Friends of mine have been raving about this place for a while, and they're people whose opinions I trust when it comes to great food in the Fort Lauderdale area. We have several pizzerias within a mile of our house in the Coral Ridge area, so we're definitely not short on options. But a 3 mile plus drive for a good pie? Not a big deal. I placed my order at 6:43 p.m. and was told it would take about 15 minutes. I got there around 7:10-ish, gave them my name, paid, and was told my order would be out shortly. The place was packed, always a good sign. Pete was right there tossing dough and making pizzas, the place was clean, areas where there was seating, very busy, and had a great energy to it. If you wanted to grab a slice of pie, they definitely have those, but they also have pretty much every Italian-American comfort food you could want: rice balls, fried ravioli, garlic knots, Italian donuts, and more. I was pleasantly impressed by the selection. I found myself staring at the display case for so long that I eventually realized I had been standing there for close to 15 minutes. Then Pete yelled out, "I burned your order!" Apparently, because I order all my pies well done, he wasn't happy with how it came out and decided to make me a new one. Was I a little disappointed? Sure. But shit happens. Mistakes happen. What matters is how you handle them. It was also a Saturday night. Nothing going on at home expect dinner with the fam and a movie afterwards. About 15 minutes later, my order was ready, and Pete and his crew absolutely made it right. They threw in some garlic knots and Italian donuts and apologized a couple of times. I wasn't expecting anything at all, so the gesture was appreciated. No harm, no foul. The Review Pizza: 4/5 The pizza was really good. It was a smidge greasy, but I'm putting most of that on the pepperoni. Plus we like a little grease. The only reason I'm giving it a 4 instead of a 5 is because I think they were trying to get the pizza out quickly since I had already been waiting. The pepperoni distribution was... interesting. One slice had maybe 1-2 pieces of pepperoni, while another had approximately 12. So, naturally, the kiddo gets the 12 pepperoni slice. That said, the sauce was excellent, and the crust was fantastic, absolutely nailed the crunch. 10/10 on the crust. Garlic Knots: 5/5 These were excellent. I love garlic, and these had plenty of it without being completely overwhelmed by it. They also give you a nice portion of marinara to dip them in, which is always a plus. Italian Donuts: WOW. These might have been the surprise of the night. One had a cannoli filling and the other tasted of raspberry jam inside. But the dough was fluffy and light. Heaven. I only tried a portion of each because I want the kiddo to have some in the morning. Yes, I showed restraint. Barely. Overall I'll definitely be going back. The food was good, the atmosphere was busy and energetic, the place was clean, and most importantly, the customer service was excellent. Pete could have simply remade the pizza and called it a day, but he went out of his way to make sure the situation was handled the right way. That says a lot. I'm especially looking forward to coming back after a round of golf, since I'll already be right across the street. Next time, though, I'm trying the Sicilian slice. That thing looked really good sitting in the case. Hats off to Pete and the crew. Great food, great customer service, and a place I'll definitely be visiting again. read more

Peter’s Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

We moved from New York to Florida and have been on the hunt for a pizza place that actually reminds us of home. We found Peter's Pizza and honestly, we've been so impressed every time. We've picked up pizza from here a few times now, including the chicken parm, and everything has always been fresh, flavorful, and really good. But this past week really stood out to us. We have two toddlers, and one of them has some food allergies. The staff went above and beyond and made a specialty pie for her with their Sicilian sauce, and she absolutely DEVOURED it. That alone meant so much to us as parents. It was also our first time actually eating inside, and everyone was so incredibly kind and accommodating. I'm sure some people might roll their eyes when they see toddlers walking into a restaurant, but the staff here made us feel completely welcome. That kind of customer service is hard to find. And then we left with a cannoli donut that was OUT OF THIS WORLD and a cheesecake made by Peter's mom that was amazing. Tonight I ordered a pie for pickup, and they weren't happy with how it came out, so they made me another one and let me leave with both. As a mom at home with two picky eaters, having my freezer stocked with extra pizza honestly felt like winning the lottery. The food is consistently fresh and delicious, but it's the quality ingredients, genuine customer service, and friendly people that keep us coming back. If you're looking for New York-quality pizza in Florida, definitely give Peter's Pizza a try. Highly recommend! read more

