Friendly, easy, delicious flourless chocolate cake. Great find in my first time in Newtown. Thanks so much. read more

The Caketeria - Delicious and pretty Flourless chocolate cake - Bakeries Near Me - Newtown, Pennsylvania

We get all of our cakes from The Caketeria. We've never been disappointed! Staff is so nice and accommodating. read more

The Caketeria - Bakeries Near Me - Newtown, Pennsylvania

For a cake place it was shocking how bad the cake and icing tasted! The decoration was lovely, but the cake itself was awful. It wasn't just my impression. Lots of guests at the shower rushed up to get a piece of cake but hardly anyone finished it. No one wanted to take the leftover cake home. We speculated that they must have just put a fresh decoration on an old stale leftover cake. I would never use this business again. read more

The Caketeria did such a beautiful job with our wedding cake. I honestly have no notes - the cake was exactly what we hoped for and tasted delicious. I gave Beth, the owner, some Pinterest inspiration, and she completely came through. The design was beautiful, the cake fit our wedding perfectly, and our guests loved it. It was one of those vendors I didn't have to worry about at all, which is exactly what you want on your wedding day. Highly recommend! read more

The Caketeria - Bakeries Near Me - Newtown, Pennsylvania

I love this place! The thing you can't see is how amazing it smells in here! Service is excellent! read more

See all

Dense cake and flavorful. The inside is bright with a nice selection of cakes and pastries for walk-in service. Area outside to sit and snack. I will come back for more birthday cakes in the future. read more

Magnificent service! Sweet displays of gorgeous temptations!! Visiting some people that are under the weather! I need mini gifts. I got a peanut butter cookie , coconut cupcake and rughela ... what a hit! Everything was well received! Fresh and delicious!! I shall be back! read more

The Caketeria - Bakeries Near Me - Newtown, Pennsylvania

See all

The cake was beautiful and delicious - and the staff is very nice! Will definitely use again read more

The Caketeria - Bakeries Near Me - Newtown, Pennsylvania

Loved the cake! So many compliments. Even the kiddo that doesn't like cake ate it. Oreo filling was so yummy. read more

The Caketeria - Bday cake - Bakeries Near Me - Newtown, Pennsylvania

After many years of supporting this business and ordering cakes here, this weekend we had a really upsetting experience. I went back-and-forth with the new owner about a design for my son's cake for a special event this past weekend. The cake was delicious, the design was fine. However, I ordered a cake that would feed 85 to 100 people and that was the agreement. I paid almost $500 for a cake and $60 for delivery. In the end, the owner acknowledged that she made a cake for 60 people even though that was never the agreement. WHOOPS!!! The cake looked dwarfed; I was so shocked and upset when I saw it that I didn't even take a picture. The fact that we were charged this amount for a tiny cake that fed 60 people at a major family event is infuriating, and not what we had discussed. New owner was completely inflexible, apathetic, and did not acknowledge that she made the wrong size cake. She showed no concern about whether we were satisfied. I will no longer be ordering anything here, and am sad and shocked at the change in ownership and the sense that we feel we were completely gauged. Buyer beware. read more

Best cupcakes ever. Expensive but worth it. Close by in Newtown and lots of offerings everyday in the cupcake range.

This past weekend I celebrated my 42nd birthday with family. My dad ordered a Vegan Carrot Cake with "Buttercream" frosting. The cake was delicious. It was moist and it was the best dessert at the party. I really enjoyed the cake and the frosting. The frosting was "buttery " and rich. There were leftovers and I brought them home (I was after all, the birthday boy). I devoured the cake later that evening. The bakers personalized the cake with a message, "Happy Birthday Paul." I was impressed with the quality of the cake and the Vegan frosting. I will definitely shop at The Caketeria in the future when shopping for any dessert and they are my go to Bakery for "specialty" desserts (ie, vegan). I wish I took a picture of the cake. It was as beautiful as it was delicious. read more

Beth created the most beautiful cake for my mom's 80th birthday--absolutely stunning and delicious! She was so helpful, kind, and easy to work with. Truly made the celebration extra special. read more

This bakery is delicious! My fiancé and I came in for a cake tasting for our wedding, and it was so cute inside. They had a table for us, and the cakes they had were so delicious! We ended up choosing both chocolate chip pound cake with ganache and the chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream and ganache, and it was so yummy! I can't wait for our wedding cake. The owner is lovely and makes such gorgeous cakes. We also left with cupcakes and a cereal treat, and those just made me even more excited because they were so good. Glad to have found a bakery nearish us that is so good. It's worth the 30 min drive FOR SURE. read more

caketeria is THE BEST bakery i have been to. Their cakes and cupcakes are amazing. Every flavor, including vegan, has been amazing. I order for them for every birthday and special event I can and they are always so friendly and accommodating with my requests. I live 1 hour away in NJ and have a family member who lives local to the bakery pick up cakes for me when needed. Definitely recommend. read more

