Ordered a Too Good to Go bag last week and got a container of banana pudding and a slice of chocolate cake. The shop is super cute and small, displaying a variety of baked goods. The person who helped me out was nice as well. The banana pudding was heavenly. Super creamy and just like the filling of a banana cream pie, with the addition of the vanilla wafers. A couple of bites and it was gone! Definitely will be back for that. The chocolate cake was super chocolatey and I loved the cake to icing ratio as it was just the right amount. The cake was moist as well, and not dry at all. What a great deal overall. I even spied a tres leches cupcake when I did my pickup but held off since I was already picking up sweets. Hope they'll have it when I go back! read more

The Cupcake Shoppe - Banana Pudding - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

I'm usually not a fan of cupcake frosting but these were light right amount of sweetness and all around delicious. I tried the cookies & cream and chocolate, both were good. The cookies & cream frosting was my favorite compared to the chocolate one. All in all solid place cupcake place. read more

See all

Another great Too Good To Go haul! I love that they give a variety of cupcakes - every thing tastes delicious! read more

The Cupcake Shoppe - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

Placed an inquiry for large order in November, didn't receive a response even til now (today is 1/3/2025). Or at least a notification that my inquiry was reviewed despite being past due. Went in today to make a small purchase and they were closed (for a break? Which they're entitled to) with a sign saying "be back -2:10). The door was still closed at 2:21pm. How am I able to give great credit when the service isn't great. At least they answer the phones, but the answers are not detailed and continue to refer to website versus what they personally recommend. read more

The Cupcake Shoppe - Tried to enter at 2:21p and the doors were still locked. - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

Solid spot for anything cake related! I got a custom cake made for my cousin for his birthday. A cookies and cream with strawberry filling and it was delicious! The cake itself was super moist despite it being in the fridge. The cookie bits were oreos and the entire cake itself wasn't too sweet. The strawberry center filling was delectable as well and worked well with the chocolate cookie bits. The cream was mildly sweet and neutral tasting so it offset and balanced out all the supposedly would be sweeter sections of the cake. It was beautifully decorate as well and the shop had a on of variety of cupcake flavors that I must try some other time. All in all, a very solid spot for all birthday, celebrations, and party needs! read more

Maybe located in an interesting area but this shop does NOT miss. This has been my go to place for the past few years to pick up cupcakes, grocery store ones weren't hitting anymore. Customer service is GREAT. Everyone here is very nice. Including the owner(?). I have been here many times and never felt received a hint of attitude or uneasiness. They are welcoming and open to explaining the flavors available. However, I don't understand the tip system for putting the cupcakes in a box but that's not important here. Everyone loves the variety of flavors and quality of cupcakes! Tiramisu, NY cheesecake, carrot, etc. This place has so many different kinds that I can't help but purchase at least a dozen, two if there are flavors that pique my interest. The frosting is delicious, the cupcakes aren't stale or too moist, the perfect amount to hold shape and the frosting on top. They also sell cake pops, banana pudding(?), and slices of cake. They may do custom orders but I feel I have a great experience perusing the different options on display that I don't need to place an order ahead of time. Overall, love this place. Will be my main cupcake shop indefinitely. read more

See all

I love all the flavors here. It's so hard to pick! The cupcakes are a large size than most bakeries which is a plus. The owner is so sweet! She greeted me once I came in! We ended up getting a banana, mint chocolate, cotton candy and vanilla which we loved. I know so basic flavors but we will be back for more! Omg we also got the banana pudding, it's literally sooooo good. I felt so guilty how good it was lol. Def it was a treat! read more

The Cupcake Shoppe - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

Note to self:: come back for a henny red cupcake asap! I have been here several times and always left satisfied! They had so many cute and new flavors today! My review is based on a Too Good To Go pickup not an actual in store purchase. The Too Good To Go process was pretty simple, parked in the parking lot to the side of the business (street parking is available) and walked right in. There was no hellos when entered and the room is so tiny so it was a bit awkward. Once the customer before me was done I just let the cashier know that I was there for a Too Good To Go order and she said one second. She grabbed a few things and placed it in a bag before wishing me a good day. The Too Good To Go order was $5.99 and I got a chocolate cupcake with Oreo cream frosting, a sprinkle cake pop, a chocolate cake pop and a rainbow rice Krispy treat (which for that price was a a steal of a deal) read more