Went to Peter's after reading all the hype started with the tomato mozzarella salad great presentation it was ok nothing special Then had a large half pepperoni and cheese pie I really don't get the hype it was not what I consider Nay style pizza the dough had no crisp the sauce was bland it wasn't bad but just not something I would go back for The 2 girls behind the counter were fantastic great service I'm sure they get repeat customers just to see them read more

Peter’s Pizzeria - Tomato mozzarella salad - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

See all

I finally made it to Peter's and let me say it lives up to the social media hype and worth the 25 minute drive from Coral Springs! We ordered the recommended best seller Ma's Margherita Pie to go and had original cheese slices while waiting. Peter and his staff are super friendly and pizza tasted great! Fresh ingredients, no seed oils, they don't even have a freezer! All fresh , all the time! If you haven't been, go! read more

See all

We've been in Florida for over 12 years. This is the best pizza we've had since we've lived here. This will be worth the drive from Coral Springs any weekend amazing pizza! I was truly skeptical when I saw the sign that said the dough was made to taste just like the water on Long Island. Call me no longer a skeptic. read more

Peter’s Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

Wow! Everything was delicious. The CPR chicken prosciutto and ranch slice was honestly mind blowing. I thought everybody was just riding the hype of this place, but it really was delicious. Surpassed my expectations, quality service. The girl at the front was so nice. A very cozy spot, so come for a quick bite or get carry out. I want to try everything but I am too full from the assorted delicacies we had for dinner. We will be back. read more

First time trying. I enjoyed everyone's reviews and delicious pictures so much that I had to try, so I did an uber eats order that was delivered on time and hot. When I opened those quality boxes and viewed the pies I was in awe! Great looking, better tasting. Nice job! Top quality ingredients, excellent size pies for the money. you can't go wrong . No need to wait any longer like I did. get an order in soon to experience this great product. Excellent! Will order again for sure. Many thanks! read more

See all

Stop doing "seasonal pizzas" when it's not a "seasonal item" the truffle pie is the only thing I'll eat here how disappointing! Truffle oil is ALWAYS in season on the shelf in the store read more

Def a stand out pizza spot. Regular pizza place size with seating inside to dine. The staff is nice. The pizza is one of the best in the area. I would recommend trying Brooklyn style as they get a nice little char to it and add fresh basil and grabs padana aged cheese sprinkled on top read more

Peter’s Pizzeria - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

See all

It is a small one bay restaurant, and if you want one or two slices of pizza, you are sort of stuck with what they have on display. This is different to a lot of pizzerias where you can order plain slices and add the toppings. The restaurant is located in a strip center on Federal Highway and there is somewhat limited parking. I tried a slice of pepperoni pizza and it was somewhat spicy. I like spicy food, but I wouldn't recommend it for most people. read more

Peter’s Pizzeria - My two slices - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

5/7/26- Delicious NY style pizza! I was born and raised in Manhattan and love pizza! Many New Yorkers are very picky about their slice of pizza as I am.. this pizza is perfectly balanced and the crust is perfect! What can I say.. I'm a fan! The variety that is displayed is amazing! Something for everyone! A definite must if you are within 100 miles of.. drive til you see the Peter's Pizzeria! You will thank me later! Always service with a smile! Love the NY style ambiance! Outside and inside seating... Now to the most delicious Italian Donuts! I took the cannoli cream filled donut with chocolate morsels on top to go.. as soon as I got home I opened the box and was instantly in love!!! I wish I had bought the rest of them in the case! The donut is light and pillowy .. the filling is the very best of cannoli cream! Truly amazing! Don't leave without at least two! I highly recommend Peter's Pizzeria! read more