We had a birthday in the family, and the birthday girl wanted a variety of cupcakes instead of a cake. We recently at a friend's home had two different cakes from The Caketeria, a chocolate and a lemon raspberry which were quite good so we decided to take the trip to Newtown to get some cupcakes. The Caketeria has its own small parking lot so that was nice in itself to not have to try and find street parking. The store is small and jam packed with all kinds of cakes and cupcakes and other delicious delicacies. You may have to wait outside because of COVID-19 rules. The staffer was following protocol with masks and keeping things clean. There were more than a dozen types of cupcakes and I have a bunch of pictures. We purchased a dozen and also got some macaroons. The staffer was surprised that we were quite decisive in our choices as she said others sometimes take upwards of twenty minutes to make decisions in what they want. Overall, the cupcakes were delicious and light and flavorful. They get the thanks from us so we didn't have to create all those flavors. None in particular stood out as exceptional; they were all just really good. It was the same with the cakes we recently had. The chocolate was good but not great, and the lemon raspberry was outstanding. I think we could find something comparable in Philadelphia, but if we have to go to Newtown, we'd visit The Caketeria again. The birthday girl was very happy. read more

See all

Sarah and Beth at The Cakeateria are amazing. I could not have picked a better bakery to make my husband and I's wedding cake- all I had were a few Pinterest photos I liked and a list of ingredients I wanted to use for the decor and when I picked up our cake a day before our big day, I cried. We got a pound cake base with raspberry filling and buttercream frosting; Hands down the best cake I've ever had. Thank you, Caketeria!! read more

The Caketeria - The cake! - Bakeries Near Me - Newtown, Pennsylvania

See all

Not only was this cake beautiful but it was also very delicious. I ordered the cake for my mom's 80th birthday. We wanted to make sure it wasn't too sweet so I ordered sponge cake. They did such a great job! Thank you so much, Beth & team!!! read more

The Caketeria - 2-tier sponge cake with mixed berries - Bakeries Near Me - Newtown, Pennsylvania

See all

What an incredibly nice staff. She was patient, incredibly helpful, and cheery. The cupcakes were fantastic. Our friends loved the cheesecake we brought over. Will definitely stop by again when in the area. read more

I ordered my daughter-in-laws baby shower cake with their recommendation lemon/raspberry...it was FANTASTIC inside and out!! I will surely be ordering all my cakes from The Caketeria! read more

The Caketeria - Bakeries Near Me - Newtown, Pennsylvania

Bad first experience, decided to try again to see if it was a fluke. It wasn't. Got 6 cupcakes for $23. They were nice looking, but the cake itself was so dry, it was hard to eat. The frosting and flavors tasted like it was just sugar. At this price point, they should be made daily and not taste like week old stock. read more

A break from the norm. It's not Stocks or Rillings. Their pound cake stands on it's own. The bday cake I picked up was really quite good and unlike anything Philly has to offer. I also like how I was able to walk in and grab a cake without any hassle or a pre-order. Nice selection as well. This Bakery Is Legit. read more

See all

We had gotten a birthday cake (not vegan) and 6 vegan cupcakes.. Everything was excellent. My family commented on how fresh and delicious everything was. My son's girlfriend said the vegan cupcake (she is not vegan) was excellent and way above what she thought a vegan cupcake would taste like The girl who waited on me was very thoughtful and attentive. read more

We usually get two cupcakes here a month and recently decided to get a dozen for Xmas eve dinner. The phone order process was seamless. We had our 12 picked out and she had her pen and pad ready. A few they didn't have so we swapped them out for our back up choices. The cupcakes are heavenly, a huge hit among children and adults. Only issue was there was about 2-3 that were not included and replaced with ones we didn't order. read more

We had The Caketeria make our wedding cake this past September and would 100% go there again. Beth was very communicative and gave us exactly what we asked for. We got the hazelnut torte, which got rave reviews from all of our guests. read more

The Caketeria - Our birch-style wedding cake. - Bakeries Near Me - Newtown, Pennsylvania

This review is long overdue. I have been depending on The Caketeria for birthday, special occasions and holidays for a number of years now. They never disappoint. The cakes are always masterpieces and are delicious. Beth and her entire staff are so kind and accommodating. They are truly a team of artist with a big heart. Besides their cakes, the fondant covered sugar cookies are to die for. They are soft and buttery and stay that way for over a week. When I order for a party, I always over order because my family can't resist them. Thank you Beth and your talented team for always being there for me. read more