See all

Okay you guys I came down from Oregon to attend a funeral and I had to go get cupcakes and of course I came to the Cupcake Shoppe. I got a day old key lime pie and it was so moist and flavorful as if it was just baked. I gotta tell you they make the best yummiest cupcakes around. read more

The Cupcake Shoppe - Key lime pie cupcake and an assortment of others. - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

Have you been here lately??!! It's simply a divine treat!! I'm sorry, but I'm not a Mini Cupcake girl, but I get those that are..and guys and kids. Either way, pick your delicious cake of choice and enjoy, knowing that it will have PLENTY of frosting! Yes, I'm a little bit of a sweet fan.... I love the 6 pack of cupcakes, in their own To Go Container, and if the offer is still good, then one is free. They're always fresh, have fun cupcakes use really good quality ingredients so you can taste it. read more

Well well well...... I'm definitely enjoying my day first of all I want to start by saying Happy New Year one of my Saturday field trip to the local downtown Hayward best cupcakes in town hands down todays choices were as follows Banana nut S'mores Red. Velvet (classic) Customer Service as on point staff always helpful with new flavors and maybe specials..... I have one thing to say if you have been to the. The Cupcake Shoppe in Hayward downtown area it's really nice and cute I love the aroma as I walk through the door hello 2024 desserts and last, but not least the ambience is cool nice different unique did I mention Unique. Yeah yes indeed. Well it's time to enjoy my cupcakes. Have a great evening everyone happy weekend everyone read more

As a Hayward native and someone who loved watching Cupcake Wars, I will ALWAYS LOVE and support The Cupcake Shoppe. I have loved them since I first tried them way back in their old location, and they have only gotten better! They are my go to for every special occasion (including my wedding-which oops I was so busy I forgot to take pictures), especially if you want to impress with some very pretty cupcakes! I work in a tiny office so I always buy between half a dozen to a dozen for work related special occasions and they're always a hit. Since I live really close to the Cupcake Shoppe, I've even had coworkers ask me if I could stop by to pick up Cupcake Shoppe for them! Of all the cupcake shops I have tried, they are probably still my top. No one beats their suuuper moist, dazzling decorated, and creativr flavored cupcakes. read more

See all

Hankering for some sweets after indulging nearby. A smallish bakery but with a lot choices for cupcakes. Ended up getting their buy 5 get 1 free deal of the cupcakes. I got the french toast and bacon, triple threat, Nutella, Oreo, toffee caramel, and strawberry shortcake. There must've been at least 30 different flavors for you to choose from. Love that the actual cake is not super sweet and the frosting makes up for the sweetness. Will be back to try other flavors as well. Oh their banana pudding is to die for!!! read more

See all

Called in yesterday to order 12 cupcakes for a gender reveal this weekend, I was told had to be special ordered in advance and it would be $60. I paid expecting it to be decent considering the amount I paid...I got basic small cupcakes with blue and pink swirl on top. So very disappointed. read more

The Cupcake Shoppe - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

I was given a cupcake to try from this place yesterday, and the icing was a beautiful teal, and pink color. At first sight, I believed it was good, bit into the cupcake and threw it away. It was gummy, no sweetness, dry flour and water. Icing was decent, but what is a cupcake if the cake in the cup is nasty . The foundation of the cake needs to be redone. read more

I've come here about 5 times now. The cupcakes are truly amazing and they have so many different flavors, some seasonal. I've had some interesting flavors such as peanut butter and jelly, French toast, almond crunch, and beyond. There are always interesting flavors and often they are true to what flavor they are teyu The biggest issue about this place is the line and slow pace. Even if I am the first in line with only one person ahead of me, they seem to chat it up and take the longest - I've been the person up next and have still waited like 10 minutes outside (due to Covid) because they just chat and answer questions and there is no rush -- even if there is 15-20 people in line. This place can really benefit from streamlining their orders more since 10-minute conversations with customers should be taking place outside - not holding everyone else up. But the flavors here are unique and good. The cupcakes are just on the sweeter and more expensive side so I don't come here too often. read more

I visited the cupcake truck and the cupcakes were amazing. Price (3/5): One cupcake is $5, which is a bit much. Food: (4.5/5) I had the tres leches cupcake and it was amazing. It has been better than cakes I've had. I've tried to make them at home and it's hard to get the texture right, but they nailed it. Just make sure you are sitting when you eat it because it will fall apart. In conclusion, I would consider getting another cupcake despite the price. read more