See all

4.5 Stars - Really good local spot for pizza and more! Peter's Pizza in Pompano Beach has become one of our go to places for a NY Style pie. Their eggplant parm is also over the top perfectly crispy, layered with rich sauce and melted cheese, and full of flavor. The Pompano Beach location appears to be larger than the Boca store (more seating including outdoor tables too). There's plenty of parking. Place your order and grab a seat a the counter or one of their community tables. You can tell they put real care into it everything they do from making their dough, the cheese they use and selection of pies. Great food, friendly service, and consistently solid quality. Highly recommend stopping in, especially for a slice or the eggplant parm. read more

Peter’s Pizzeria - Baked eggplant Parm - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

See all

Still the best pizza around BY FAR. We had the Blanca (white) pizza with ricotta and shredded mozzarella last night. It was to die for. The crust is perfectly cooked. Peter knows dough and high quality ingredients. This might be my new fave pizza off the menu. Also, not long ago, I had the eggplant rollatini appetizer. The portion is so generous, I had two meals out of it. The Sicilian part of me is very happy to have such a fabulous Italian spot so close by. Plus, the people who own and work here are so kind. They treat you like family. read more

See all

Barely any chicken in the sub. All bread! Sauce and cheese were good though. Not worth the price. read more

Peter’s Pizzeria - Chicken Parm Sub - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

Great pizza, fried ravioli, and chicken parm. Found this place through yelp and it deserves the stars. The workers were friendly and told us about the food. Really enjoyed it. read more

Peter’s Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

Strong five stars earned at Peter's Pizzeria. Not sure if they served slices but we took a chance. Upon entry I noticed several artisan pizzas on display and knew this was the place for a slice. The owner told me that he had a White Pizza coming out of the oven right now and was a top seller. The piping hot pizza looked amazing with loads of ricotta cheese sparsely topped with basil. This creation needed to be in my belly quickly. We ordered an epic slice for $6.00 which is on the higher end but you always pay an extra few bucks for a specialty slice. He cut the slice in half to share with my wife. The dark charred undercarriage gave that first bite a nice crunchy sound with the sweet creamy ricotta cheese to follow. We loved it. The bathroom was clean with blue tiled walls and blue speckled flooring. read more

See all

Phenomenal everything!! Pizza, sandwiches, meatballs, salads, pasta, calzones, Stromboli, rice balls, chicken wings, vodka sauce, etc... and the list goes on and on! Forget all the other so called New York style pizza places. Peter's wins 1st place hands down. Great staff! Peter, Nick, Daria ...and the rest of the staff not only are so talented but inviting and make you feel like your with family eating your meals. I also appreciate them accommodating me with my food allergy issues. No dairy or oil on my pizza and it still came out phenomenal! read more

See all

just left peter's pizzeria. quality is the first thing that comes to mine. I mentioned it to the owner and he told me everything is imported! you can tell! The ceaser salad, fried ravioli, 2 pizza, desserts was all great ! My family of 7 sat comfortably and the place is clean! will be back , this was my 2nd time i just forgot to leave the review the first time. read more

Peter’s Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

Wife and I were craving a late-night bite and came into Peter's Pizzeria around 10pm on a Saturday. First time here and saw the solid Yelp reviews and figured why not. Let me just say, South Florida doesn't exactly overflow with proper pizza places... The place had a bunch of slices to choose from. I went with the long hots & sausage (couldn't pass that up) and also grabbed a Sicilian because I needed to know if they could nail the thick cut. Wife kept it classic with pepperoni. All three were solid. Like really solid. Turns out the owner's from Long Island, so it's LI style. What' they've have is a dough room that supposedly replicates Long Island tap water. The dough & crust...Crisp on the bottom, nice chew, none of that soggy stuff like others around town. They're also using San Marzano tomatoes too, which you just don't see much in South Florida pizza. Guy behind the counter was super friendly. Asked if it was our first time, then tossed us a few bonus slices!! Grandma's pie, a white slice, and another Sicilian. Worth a star for that alone! We took bites of everything, and honestly...Not a bad slice in the bunch. My long hot-sausage one was my fav! Could've eaten a whole tray of that. Chatted a bit, they've only been open 8 months. Fingers crossed they stick around. I've already told a few people and we'll definitely be back (or ordering in). Friendly crew, killer dough, and close to home. As someone with a pizza palate trained in the Northeast, this spot makes the cut. One of the rare South Florida places that actually gets it right. Pizza rotation: updated read more

