They had a girl dinner special going on for Valentine's Day!! Honestly I think they should add it as a weekly special one night a week or a night a month. I would 100% go back for it. The ranch is so good with the fries! I wish they had more options for what kind of martini you could get! The service was good!! It was busy when we went so we just sat at the bar! read more

The Coxcomb - Caesar Salad and fries - Sandwiches Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

Had a reservation last Saturday for 7pm. The night started off great we were seated promptly, greeted and order drinks quickly. We decided to try a pizza (hot honey) for an appetizer and it was delicious! We waited a little bit to put our food order in as per the waitresses recommendation because we didn't want the food coming out at the same time. However, we ended up waiting over 30 minutes for our food (maybe longer!) which was frustrating. The cheesesteak was good and a nice portion for the price l. I thought the chicken/fish and chips platter looked a little scarce for the price. The bar was pretty packed but the restaurant itself was not. We didn't realize it was trivia night, seems a lot of regulars in attendance. read more

See all

The atmosphere at Coxcomb was bland but acceptable, a lot different than Bella which they replaced. Our first time being there I was not impressed, being in the hospitality industry I expect a better experience. The service was good very polite and friendly and that's where it ended for me. Food took to long to be served and the value of what you received wasn't good at all compared to the same dish else where. I don't recommend this restaurant. I don't say that very often. We will not be returning. I would have liked to have tired the pizza but won't consider another visit read more

See all

The manager was less than hospitable, actually had a poor attitude. Left and will never return and be sure to share the story. His final comment was have a nice night read more

Ordered takeout yesterday as we sometimes do, although we more often dine in. As I walked in their door at the promised pickup time my order was arriving at the hostess desk hot from the kitchen. Can't ask for better than that. Still hot ten minutes later when we started to eat at home. Good food and good service. Perfect! read more

Solid spot for pretty good bar and American food. Not sure why the reviews skew so negative. I got to try their classic white pizza. It was a great size and a solid deal for a well made pizza. Nothing exceptional, but still, very good. They definitely did not shy away from the garlic or the pepper with this pizza, perhaps excessively so. But, it was very thin and very flavorful, so I don't mind. It's well worth a spot if you want to watch a game and also enjoy some pies, wings, and other classic American items without breaking the bank. read more

The Coxcomb - White pizza - Sandwiches Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

See all

Wow! Went to coxcomb because Panera discontinued their French Dip. While it wasn't the ciabatta bread I was craving, it was a pleasant surprise. They put their French dip on a folded pizza that is DELICIOUS. It's huge, so I'm no longer surprised why it didn't automatically come with fries (at least on the DoorDash app). Anyway, amazing, you need to try! The only other comment is the crispy onions seemed like they needed to be cooked more, wasn't crispy and the onions seemed on the raw side but still amazing. read more

The Coxcomb - French Dip - Sandwiches Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

I usually don't write bad reviews so this pains me because we were really excited to eat here. We were seated immediately but waited 20 minutes to get greeted by our waitress every though she made eye contact with us struggling with our very hungry kids the whole time. Finally ordered and the "coke" didn't didn't taste like regular coke, almost flat tasting. The food was well over seasoned and to each their own with that but I was super disappointed with how the kids' chicken fingers looked when they came out, they were really over done and I spent most of my meal scratching off the black on the fries so my kids could eat something. I sadly was going to make a reel for my social media but I don't feel like I can suggest this experience to others. read more

The Coxcomb - Kids Chicken Tenders - Sandwiches Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

Just make normal food will you . A panino cheese steak. How about just a cheese steak.