The Cupcake Shoppe - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

I'm just going to start by saying saying these cupcakes are hella GOOD! I've been "meaning" to stop by for years and never made it. I had them bookmarked and all. Had a function that I wanted gourmet cupcakes for and didn't want to pre order, hope and wait that they were good. I came in and immediately noticed how many different cupcakes they had and how well made they appeared. The employees were just there, There was no customer service, good or bad...and maybe that's bad. I would recommend a simple hello, thanks for coming in, or did you see/find everything when you pay...maybe a greeting of anything; but the cupcakes were amazing, PERFECT & the reason I'm giving 4 stars. This would be a 5 star business and it could have been an off day for the employees, but they need a little pep in their step. I've already recommended them for their cupcakes so I'd definitely be back. read more

The Cupcake Shoppe - Treats - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

A really small hole in the wall cupcake shop. Quick and easy service and the lady who helped me answered my questions about the flavors. She also made a really good recommendation for the churro cupcake. Decent spot if you want a sweet treat. read more

Came by for my TGTG app order. Picked up a 1/2 dozen cupcakes - flavors of banana creme, chocolate, peanut butter, chocolate chip, toasted almond. Very nice young man was at the counter helping us. Convenient parking lot in the back. Nice local small business owner in downtown Hayward. Come check them out and support local! It's way better than any big chain bakery. read more

Being a native of Hayward, I always like to find and support local businesses. The Cupcake Shoppe is one of the those Hayward treasures. I love going there every chance I get. The cupcakes are amazing and the staff is always willing to help you in your choices. The Margarita Cupcakes with a shot are amazing. It is a small place but the inside is amazing with the murals and it always smells good inside. read more

The Cupcake Shoppe - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

THE BEST CUPCAKES in The Bay Area can be found at this little shop in downtown Hayward. They have so many unique flavors that taste straight up like the actual flavor! If you're a fan of pudding, I highly recommend getting the gourmet Banana Pudding that has an actual cupcake inside! If this doesn't convince you enough, this shop has been featured on TV and actually won Food Network awards! Bookmark this place for your next sweet tooth craving or the next time you need an idea of what to bring to a party! read more

The Cupcake Shoppe - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

DELICIOUS!! And the staff is incredible!!! They are always extremely friendly and polite. Have been here several times and they never disappoint. read more

Big shout out to ya'll! I was on my way to this amazing shop how ever traffic was bad that night I ended up getting there a few minutes late, they were kind enough to receive me still! Talk about great costumer service! Also I'm sure their cupcakes are first to none in Hayward. read more

I have always loved this place until it came time to order a special cake. I was emailing someone regarding decoration, flavoring, filling, and date of pick up. I get a text the day of notifying me a new employee wrote the wrong date down. Unfortunately, I needed that cake that night and was unable to find another cake elsewhere as I wanted it a certain way. I requested my refund back and received it. I understand people make mistakes which is why I was never going to write the review, but I noticed this happened to someone else in the reviews. Just when I thought I was going to give them another try for a gender reveal order. read more

Ordered my nephews birthday cake from here because at the ripe age of 4, he requested rainbow everything. This shoppe happened to have a rainbow layered cake with rainbow sprinkles. My fam and I decided to drive past the shop the afternoon before we were scheduled to pick up the cake (mostly to see where it was) and decided to pop in and grab us some cupcakes. I had a pumpkin brownie, my sister their birthday cake, and my mom their salted caramel. The cupcakes were fine in my opinion. The frosting was a little sweet but balanced okay with the cupcake part. I also decided to take a chance to see if my order was ready for pickup so I wouldn't have to go back- and it was! We kept the cake in the fridge and pulled it out about an hour or so before we wanted to serve it. My nephew loved all the colors. The cake on the other hand wasn't really our vibe. It was super dense and the frosting was overwhelming sweet. We might be back to get some cupcakes or try the other desserts as there were non cake options. But if you don't like dense cake and/or exceedingly sweet frosting, I'd steer clear of their cakes. Or at least the rainbow one. read more

The Cupcake Shoppe - 6 Layer Rainbow Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

I placed an order for mini cupcakes for my aunt memorial weeks in advance. On the day I was supposed to pick them up, she said she was running behind & could she deliver. OK, fine. Then the next morning when I text her to ask what time she was coming, she said she was having car trouble & wasn't going to make it within the 2 hrs I needed to leave. I thought about going to get them from her but she was 1.5 hrs away from where the memorial was. Then when I asked her to zelle me a refund so that I could go buy cupcakes somewhere else, she said she could only refund via PayPal. Im still waiting for the $. This was terribly unprofessional and she made a hard day even harder. read more

Husband brought a cupcake home. I'm now a fan. Can't wait to go there myself. I couldn't believe how delicious a cupcake could be.

