant piece of bread. They get an A+ for presentation and the flavor, but only once we threw it in the air fryer to heat it all up again... I hate having to reheat food when I'm starving and already waited forever for the food to get here. The pizzas are super overpriced, but maybe that's because I ordered delivery, I'm not really sure. Again, only getting a 3 star for taste and presentation, otherwise I'm annoyed that I spent so much money for cold to the touch food. Update: now I'm more annoyed because whatever customer this manager is referring to that called their restaurant was in fact NOT me. Lol So before assuming you should probably ask for a phone call first. The driver had one stop and it was me... and I paid priority to make sure of that. This also confirms this happens more often than not.... Which makes me feel like I made a pretty good review. I won't change my view or review. Have a good one. read more

The Doughfellas - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

See all

Friend recommend this spot and I was not disappointed. Visited in a Friday evening to satisfy a pizza craving and we were not disappointed. The person at the counter was super friendly and explained the menu in great detail. The location is very chill and has indoor seating and an outdoor waiting area (it gets pretty busy). We went with two 14 inch pizzas (one half margarita half Portuguesa and one half calabresa half chicken catupiry). We also had the tiramisu. We really loved the pizza and will be visiting in the near future. read more

The Doughfellas - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

See all

This place was absolutely delicious! Very cute family owned pizza place with fresh Ingredients. Let's start off with their wonderful staff. We were greeted upon entering and offered choices of some of their new offerings. They were very helpful and made ordering nice and smooth. Now let's talk dough. Their incredible airy dough oils be eaten all by itself. It was perfect! My family and I enjoyed a cheese pizza, Calabresa Pizza, and the Burrata Focaccina. I had never experienced black olives on a pizza the way I did tonight. There's not one thing we didn't enjoy. The staff was so friendly and helpful and the pizza was like nothing I've ever had. If your in the area, this is a MUST for all pizza lovers around. read more

See all

Ordered a margarita pizza - add pepperoni. The slices were a little floppy but the crust was very good. I also really liked the sauce. I just found that the pizza was a little salty. It could've been from the pepperoni so I will definitely try it again and will order well done. read more

The Doughfellas - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

Wow! The food here is so good and staff are so friendly. It was our first time so we wanted to try a variety- salad, garlic bread (so garlicky- in the best way) & a couple pizzas! I opted for a classic Margherita pizza and went with the suggestion of staff for one of their most popular- the chicken catupiry. The name comes from the type of cheese added- mild flavor but absolutely delicious! So glad we went with that suggestion as it was an absolute hit for us! We absolutely will come back. We ate our food in the restaurant which was small and cute. They were kind and brought everything out as it was freshly made- so it was hot and delicious! We were craving pizza and so glad we found this place to quench that desire. 10 out of 10! read more

See all

Doughfellas makes a good pie, all the reviews are correct. They are fast too, I went in and ordered and was out the door with a delicious pie in about 5 minutes. I also tried their Caesar salad which was also pretty great. The owner greeted me and went over his menu with me, which I thought was nice. Place is a little hard to get in and out of if you're driving. There isn't a ton of space inside either. Food is definitely worth the trip! read more

The Doughfellas - "A perfect cheese pizza, all for myself!" - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

Doughfellas is a great spot for pizza! While I have only ever called in my order for takeout, there is some seating inside and it has always been clean and comfortable. The service was great the last time I was in and we've never had a bad experience. I ordered the 12" Spinach Goat Cheese Pizza and it was the perfect size for dinner. The crust was great and overall the pizza was really tasty. Pro tip - if you are ordering ahead, call your order in instead of using the online portal as the online version is a little more expensive. read more

The Doughfellas - Spinach goat cheese - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

I'm actually really sad I don't have a picture of the pizza that we got due to the fact that we tried one bite and gobbled the rest down it was so DELICIOUS. My dad and I were looking for a new good pizza spot and I read the reviews on this place and it definitely did not disappoint. The ingredients you can tell are fresh and the homemade desserts were a perfect way to top off the pizza. We had The Calabrese With the sausage and olives, onions and I added hot honey. Yummmmm, but I could tell any pizza here would be amazing. Definitely my new go to. read more