Well, I know of several people (my friends and family included) that went to the Coxcomb when it first opened and did not have a great experience. I went with my wife recently, after the restaurant has been open for about a year and wow what an opposite experience we had in comparison to those that went when it first opened. First and foremost, the menu is really extensive, with lots of different choices of food. Everything we had was great. My wife had a salad, which was full of good stuff. I had a panini sandwich, that I enjoyed immensely. We started off with Calamari. The atmosphere is nice with a decent bar area and lots of seating. The wait staff was friendly and attentive. If you tried this in the first couple of months that they were open and did not enjoy, I strongly recommend that you give it another try! read more

The Coxcomb - Panini sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

See all

First time here and it exceeded my expectations weight staff, servers manager/owner were all fantastic. The establishment was clean with a full bar. The food was very good. i expect to be back. read more

See all

The service was excellent! Super friendly and kept us updated on the food. Food was delicious! read more

The Coxcomb - Pork Chop was tender & tasty - Sandwiches Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

See all

Food was delicious. Family likes the fried pickles. The pizza's were excellent. The fish (cod) wasn't freshly prepared. . The sauces were fresh and tasty. Our server was brilliant! They could use some sound absorbing material on the walls and ceiling. I will order takeout the next try. . read more

One of our new favorites in the Monroeville/Murrysville area. Been twice for brunch and not disappointed. The price and the tastes are both excellent. Personal favorite for both taste and value is the breakfast pizza! Space is great for small and big groups alike and the design is perfect for catching "the game" while balanced with a family friendly dining experience. Service is super friendly, but is fairly slow especially given the restaurant is not super busy. This is the single thing that keeps this from being a five star option, but if you're up for patience, the food comes out hot and is yummy. Highly recommend. read more

Two stars for service. Why management would book a single bartender (working hard) + barback (working hard) on wing night during a holiday week is curious and potentially telling. Intrigued? See below! My wife and I have been to Coxcomb probably 10 or 12 time, but this last (final) visit was egregiously poor from both a quality and management standpoint. Here's the traditional "I've been service industry, and I'm patient to a fault" disclaimer, and I'll again state the service isn't the issue. This visit, we ordered two different plates of wings, a side salad, a chicken strip and fries entree, and a cheese dip app. Wings ordered crispy/well done. It took about 45 minutes (and two drinks) before the side salad came out, and to be fair, the lettuce was crispy and had dressing, just like a side salad (that's usually pre-prepared and comes out in five to seven minutes). After an hour, our cheese dip app came out -- alongside the chicken strip entree. The cheese dip was gloopy and thick and entirely inedible (and also arrived 30-45 minutes too late for *an appetizer.*) I told the bartender it was not up to standard, and they apologized and said it'd be removed from the check. After another 10-15 minutes, the wings arrived (which, ordering them well-done, is fine, contextualy.) Despite ordering two entirely different sauces, one with a dry rub (dry + wet = awesome), they were indistinguishable from each other and also were not at all well-done. I ate three of 12 wings and, disappointed, dumped them together on a plate. At this point the bartender said they'd get the manager. Upon hearing our complaints, the manager reiterated that they'd take off the cheese dip (heard), but that the wings were rung up as the same sauce, and my complaints that they were rubbery were untrue because "they came out of the fryer crispy." Cool -- not how they were delivered, so I wonder how long they sat for? She also said they were *very* busy, but I'm not sure how that makes my sludgy, inedible cheese dip or flabby, boring wings better. See again: maybe have the appropriate (or appropriately trained) staff...? Anyway, literally (not figuratively), in the middle of this discussion ,she turned on her heel, "apologized," printed the check, handed it to us, and left. So anyway, go to Coxcomb if you want decent bar service, bad food, and management that outwardly and obviously doesn't care if you had a terrible experience because they have a cache of townie locals who will go there no matter what. Also they own Pittsburgh Pickle Company which, since the pickles are in a jar, have never given me a negative experience (but makes me wonder if other jared pickles would give me a better experience?) and also Beerhive, which has a great burger but also I knew a bartender there from a previous restaurant so maybe I'm just lucky and the bulk of Beehive is bad at their job, too. Experience at your own risk. read more

Coxcomb is the old Bella Luna. It got a major upgrade with food and service. The food is BIG TIME good and reasonably priced. Our waiter's name was Christian. He was awesome. Super energetic and very friendly. You can tell he loves his job. As long as the food remains this good they'll succeed. read more

See all

Delicious scratch cooking. Very friendly staff. Great service. Nice variety of dishes. Clean and cool design of the restaurant. Modern feel. Joined the lunch club rewards program. Buy 5 lunches and receive $10 off your next visit. Looking forward to trying more dishes including the pizza, it looked great! Wide open dining room with a separate private dining room. Worth a trip to try for yourself. Highly recommended! read more