See all

We have been coming back to The Caketeria since we moved to the area 3 years ago and are NEVER disappointed. The cupcakes are fluffy and filled and they have some vegan options as well! They did an outstanding job with our son's first birthday cake, came out exactly as the picture we found on Pinterest and tasted like a dream (chocolate chip pound cake with fudge filling oh yumm) Would highly recommend and look forward to using them for our future events read more

See all

My husband's favorite treat are Yodels. So, for his birthday, I asked them to make an upscale Yodel Cake. It was a huge hit and absolutely delicious. read more

The Caketeria - Yodel came - Bakeries Near Me - Newtown, Pennsylvania

See all

We couldn't image a better wedding cake. Beth did a wonderful and excellent job! The tasting was ready enjoyable. Beth introduced all flavors and layers in details and also gave a lot of useful suggestions. Beth is professional and detail-oriented. I also feel she is a very caring person and will take care of my wedding cake with her passion and love. She is reliable and she really cares what she does for her customers. We communicated through email most of time. She responded efficiently and is open to change. Finally, the wedding cake came to our venue on time. It's just STUNNING and FRESH!!! Thank you Beth! read more

The Caketeria - Bakeries Near Me - Newtown, Pennsylvania

I do not write a lot of reviews but had to for The Caketeria in Newtown, PA. Wanting my daughter's Baby Shower to be perfect - I found a design of a cake I wanted for the event. The Caketeria's cake was far better than my original design. Beth and her team have such a passion for what they are doing. The cake was not only the prettiest cake I have seen but was delicious. If you have an a event and you want it extra special definitely choose The Caketeria for your dessert needs!!! read more

The Caketeria - Cupcakes and cake from The Caketeria - Bakeries Near Me - Newtown, Pennsylvania

See all

Beautiful and delicious bridal shower cake. We loved the writing style used. 100% recommend. read more

The Caketeria - Caketeria bridal shower cake - chocolate with raspberry filling and buttercream icing. Perfect! - Bakeries Near Me - Newtown, Pennsylvania

The Caketeria did my daughter and son in laws wedding cake. They picked chocolate cake with chocolate icing. It was OUTSTANDING. Three weeks later I am still getting compliments and being asked where we got the cake. Sam & Mike (bride and groom) are not waiting to eat the top layer but they will save a slice for their anniversary! Run, don't walk, to get your cake at the The Caketeria. Unforgettable. I am going myself to order Mothers Day cupcakes! PS - Beth is the best! read more

Have gotten 4 of my son's custom birthday cakes here and they blow me away every time. Delicious and beautiful! Great customer service too. (I broke the fishing pole in the Animal Crossing Cake, not them, lol!) read more

See all

I bring my grandkids here to pick out cupcakes. Every one has been so tasty and beautifully decorated. We love this tradition!

Quick wedding, fast decisions, super stressful...but NOT at The Caketeria! They were SOOOO helpful, friendly, and creative. The chocolate cake, coffee liquor, and raspberry puree was absolutely delicious! We had one piece of cake left because everyone loved it sooo much! Thank you so much for the professionalism and helping my wedding day be perfect. read more

The best cake around! Everyone at my daughters birthday said it was the best birthday cake they've ever had. Vanilla pound cake with oreo filling is to die for! The staff is super friendly and makes sure the cake is perfect! read more

The Caketeria - a birthday cake for a little girl - Bakeries Near Me - Newtown, Pennsylvania

The cakes are OK and the price is too expensive! I am also a baker and I will not recommend this place to my circle.

I cannot recommend this place enough- the venue my husband and I got married at had partnerships with The Caketeria and one other bakery for our wedding cake, so we tried both. The cake and the service at The Caketeria made it the obvious choice. Neither of us are even big cake people but we loved everything Beth shared with us to try, and she was more than willing to make our cake everything we wanted it to be. We ended up picking multiple flavors for one cake, and the final result was one of the best cakes I ever had (not to mention it was gorgeous!) read more

The Caketeria - Our wedding cake from Caketeria - Bakeries Near Me - Newtown, Pennsylvania

My go to place for the past 4 years for ALL of my cake needs. Beth is talented, accommodating, and delightful! read more

See all

Anyone who knows me knows that I love this place best cakes ever.. it's cool to know how to make a nice design on a cake but it's even cooler to be able to make a nice design on a cake and have it taste amazing you can't beat that!! read more