Peter’s Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

See all

Peter's continues to impress. The pizza is maybe the best in Florida, but don't overlook the rest of the menu. The Walnut Salad w/Arugula was so amazing last time, needed another fix... perfect. First time trying their pasta... Rigatoni with Vodka Sauce and Meatballs... great! Had a Pepperoni Pizza and added Ricotta to half the pie. Awesome! If you love pizza, you HAVE to check this place out. Peter is amazing... if you watch his Instagram videos you'll get a good idea of his passion for pizza and his dedication to making the best pizza... and more. You'll also be introduced to some of his staff... Nick (expert pizza maker) and Daria (works the front counter) talking about the restaurant and having some fun. It's a good introduction to the restaurant and the bond you'll feel the employees have for each other as well as their customers. TIP: If they have the fantastic Raspberry Bars they make (they sell out fast)... get one! VERY HIGHLY RECOMMENDED - SPECIAL PLACE read more

See all

Great pizza served with a great attitude by the friendly staff Definitely will be back to try different slices read more

This place is delicious! A wide range of personal slices to grab at the register and everything is cooked fresh. You can order pies off the menu, apps, pasta and dessert. The staff is super friendly and welcomed us right when we got in and we went down the case picking out each thing we wanted. A Sicilian Vodka slice; a pepperoni slice and I couldn't pass up the fried ravioli or an order of the meatballs to share with the baby. Everything was so good, you can tell the ingredients are different and everything is made with care. There's a dough making station in the back where you can see them making the dough- it's a really cool place with great food. Highly recommend. read more

Peter’s Pizzeria - Gotta try it all! - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

See all

Ordered takeout and didn't realize the pizzas WERE GIANT!!! Workers were all super kind and speedy. Reminds me of pizzas places back in NY/NJ. Would definitely get again! read more

The pizza was amazing. I was a little disappointed with the Greek salad, not your regular Greek salad more like a house salad. The garlic knots were small and dry. I would not get either of those again. I would go back for sure for the pizza. The seating inside is limited so they probably do a better take out business. If you eat in there is no beer or wine to order. read more

Genuinely delicious pizza tip to tail with a perfect amount of sauce to cheese ratio. Each bite was savored by the crispness of the crust. There wasn't a morsel left on our plate. I know people categorize Peter's as 'New York' style, but to me it is more refined with a somewhat artisanal look and taste. We ordered 3 slices; one plain, one pepperoni ( regular not cupped variety) and split a white slice. ( add 2 soft drinks and the total was $20 and change plus a tip) We ate the white first since it usually gets cold the quickest. Both sides had 2 clumps of soft, milky cheese not quite burrata but not really ricotta. Whoa Nelly! Yum! Peter's Pompano location is not fancy. It's normal pizzeria sized with counter/ bar seats, a few inside tables and a few outside as well. Snag them as soon as you get there, they go quickly. Plenty of parking, plenty of happy faces. Oh, how I love pizza. read more

Peter’s Pizzeria - Crispy crust - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

See all

as of right now they have best pie in South Florida. Food was amazing knots and wings were fire, pizza second to none. The people are amazing best staff give them a raise. My only complaint was the wings because they were little that's all. read more

Peter’s Pizzeria - Pepperoni ricotta and basil - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