Excellent place to pick up some celebratory cupcakes! I have bought them for kids' birthdays in the past, and yesterday we picked a bunch to bring to the nursing home for my dad's 92nd birthday. It was hard to choose, but we got a dozen variety of the regular sized, and a dozen of the minis, for those who only want a nibble. All were delicious, and we shared with the friends and staff. I couldn't resist picking up their banana pudding with nilla wafers for myself. Yummy. They even had a complimentary birthday candle for me to grab. My dad: "I only want one candle. If you put 92 candles on my cupcake, it would look like the coronavirus." read more

Love the variety of cupcakes here! Located in downtown Hayward, there's a lot behind the place with plenty of parking on a weekday lunch. It's a tiny shop with no space to dine in, best to order takeout. I ordered ahead online a few days earlier and thought there was no need to do that. When I arrived they put together my order based on the inventory they had in hand. I didn't get one of the flavor that was on the website for that day, so I guess its just based on what they make that day. There's a variety of flavors from tres leches to chocolate to mint chocolate to oreo... the list goes on. The cupcakes looked very appetizing as well! They also serve other desserts such as cookies and krispies. Less than $5 per cupcake, but there's a buy 5 get 1 free deal. I was able to get half a dozen cupcakes for about $25. Not bad! I bought them during lunch and left them in fridge during day (wasn't sure if I could leave them out but wanted to be safe). They were still good towards 830pm after dinner. Most people enjoyed the dulce de leche flavor, but I personally enjoyed the snickerdoodle. I didn't know the triple threat was just chocolate/vanilla/red velvet, for some reason I thought it was 3 types of chocolate. That would be the least favorite for everybody. I can't wait to come back here and try their other flavors, like the mint chocolate and carrot. Looks like they have day old cupcakes for a fraction of price, will get those next time! read more

Cupcake shoppe won on Food Network's, "Big Time Bake." I got to know about this place on Instagram and their Wednesday specials had me wanting to explore this confectionary establishment. I'm very loyal to Small Cakes in the East Bay. This place is distinct and here are my thoughts... The cupcakes are pricy ($4) but JUMBO size. The icing is thick and the cupcake is a dense cake texture. The variety of flavors offered are creative and well thought out in construction. Meaning, there appears to be many details put into one cupcake. The s'mores cupcake had actual marshmallow paste oozing from within. I enjoyed the Boston cream pie that had a whip topping dipped in a chocolate hardened mixture. The custard filling was thick and hearty. The customer service was attentive with the helper making sure to explain all the flavor options. If you want to save money, consider trying their day old cupcakes ($2) because the horchata cupcake had a pipette with actual horchata beverage. My kids were visually stimulated by the creations. I personally found the flavors to be forgettable. The cake consistency all are relatively the same texture. The game changer is if it has filling or not/ the icing enhances that cupcake base. I think it boils down to going after the flavor you want (check daily menu options on website) and sticking to that one cupcake that becomes the holy grail. I did notice a customer came in and asked for the last animal cookie cupcake that we had appeared to get! I just tried the cupcake that looked minimal in supply to decide which was popular. This process of elimination may help you also! I liked how when the server was busy she let her customers know she would be right with them or let them know what she was working on that creating a delay. The buzz about this place makes it where certain times are busier than others. No stay at home order is going to keep me six feet from a fabulous cupcake! read more

See all

First time. Nice cupcakes. We ordered the Black Forest, Lemon, and Lavender. Each one is flavored to represent the names. You can also add the alcohol based Margarita and the Mango Pineapple as they are also Yummy and enjoyable. Check it out. read more

The Cupcake Shoppe - Mango and Pineapple plus Margarita - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