See all

Pierogis were a good tasty app. Place could still benefit from some sound absorbing materials. The all hard surfaces make for a louder than comfortable atmosphere with even minimal patrons. Greasy smell ended up driving us to an early exit! read more

Good food, good service, and nice location. We had an early dinner (3:30pm) so service was on point. Coxcomb salad and strips and chips were dinner choices. Initially , I was thinking, meh-it's just another chicken spot! BUT...our chicken strips were super moist! The brine prep is worth a trip to Coxcomb! My fresh cut French fries were so well seasoned, hubby couldn't keep his hands outta my plate. read more

The Coxcomb - Coxcomb Chicken salad - Sandwiches Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

See all

We've been here twice now. Once in December 2023, ordered pizza, and it was good. Went again in April 2024, ordered an order of fried pierogi and they were good, then ordered the wings and they were horrendous. They had a lot of potential - they were very large wings. Kitchen must not have adjusted from the normal wings because they were extremely undercooked. They were served as whole wings. No big deal, if the wings are cooked properly the sections should tear apart. These... not even close. I struggled to tear these apart because I figured with the amount of effort I had to put in, the wing would go flying out of my hand across the bar. The skin was rubbery, the meat was chewy, and only 4 of the wings were cooked all the way through. These were, hands down, the worst chicken wings I've ever had. read more

The food was very good and plentiful! The service was excellent and our server was great He was very friendly and helpful as I have food allergies and was able to help me to get the right order. We will definitely be returning to the Coxcomb!! read more

Service by Csssi and helper was great! Went for happy hour for the first time with a friend and we thoroughly enjoyed ourselves. Really like the atmosphere, sort of industrial. Nice happy hour prices on wine and beer and discounts on mixed drinks. We were both happy. We enjoyed wings, prefer the small ones, but they were still good. We also had chips with a smoked queso. chips were fresh and delicious. The queso was good. Will definitely return soon with a gang. Happy to have this place close by and look forward to patronizing. read more

We had dinner today. Great food and great service. Very reasonably priced. I had the Pittsburgh steak hoagie and loved it.

Everything was incredibly spicy. Even the french fries were coated with pepper. out of five of us in our party only one person liked their meal. I will never go back there. read more

We live nearby and feel we are limited in solid food/happy hour/beer choices. We generally enjoy local breweries as well as home made food (no chain restaurants). We were happy to see this restaurant opened so close to our home and took us a few months to actually try it. We went tonight and all around the service was awesome. From the hostess, to bartenders, to our server everyone was friendly and accommodating. We were extremely happy to see so many local breweries with beer on tap. The chicken wings were excellent. The chicken and fish were great and the pizza was good. Overall we are extremely happy with our experience at The CoxComb and are happy to have a new local favorite to frequent. We have a 3 year old and typically stray towards breweries as they are a bit more kid tolerant but felt right at home with our 3 year old. I'm sure we will enjoy many more happy hours here. We never tried the previous restaurant at this location but hope the coxcomb stays for years to come. I'm assuming the clientele from the previous restaurant to this one is very different and I would imagine the bad reviews would be skewed this way. If you want a yummy meal, I doubt you'll be disappointed here. read more

They need decorations and a more lively vibe. I support all local business and have been there a couple times, but it seems a bit underdone. It just feels like one of those places that might not be around long. Murrysville likes upscale. Hope I am wrong and that they are wildly successful. read more

Excellent experience! Found this place online while traveling for a convention and had a great time. Food is made from scratch and delicious. Bartender Christian was very personable and his service was spot on. He made our night. I recommend the meatball sandwich and the burrata salad. read more

I wanted to like this place and try to support local businesses but I probably won't go back. If you like pickles, well you are in luck. Sandwiches were quite interesting and I have had a better chicken sandwich at Chick-fil-a. Pastrami sandwich, not sure if it was Pastrami and no Swiss! Service was slow even though no one there. The place was nice and the bar was impressive but the rest, not so much. read more

The Coxcomb - Pastrami with Swiss cheese - Sandwiches Near Me - Monroeville, Pennsylvania

See all

LARGE portions! Pizza and chicken tenders are tasty. Good value for the money. Service was attentive.