A counter service establishment with 5 or so tables, the Doughfellas is a great pizza place if you like chewy, lightly charred pizzas where the focus is the dough. Everything we ordered was great. We got a '14 inch pizza and a focacciana more than enough food for two people. The physical location is pretty bare bones (although the tables were very stylish) a few tables and I didn't notice a bathroom for patrons. No worries though because the pizza came out pretty quick, was really hot, super fresh and delicious. Something cool about this place was you can take home their fresh dough to make pizza at home!! We definitely will be back to try that out. read more

See all

OMG. I love the pizza here. Highly recommended Try the specialty pizzas. Service was great as well. They have brazilian style pizzas with catupiry cheese. They also have a special Guarana. I love this place. read more

We fly from Kentucky every year to eat here if that tells you anything! It's my all time favorite pizza. The people are amazing! read more

The Doughfellas - Menu. - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

Another awesome experience at The Doughfellas, to no surprise. We called in 2 pizzas for pick up, and they were ready just about as I walked in. The customer service was great as usual. We had a margarita pizza, added pepperoni to half, and a calabresa pizza. Both were fantastic. Next time I am going to pick up some desserts too because I can't say no to tiramisu twice. Inside still smelled as good as ever with the aroma of fresh baked pizzas filling the entire shop. Looking forward to my next pizza here (and some dessert). Thanks again Doughfellas! read more

Amazing Pizza! The dough is so delicious and they are using fresh ingredients. We ordered one white pizza (fresh mozzarella, ricotta, onions, basil, pistachio and truffle oil), and a pepperoni pizza, we loved it! Super nice staff. We will definitively go back, and will recommend this place! read more

See all

This pizza is so.damn.good. At first I thought the pepperoni was sliced too thin but realized it's much more about the ah-mazing crust. And the mozzarella. Just these two alone are sooo good. Baked to perfection and greeted by friendly faces at pickup, this little joint earns my gold medal as one of the top pizzas I've ever had. And...must try the sinful Chocolate Mousse gelato. So rich, deep, delicious...concentrated. Initially looks like a little serving...but don't sleep on this!! read more

The service is top-notch - people who are friendly and care about their customers. The place is really a takeout counter but you can get very limited table service if you don't mind the feeling that you are dining at a takeout counter. The food is old school rising dough yeast or fermented crust that gets some nice charred edges on it. I can't get to a five rating simply because, even though the flavor is excellent, the crust is too soggy and thin in the center. I had the pepperoni pizza and it was on the greasy side which is a neutral for me. read more

Best pizza in Florida and great desserts, too! On top of that, it's always a great experience placing and picking up the orders. Great customer service and amazing food 100/10. read more

Not my jam........ nothing bad but I would not return. No pineapple (I know I know I'm weird) but my next fav is ham and bacon...... no bacon. Ended up with just pepperoni and garlic bread. Pizza was meh...... super greasy and just ok. Very thin crust which I appreciated. Garlic bread was also meh...... came with chunks of garlic that tasted almost like toasted almonds. Had great reviews but def not my pizza place. Wouldn't go again. read more

The pizza is fantastic and the owner and staff are so welcoming and warm. My niece and I sit there For hours over pizza catching up. And they are always so warm and welcoming encouraging us to talk. We like their pizza so much we've never tried anything else. But the stuff does look good. read more

Wow! The cheese pizza was delicious and fine quality ingredients! The house salad had fresh mixed greens including delicious spinach and actual buffalo mozzarella as well as heirloom cherries - like are you kidding me?! So delicious and just not done. Other restaurants don't do things like this. Also, the hard boiled eggs were chopped so fine and evenly distributed. Also, the vinegrette dressing was incomparable. We will be back very soon for more. Unbelievable. read more

Had the Marg pizza and the sausage / onion. Both were delicious, the quality of the ingredients can be seen and tasted. Light airy crunchy dough with a nice chew is pleasant to eat. The toppings were also quality in their own rights. read more

I walked in just after 5 on a Friday with a pizza craving, and the first thing I noticed was how good it smelled in there! It made me even hungrier. I took home 2 12-inch pizzas - 1 cheese, and 1 white, and a Cesar salad. The truffle oil on the white pizza smelled amazing, and I definitely got some looks of jealousy in the elevator when I got home home. :) The crust was perfect, the flavors were great, but that white pizza was a whole experience. I definitely should have had it with some white wine sitting next to the water. It's rich, but the melding of flavors is so nice, and feels really indulgent. Thank you for perfect pizza! I'll be coming back the next time I'm in town. read more