I think I found my perfect slice of heaven. The guy recommended the White Pie that had ricotta cheese and basil. The slice was cooked well done and looked, smelled and tasted great. Loved the huge ball of fresh white dough in the window ready to make into a pizza. Will return for a whole pizza soon. read more

See all

We have been there twice in the last week..the first time was because they had really good reviews and recommendations from our friends. The second time we just needed a slice of their Sicilian pizza to go because it is that good. The location is in a strip center and there is not a lot of seating inside and two small tables outsides parking is ok in the lot. All the tables were full on a Thursday evening but we were able to sit at the counter which was fine. The staff are all very friendly and helpful. You order at the front and they call out your name when your food is ready. There is a glass enclosure in the back where you could watch the guys making the pizza dough. There is a glass case in front with all the different slices and varieties of pizza. They also had fried ravioli, rice balls and rolled dough with fillings. On our first visit we tried the chopped Italian salad recommended from a friend along with Sicilian and Pepperoni slices. The Sicilian is square and think. We loved it. I enjoyed the pepperoni as well..it was quite spicy with lots of meat. The salad was really good too. It was very filling with loads of salami and cheese! I will definitely be back and try other slices! The white pizza looked amazing and from what I read, they are all good. read more

See all

Nothing to say but WOW! I am a pizza snob for sure and south Florida has many many options... I put Peters at the same level as Steve's, Angelo's corner from the old Hollywood beach days, and far above the new comers like Mr. 01 or Joe's or WHATEVER. The attention to detail--having a separate Dough room and reverse osmosis water to make sure the dough is perfect...Who does that? You know who?Someone who cares about being the BEST and treating his customers like kings and queens. Hands down among not only the best in Florida but the best period. read more

This pizza is outstanding!!! We have had amazing Ny pizza from NY, Boca , Hollywood fl, Miami beach... We were so impressed with Peters pizza filtration system and temperture of dough and dough room quality we came from Cape Coral fl to try this place!! It is impeccable and literally one of the best pizza i have ever had!! The garlic knots were delicious too!! Peter was so welcoming and informative and the staff was Amazing and making sure everything was perfect!! I recommend everyone to check this place out!! It was so nice and clean and in a great plaza.. read more

As a New Yorker this is definitely the best pizza I've had in Florida. I've gone to both locations and the food has been consistent and delicious at both. I am so happy to have found this place. I've lived in Florida for 14 years and have been looking for great NY pizza ever since so I'm thrilled to have found this place. Highly recommend! read more

Excellent Pizza!! Thin, chewy, crispy crust with great flavors. A great selection of fresh tasty toppings. Large pies that Peter will make half and half flavor choices. A large selection of freshly made slices. Delicious fresh salads. Clean and relaxing environment to dine in. Friendly and professional staff. A great place to dine in or take out. The patrons are relaxed and friendly and chat about the food and share their tables. Honestly THE BEST PIZZA!! Thank you!! Highly recommend this place!! read more

Peter’s Pizzeria - Fresh dough rising - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

Just came there today traveled from WPB... ordered six slices..Various items delicious highly recommend the white pizza , the à la Vodka and the chicken Parm. Service was on point and extremely helpful such a family atmosphere. We will back.. read more

This place is amazing! My second time here and it is worth the drive. Service is the best and friendly. The food is true authentic Italian. This has to be the best pizza in South Florida. I will always come here. I love this place and the people here. Wow! Treat yourself. read more