The food is edible at best, there are much better places to go. The staff was annoyingly incompetent. This was our second time trying it and there won't be a third. Giant eagle has better chicken tenders, I love dill but the "ranch" is basically dill sauce. My husband couldn't tell the different between his fried fish and fried chicken at first. Everything over salt and peppered to make up for lack of anything else. read more

Solid food albeit very greasy. Tenders were ok ,not very flavorful . Fries were average and not many given with our meals. Fermented hot sauce was odd. The free dipping sauce they give you has horseradish in it and was not to our liking . If you like horseradish then you will dig it. Fish and chips were the same greasy batter heavy pieces. The actual fish was very good but the batter detracts from it. Fried pickles were the only thing that were just north of average. I would not make another trip from what we experienced. Maybe a bad day to visit? Eh at best . read more

Individual pizzas were awesome, atmosphere great, service great, just need a jukebox and they would have everything anybody wants

For the record, if anyone ever asks "is your Margarita pizza anything like the old Bella Luna pizza?" The answer is should be a resounding No! Your has no fresh mozzarella or fresh basil. Just regular cheap pizza cheese and thin strips of dried basil. A sad substitute read more

This is your typical bar food place. The ambiance was nice. Tables set up outside. You actually get a whole wing and not a wing-ding. The bbq sauce needs some work. I Haven't tried anything else on the menu read more

Their Chicken & Corn Chowder is a great offering but so far the rest has been mostly mediocre. Pizza was fairly good but Angus burger was not very tasty. As to service we have liked it. Noise level is a bit much especially near the bar. Will go back for the chowder and may try some other items but three stars is the best I can do right now. read more

Good neighborhood restaurant for a casual meal. We like the Pittsburger salad and cheesecake sandwich with good fries. Really friendly staff too. read more

My wife and I have been here 3 times. Each time we tried something different. The food and the atmosphere are terrific. The food is flavorful and always fresh. We are so happy to find a local restaurant that is not afraid to season their food. The staff is also friendly and attentive. Best restaurant in Monroeville and Murrysville area! read more

Been there once so far. I had a great Bacon Burger on an exceptional homemade bun. (I'd go back just for the bun!) My wife had an equally delicious Chicken Sandwich. Service was very attentive. One visit isn't conclusive. I'll change the review if necessary. read more

It's almost like the owners built their menu to speak directly to me. It's everything I like! The chicken is incredible - that breading, wow. Fries are awesome. Pickles really standout and add crunchy texture to already crispy chicken sandwich, love the variety of these. Staff is always friendly. Decor and aesthetics of this place are great as well. What more can I say? We are blessed to have a place like this added to a growing list of great, locally owned restaurants in the Murrysville area. Just try it! read more

Ordered takeout this evening, as we love trying all of our local places. They had accidentally burnt the fish and said they had to remake it, which was thoughtful. They said it would be an additional ten minutes. However I think waiting on the new fish may have thrown the rest of the order off. The steak pizza was cold, yet severely burnt. Not in a brick oven kind of way, but in a blackened sort of way. The flavor of the pizza was really good though, so I think had it not sat so long and wasn't as black it would've been really good. The new Cajun fish was still extremely dark and hard, we pulled most of the breading off and discarded it. The actual fish was good underneath. I believe the cook must just be having trouble getting the frying right. The fries were cold and soggy and the steak salad must've sat with the hot steak and fries for so long that it was a sloppy wilted mess. Again, probably just a result of having to wait for the new fish. The chicken strips were good, despite being dark and extra crisp, the chicken itself was tender and juicy. The hostess was very nice, although she was running back and forth like crazy despite most of the restaurant still being empty. There were several other employees, while nice and smiling, seemingly just standing around. The hostess went back to check on our food three times in between answering phones and seating people. All in all it ended up taking 25 extra minutes, so I'm sure that made it difficult to keep the rest of the food fresh. We all agreed it's not a place we would try again. Hopefully they can get the cooks up to speed so they can stick around for a while. We could use a restaurant with a fun, adventurous menu. Sadly, tonight they just missed the mark. read more