I'm not even a "sweets person," but The Cupcake Shoppe has convinced me that a little bit of sugar every now and then will satisfy that craving! I can't believe I didn't find out about this place until this year. I first tried their cupcakes through someone else, and I liked them so much! The thing I love about them is that they have something for everyone. They can get a little on the sweet side, but I usually don't eat a full cupcake. I like to get half a dozen of jumbos and sample from each of them. The shop is super small and with COVID, only one customer is allowed at at time. I usually go at really odd times, so it's never packed. Their customer service is also sincere and superb! My current obsession is the pumpkin cheesecake! I hope they serve it year round. My next favorite is the strawberry shortcake. I have so many more, but those are my top two! read more

The Cupcake Shoppe - Standard cupcake day: Strawberry short cake, dulce de leche...and I forgot! - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

I came around 2:45pm on a Tuesday. Strawberry Shortcake was already sold out. So if you are laying around browsing Yelp, get up, now, go, it's worth it! A coworker of mine kept telling about this place. I had the opportunity to stop by on my day off. It's a small shop on Main Street. There is limited street parking, but don't fret, there is a parking lot in the back of the building. Upon arrival there were two people in line outside. There was no signage stating capacity, but it looked as if only one customer went in at a time. I bought a frozen banana cupcake along with the maple bacon. Both were scrumptious, but that maple baaaacon!!!! It was off the charts. (P.s they also have alcohol cupcakes ready to buy) I had intentions of only getting cupcakes, but i decided to indulge. My son wanted to try a cake pop. It was chocolate on the outside, i believed marble inside. He inhaled it. So my assumption is he liked it. We also couldn't walk out of there without trying the chocolate covered bacon. I could absolutely eat those slices everyday! The sweet of the chocolate along with salt and chew of the bacon meshed perfectly together. They have a batch of brownies that sit at eye level right next to the register. I felt like they were begging me to take them home. They were big and thick, and looked moist and chewy. I was tempted but decided I had enough sweets for now. Next time they will be going home with me! I'm glad I tried this place. Impressive. Can't wait to go back. read more

See all

Next time I have an event I will use the cupcake shoppe. They are up there with bundts. I love the variety. On this day we happily bout have a dozen cupcakes and cake pop. Samosa was my favorite!, honorable mention- peanut butter and creativity - lemon infused with vodka. read more

The Cupcake Shoppe - Yum - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

My husband and I were out and about and had a sweet tooth. Mind you - we ALWAYS have a sweet tooth. So on our way home we stopped by this little shop and it's not just a little shop , its a little shop of cupcake goodness! And a rarity because it's probably one of the very few shops you can get alcohol on your delicacies! We ended up buying 3 cupcakes, mine being the margarita one. My husband got one with bacon, the other I'm not sure what it is, I guess my memory is not all what it is! But all and all the shop employees made us feel comfortable and welcome in here and was very patient with my husband while he decided on which ones to pick out. Total price for 3 cupcakes - About $15 ish or so about 17ish after tip. Well worth the price and is different than if you got a cupcake from a grocery store. This is a unique experience one has to try for themselves. read more

The Cupcake Shoppe - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

Cupcakes were too dense and in my opinion had too much sugar on them. I tried different flavors but they all tasted similar just different colors/toppings. I think they were too expensive for what was given. They have a huge menu and I think it would be better to minimize the amount of items being sold to really focus on their flavors instead of the quantity. read more

Love this spot. The cupcakes are so good and there are tons of flavors to choose from. They did a custom cupcake order for me with just a few days notice and made my kids' rainbow cupcake dreams come true. Truly a 5 star business! read more

Small shop with no seating. Prompt and courteous service. I picked up a 6 pack variety of cupcakes. The frosting is sugar loaded. I had to remove more than 75% of the frosting. The strawberry lemonade was only one out of 6 that was not overly sweetened. The cake is quite sweet by itself and is really dense, like a pound cake. It's a bit pricey. I would come back just for the strawberry lemonade cupcake. read more

First time trying this place and reviews seems good so have it a shot. Placed an order to for the chocolate cake slice and banana pudding. Kind of a sucker for a good banana pudding so I was excited. Picked up the order and folks there are very nice. First tried the chocolate cake and it was ok, maybe it was stored away for a lil too long but it wasn't my fav. Tried the banana pudding and it was awesome! Tasted freshly made and not too sweet just how I like it! Would try again but will skip the chocolate cake this time round :) read more

The Cupcake Shoppe - Small Banana Pudding - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California