Long before opening his pizza restaurants in his hometown of Port St. Joe in north-west Florida and in Boca Raton with his brother Bobby Pokora, young Peter Izzo, a "pizzapreneur" was honing his pizza making skills in Long Island. Peter went on to earn a degree from NYIT School of Hospitality Management and then headed to Florence, Italy to perfect his culinary skills. On 11/20 Peter launched his flagship restaurant in Pompano Beach in the Park Plaza shopping Center on Federal Highway. The new restaurant has an industrial look with large glass windows letting in light, high ceilings, an open kitchen, and wood tables. The new Pompano location includes a glass enclosed prep room where you can see dough being made, a wall with bricks taken from Brooklyn, and an expanded menu. Peter's Pizzeria has developed the catch phrases "Saving lives one slice at a time,", "Buongiornoooooo Pizza Loverssssss!", and "slice appétit." Peter's Pizzeria specializes in New York style pizza made with Italian flour. All slices are finished with stracciatella, fresh basil, and grated grana padana. It was hard to choose from all of the tempting choices in the case but I finally decided on the BBQ pizza, white pizza, and the Sicilian slices. The crust and sauces were perfect and they were all an amazing 10/10. Besides pizza, the menu also offers hot subs, rolls, calzones, pasta, and decadent desserts. Fun fact: Peter was a contestant on the 18th season of The Bachelorette and he returned for the 8th season of Bachelor in Paradise. So when you are looking for a little celebrity mixed in with amazing Italian food, you know where to go. read more

See all

A slice of NY heaven. This place has the prefect crust, the right amount of sauce that taste like home. A must try for those craving a real slice. Thank you guys. read more

Wonderful pizza. Everything we tried was superb. Since we preferred different toppings we were able to make everyone happy by ordering slices. Definitely going back! read more

Peter's Pizza is a new "upscale" pizzeria and more! On the east side of Federal Highway sits this welcoming eatery, offering pastas, salads and Pizza, all carefully and skillfully crafted! Peter knows every aspect of creating the perfect pizza dough. He submitted water samples and developed a filtration system that yields the perfect dough which is mixed and proofed in his climate controlled "Dough Room", visible and on stage to patrons through large glass windows. The results of Peter's careful planning and execution, yields a delicious pizza, hearty enough to hold up and not sag, with whatever toppings you choose! Traditional and inventive pies are served with pride and smiles for you to enjoy. The crew here are friendly, helpful and share Peter's desire to ensure you enjoy your dining experience! read more

See all

Walked from the beach to this place. The service was wonderful! They genuinely cared about our experience. I got a slice of the White Pizza and a slice of the Buffalo chicken. They were served hot. The crust was thin and had the perfect crispness to it. Loved the flavors! My husband got the meatball sub and it was a good size! Well worth the walk and I hope we get to go back while we're in town! read more

Peter’s Pizzeria - White Pizza slice and Buffalo Chicken slice - Pizza Near Me - Pompano Beach, Florida

See all

We had an excellent experience here today. I'd seen a picture of the Yelp Fort Lauderdale staff at a pre-opening VIP intro recently as well as seeing their "coming soon" door signs month ago while visiting the coffee shop nearby -- and bookmarked the location. After reading about their grand opening yesterday, we decided to stop in for a light lunch. Many places in south Florida tout that they are NY style pizza, but this place actually delivers. We got to meet owner, Peter, and he told us about his efforts to research and insure New York water characteristics would be able to be duplicated and achieved -- and that this would be key in the flavor of the products he offered, as well. Right now in their soft opening, they're concentrating on pizzas. Although they also have a couple salads as well as subs and wings. More meals will be added later. There are quite a few pizza varieties from which to choose. And as they offer slices of most of these, you can sample different ones to see which is your favorite. My husband had a square slice of their grandma pie. The thin crust was topped with tomatoes and fresh mozzarella. And I tried their white pizza with shredded mozzarella and ricotta. Each of us loved our slices and especially the pizza dough and crispy crusts. All the staff were personable and welcoming. We got to chat with several of them. They also have a Boca raton location, but this one will become their flagship. Peter also let us try their Italian chopped salad. This was fantastic! Provolone cheese, salami, prosciutto, black olives, and iceberg were all chopped in small pieces together. Each bite had a taste of every ingredient. And their balsamic dressing was the perfect addition. This salad could be a meal in itself or perfect to share along with some pizza. We definitely will be back - soon I hope -- to try more of their menu. Welcome to the neighborhood! read more

See all